Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T05:22:36.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Empire and National Identities: The Case of Scotland

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

John M. MacKenzie
John M. MacKenzie
Affiliation:
The Institute of Historical Research, London
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The modern historiography of the origins of British national identities seems riven with contradictions and paradoxes. First there is a major chronological problem. Is the forging of Britishness to be located in the sixteenth, seventeenth, eighteenth or nineteenth centuries? Second, there is a difficulty in the compilation of such identities. Are they to be found in negative reactions to the perceived contemporary identities of others or in positive, if mythic, readings of ethnic history? Third, can there be a British identity at all when the cultural identities of what may be called the sub-nationalisms or sub-ethnicities of the United Kingdom seem to be forged at exactly the same time? And fourth, did the formation of the British Empire and the vast expansion of British imperialism in the nineteenth century tend towards the confirmation of the identity of Greater Britain or of the Welsh, Irish, English and Scottish elements that made it up?

Type
Identities and Empires
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 8 , December 1998 , pp. 215 - 231
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1998

References

1 Seeley, J. R., The Expansion of England: Two Courses of Lectures (London, 1883), p. 130Google Scholar.

2 Wormald, Jenny, ‘The Creation of Britain: Multiple Kingdoms or Core and Colonies’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, sixth series, II (1992), p. 194Google Scholar.

3 Patriotism: the Making and Unmaking of British National Identify, 3 vols., ed. Samuel, Raphael (London, 1909)Google Scholar; ‘History, the Nation and the Schools’, Special Feature, History Workshop, 29 (spring, 1990), pp. 92–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Schama, Simon, Landscape and Memory (London, 1995)Google Scholar; Jacobs, Jane M., Edge of Empire: Postcolonialism and the City (London, 1996)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Wormald, ‘Creation of Britain’; Scots and Britons: Scottish Political Thought and the Union of 1603, ed. Mason, Roger A. (Cambridge, 1994)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Withers, Charles W.J., ‘Royalty and Empire: Scotland and the Making of Great Britain, 1603–1661’, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 113 (1997), pp. 22–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Seeley, , Expansion, p. 131Google Scholar.

7 The most recent examination of this myth of English national character is Richards, Jeffrey, Films and British National Identity: From Dickens to Dad's Army (Manchester, 1997)Google Scholar.

8 Colley, Linda, Britons, Forging the Nation 1707–1837 (New Haven and London, 1992)Google Scholar.

9 Edward, Said, Orientalism (London, 1978)Google Scholar; Culture and Imperialism (London, 1993)Google Scholar.

10 Bolt, Christine, Victorian Attitudes to Race (London, 1971)Google Scholar; Lorimer, Douglas A., Colour, Class and the Victorians (Leicester, 1978)Google Scholar; The Expansion of England: Race, Ethnicity and Cultural History, ed. Schwarz, Bill (London, 1996)Google Scholar.

11 Smith, Anthony D., National Identity (Harmondsworth, 1991)Google Scholar.

12 See, for example, White, Arnold, Efficiency and Empire, edited by Searle, G. R. (Brighton, 1983Google Scholar, first published London, 1901); Stead, Alfred, Great Japan, a Study in National Efficiency (London, 1906)Google Scholar; SirNorman, Henry, The Peoples and Politics of the Far East (London, 1907)Google Scholar.

13 Morgan, Prys, ‘From a Death to a View: the Hunt for the Welsh Past in the Romantic Period’, in The Invention of Tradition, ed. Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence (Cambridge, 1983), pp. 43–100Google Scholar.

14 Sheehy, Jeanne, The Rediscovery of Ireland's Past the Celtic Revival 1830–1930 (London, 1986)Google Scholar.

15 Seeley, , Expansion, pp. 47, 50Google Scholar.

16 Green, Martin, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire (London, 1980)Google Scholar.

17 Williams, Gwyn A., When Was Wales? (Harmondsworth, 1991), pp. 124–5, 139, 225Google ScholarPubMed.

18 Ibid., pp. 221, 223.

19 Ibid., p. 222.

20 Morgan, Kenneth O., Rebirth of a Nation: Wales 1880–1980 (Oxford, 1981), pp. 30–1, 45Google Scholar.

21 Cave, Richard Allen, ‘Staging the Irishman’ in Bratton, J. S. et al. , Acts of Supremacy: The British Empire and the Stage, 1790–1930 (Manchester, 1991), pp. 62–128Google Scholar; An Irish Empire? Aspects of Ireland and the British Empire, ed. Jeffery, Keith (Manchester, 1996)Google Scholar.

22 Smith, Dai, Wales! Wales? (London, 1984), pp. 29–32Google ScholarPubMed.

23 Colley, , Britons, p. 83Google Scholar; Maver, Irene, ‘The Guardianship of the Community: Civic Authority Before 1833’ in Glasgow: Vol. 1: Beginnings to 1830, ed. Devine, T.M. and Jackson, Gordon (Manchester, 1995), pp. 244, 259Google Scholar.

24 Bryant, G.J., ‘Scots in India in the Eighteen Century’, Scottish Historical Review, lxiv (1985), pp. 22–41Google Scholar; Lenman, Bruce, The Jacobite Clans of the Great Glen, 1650–1784 (London, 1984), pp. 209, 217–18Google Scholar.

25 Pittock, Murray, The Invention of Scotland: the Stuart Myth and the Scottish Identity, 1638 to the Present (London, 1991)Google Scholar; see also Kidd, Colin, Subverting Scotland's Past: Scottish Whig Historians and the Creation of an Anglo-British Identity, 1689–c.1830 (Cambridge, 1993)CrossRefGoogle Scholar and The Manufacture of Scottish History, eds. Donnachie, Ian and Whatley, Christopher (Edinburgh, 1992)Google Scholar.

26 MacKenzie, John M., ‘David Livingstone: the Construction of the Myth’, in Sermons and Battle Hymns: Protestant Popular Culture in Modern Scotland, ed. Walker, Graham and Gallagher, Tom (Edinburgh, 1990), pp. 24–42Google Scholar; MacKenzie, John M., ‘David Livingstone and the Worldly After-life: Imperialism and Nationalism in Africa’ in David Livingstone and the Victorian Encounter with Africa, ed. MacKenzie, John M. (London, 1996) pp. 201–17Google Scholar.

27 T. M. Devine, ‘The Golden Age of Tobacco’ and Gordon Jackson, ‘New Horizons in Trade’ in Glasgow, ed. Devine and Jackson.

28 McGilvary, George Kirk, ‘East India Patronage and the Political Management of Scotland, 1720–74’ (Ph.D. thesis, The Open University in Scotland, 1989)Google Scholar; Fry, Michael, The Dundos Despotism (Edinburgh, 1992)Google Scholar.

29 Riddy, John, ‘Warren Hastings: Scotland's Benefactor’ in The Impeachment of Warren Hastings, ed. Carnall, Geoffrey and Nicholson, Colin (Edinburgh, 1989), pp. 30–57Google Scholar; Rendall, Jane, ‘Scottish Orientalism: from Robertson to James Mill’, The Historical Journal, 25 (1982), pp. 43–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McLaren, Martha, ‘Writing and Making History: Thomas Munro, John Malcolm, and Mountstuart Elphinstone: Three Scotsmen in the History and Historiography of British India’ (Ph.D. thesis, Simon Fraser University, British Columbia, 1992)Google Scholar.

30 Hargreaves, John D., Academe and Empire: Some Overseas Connections of Aberdeen University 1860–1970 (Aberdeen, 1994), pp. 26, 28, 34–5, 62–5Google Scholar and passim.

31 MacKenzie, John M., ‘On Scotland and the Empire’, International History Review, XV (1993). p. 734Google Scholar.

32 David S. Macmillan, ‘Scottish Enterprise and Influences in Canada, 1620–1900’ and James G. Parker, ‘Scottish Enterprise in India, 1750–1914’ in The Scots Abroad, ed. R. A. Cage; The Thistle and the Jade: a Celebration of 150 Years of Jardine Matheson and Co., ed. Keswick, Maggie (London, 1982)Google Scholar.

33 MacKenzie, , ‘Scotland and the Empire’, pp. 732–7Google Scholar; the notion of the Scottish ethic is based upon Davie, George Elder, The Democratic Intellect: Scotland and her Universities in the Nineteenth Century (Edinburgh1, 1961)Google Scholar. See also A Union for Empire: Political Thought and the British Union of 1707, ed. Robertson, James (Cambridge, 1995)Google Scholar.

34 Forsyth, David S., ‘Empire and Union: Imperial and National Identity in Nineteenth-Century Scotland’, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 113 (1997), pp. 7–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Hargreaves, Academe and Empire, passim; see also Hargreaves, John D., Aberdeenshire to Africa: Northeast Scots and British Overseas Expansion (Aberdeen, 1981)Google Scholar.

36 For the scientific reputation of Livingstone, David see Dr. Livingstone's Cambridge Lectures Together with a Prefatory Letter by the Rev. Professor Sedgwick, ed. with an introduction, life of Dr Livingstone, notes and appendix by the RevMonk, William (London, 1858)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 Grove, Richard, Green Imperialism: Colonial Expansion, Tropical Island Edens and the Origins of Environmentalism, 1600–1860 (Cambridge, 1995), pp. 312, 347Google Scholar; Grove, Richard, ‘Scottish Missionaries, Evangelical Discourses and the Origins of Conservation Thinking in Southern Africa, 1820–1900’ in Ecology, Climate and Empire: Colonialism and Global Environmental History, 1400–1940, ed. Grove, (Cambridge, 1997) pp. 86–123Google Scholar.

38 Brown, John Croumbie, Management of Crown Forests at the Cape of Good Hope Under the Old Regime and the New (Edinburgh, 1887), p. iiiGoogle Scholar.

39 See, for example, Trollope, Anthony, Australia (London, 1873), p. 420Google Scholar; SirDilke, Charles Wentworth, Greater Britain (London, 1872), pp. 373–4 and 533Google Scholar; Froude, J.A., Oceana or England and Her Colonies (London, 1886), p. 116Google Scholar.

40 For a survey of this literature, see MacKenzie, ‘Scotland and the Empire’. As well as Gibb's Scottish Empire (London, 1937)Google Scholar, he also published Scotland in Eclipse (London, 1930)Google Scholar and Scotland Resurgent (Stirling, 1950)Google Scholar.

41 MacKenzie, , ‘Livingstone, Construction of the Myth’, pp. 32–5Google Scholar.

42 Nenadic, Stana, ‘The Victorian Middle Classes’ in Glasgow: Vol. II, 1830–1912, ed. Fraser, W. Hamish and Maver, Irene (Manchester, 1996), p. 288Google Scholar.

43 McEwan, Cheryl, ‘“The Mother of all the Peoples”: Geographical Knowledge and the Empowering of Mary Slessor’ in Geography and Imperialism 1820–1940, ed. Bell, Morag, Button, Robin and Heffernan, Michael (Manchester, 1996), pp. 125–50Google Scholar; Stewart, Gordon, Jute and Empire (Manchester, forthcoming 1998)Google Scholar.

44 Springhall, J. O., Youth, Empire and Society (London, 1977)Google Scholar; Sure and Stedfast a History of the Boys' Brigade, 1883–1983 (London, 1983)Google Scholar.

45 MacKenzie, John M., ‘The Provincial Geographical Societies in Britain, 1884–1914’ in Geography and Imperialism, ed. Bell, et al. , pp. 93–124Google Scholar.

46 Calder, Angus, ‘Samuel Smiles: the Unexpurgated Version’, The Raven Anarchist Quarterly, v (1992), pp. 79–89Google Scholar.

47 McCracken, John, Politics and Christianity in Malawi, 1875–1940 (Cambridge, 1977)Google Scholar.

48 Moir, F. L. M., After Livingstone: an African Trade Romance (London, n.d.)Google Scholar; Gibb, , Scottish Empire, p. 147Google Scholar; Thistle and the Jade, ed. Keswick.

49 SirLipton, Thomas J., Leaves from the Lipton Logs (London, 1931)Google Scholar; Crampsey, Bob, The King's Grocer: The Life of Sir Thomas Lipton (Glasgow, 1995)Google Scholar.

50 Kinchin, Perilla and Kinchin, Juliet, Glasgow's Great Exhibitions (Bicester, 1988), pp. 17–53Google Scholar; Illustrated London News, 12 May 1888. The Glasgow Room of the Mitchell library, Glasgow, holds albums of cuttings and photographs relating to this exhibition.

51 Official Catalogue, Scottish Exhibition, Glasgow, 1911Google Scholar; Souvenir Album of the Scottish Exhibition of National History, Art and Industry, Glasgow 1911Google Scholar; Scottish Exhibition of National History, Art and Industry, Glasgow 1911, Palace of History, Catalogue of Exhibits, 2 vols., Glasgow, 1911Google Scholar.

52 Forsyth, , ‘Empire and Union’, pp. 9–11Google Scholar; Finlay, Richard J., ‘The Rise and Fall of Popular Imperialism in Scotland 1850–1950’, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 113 (1997), pp. 13–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Finlay, , ‘Rise and Fall’, pp. 19–20Google Scholar.

54 MacKenzie, John M., Propaganda and Empire (Manchester, 1984), pp. 256–7Google Scholar and passim.

55 See for example, Scotland's Welcome, 1938, ed. Maine, G.F. (Glasgow, 1938)Google Scholar; Oakley, C.A., The Second City (London, 1946)Google Scholar.

56 Richards, Jeffrey, Visions of Yesterday (London, 1973)Google Scholar; Imperialism and Juvenile Literature, ed. Richards, Jeffrey (Manchester, 1989)Google Scholar; MacKenzie, , ‘Scotland and the Empire’, p. 738Google Scholar. See also Finlay, Richard J., ‘“For or Against?”: Scottish Nationalists and the British Empire’, Scottish Historical Review, LXXI (1992), pp. 184–206Google Scholar and ‘National Identity in Crisis: Politicians, Intellectuals and the “End of Scotland”, 1920–1939’, History, 79 (1994), pp. 242–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 Kinchin, and Kinchin, , Glasgow's Great Exhibitions, pp. 127–85Google Scholar; Crampsey, Bob, The Empire Exhibition of 1938: the Last Durbar (Edinburgh, 1988)Google Scholar; Empire Exhibition, Official Guide (Glasgow, 1938)Google Scholar; A Souvenir of the Empire Exhibition (Glasgow, 1938)Google Scholar, among many other sources.

58 MacKenzie, John M., ‘Glasgow: an Imperial City?’ in Driver, Felix (ed.), Imperial Cities (Manchester, forthcoming)Google Scholar.

59 Moss, Michael S. and Hume, John R., Workshop of the British Empire: Engineering and Shipbuilding in the West of Scotland (London, 1977)Google Scholar.

60 A History of the North British Locomotive Company Limited (Glasgow, privately published, 1953), p. 10Google Scholarand passim.

61 MacKenzie, , ‘Scotland and the Empire’, pp. 732–7Google Scholar.

62 Scotland and Europe, 1200–1850, ed. Smout, T.C. (Edinburgh, 1986)Google Scholar; Scotland and the Sea, ed. Smout, T.C. (Edinburgh, 1992)Google Scholar; Fischer, Th. A, The Scots in Germany: Being a Contribution towards the History of the Scot Abroad (Edinburgh, 1902)Google Scholar.

63 Nairn, Tom, The Break-Up of Britain (London, 1977)Google Scholar.

64 SirCoupland, Reginald, Welsh and Scottish Nationalism (London, 1954)Google Scholar.

65 See, for example, Coupland's memorandum on Ireland, July 1933, published in Imperial Policy and Colonial Practice, 1925–45, British Documents on the End of Empire, ed. Ashton, S. R. and Stockwell, S. E. (London, 1996), Part I, pp. 281–6Google Scholar.

66 Coupland, , Welsh and Scottish Nationalism, pp. xv, 12, 113Google Scholar.

67 Williams, Tim, ‘The Anglicisation of South Wales’ in Patriotism, ed. Samuel, , vol. IIGoogle Scholar, Minorities and Outsiders, pp. 193—203; Gwyneth Tyson Roberts, ‘“Under the Hatches”; English Parliamentary Commissioners’ Views of the People and Language of Mid-Nineteenth-Century Wales’ in The Expansion of England, ed. Schwarz, , pp. 171–97Google Scholar.

68 McKay, Ian, ‘Tartanism Triumphant: The Construction of Scottishness in Nova Scotia, 1933–1954’, Acadiensis, XXI (1992), pp. 5–47Google Scholar; Brooking, Tom, ‘“Tom McCanny and Kitty Clydeside”—the Scots in New Zealand’ in The Scots Abroad, ed. Cage, , pp. 156–90Google Scholar.