Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T10:01:37.690Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Elie Halévy and the Birth of Methodism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

J. D. Walsh
J. D. Walsh
Affiliation:
Jesus college, Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Probably the most famous passages in Halévy's work are those attributing England's immunity from revolution after 1789 to the influence of Methodism. The ‘Halévy thesis’ encouraged, though it did not begin, a debate which still fizzes, jumps and occasionally explodes. Little attention has been given to Halévy's first essay in Methodist history, ‘The Birth of Methodism in England’, which appeared in La Révue de Paris in 1906, even though one of its central themes prefigured his famous thesis. After decades of neglect, this has been disinterred, translated and excellently introduced by Bernard Semmel. Compared with Halévy's major writings it is thin and slightly documented, for much of the primary research on which it was based was crowded into a few weeks in the Bodleian Library, after which he seems to have been discouraged by the misleading news that his subject had been pre-empted. The essay remained a rather slender piece, sweepingly written, which found its outlet in a cultural periodical rather than a learned journal. But it is something of a tour de force.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 25 , December 1975 , pp. 1 - 20
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1975

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Halévy, E., The Birth of Methodism in England, transl. with introduction by Semmel, B. (Chicago, 1971)Google Scholar.

2 ‘Alain’ (Chartier, E. A.), Correspondance avec E. et F. Halévy (8e édn, Paris, 1958), pp. 331–32Google Scholar.

3 See Everitt, A. M., The Pattern of Rural Dissent: the Nineteenth Century (Leicester, 1972)Google Scholar; Currie, R., ‘A Micro-theory of Methodist Growth’, Proceedings of the Wesley Historical Society, xxxvi (1967), pp. 65–73Google Scholar. Also the important unpublished theses by Greaves, B., ‘Methodism in Yorkshire 1740–1851’ (Liverpool University Ph.D., 1968)Google Scholar, Thompson, D. M., ‘The Churches and Society in Leicestershire 1851–1881’ (Cambridge University Ph.D., 1969)Google Scholar, Gilbert, A. D., ‘The Growth and Decline of Nonconformity in England and Wales’ (Oxford University D.Phil., 1973)Google Scholar.

4 Coleman, T., Memorials of the Independent Churches in Northamptonshire (London, 1853), pp. 54 ffGoogle Scholar.

5 See Moore, C. A., Backgrounds of English Literature 1700–1760 (Minneapolis, 1953), pp. 179–235Google Scholar.

6 See Walsh, J. D., ‘Origins of the Evangelical Revival’, in Essays in Modern English Church History, ed. Bennett, G. V. and Walsh, J. D. (London, 1966), pp. 138–48Google Scholar.

7 Shankland, T., ‘Sir John Philipps; the S.P.C.K. and the Charity-School Movement in Wales 1699–1737’, Transactions of the Honourable Society of Cymmrodorion (1904–1905), pp. 74 ffGoogle Scholar; Memoirs of Sir J. Barnard (repr. London, 1885), pp. 2–12.

8 See Greene, J. P., ‘Search for Identity: an Interpretation of the Meaning of Selected Patterns of Social Response in Eighteenth Century America’, Journal of Social History, iii (1970), pp. 195–99Google Scholar.

9 (Seagrave, R.), A Letter to the people of England (2nd edn, London, ? 1735), p. 20Google Scholar.

10 George Whitefield's Journals (London, 1961), p. 461Google Scholar.

11 E.g. The Journal of the Rev. C. Wesley, ed. Jackson, T. (London, 1849), i, pp. 192, 234, 358, 430, 441Google Scholar; ii, p. 81.

12 Davison, W. H., Centenary Memorials of Duke's Alley Chapel, Bolton (Bolton 1854), p. 49Google Scholar; Burdsall, R., Memoirs (2nd edn, York, 1811), p. 139Google Scholar.

13 Broxap, H., The Later Nonjurors (Cambridge, 1924), p. 214Google Scholar.

14 The Causes and Reasons of the Present Declension among the Congregational Churches (London, 1766), p. 9Google Scholar; Tyerman, L., The Life of the Rev. G. Whitefield (2nd edn, London, 1890), i, pp. 484–86Google Scholar.

15 The Northampton Group of Moravian Chapels (London, 1886), p. 10Google Scholar.

16 See John Rylands Library, Eng. MS 1076 (24).

17 Whitefield's Journals, p. 275.

18 The Letters of the Rev. J. Wesley, ed. Telford, J. (London, 1931), ii, p. 271Google Scholar.

19 Dallimore, A. A., George Whitefield (London, 1970), i, p. 233 ffGoogle Scholar.

20 The Works of the Rev. G. Whitefield (London, 1771–1772), i, p. 30Google Scholar; Procs. Wesley Hist. Soc., vi (1907), pp. 102–03, 124–27Google Scholar.

21 Whitefield's Journals, p. 89.

22 See Ashton, T. S., Economic Fluctuations in the Eighteenth Century (Oxford, 1959), pp. 76, 146–47Google Scholar; John, A. H., ‘The Course of Agricultural Change’, in Studies in the Industrial Revolution, ed. Pressnell, L. S. (London, 1960)Google Scholar; Mann, J. de L., The Cloth Industry in the West of England from 1640 to 1880 (Oxford, 1971), pp. 37 ff, 89 ffGoogle Scholar; Creighton, C., A History of Epidemics in Britain (2nd edn, London, 1965), i, p. 27Google Scholar; ii, p. 80.

23 See Cross, W. R., The Burned-over District (New York, 1950), p. 75Google Scholar; Smith, T. L., Revivalism and Social Reform in Mid Nineteenth Century America (New York, 1957), pp. 63–64Google Scholar; Walker, R. B., ‘The Growth and Typology of the Wesleyan Methodist Church in New South Wales 1812–1901’, Journal of Religious History, vi (1971), pp. 337–39Google Scholar. I am indebted to Dr Robert Currie for the information about English Methodist membership.

24 The Journal of the Rev. J. Wesley, ed. Curnock, N. (London, 1938), iii, pp. 97, 181Google Scholar; Tyerman, , Life of Whitefield, ii, p. 109Google Scholar. For an attempt to identify the age and occupation of those named on a fragmentary list surviving from Bristol in 1741, see Goss, W. A., ‘Early Methodism in Bristol’, (unpublished M.A. thesis, Bristol University, 1932), pp. 69–81Google Scholar.

25 Letters of J. Wesley, ii, p. 271.

26 Whitefield, , Works, i, p. 325Google Scholar.

27 Tuck, S., Wesleyan Methodism in Frome (Frome, 1837), pp. 32–34Google Scholar.

28 Toulmin, J., The History of Taunton, 2nd edn enlarged by Savage, J. (Taunton, 1822), pp. 192–93Google Scholar; Dunsford, M., Historical Memoirs of Tiverton (Exeter, 1790), pp. 232–35Google Scholar; (anon.), A History of the Devizes (Devizes, 1859), pp. 380–90Google Scholar; Brockett, A., Nonconformity in Exeter 1650–1875 (Manchester, 1962), pp. 121 ffGoogle Scholar.

29 MS Inghamite notebook, Colne Public Library.

30 Letters of J. Wesley, iii, p. 85.

31 Ibid., vii, p. 352.

32 Hill, C., Society and Puritanism in Pre-Revolutionary England (London, 1964), pp. 131–34Google Scholar.

33 The Baptist Annual Register, ed. Rippon, J. (London, 1790–1802), ii, p. 461Google Scholar.

34 E.g. Walzer, M., The Revolution of the Saints (London, 1966), pp. 199 ffGoogle Scholar.

35 Journal of J. Wesley, iii, p. 288.

36 See Mann, , The Cloth Industry in the West of England, pp. 109–12Google Scholar.

37 Journal of J. Wesley, ii, p. 173.

38 The Works of the Rev. J. Wesley, ed. Jackson, T. (3rd edn, London, 1872), viii, p. 239Google Scholar.

39 Ibid., vii, p. 21.

40 Ibid., v, p. 15.

41 Whitefield's Journals, p. 216; Journal of J. Wesley, iii, p. 73.

42 Ibid., ii, p. 216.

43 Ibid., iii, p. 74.

44 Ibid., ii, p. 202.

45 Letters of J. Wesley, vi, p. 61.

46 Whitefield's Journals, p. 241.

47 Letters of J. Wesley, ii, p. 271.

48 Journal of J. Wesley, ii, p. 323.

49 Journal of C. Wesley, i, p. 249.

50 Barbour, H., The Quakers in Puritan England (New Haven, 1964), p. 189Google Scholar.

51 Procs. Wesley Hist. Soc. xiv (1924), pp. 29–30Google Scholar.

52 See Jones, M. H., The Trevecka Letters (Caernarvon, 1932), pp. 185–206Google Scholar.

53 Whitefield, , Works, vi, p. 231Google Scholar.

54 Three Letters from the Rev. Mr. G. Whitefield (Philadelphia, 1740), p. 2Google Scholar.

55 The Weekly Miscellany, 26 July 1740.

56 Seward, W., Journal of a Voyage from Savannah (London, 1740), p. 45Google Scholar.

57 Methodist Archives, MS Copies of Original Letters collected by L. Tyerman, iii, pp. 301–02.

58 A Brief Account of Howell Harris (Trevecka, 1791), p. 45Google Scholar.

59 Whitefield, , Works, vi, pp. 237–38Google Scholar.

60 Ibid., vi, p. 238.

61 Ibid., v, p. 133.

62 Ibid., v, p. 272.

63 Journal of J. Wesley, iv, p. 52.

64 The Poetical Works of J. and C. Wesley, ed. Osborn, G. (London, 1868–1871) p. 301Google Scholar.

65 Ibid., xi, p. 411.

66 Ibid., x, p. 327.

67 Ibid., ix, p. 411.

68 Letters of J. Wesley, vii, p. 343; Wesley, J., Works, vi, p. 283Google Scholar.

69 Procs. Wesley Hist. Soc., xxviii (1951–1952), p. 49Google Scholar; Wesley, J., Works, xi, pp. 183–84Google Scholar.

70 See Walsh, , ‘Origins of the Evangelical Revival’, pp. 140–41Google Scholar; Kend-rick, T. F. J., ‘Sir Robert Walpole, the Old Whigs and the Bishops, 1733–1736’, The Historical Journal, xi (1968), pp. 421–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kramnick, I, Bolingbroke and his Circle (Cambridge, Mass., 1968)Google Scholar.