Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T07:46:02.077Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Early-Nineteenth-Century Reactions to Benthamism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

J. R. Dinwiddy
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

IN 1965 a very distinguished Bentham scholar read a paper to this society on Bentham and the French Revolution. During the period dealt with by that paper Bentham became an honorary citizen of France (largely through his friendship with Brissot), but he remained little known either in Britain or on the Continent. Thirty years later, he was world-famous. In 1825 members of the Colombian Congress in Bogot were quoting Bentham at each other much as eighteenth-century Englishmen had quoted Cicero in the House of Commons; and among the leaders of the Decembrist mutiny of the same year in St Petersburg were men who confessed to having been influenced by Bentham's works. In 1829 a weekly newspaper was appearing at Boston, Massachusetts, which carried his phrase the greatest happiness of the greatest number as its motto, while a journal called L'Utilitaire was being published at Geneva to propagate his ideas. This paper will not tackle the large and controversial subject of the extent and significance of Bentham's influence. It will address itself to questions that are more limited, though they have some bearing on the larger topic. These questions are: how did those outside the circle of his followers react to his ideas, and what attempts were made to challenge or refute them?

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 34 , December 1984 , pp. 47 - 69
Copyright
Copyright Royal Historical Society 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 By Burns, J. H., Transactions, 5th series, 16 (1966), 95114Google Scholar. I should like to thank Professor Burns, Dr Fred Rosen, and above all Mr William Thomas, for helpful suggestions regarding my paper.

2 McKennan, Theodora, Santander and the Vogue of Benthamism in Colombia, Ph.D. thesis, Loyola University, Chicago, 1970, 1645Google Scholar; Salkind, E., Die Dekabristen in ihrer Beziehung zu Westeuropa, Jahrbcher fr Kultur und Geschichte der Slawen, Band iv, Heft iv (1928), 5378Google Scholar.

3 The ankee and Boston Literary Gazette, edited by Neal, John, 1828 1829Google Scholar.

4 Edited by Antoine-Elise Cherbuliez, 182930.

5 Traits de lgislation civile et pnale, ed. Dumont, E. (3 vols, Paris, 1802)Google Scholar.

6 Kirk, Russell, Scott and Bentham, Fortnightly Review, New Series, clxxii (1952), 397403Google Scholar.

7 The Friend, ed. Rooke, Barbara (2 vols, 1969), I. 31325Google Scholar.

8 Southey to Henry Taylor, 31 Dec. 1825, 19 Apr. 1828, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Eng. letters d. 6, ff. 42, 204; Life and Correspondence of Robert Southey, ed. Southey, C. C. (6 vols, 1849 1850), V. 290Google Scholar.

9 Parry, William, The Last Days of Lord Byron (1825), 1559Google Scholar.

10 See Clair, William St., Postscript to The Last Days of Lord Byron, Keats-Shelley Journal, xix (1970), 47Google Scholar.

11 The Times, 19 May 1825.

12 North American Review, xxvi (1828), 1889Google Scholar.

13 Mack, Mary has said Jeremy Bentham: An Odyssey of Ideas 17481792 (1962), 198Google Scholar that his political writings are all popular and easy; but this is far from being the case.

14 Maria Edgeworth to Mrs Marcet, 21 Jan. 1818, in Huserman, H. W., The Genevese Background (1952), 88Google Scholar.

15 Quarterly Review, xxi (1819), 175Google Scholar.

16 Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, xi (1822), 3657Google Scholar. For a fine parody of Bentham's style by Maurice, F. D., see Metropolitan Quarterly Magazine, i (1826), 35377Google Scholar.

17 Bentham was inclined to attribute this to his being a bencher of Lincoln's Inn, buta more basic explanation can perhaps be found in the remark of Timothy Tickler of Blackwood's xv (1824), 146Google Scholar that his absurd peculiarities rendered him harmless.

18 Der Index der verbotenen Bcher, ed. Hilgers, Joseph (Freiburg, 1904), 456Google Scholar.

19 McKennan, , Santander, 170216Google Scholar; Rojas, Armando, La Batalla de Bentham en Colombia, Revista de Historia de Amrica, xxix (1950), 3751Google Scholar.

20 See Schwartz, Pedro, La Influencia de Jeremas Bentham en Espaa, Informacin Comercial Espaola, 10. 1976, 39, 44, 50Google Scholar.

21 Hermosilla, Jos Gomez, El Jacobinismo (3 vols, Madrid, 1823), I. 217, 281Google Scholar.

22 Vidal, Jos, Orgen de los errores revolucionarios de Europa, y su remedio (Valencia 1827), 254n., 268, 274, 27980, 2889, 307Google Scholar. Another Spanish Catholic who criticised Bentham at length from a natural law position, though he was a liberal in politics, was F. Martnez Marina; but the work in which he did so was not published until a hundred years after his death. See his Principios naturales de la moral, de la poltica y de la legislacin, ed. Posada, Adolfo (Madrid, 1933), esp. 749, 13853, 16883Google Scholar.

23 Bentham, , Deontology, together with A Table of the Springs of Action and The Article on Utilitarianism, ed. Goldworth, Amnon (Oxford, 1982), 49 & nGoogle Scholar.; Cooper, C. P., Lettres sur la Cour de la Chancellerie d'Angleterre, ed. Royer-Collard, P. (third edn., Paris, 1830), 372nGoogle Scholar.

24 Bentham to William Plumer jr., n.d. c. Dec. 1818, Plumer MSS., New Hampshire State Library. His arguments in favour of codification were set out in the Traits de lgislation, in Papers relative to Codification and Public Instruction (London, 1817)Google Scholar, in Codification Proposal addressed to all Nations professing Liberal Opinions (London, 1822)Google Scholar, and in another volume edited by Dumont, , De l'organisation judiciaire et de la codification (Paris, 1828)Google Scholar.

25 Livingston, to Bentham, , 10 08. 1829, in The Works of Jeremy Bentham, ed. Bowring, John (11 vols, Edinburgh, 1843), XI. 23Google Scholar.

26 Bloomfield, Maxwell, William Sampson and the Codifiers: the Roots of American Legal Reform 18201830, American Journal of Legal History, xi (1967), 2456Google Scholar; Hezel, G. M., The Influence of Bentham's Philosophy of Law on the Early Nineteenth Century Codification Movement in the United States, Buffalo Law Review, xxii (1972 1973). 255Google Scholar.

27 ber die Nothwcndigkeit eines allgemeinen brgerlichen Rechts fr Deutschland (Heidelberg, 1814)Google Scholar.

28 Stimmen fr und wider neue Gesetzbcher, Zeitschrift fr geschichtliche Rechtswissenschaft, Band iii (1817), 152Google Scholar.

29 E.g. Kritische Zeitschrift fr Rechtswissenschaft und Gesetzgebung des Auslandes, Band i (1829), 25270Google Scholar; Band iii (1831), 8897. For earlier remarks about how little known Bentham's works were in Germany, see Hermes oder kritisches Jahrbuch da Literatur, Band xv (1822), 331Google Scholar, and Kritische Zeitschrift fr Rechtswissenschaft, Band i, Heft iii(1827), 1Google Scholar.

30 Blondeau, Hyacinthe, Essais sur quelques points de jurisprudence (Paris, 1819), esp. 4756, 612Google Scholar; Dumont to Bentham, 10 Aug. 1821, Bentham MSS., X, 1245, University College London.

31 Bentham, , Papers relative to Codification and Public Instruction, Supplement, 1301Google Scholar (Works, ed. Bowring, , IV. 500)Google Scholar.

32 Bonnecase, Julien, La Thmis (1819 1831)Google Scholar; son fondateur, Athanase Jourdan (Toulouse, 1912), 545, 967Google Scholar.

33 He referred on this point to Bentham's De l'influence des temps et des lieux en matire de lgislation, which formed part of the Trais de lgislation.

34 Annales de Lgislation et de Jurisprudence, i (1820), 166Google Scholar.

35 Revue Encyclopdique, xxxi (1826), 62641Google Scholar.

36 Lerminier, Eugne, Introduction gnrale l'histoire du droit (Brussels, 1830), 2405Google Scholar; Philosophic du droit (Paris, 1831), 31213Google Scholar.

37 Hammond's proposals for the consolidation of the criminal law helped to prepare the ground for Peel's statutes of 182730; see Radzinowicz, Leon, History of English Criminal Law and its Administration from 1950 (4 vols, 1948 1968), I. 5747Google Scholar.

38 Humphreys, after the publication of his Observations on the Actual State of the English Laws of Real Property, with the Outlines of a Code (London, 1826)Google Scholar, was hailed by Bentham as an unavowed disciple of his (Bentham to Peel, 19 Aug. 1826, Bentham MSS., XI, 2013); but he appears to have been inspired by Continental civil codes rather than by Bentham.

39 Bentham on Codification, Edinburgh Review, xxix (1817), 21737Google Scholar.

40 See Flood, J. W., The Benthamites and their Use of the Press 18101840, Ph.D. thesis, University of London, 1974, chap. ivGoogle Scholar.

41 Mill, J. S., Autobiography and Literary Essays, eds. Robson, J. M. and Stillinger, J. (Toronto, 1981), 133Google Scholar.

42 Reddie, James, Letter to the Lord High Chancellor (1828), 57, 4452Google Scholar.

43 Cooper, , Lettres, 35072Google Scholar.

44 Eunomus, Juridical Letters; addressed to the Right Hon. Robert Peel, in reference to the present Crisis of Law Reform. Letter I (1830), 4, 1224Google Scholar.

45 Park, J. J., A Contre-Projet to the Humphreysian Code (1828), 229Google Scholar.

46 Cullen, C. S., Reform of the Bankrupt Court; with a Letter to John Smith, Esq. M.P. (2nd edn., 1830), iiixiGoogle Scholar.

47 Cf. Sutton Sharpe et ses amis franais, ed. Gunnell, Doris (Paris, 1925), 13, 99Google Scholar; Thmis, x (1830, 372Google Scholar.

48 The Jurist, ii (1828 1829), 181218Google Scholar.

49 For an anecdote which illustrates his vagueness about it, see Gans, Eduard, Rckblicke auf Personen und Zustnde (Berlin, 1836), 2016Google Scholar.

50 Bentham MSS., LXXXIII, 157.

51 Bentham to Livingston, 23 Feb. 1830, Livingston MSS., John Ross Delafield Foundation, New York.

52 Bentham to Adolphe Hauman, 4 Aug. 1831, Osborn Collection, Yale University.

53 Jeremy Bentham to his Fellow-Citizens of France, on Houses of Peers and Senates (1830), 10 (Works, ed. Bowring, , IV. 425)Google Scholar.

54 Schwarz, A. B., John Austin and the German Jurisprudence of his Time, Politica, 1 (1934 1935). 17899Google Scholar.

55 Austin, John, Lectures on Jurisprudence, 3rd edn., ed. Campbell, Robert (2 vols, 1869), II. 689704Google Scholar.

56 Law Magazine, iv (1830) 244Google Scholar.

57 Cooper, , Lettres, 370, 396Google Scholar.

58 Meijer, J. D. (alias Meyer, ), De la codification en gnral, et de celle de l'Angleterre en particulier (Amsterdam, 1830), pp. ix, xii, 126nGoogle Scholar.

59 de Avila Martel, Alamiro, La Filosofia jurdica de Andrs Bello, in Actas del Congreso International Andrs Bello y el Derecho (Santiago de Chile, 1982), 4162, esp. 489Google Scholar. One should add that Bello subsequently came under the influence of Savigny, and the code he drafted in the 1840s and '50s was an eclectic one which drew only to a limited extent on Bentham's ideas.

60 Stokes, Eric, The English Utilitarians and India (Oxford, 1959), 184233Google Scholar.

61 Edinburgh Review, xxii (1813), 1131Google Scholar.

62 Ibid., ix (1807), 483; li (1830), 4812. Cf. Macaulay's tribute, ibid., lv (1832), 553.

63 Ibid., xxii (1813), 1011.

64 Ibid., xlviii (1828), 457520.

65 SirMackintosh, James, Dissertation on the Progress of Ethical Philosophy (Edinburgh, 1836), 290Google Scholar. (This work was written in 182830 for the Encyclopaedia Britannica.).

66 Hansard, , Parliamentary Debates, xxxvi, 784Google Scholar; xxxviii, 11645.

67 Bentham had actually recommended a somewhat less comprehensive franchise, which he called virtually universal suffrage: see his Plan of Parliamentary Reform, in the form of a Catechism (1817), pp. lxxxc (Works, ed. Bowring, , III. 45864)Google Scholar.

68 Edinburgh Review, xxxi (1818), 165203Google Scholar.

69 Bentham to John Herbert Koe, 1 Feb. 1818, Koe MSS., Wilbraham Temple, Cambridge.

70 Bentham MSS., CXXXI, 27183.

71 Edinburgh Review, xlix (1829), 1803Google Scholar.

72 Article on Utilitarianism, in Deontology, ed. Goldworth, 30910.

73 Edinburgh Review, xxxi (1818), 174Google Scholar; xlix (1829), 292.

74 Ibid., iv (1804), 1015.

75 Mackintosh, , Dissertation on the Progress of Ethical Philosophy, 2923Google Scholar.

76 Edinburgh Review, xxii (1813), 234nGoogle Scholar. Dumont had written in a detailed reply to Jeffrey, which he never published: L'objet de Mr. B. n'est point de rejeter les rgles gnrales, mais de les vrifier par le principe de l'utilit. (MS. Dumont 55, f. 127, Bibliothque publique et universitaire, Geneva).

77 Edinburgh Review, xlix (1829), 294Google Scholar. Cf. Utilitarian Logic and Politics, eds. Lively, Jack and Rees, John (Oxford, 1978), 2613Google Scholar. This was also to be the central argument in one of the main attacks made on Bentham's moral philosophy inthe 1830s: Thodore Jouffroy, , Cours de droit naturel (2 vols, Paris, 1834 1842)Google Scholar, I, Leon xiv.

78 Cf. my paper Bentham on Private Ethics and the Principle of Utility, Revue Internationale de Philosophie, xxxvi (1982), 278300Google Scholar.

79 Traits de lgislation, I. xxx, 93.

80 Quarterly Review, x (1814), 489Google Scholar; New Monthly Magazine, x (1824), 74Google Scholar.

81 de Bonald, Vicomte, Lgislation primitive, considre dans les derniers temps par les seules lumires de la raison (3rd edn., 2 vols, Paris, 1829), I. 113Google Scholar.

82 Hodgskin, Thomas, The Natural and Artificial Right of Property Contrasted (1832), 21Google Scholar. There were other contributors to early socialist thought, the Saint-Simonians, who had no objection to the dirigiste element in Bentham's system, though they differed from him on other points: see Duvergier, J. -B., De la lgislation, in Opinions littraires, philosophiques et industrielles (Paris, 1825), 199212Google Scholar; Enfantin, B. -P. et al. ., Doctrine de Saint-Simon. Exposition. Premitre anne, 1829 (2nd edn., Paris, 1830), 2415Google Scholar.

83 Collected Letters of Thomas and Jane Carlyle, eds. Sanders, C. R. and Fielding, K. J. (Durham, North Carolina, 1970), V. 21112Google Scholar.

84 Edinburgh Review, xlvi (1827), 348Google Scholar; liv (1831), 357.

85 Ibid., xlix (1829), 44752. Cf. Schneewind, J. B., Sidgwick's Ethics and Victorian Moral Philosophy (Oxford, 1977), 1668Google Scholar.

86 Wellek, R., Immanuel Kant in England 17931838 (Princeton, 1931), 16471, 183202Google Scholar; Park, Roy, Hazlitt and Bentham, Journal of the History of Ideas, xxx (1969), 373Google Scholar.

87 Hazlitt, William, The Plain Speaker (2 vols, 1826), I. 11215Google Scholar.

88 Rossi, Pellegrino, Trait de droit pnal (3 vols, Paris, 1829), I. 176, 178Google Scholar.

89 Bentham, , Tactique des assembles lgislatives, suivie d'un Trait des sophismes politiques, ed. Dumont, (2nd edn., 2 vols, Geneva, 1822), II. 255369Google Scholar; Revue Encyclopdique, xix (1823), 57885Google Scholar.

90 He admitted this to Dumont at a dinner party in Paris in 1817: MS. Dumont 16, f. 9.

91 Benjamin, Constant, Principes de politique applicables tous les gomernements, ed. Hofmann, E. (Geneva, 1980), 5960Google Scholar. The passage appears to have been written in 1802; it was published in the Mercure de France, Nov. 1817, 2489.

92 Constant, Mlanges de littrature et de politique (Paris, 1829), 148Google Scholar.

93 de Stal, Auguste, Lettres sur l'Angleterre (Paris, 1825), 3235Google Scholar.

94 Ibid., 310.

95 E.g. L' Utilitaire, i (1829), 399401Google Scholar.

96 Dumont to Bentham, 21 Aug. 1822, Bentham MSS., X, 128. Dumont added (to Bentham, 28 Nov. 1822, ibid., CLXXIV, 70) that the main objection to the word utility was le malheureux liaison vulgaire tabli entre ce mot et l'intrt personnel.

97 Remarks on Bentham's Philosophy, in Bulwer, E. L., England and the English (2 vols, 1833), II. 33941Google Scholar.

98 de Stal, Germaine, De l'Allemagne (3 vols, Paris, 1813), III. 18nGoogle Scholar. Cf. Norman King, The airy form of things forgotten; de Stal, Madame, l'utilitarisme et l'impulsion librale, Cahiers staliens, no. 11 (1970), 526Google Scholar.

99 Revue Encyclopdique, xliv (1829), 2634Google Scholar.

100 J.-B. Say to Dumont, 10 Aug. 1829, MS. Dumont 77, f. 9; Say, Mlanges et correspondence d'conomie politique, ed. Comte, Charles (Paris, 1833), 36274, 40641Google Scholar.

101 Hazlitt, , The Plain Speaker, I. 11415, 438Google Scholar; Morning Post, 24 Aug. 1835, reprinted in Whigs and Whiggism: Political Writings by Benjamin Disraeli, ed. William Hutcheon (1913), 50.