Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T14:03:09.877Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

General De Gaulle and his Enemies: Antigaullism in France Since 1940

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Julian Jackson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On the centenary of General de Gaulle's birth in November 1990, hundreds of historians, politicians and statesmen gathered in Paris to discuss his life. Their deliberations were published in seven volumes running to several thousand pages. The participants included former opponents who now declared themselves ‘posthumous Gaullists’ or ‘remorseful’ ones. The whole occasion seemed to fulfil André Malraux's prediction: ‘Everyone is, has been or will become Gaullist.’ Of those who were not, never had been, or would never become Gaullist, little was said.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 9 , December 1999 , pp. 43 - 65
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1999

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Institut de Gaulle, Charles, De Gaulle en son siècle, 7 vols (Paris, 1991–1992)Google Scholar. For the posthumous Gaullists, , see vol. 1, De la mémoire des hommes et des peuples, 525–31Google Scholar.

2 Figueras, A., De Gaulle l'Impuissant (Paris, 1970)Google Scholar.

3 Isorni, J., Jusqu'au bout de notre peine (Paris, 1963), 130Google Scholar. Also Maurice Bardèche in Vandromme, Pol, La Droite buissomère (Paris, 1960), 63Google Scholar.

4 The exceptions are the unpublished thesis by Foro, P. ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme. Réalités et représentations (1940–1953)’, Doctorate, University of Toulouse II, 1997Google Scholar; and ‘Les AntiGaullistes’, in De Gaulle en son siècle, vol. VII, 357–80Google Scholar. I would also like to thank Richard Vinen for showing me his unpublished paper on right-wing anti-Gaullism.

5 La Nation française, 4 November 1959.

6 Documents nationaux, June 1946.

7 Courtois, S. and Lazar, M., Cinquante ans d'une passion française: de Gaulle et les Communistes (Paris, 1991)Google Scholar.

8 Foro, , ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme’, 258Google Scholar.

9 Mouillaud, M., La Mystification (Paris, 1958)Google Scholar; De Gaulle: ce qu'il est, ce qu'il vent (Paris, 1958)Google Scholar.

10 Claude, H., Gaullisme et Grand Capital (Paris, 1960)Google Scholar; Duclos, J., Gaullisme, technocratie, corpomtisme (Paris, 1963)Google Scholar.

11 Lazar, M., ‘De Gaulle et les Communistes: confrontation de deux légitimités’, in De Gaulle en son siècle, vol. II, 328–39Google Scholar, and Courtois, S., ‘Le PCF et le Gaullisme: 1958–1969’, 340–56Google Scholar.

12 Kriegel, A., ‘Un Phénomène de haine fratricide: Léon Blum vu par les Communistes’ in Kriegel, A., et les roses (Paris, 1968)Google Scholar.

13 Nora, P., ‘Gaullistes et Communistes’, in Nora, P. (ed.), Les Lieux de mémoire III. Les France. I. Conflits et partages (Paris, 1992), 347–93Google Scholar.

14 Pineau, C. in Wieviorka, O., Nous entrerons dans la carrière. De la Résistance à l'exercice du poiuvoir (Paris, 1994), 260Google Scholar.

15 Ravanel, S., Esprit de la Résistance (Paris, 1995), 203Google Scholar.

16 Bourdet, , L'Aventure incertaine: de la Résistance à la Restauration (Paris, 1975), 202, 412, 418Google Scholar; also Frenay, H., La Nuit finra (Paris, 1973), 561–2Google Scholar.

17 Wieviorka, , Nous entrerons, 364Google Scholar.

18 Vistel, A., L'Héritage spirituel de la Résistance (Lyon, 1955), 58Google Scholar. See also Viannay, P. [Indomitus], Nous sommes des rebelles (Paris, 1945)Google Scholar; Pineau in Wieviorka, O., Nous entrerons, 27Google Scholar; Wieviorka, O., ‘Du Bon usage du passé. Résistance, politique, mémoire’, Mots, 32 (1992), 67–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Gillois, A., Histoire sécrète des Français à Londres (Paris, 1972), 52Google Scholar.

20 Aron, R., Chroniques de guerre: la France libre 1940–1945 (Paris, 1990)Google Scholar.

21 Foro, , ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme’ 165–6Google Scholar.

22 Muselier, , De Gaulle contre le gaullisme (Paris, 1948)Google Scholar.

23 de Kérillis, H., De Gaulle dictateur (Montreal, 1945)Google Scholar. See also Boulic, J.-Y. and Lavaure, A., Henri de Kérillis. L'Absolu patriote (Rennes, 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Foro, , ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme’, 105–6, 119–20Google Scholar; , J. P. and Cointet, M., La France à Londres 1940–1943 (Brussels, 1990) 110–11Google Scholar; Allard, P., Ici-Londres (Paris, 1942)Google Scholar.

25 Foro, , ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme’, 108Google Scholar.

26 Special issue of the collaborationist Notre combat pour la Nouvelle France socialiste, November 1942, devoted to Gaullism.

27 The Resistance publishing house had been called Editions de Minuit; the anti-Gaullist Alfred Fabre-Luce published his writings under the imprint Editions de Midi.

28 Rougier, L., Le Bilan du Gaullisme (n.p., 1946)Google Scholar; La France jacobine (Brussels/Paris, 1947)Google Scholar; La Défaite des vainqueurs (Paris/Brussels, 1947)Google Scholar; De Gaulle contre de Gaulle (Paris, 1948)Google Scholar.

29 Bardéche, M., Lettre à François Mauriac (Paris, 1947), 173Google Scholar.

30 Rivarol, 8 February 1951.

31 Bardèche, , Lettre, 183Google Scholar.

32 Fabre-Luce, A., Le Plus illustre des Français (Paris, 1960), 22Google Scholar.

33 Documents nationaux, April 1946.

34 Girard, L.-D., Montoire. Verdun diplomatique (Paris, 1948)Google Scholar.

35 Fabre-Luce, A., Au Nom des silencieux (Paris, 1945), 118Google Scholar.

36 Fabre-Luce, , Le Plus illustre, 60Google Scholar.

37 Défense de l'Occident, January 1953.

38 Weygand, M., Recalled to Service (1952), 220Google Scholar.

39 Documents nationaux, April 1946.

40 Rougier, , Le Bilan, 16Google Scholar.

41 Rougier, , De Gaulle, 93Google Scholar.

42 Documents nationaux, April 1946.

43 Rivarol, 26 April 1951.

44 Desgranges, J.-M., Les Crimes masqués du ‘Résistentialisme’ (Paris, 1948)Google Scholar.

45 Recent versions of this line are Giraud, H.-C., De Gaulle et les Communistes, 2 vols (Paris, 1988–1989)Google Scholar, and Ronzyé, H., Gaullisme ou gaulchévisme (Paris, 1995)Google Scholar.

46 Fabre-Luce, A., Gaulle deux (Paris, 1958)Google Scholar; Le Plus illustre des Français (Paris, 1960)Google Scholar; Haut cour (Paris, 0000)Google Scholar; Le Général en Sorbonne (Paris, 1960)Google Scholar. See also Vingt-cinq ans de liberté III. La Récompense 1946–61 (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar; Au Nom des silencieux (Paris, 1944)Google Scholar; Double prison (Paris, 1945)Google Scholar.

47 Documents nationaux, November 1945.

48 Foro, , ‘L'Anti-Gaullisme’, 231–76Google Scholar.

49 Bigegaray, C. and Isoart, P., Les Droites et le Génêral de Gaulle (Paris, 1991), 26Google Scholar.

50 Réalisme, II December 1948.

51 For example, Réalisme, 15 February 1948.

52 Rivarol, 8 February 1951.

53 Défense de l'Occident, No. I, December 1952.

54 Rivarol, II May, 29 May 1958. A similar line was taken by Dacier, M. in Ecrits de Paris, 06 1958Google Scholar.

55 Isorni, J., Ainsi passent les républiques (Paris, 1959)Google Scholar.

56 Rivarol, 14 August 1958, II September 1958.

57 Rivarol, 16 October 1958.

58 Ecrits de Paris, December 1961.

59 Girardet, R., ‘L'Héritage de l'Action Française’, Revue française de science politique, vii, 4 (1957). 765–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 La Nation française, 18 July 1956.

61 Salleron, Louis, a former supporter of the Vichy, wrote that he supported de Gaulle for the same reasons he had supported Pétain: La Nation française, 28 01 1959Google Scholar.

62 La Nation française, 7 October 1959.

63 Girardet, R., Singulièrement libre (Paris, 1990), 135Google Scholar.

64 La Nation française, 7 December 1960.

65 Soustelle, J., L'Espérance trahie 1958–1961 (Paris, 1962)Google Scholar.

66 Défense de l'Occident, February 1962.

67 Rougier, , De Gaulle, 16, 20, 82Google Scholar; Bilan du Gaullisme, 28.

68 Rivarol, 13 April 1961.

69 Pleyber, , Esprit publique, 03 1961Google Scholar.

70 Rivarol, 30 October 1958, 2 July 1960, 25 July 1960.

71 Esprit publique, 23 December 1960. Also Mery, [Girardet] in La Nation française, 18 03 1960Google Scholar.

72 Rivarol, 6 October 1960.

73 The government survived a censure motion on nuclear policy in October 1960.

74 The debate was held on 4 October 1962.

75 Reynaud, P., La Politique étrangère du gaullisme (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar.

76 Esprit Public, November 1962. Boutang criticised de Gaulle's, ‘machine of police dictatorship’ and his move to totalitarian dictatorship of one party: La Nation française, 17 10 1962, 14 November 1962Google Scholar. Bardèche, , however, criticised him for consolidating democracy: he was a replay of Doumergue or Macmahon: Défense de l'Occident, 05 1958, January 1959Google Scholar.

77 Perret, , L'Esprit Publique, 06 1963Google Scholar.

78 See, respectively, the articles of Aimel, G. and Pleyber, J., Ecrits de Paris, 03 1961Google Scholar.

79 Défense de l'Occident, March 1964.

80 Right-wing leader cited in Vinen's unpublished paper, 15.

81 Rivarol, 16 December 1965, reminded its readers (incorrectly) that however distasteful Mitterrand might be, he did at least have a Cagoulard past.

82 On the choices of the extreme right groups in the first round, see Europe Action supplement of December 1965. Esprit publique supported the centrist turn which led to another split and the departure of the more right-wing elements. The paper folded in February 1966. In general, see Duprat, F., Les Mouvements d'extrême droite en France depuis 1944 (Paris, 1972)Google Scholar; Bergeron, F. and Vilgier, P., De le Pen à le Pen (Paris, 1985)Google Scholar.

83 Laurent, J., Mauriac sous de Gaulle (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar; and Année 40. Londres, de Gaulle, Vichy (Paris, 1965)Google Scholar. See also Histoire égoïste (Paris, 1976)Google Scholar.

84 Duprat, , Les Mouvements, 162Google Scholar.

85 Rivarol, 16 May 1968.

86 Rivarol, 6 June 1968.

87 Europe action, January 1963, March 1963.

88 Défense de l'Occident, June/August 1968.

89 L'Esprit publique, July /August 1961.

90 Ariés, P., Historien de Dimanche (Paris, 1980), 184Google Scholar. See also Fay, Bernard in Ecrits de Paris, 08 1968Google Scholar.

91 L'Esprit publique, January 1963.

92 Duras, M., La Douleur (Paris, 1986), 32–3Google Scholar.

93 Ecrits de Paris, June 1990.

94 Mitterrand, F., Le Coup d'Etat permanent (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar.

95 Mitterrand, F., Ma Part de vérité (Paris, 1969), 23–4Google Scholar; also Mitterrand in Wieviorka, , Nous entrerons, 343–5Google Scholar.

96 Conan, E. and Rousso, H., Un Passé qui ne passe pas (Paris, 1994), 187Google Scholar.

97 Pean, P., Une Jeunesse française. François Mitterrand 1934–1947 (Paris, 1994)Google Scholar.

98 Conan and Rousso, Un Passé quine passe pas Mitterrand's last thoughts on the subject were: Mitterrand, F., Mémoires interrompues (Paris, 1996), 70–82, 123–4Google Scholar.

99 Le Figaro, 21 October 1998.