Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T13:41:56.037Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Prehumanism of Benzo D'Alessandria

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 July 2016

J. R. Berrigan*
Affiliation:
University of Georgia

Extract

Any discussion of the intellectual life in fourteenth-century Italy is inevitably directed by the personality and achievement of Petrarch. Although we no longer believe that a whole new age begins with him, although we recognize considerable medieval elements in his work, we still regard him as the father of the strongest movement in the Renaissance–humanism. After his long years of succesful work, that was at once well publicized and well remunerated, there could be no inversion of the hour-glass. From him there proceeded the splendid parade of Boccaccio, Salutati, Guarino, and Bruni. There can be no quarrel with the general truth of this Petrarchan primacy, but, as in all historical abstractions, there are some unfortunate results. These are particularly prevalent in the decades before Petrarch. His shadow is over the whole period. We have difficulty in appreciating his predecessors as anything but precursors. If we resist the temptation to dismiss them all as unimportant, we are nonetheless constrained to deal with them as relative to a later Petrarch, as the very term prehumanism implies. The period is obscure enough without adding this element of ambiguity to it. Unable to jettison the term, we can still underline its inadequacy and establish the substantial nature of the movement, even without reference to Petrarch.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Fordham University Press 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See Weiss, Roberto, The Dawn of Humanism in Italy (London 1947); on the Capitular Library of Verona, see my ‘Verona and the Classicist,’ Classical Bulletin 42 (1965) 1–4. The prize of the Capitular was its codex of Catullus, on which see Ullman, B. L., ‘Hieremias de Montagnone and his Citations from Catullus,’ Studies in the Italian Renaissance (Storia e letteratura 51; Rome 1955) 81–115 (originally published in Classical Philology 5 [1910] 66–82); Ullman cites the earlier article of Hale, W. G., ‘Benzo of Alexandria and Catullus,’ ibid. 56–65.Google Scholar

2 da Pastrengo, Guglielmo, Libellus de originibus rerum (Venice 1547) 16; with adaptations, Guglielmo quotes from Catullus, Carm. 1.5–7. For the bibliography on Benzo, see Costanza, Mario, Biographical and Bibliographical Dictionary of the Italian Humanists … (Boston 1962) I 519, V 250. For further aspects of Benzo's work, see my recent articles: ‘The Trojan War in the Chronicon of Benzo d'Alessandria,’ Classical Journal 61 (1966) 219–221; ‘Mythology in Benzo d'Alessandria,’ Classical World 60 (1967) 366–367.Google Scholar

3 Bugati, G., Memorie storico-critiche intorno alle reliquie ed il culto di S. Celso (Milan 1782) 132. On the fourteenth-century Dominican Galvaneo Fiamma, see my ‘Benzo d'Alessandria and the Cities of Northern Italy,’ Studies in Medieval and Renaissance History 4 (1967) 136–137 (for the complete text, pp. 127–192), an article (referred to below simply as Studies) in which the text of a portion of Benzo's Chronicon is published, principally that of Lib. XIV, Cap. cxxxvi-clxi; see also Potthast, A., Wegweiser durch die Geschichtswerke des europäischen Mittelalters bis 1500 I (2nd ed., Berlin 1895) 489. Fiamma's reference to Benzo's work is referred to by Ferrai, L., ‘Benzo d'Alessandria e i cronisti milanesi del secolo xiv,’ Bullettino dell' Istituto storico Italiano 7 (1889) 105; the passage is from a lost version of Fiamma's Chronica maior: ‘In hac Bencius Alexandrinus, notarius episcopi Leonis de Lambertenghis, ordinis Minorum, magnam scripsit chronicam….’ The reader may wish to be reminded that, according to arguments given by Sabbadini, R., Le scoperte dei codici latini e greci II (Florence 1914) 130, only a portion of Benzo's Chronicon survives in the Ambrosian MS.Google Scholar

4 Rajna, P., ‘II teatro di Milano e i canti intorno ad Orlando ed Ulivieri,’ Archivio storico Lombardo 14 (1887) 20.Google Scholar

5 Biscaro, G., ‘Benzo da Alessandria e i giudizi contro i ribelli dell' impero a Milano nel 1311,’ Archivio storico Lombardo 34 (1907) 36; Ferrai, L., ‘Benzo d'Alessandria’ 112.Google Scholar

6 Benzo, f. 113r: ‘Nam si ceteras in hoc opere conscribendo provincias hanc inmemoratiam obmitterem in qua patriam sum sortitus posset michi ascribi ingrati civis officium.’ This and subsequent references are to the leaves of the MS Ambros. B 24 inf., which I cite from microfilm made available by the Biblioteca Ambrosiana.Google Scholar

7 Rajna, , ‘II teatro di Milano’ 20.Google Scholar

8 See below, p. 255.Google Scholar

9 Benzo, f. 146r ; Berrigan, , Studies 155. (Where the passage cited from Benzo has been published in Studies, I refer, as here, to the pages of that article.) Google Scholar

10 Ibid., f. 147v; Studies 168169.Google Scholar

11 Ibid., f. 146r; Studies 158.Google Scholar

12 Ibid., f. 146v; Studies 161.Google Scholar

13 Sabbadini, R., ‘Benzo d'Alessandria: Appunti,’ Studi medievali 2 (1907) 575576.Google Scholar

14 Benzo, f. 149v ; Studies 180.Google Scholar

15 Ibid., f. 139v .Google Scholar

16 Ibid., f. 212v .Google Scholar

17 Ibid., f. 233r. Book XXI is a prose version of Statius' Thebaid; in this passage Benzo reveals his mode of operation. In the previous May he had done a preliminary rendition of the poem; in April of 1320 he had taken the task up again and had finished Book XXI on May 9th.Google Scholar

18 Ibid., f. 148r; Studies 171.Google Scholar

19 Biscaro, , ‘Benzo da Alessandria’ 8.Google Scholar

20 Sabbadini, , ‘Benzo d'Alessandria,’ Enciclopedia Italiana (1931) 6.665.Google Scholar

21 Benzo, f. 150v ; Studies 188.Google Scholar

22 Savio, F., ‘La Cronaca di Filippo da Castel Seprio,’ Atti della R. Accademia delle scienze di Torino 41 (1906) 14.Google Scholar

23 Benzo, f. 149v ; Studies 179: ‘Facit querere retro in decimo folio; quesivi et non inveni.’ Google Scholar

24 Ferrai, , ‘Benzo d'Alessandria’ 106.Google Scholar

25 Savio, , ‘La Cronaca’ 14.Google Scholar

26 Possibly Can Grande's campaign of 1317; see Studies 179.Google Scholar

27 A misreading of this passage made Benzo into a Franciscan. See above at n. 5.Google Scholar

28 See above at n. 3.Google Scholar

29 See Studies 129 n. 7.Google Scholar

30 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

31 Vatican Archives, A. A. Arm. C, 539.Google Scholar

32 Savio, , ‘La Cronaca’ 15.Google Scholar

33 Ferrai, , ‘Benzo d'Alessandria’ 108.Google Scholar

34 Biscaro, , ‘Benzo da Alessandria’ 36.Google Scholar

35 Mussato, A., De gestis Italicorum, RIS1 10 (Milan 1727) 715.Google Scholar

36 Ibid. 768.Google Scholar

37 Cipolla, C., ‘Attorno a Giovanni Mansionario e a Guglielmo da Pastrengo,’ Miscellanea Ceriani (Milan 1910) 746.Google Scholar

38 Weiss, , The Dawn of Humanism 14.Google Scholar

39 His most important and abundant source was the Capitular Library of Verona, on which see above n. 1.Google Scholar

40 Benzo, f. 140v .Google Scholar

41 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

42 Ibid., f. 141r; it is regrettable that no account is taken of this chapter on Rome in the four volumes of Valentini, R. - Zucchetti, G., Codice topografico della città di Roma (Rome 1940–1953).Google Scholar

43 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

44 Ibid. f. 142v: ‘quamquam et vetustate et incursibus hostium et ab ipsis eciam civibus ac a summis pontificibus et imperatoribus multa sunt consumpta et pariter deformata.’ Google Scholar

45 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

46 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

47 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

48 Loc. cit. The quotation from Ausonius is an adaptation of 11.1, a single-line characterization of the city: ‘Prima urbes inter, divum domus, aurea Roma.’ Google Scholar

49 Loc. cit. For this famous leonine hexameter, see Walther, Hans, Initia carminum ac versuum medii aevi posterioris latinorum … (Carmina medii aevi posterioris latina 1; Göttingen 1959) no. 16838.Google Scholar

50 Ibid., f. 139r: ‘Luca Tuscie lucida civitas dicta est secundum Hugucionem a loco quodam maris, qui Lucus dicitur, unde delati fuerunt quidam a quibus Lucenses originem habuerunt. Alii dicunt quia tempore nativitatis Christi vocabatur Auringa, sed quia prius pervenit ad fidem et primitus episcopum ab apostolica sede recepit et prima reluxit in fide, inde fuit Luca ab hominibus nuncupata.’ For the De origine civitatis , see Hartwig, O., Quellen und Forschungen zur ältesten Geschichte der Stadt Florenz I (Marburg 1875) 3763.Google Scholar

51 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

52 Loc. cit. Google Scholar

53 Renucci, P., Dante disciple et juge du monde grécolatin (Paris 1954) 59.Google Scholar

54 Benzo, , f. 139v .Google Scholar

55 Rubinstein, N., ‘The Beginnings of Political Thought in Florence,’ Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 5 (1942) 198227.Google Scholar

56 Latini, Brunetto, Li Livres du Tresor, ed. Carmody, F. (Berkeley and Los Angeles 1948) I 37.Google Scholar

57 Inferno 26.1–3.Google Scholar

58 Purgatorio 6.136138.Google Scholar

59 Paradiso 15.97126.Google Scholar

60 Benzo, , f. 139v .Google Scholar

61 Inferno 15.6163, 73–78.Google Scholar

62 Benzo, , f. 139v .Google Scholar