Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-07T23:31:53.524Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Influence of Ramon Lull and Jan van Ruysbroeck on the Language of the Spanish Mystics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 July 2017

Helmut A. Hatzfeld*
Affiliation:
The Catholic University of America

Extract

The originality of the imaginative concepts, terms and symbols of the classical Spanish mystics has elicited several philological approaches. All of them try to explain or rather to account for this originality. Each of these different methods, however, is characterized by a striking onesidedness and exclusiveness of view. In order to find out where further research has to start from, it is necessary first to review the attempts of investigation made till now. They may be designated as the non-historic, the synthetic, the secular, the Arabic and the Germanic theses.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 1946 by Cosmopolitan Science & Art Service Co., Inc. 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The works of the following mystics will be discussed:Google Scholar

2 Baruzi, Jean, Saint Jean de la Croix et le problème de l'experience mystique (deuxième ed. Paris 1931).Google Scholar

3 de Jesús, Santa Teresa, El libro de su vida ch. 17 (ed. Santullano, Luis, Obras completas, Madrid 1940, p. 62a).Google Scholar

4 Ibid. ch. 11, p. 38a.Google Scholar

5 Etchegoyèn, Gaston, L'amour divin. Essai sur les sources de Sainte Thérèse (Paris 1923).Google Scholar

6 Pidal, Ramón Menéndez, El estilo de Santa Teresa (La lengua de Cristóbal Colón y otros estudios, Buenos Aires 1942) 144.Google Scholar

7 Alonso, Dámaso, La poesía de San Juan de la Cruz (Madrid 1942).Google Scholar

8 Palacios, Miguel Asín, El Islam cristianizado (Madrid 1931).Google Scholar

9 Massignon, Louis, Essai sur les origines du lexique technique de la mystique musulmane (Paris 1922) 35; Arberry, Arthur J., An Introduction to the History of Sufism (London 1942) 53–57.Google Scholar

10 de la Nativité, Père Elisée, ‘L'expérience mystique d'Ibn Arabî est-elle surnaturelle,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 17 (1931) II, 136168.Google Scholar

11 Palacios, Asín, Islam 530ff. I am grateful for the literal translations to Rev. Drs. Edward P. Arbez and Patrick Skehan of Catholic University. Dr. Arbez draws my attention particularly to Dozy, R., Supplément aux Dictionnaires Arabes I (Leiden-Paris 1927) 184b-185a: tağrid = ‘quitter le monde, aller vivre dans la retraite et la pauvreté …, se délivrer de la conscience de sa propre individualité, etc.’ Google Scholar

12 Asín Palacios, M., ‘Un précürseur hispano-musulman de Saint Jean de la Croix,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 17 (1932) II, 113167.Google Scholar

13 Ibid. 135.Google Scholar

14 Ibid. 136.Google Scholar

15 Histoire littéraire de la France 29 (Paris 1885) 1386.Google Scholar

16 Arberry, , op. cit . 6.Google Scholar

17 Lull, Ramon, El llibre d'Amic e Amat (Els Nostres Classics, Barcelona 1927) 25.Google Scholar

18 Asín Palacios, M., ‘El lulismo exagerado,’ Cultura Española I (1906), 533541.Google Scholar

19 Palacios, Asín, Islam 219220.Google Scholar

20 Ribera, Julián, ‘Orígenes de la filosofía de Ramón Lulio,’ Homenaje a Menéndez Pelayo (Madrid 1899) 191216.Google Scholar

21 Sáinz Rodriguez, P., Introducción a la historia de la Literatura mística en España (Madrid 1927) 170, 173.Google Scholar

22 Ibid. 188.Google Scholar

23 Lulio, Ramón, El libro del Amigo y del Amado (Madrid 1940), Introducción 19.Google Scholar

24 Groult, Pierre, Les mystiques des Pays-Bas et la littérature espagnole du seizième siècle (Louvain 1927).Google Scholar

25 Ibid. 242.Google Scholar

26 D'Asbeck, Melline, La mystique de Ruysbroeck l'Admirable. Un echo du Néoplatonisme au XIVe siècle (Paris 1930).Google Scholar

27 Sáinz Rodriguez, P., Introducción 244.Google Scholar

28 de Montoliu, Manuel, El alma de España (Barcelona s.d.) 674.Google Scholar

29 Reypens, L. S.J., ‘Ruusbroec en Juan de la Cruz: Hun overeenstemming omtrent het toppunt der beschouwing,’ Ons geestelijk erf 5 (1931) 143185: The principal coincidence is supposed to be the concept of the unio mystica as a participation in the trinitarian life, different, however, from the beatific vision.Google Scholar

30 ‘Ruysbroeck et Saint Jean de la Croix,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 17 (1932) 234.Google Scholar

31 Baruzi, , St. Jean de la Croix 144.Google Scholar

32 Joaquin Sanchís Albentosa, Fr. O.F.M., ‘La escuela mística alemana y sus relaciones con los místicos de nuestro siglo de oro: Ruysbroeck,’ Verdad y vida 2 (1944) 290.Google Scholar

33 de la Cruz, San Juan, Noche oscura del alma, book 2, ch. 18 (ed. Bernardo de la Virgen del Carmen, P. y Silverio de Santa Teresa, P., Obras, Buenos Aires 1942:1, 540).Google Scholar

34 Cántico espiritual , canción 26, ibid. II, 190.Google Scholar

35 Poem: Entréme donde no supe, ibid. II, 510.Google Scholar

36 Silverio de Santa Teresa, P., La doctrina de Santa Teresa (Madrid 1944) 39, 45.Google Scholar

37 de Osuna, Francisco, Tercer Abecedario Espiritual (ed. Miguel, Mir, Escritores místicos españoles, in Nueva Biblioteca de Autores Españoles 16, Madrid 1911, pp. 378a-380a).Google Scholar

38 de la Cruz, San Juan, Puntos de amor , Obras II, 441.Google Scholar

39 Cántico espiritual , Obras II, 61.Google Scholar

40 Lull, Ramon, Art amativa (ed. Obrador, M. y Bennassar, y Moss. Salvador Galmés, Obres, 20 vols. Palma de Mallorca 1906–1938; vol. 17: 1933).Google Scholar

41 Llibre de Sancta Maria , Obres 9 (1915) 125.Google Scholar

42 Lull, Ramon, Poesies (ed. Moner, Ramon d'Alos, Els Nostres Classics, Barcelona 1925, pp. 3031).Google Scholar

43 Pfandl, Ludwig, Geschichte der spanischen Nationalliteratur der Blütezeit (Freiburg 1929) 148.Google Scholar

44 van Ruusbroec, Jan, De gheestelijke brulocht (ed. Poukens, J. B. S.J., Reypens, L. S.J., Stracke, D. A. S.J., Schurman, M. S.J., van Mierlo, J. S.J., Werken, 4 vols. Mechelen-Amsterdam 1932–1934: I, 170).Google Scholar

45 El Islam cristianizado 237, 515.Google Scholar

46 Art amativa , Obres 17, 155, no. 7.Google Scholar

47 Ibid. no. 11.Google Scholar

48 Ibid. 171, no. 162.Google Scholar

49 Ibid. 299, no. 793.Google Scholar

50 Ibid. 281, no. 571.Google Scholar

51 Ibid. 176, no. 214.Google Scholar

52 Ibid. 373, 20a questió.Google Scholar

53 Oracions de Ramon , Obres 18, 333.Google Scholar

54 Histoire Littéraire de la France 29 (Paris 1885) 15.Google Scholar

55 Ibid. 5.Google Scholar

56 Rims , Obres 19, 265.Google Scholar

57 Vida, ch. 18, Obras, p. 67a.Google Scholar

58 Amic e Amat 89, no. 298.Google Scholar

59 Hores de Sancta Maria , Obres 10, 261.Google Scholar

60 Alonso, Dámaso, Poesía 233.Google Scholar

61 Poem: Entréme , Obras II, 510.Google Scholar

62 Cf. de Castel, Jean, De adhaerendo Deo.Google Scholar

63 Teresa, Santa, Obras 643a–b.Google Scholar

64 Llibre de Contemplació, ch. 102, Obres II, 232236.Google Scholar

65 Vida, Obras 65a.Google Scholar

66 Rodríguez, Sáinz, Introducción 99.Google Scholar

67 de León, Luis, Los nombres de Cristo (ed. de Onís, F., Madrid 1931; II, 217218).Google Scholar

68 Meyer-Lübke, Wilhelm, Romanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch (3d ed. Heidelbe 1935) no. 548, 44b.Google Scholar

69 Tercer Abecedario 380b-381a.Google Scholar

70 Palmer, E. H., Oriental Mysticism, A Treatise on the Sufistic and Unitarian Theosop (2nd ed. London 1938) 71.Google Scholar

71 Arbre de filosofia d'amor , Obres 18, 75.Google Scholar

72 Ibid. 77.Google Scholar

73 Ibid. 157.Google Scholar

74 Art amativa, Obres 256.Google Scholar

75 Ibid. 236.Google Scholar

76 Arbre de filosofia d'amor , Obres 18, 76.Google Scholar

77 Cántico espiritual, canc. 12, Obras II, 84.Google Scholar

78 Peers, Edgar Allison, The Complete Works of Saint John of the Cross (London 1934) II, 65.Google Scholar

79 Cántico espiritual , Obras II, 85.Google Scholar

80 Crisógono, P., La doctrina de Santa Teresa 5052.Google Scholar

81 Llibre de Benedicta tu , Obres 10, 301.Google Scholar

82 Llibre de demonstracions , Obres 14, 31.Google Scholar

83 Alonso, Dámaso, Poesía 383.Google Scholar

84 Ibid. 385.Google Scholar

85 Ibid. 384.Google Scholar

88 Rohlfs, Gerhard, Sprache und Kultur (Braunschweig 1928) 15.Google Scholar

87 Ibid. 15.Google Scholar

88 Palacios, Asín, Islam 459.Google Scholar

89 Güntert, Hermann, Kalypso, Bedeutungsgeschichtliche Untersuchungen (Halle 1919) 231.Google Scholar

90 Cántico espiritual , Obras II, 73.Google Scholar

91 Güntert, , Kalypso 231.Google Scholar

92 Cántico espiritual , canc. 24, Obras II, 506.Google Scholar

93 Palacios, Asín, Islam 497.Google Scholar

94 Lull, Ramon, Llibre de Blanquerna, book 1, ch. 1, Obres 9, 9.Google Scholar

95 Ibid. book 2, ch. 42, Obres 9, 132.Google Scholar

96 Art amativa , Obres 17, 294, no. 734.Google Scholar

97 Vida, ch. 28, Obras 112a.Google Scholar

98 Amic e Amat 101, no. 349.Google Scholar

99 Moradas, book 1, ch. 2, Obras 327b.Google Scholar

100 Vida, ch. 40, Obras 189a.Google Scholar

101 Horten, M., Texte zu dem Streite von Glauben und Wissen im Islam (Bonn 1913) 3, 6; texts from Alfârâbi.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

102 Palmer, E. H., Oriental Mysticism 70.Google Scholar

103 Cántico espiritual, canc. 26, Obras II, 187.Google Scholar

104 Art amativa , Obres 17, 158, no. 33.Google Scholar

105 Also ibid. 85, no. 282: ‘Bevia l'amic amor en la font de son amat.’ Google Scholar

106 Art amativa , Obres 17, 176.Google Scholar

107 Amic e Amat 30, no. 21.Google Scholar

108 de la Cruz, San Juan, Cántico espiritual, canc. 26, Obras II, 189.Google Scholar

109 Ibid. canc. 12, Obras II, 8788.Google Scholar

110 Obras II, 514 with the addition, however, of strophe 2 from the Sanlúcar manuscript. P. Silverio's critical text has found many competent objections (Dom Chevalier, Allison Peers). If one omits strophe 2, the poem turns to become a eucharistic poem. But strophe 9ff.—‘Aquesta eterna fonte está escondida/En este vivo pan por darnos vida’—certainly does not mean that the mystic in his dark night has the consolation to know that the fountain of life flows in the Blessed Sacrament. Otherwise Saint John of the Cross could not say: ‘Cuando me pienso aliviar/De verte en el Sacramento/Háceme más sentimiento/El no te poder gozar;/Todo es para más penar/Por no verte como quiero’ (Vivo sin vivir en mí, Obras II, 512).Google Scholar

The true meaning is that God, in the scintilla animae of the mystic during the dark night, is equally present as in the Blessed Sacrament: ontologically real but ‘in darkness’, i.e. not experienced except por fe. And the poet's longing, despite all the statements about the hidden place of the fount, is for the experienced unio mystica.

111 Alonso, Dámaso, Poesía 124.Google Scholar

112 Ibid. 21.Google Scholar

113 Llama de amor viva, canc. 3, Obras II, 347, 348.Google Scholar

114 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 25.Google Scholar

115 De gheestelike brulocht, Werken I, 178.Google Scholar

116 Het rijcke der phelieven, Werken I, 25.Google Scholar

117 Ibid. 58.Google Scholar

118 De gheestelike brulocht, Werken I, 122. Another example which shows that the water of the Divine fount of love is hot like burning love—which accounts for San Juan's mixing up the images of water and fire—is found in the book Vanden XlI Beghinen: ‘Die … riviere der gracien Gods vloeyt uten heilighen Gheest: die es heet ende claer ende vloeyt … in onse binnenste.’ Werken IV, 151.Google Scholar

119 Vida, ch. 15, Obras 54a.Google Scholar

120 von der Leyen, Fr, ‘Unbekannte Predigten Meister Eckeharts,’ Zeitschrift fur deutsche Philologie 38 (1906) 189f.Google Scholar

121 l'Admirable, Ruysbroeck, Oeuvres (Traduites du flammand par les Bénedictins de St.-Paul-de-Wisques, Bruxelles 1921) II, 17, and Van den gheesteliken tabernakel, Werken II, p. xliii.Google Scholar

122 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 3, Obras I, 470.Google Scholar

123 Cántico espiritual, Obras II, 186.Google Scholar

124 Van den gheesteliken tabernakel, Werken II, end of the treatise.Google Scholar

126 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 25.Google Scholar

126 de Osuna, Fr., Tercer Abecedario 429a.Google Scholar

127 Teresa, Santa, Moradas, book 4, ch. 3, Obras 349b-350a. Three lines later, Santa Teresa continues with a striking Ruysbroeckian simile, where the powers of the soul are compared to the common people in the king's castle which is on the outskirts: ‘Hagamos cuenta que estos sentidos y potencias … son la gente de este castillo …,’ ibid. 350a; 'en la ronda del castillo; ibid. 325a.—‘Dat ghemeyne volk dies rijcken dat sijn alle die crachte der zielen.’ Gheestelijke Brulocht, Werken I, 137.Google Scholar

128 D'Asbeck, Melline, La mystique de Ruysbroeck 285, quoting from Der spieghel der ewigher salicheit, ch. XVII.Google Scholar

129 Groult, P., Les mystiques des Pays-Bas 208.Google Scholar

130 Berger, Kurt, Die Ausdrücke der Unio mystica im Mittelhochdeutschen (Berlin 1935) 58.Google Scholar

131 Groult, P., Les mystiques des Pays-Bas 243.Google Scholar

132 de los Angeles, Juan, Diálogos de la Conquista del Reino de Dios (ed. Jaime Sala, P. Fr., Obras místicas, in Nueva Biblioteca de Autores Españoles, Madrid 1912; I, 42b43a.)Google Scholar

133 Noche oscura, Obras I, 494.Google Scholar

134 Cántico espiritual, canc. 1, Obras II, 24.Google Scholar

135 Tercer Abecedario, Trat. 18, ch. 1, p. 527b528a.Google Scholar

136 Moradas, book 4, ch. 2, Obras 347b.Google Scholar

137 Nombres de Cristo III, 93.Google Scholar

138 Ibid. 16.Google Scholar

139 Alonso, Dámaso, Poesías 120.Google Scholar

139a Estrada, Francisco López, ‘Una posible fuente de San Juan de la Cruz,’ Revista de filología española 28 (1944) 473477.Google Scholar

140 de Osuna, Fr., Tercer Abecedario, Trat. XII, ch. 2, p. 454a.Google Scholar

141 Ibid. 357a–b.Google Scholar

142 Cántico espiritual, canc. 31, Obras II, 222.Google Scholar

143 Ibid. 235.Google Scholar

144 Paradiso XX, 9799.Google Scholar

145 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 80.Google Scholar

146 L'ornement des noces spirituelles de Ruysbroeck l'Admirable (trad. par Maeterlinck, M., Bruxelles 1900, Introduction, p. xcii).Google Scholar

147 de los Angeles, Juan, Lucha espiritual y amorosa entre Dios y el alma 289a.Google Scholar

148 Teresa, Santa, Vivo sin vivir en mí, Obras 640a.Google Scholar

149 Saínz Rodriguez, P., Introducción 190.Google Scholar

150 Art amativa , Obres 296, no. 764.Google Scholar

151 Ibid. 212, no. 597.Google Scholar

152 Amic e Amat , Obres 76, no. 240.Google Scholar

153 Pidal, Ramón Menéndez, Estilo de Santa Teresa 2425.Google Scholar

154 Lull, R., Blanquerna, ch. 112, §8 (Spanish edition, Madrid 1929, p. 225).Google Scholar

155 Poem: Yo toda me entregué y dí, Obras 642b.Google Scholar

156 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 149.Google Scholar

157 Ibid. 148.Google Scholar

158 Ibid. 150.Google Scholar

159 Ibid. 151.Google Scholar

160 D'Asbeck, M., La mystique de Ruysbroeck 91.Google Scholar

161 Cp. Frazer, James George, The Golden Bough (New York 1940) 156.Google Scholar

162 Cántico espiritual, canc. 6, Obras II, 54.Google Scholar

163 Ibid. 5657.Google Scholar

164 De gheestelike brulocht, Werken I, 140.Google Scholar

165 Baruzi, , Saint Jean de la Croix 298367.Google Scholar

166 Reypens, L., ‘La “nuit de l'esprit” chez Ruusbroec,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 23 (1938) II, 7581.Google Scholar

167 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, end.Google Scholar

168 En una noche oscura, Obras II, 501.Google Scholar

169 In Canticum Canticorum, Sermo 74, §7 (PL 183, 1142).Google Scholar

170 Tercer Abecedario, Trat. VI, ch. 2, 379b.Google Scholar

171 Conquista del Reino de Dios 146a.Google Scholar

172 de Jaegher, Paul, Anthologie mystique (Paris 1933) 53.Google Scholar

173 Ibid. 52.Google Scholar

174 Vida, ch. 20, Obras 76a.Google Scholar

175 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 7, Obras I, 484.Google Scholar

176 PL 175, 117.Google Scholar

177 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 10, Obras I, 500.Google Scholar

178 Nombres de Cristo I, 239, and II, 235.Google Scholar

179 da Cruz, Agostinho, Obras poeticas (ed. dos Remedios, Mendes, Coimbra 1918, p. 160).Google Scholar

180 Cf. Lucien-Marie de Saint Joseph, P., ‘A la recherche d'une structure essentielle de la Nuit de l'Esprit,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 23 (1938) II, 254281.Google Scholar

181 Entréme donde no supe, estr. 5, Obras II, 510.Google Scholar

182 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 1, ch. 2, Obras 1,17.Google Scholar

183 Garrigou-Lagrange, Reginald, Les trois âges de la vie intérieure (Paris 1938) II, 485.Google Scholar

184 Noche oscura, book 1, ch. 12, Obras I, 450.Google Scholar

185 Entréme donde no supe , Obras II, 510.Google Scholar

186 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 1, ch. 2, Obras I, 17.Google Scholar

187 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 3, Obras I, 470.Google Scholar

188 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 2, ch. 1, Obras I, 75.Google Scholar

189 Cantar del alma, Obras II, 514.Google Scholar

190 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 18, Obras I, 538.Google Scholar

191 Cántico espiritual, canc. 15, Obras II, 504.Google Scholar

192 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 1, ch. 2, Obras I, 17.Google Scholar

193 Cántico espiritual, canc. 15, Obras II, 508.Google Scholar

194 Baruzi, Jean, ‘Introducción al estudio del lenguaje místico,’ Boletín de la Academia de Letras 10 (Buenos Aires 1942) 730.Google Scholar

195 En una noche oscura, estr. 5, Obras II, 501.Google Scholar

196 Berger, K., Ausdrücke der Unio mystica 124.Google Scholar

197 En una nocha oscura, estr. 2, Obras II, 501.Google Scholar

198 Revista de Filología Hispánica 5 (1944) 392.Google Scholar

199 Alonso, Dámaso, Poesía 111.Google Scholar

200 De mystica theologia (Dionysiaca: Recueil donnant l'ensemble des traductions latines des ouvrages attribués au Denys de l'Aréopage 1; Paris 1937) 566D.Google Scholar

201 Puech, Henri-Charles, ‘La ténèbre mystique chez le Pseudo-Denis l'Aréopagite et dans la tradition patristique,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 23 (1938) II, 3353.Google Scholar

202 Pierre Debougnie, C.SS.R., ‘Le “purgatoire” de Catherine de Gênes,’ Etudes Carmélitaines 23 (1938) II, 92101.Google Scholar

203 Palacios, Asín, Un précurseur 113167.Google Scholar

204 Etudes Carmélitaines 23 (1938) II, 5460.Google Scholar

205 Ibid. 59.Google Scholar

206 ‘Queriendo, mientras moramos en este destierro contemplar … las cosas de Dios, se ciegan los ojos del ánima é le acontece como al mosquito que se quema por bolar a la lumbre é conocer aquella claridad que de noche ve resplandecer’ (Tercer Abecedario, Trat. 3, ch. 1, p. 349b).Google Scholar

207 ‘La ilustración del entendimiento se puede convenientemente entender por la similitud de la aurora o alba de la mañana que se va levantando poco a poco y se dilata … y dilatándose es clarificada.’ (Vida perfecta, Diál. IV, Obras I, 218b).Google Scholar

208 Llibre de Santa Maria, ch. 30, Obres 18, 227.Google Scholar

208a Ibid. Google Scholar

209 Amic e Amat 89, no. 299.Google Scholar

210 Ibid. 30, no. 25.Google Scholar

211 Art amativa 99, no. 343.Google Scholar

212 Amic e Amat 4246, nos. 79, 94, 99.Google Scholar

213 Ibid. 75, no. 232.Google Scholar

214 Ibid. 28, no. 9.Google Scholar

215 Ibid. 36, no. 51.Google Scholar

216 Ibid. 38, no. 64.Google Scholar

217 El Islam cristianizado 298.Google Scholar

218 Amic e Amat 35, no. 58.Google Scholar

219 Ibid. 77, no. 243.Google Scholar

220 Ibid. 63, no. 178.Google Scholar

221 Ibid. 104, no. 363, 364.Google Scholar

222 Noche oscura, book 1, Prólogo, Obras I, 405.Google Scholar

223 Poesies 115.Google Scholar

224 Palacios, Asín, Un précurseur 134.Google Scholar

225 Vida perfecta, Diál. I, Obras I, 173a.Google Scholar

226 Art amativa 217, no. 658.Google Scholar

227 Plant de Nostra Dona. Poesies 57.Google Scholar

228 De la pena que sentia Nostra Dona. Ibid. 66.Google Scholar

229 Amic e Amat 31, no. 30.Google Scholar

230 Diccionari Català-Castellà-Llatì-Francès-Italià (Per una Societat de Catalans, Barcelona 1839, s.v. revenir ).Google Scholar

231 Literal translations: to strip, despoil, divest, dispossess, forsake, loose, free, empty, uproot, disinterest, detach, alienate, uproot, resign, clean, polish oneself. Most of these expressions can be found in de Osuna, Fr., Tercer Abecedario, Trat. VI, ch. 2, 3.Google Scholar

232 ThLL: denudatio, p. 549. Forcellini, , Totius Latinitatis Lexicon (Prati 1868): nudatio , p. 307.Google Scholar

233 Hanssen, Federico, Gramática histórica de la lengua castellana (Halle 1913) §303, p. 133.Google Scholar

234 Kluge, Friedrich, Etymologisches Wörterbuch der deutschen Sprache (Strassburg 1910) 61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

235 Verwijs en Vordam, E., Middelnederlandsch Woordenboek (S'Gravenhage 1885) 1321.Google Scholar

236 Van Dam, C. F. A., Spaans Handwoordenboek (Den Haag 1937) II, 124.Google Scholar

237 Verwijs en Verdam, E., Woordenboek 1322.Google Scholar

238 Such a study could easily be done with the texts printed in Lieftinck, Gerard Isaac, De Middelnederlandsche Tauler-Handschriften (Groningen 1936).Google Scholar

239 Een spieghel der eeuwigher salicheit, Werken III, 206.Google Scholar

240 Ioannis Rosbrochii, D. Speculum aeternae salutis, ch. 20 (ed. per Laurentium Surium, F., Omnia, Opera; Nunc demum post annos ferme ducentos e Brabantiae Germanico idiomate reddita Latine, Coloniae 1552, p. 42).Google Scholar

241 Een spieghel der eeuwigher salicheit, Werken III, 216.Google Scholar

242 Speculum aeternae salutis, ch. 26, p. 46.Google Scholar

243 Ruysbroeck, , Van den gheesteliken tabernakel, Werken II, 56.Google Scholar

244 Massignon, , Lexique musulmane 74, 246, 255, 283.Google Scholar

245 Woordenlijst, Werken III, 301 and II, 368.Google Scholar

246 Subida del Monte Carmelo, Obras I, 167.Google Scholar

247 Ibid. 164.Google Scholar

248 Ibid. 222223.Google Scholar

249 Llama de amor via, Obras II, 326.Google Scholar

250 Ibid. 339.Google Scholar

251 Ibid. 376–77.Google Scholar

252 Subida del Monte Carmelo, Pról., Obras I, 12.Google Scholar

253 Ibid. 83.Google Scholar

254 Ibid. 85.Google Scholar

255 Cántico espiritual, Obras II, 164.Google Scholar

256 Llama de amor viva, Obras II, 408.Google Scholar

257 Lucha espiritual 304b-305a.Google Scholar

258 Conquista del Reino de Dios 137b.Google Scholar

259 De gheestelike brulocht, Werken I, 224.Google Scholar

260 Ibid. 241.Google Scholar

261 Ibid. 144.Google Scholar

262 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 5.Google Scholar

263 Ibid. 5.Google Scholar

264 Ibid. 7.Google Scholar

265 Vanden XII Beghinen, Werken IV, 22.Google Scholar

266 Ibid. 22.Google Scholar

267 Van VII Trappen, Werken III, 260.Google Scholar

268 Ibid. 266.Google Scholar

269 Een spieghel der eeuwigher salicheit, Werken III, 168.Google Scholar

270 Baruzi, , Saint Jean 315.Google Scholar

271 Subida del Monte Carmelo, Obras I, 299300.Google Scholar

272 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 5.Google Scholar

273 Osuna, , Tercer Abecedario, Trat. 13, ch. 4, p. 466b. Osuna may have known Ruysbroeck from the fragments of 1512.Google Scholar

274 Cisógono de Jesús Sacramentado, P., San Juan de la Cruz (Barcelona 1935) 145154.Google Scholar

275 Morradas, book VI, ch. 5, Obras, 386a.Google Scholar

276 Tercer Abecedario, Trat. IV, ch. 5, p. 364a.Google Scholar

277 Conquista del Reino de Dios, Diál. I, 46a.Google Scholar

278 Cántico espiritual, canc. 14, Obras II, 100.Google Scholar

279 Llama de amor viva, canc. III, v. 3, Obras II, 358.Google Scholar

280 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 28.Google Scholar

281 Ibid. 34.Google Scholar

282 Ibid. 39.Google Scholar

283 Pidal, Ramón Menéndez, Manual de gramática histórica española (Madrid 1929) §83, 5, p. 197.Google Scholar

284 The Divine Union in the Subida del Monte Carmelo and the Noche Oscura of Saint John of the Cross (Diss. Cath. Univ. Washington 1941) 82.Google Scholar

285 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 2, ch. 32, Obras I, 258.Google Scholar

286 Llama de amor viva, Obras II, 324.Google Scholar

287 Ibid. 327.Google Scholar

288 Cántico espiritual, Obras II, 179.Google Scholar

289 Moradas, book VI, ch. 2, Obras 372a373b.Google Scholar

290 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 67.Google Scholar

290a Ibid. Google Scholar

291 De gheestelijke brulochi, Werken I, 221.Google Scholar

292 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 25.Google Scholar

293 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 225.Google Scholar

294 Ibid. 196.Google Scholar

296 Vanden VII sloten, Werken III, 111.Google Scholar

253 Etudes Carmélitaines 17 (1932) II, 241, referring to Summa Ia IIae q. 180 a. 5 ad 1.Google Scholar

297 Reypens, L., Nuit de l'esprit 79.Google Scholar

298 Ibid. 79.Google Scholar

299 en Verdam, Verwijs, Woordenboek, s.v. gerenen 1538.Google Scholar

300 Berger, K., Ausdrücke der Unio mystica 60.Google Scholar

301 Ibid. 58.Google Scholar

302 Grimm, Jacob und Grimm, Wilhelm, Deutsches Wörterbuch (Leipzig 1897) 3707.Google Scholar

303 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 196197.Google Scholar

304 en Verdam, Verwijs, Woordenboek 1551.Google Scholar

305 Surius, , Rosbrochii Opera Omnia 387.Google Scholar

306 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 196197.Google Scholar

307 Surius, , Rosbrochii Opera Omnia 348.Google Scholar

308 Subida del Monte Carmelo, book 2, ch. 32, Obras I, 258259.Google Scholar

309 Muller, Ph., Jan van Ruysbroeck, Van den blinkenden steen met W. Jordaens' latijnsche vertaling (Studien en tekstuitgaven 4, Leuven 1921) 8891.Google Scholar

310 de los Angeles, Juan, Obras místicas, Introducción xii.Google Scholar

311 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 40.Google Scholar

312 Ibid. 3233.Google Scholar

313 Conquista del reino de Dios, Diál. VIII, 128a.Google Scholar

314 Llama de amor viva, Obras II, 346.Google Scholar

315 de León, Luis. De la vida del sabio (ed. Schlüter-Storck, , Obras poéticas, Münster 1853, p. 20).Google Scholar

316 Conquista del reino de Dios, Diál. X, 145a.Google Scholar

317 Ibid., Diál. I, 44b.Google Scholar

318 Moradas, Obras 412a.Google Scholar

319 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 30.Google Scholar

320 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 30.Google Scholar

321 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 26.Google Scholar

322 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 181.Google Scholar

323 Vanden XII beghinen, Werken IV, 6162.Google Scholar

324 Cántico espiritual, canc. 14, Obras II, 105.Google Scholar

324a Ibid. Google Scholar

325 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 88.Google Scholar

326 Ibid. 80.Google Scholar

327 de la Cruz, San Juan, Cántico espiritual, canc. 7, Obras II, 59.Google Scholar

328 Teresa, Santa, Vivo sin vivir en mi, Obras 641.Google Scholar

329 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 19.Google Scholar

330 Lucha espiritual 354a.Google Scholar

331 Een spieghel der eeuwigher salicheit, Werken III, 216217.Google Scholar

332 Tercer Abecedario, Trat. 21, ch. 4, p. 565.Google Scholar

333 Cántico espiritual, canc. 28, Obras II, 506.Google Scholar

334 En una noche oscura, estr. 6, Obras II, 502.Google Scholar

335 Van den gheesteliken tabernakel, Werken II, 364.Google Scholar

336 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 27.Google Scholar

337 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 200.Google Scholar

338 En una noche oscura, estr. 8, Werken II, 502.Google Scholar

339 Cántico espiritual, canc. 20, Obras II, 505.Google Scholar

340 En una noche oscura, estr. 6, Obras II, 502.Google Scholar

341 Cántico espiritual, canc. 27, Obras II, 506.Google Scholar

342 Ibid., estr. 7, Obras II, 502.Google Scholar

343 Cántico espiritual, canc. 39, Obras II, 508.Google Scholar

344 Ibid. 267.Google Scholar

345 Ibid. canc. 14, Obras II, 504.Google Scholar

346 Vanden XII beghinen, Werken IV, 25.Google Scholar

347 Cántico espiritual, canc. 14, 15, Obras II, 117.Google Scholar

348 Vanden XII beghinen, Werken IV, 25.Google Scholar

349 Llama de amor viva , quoted by Crisógono de Jesús Sacramentado, P., San Juan de la Cruz. Su obra científica y su obra literaria (Madrid 1929) II, 132.Google Scholar

350 Van VII Trappen, Werken III, 263.Google Scholar

351 Een spieghel der eeuwigher salicheit, Werken III, 207208.Google Scholar

352 En una noche oscura, estr. 8, Obras II, 502.Google Scholar

353 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 74.Google Scholar

354 Llama de amor viva, Prólogo, Obras II, 285.Google Scholar

355 Poem: Oh llama de amor viva, canc. 1, 3, Obras II, 286.Google Scholar

356 Ibid. 320.Google Scholar

357 In Ecclesiasticum homilia I (PL 175, 117).Google Scholar

358 Predica del 24 ottobre 1305 (ed. Levasti, Arrigo, del Duecento, Mistici e del Trecento, , in I Classici Rizzoli, Milano-Roma 1935, 521522).Google Scholar

359 Nombres de Cristo I, 239 and II, 235.Google Scholar

360 La conversión de la Magdalena (Biblioteca de autores españoles 27, Madrid 1853) 359 Google Scholar

361 Noche oscura, book 2, ch. 10, Obras I, 500.Google Scholar

362 Llama de amor viva, Prólogo, Obras II, 284.Google Scholar

363 Cántico espiritual, canc. 39, Obras II, 508.Google Scholar

364 Ibid. 274.Google Scholar

365 Llama de amor viva, Obras II, 312–13.Google Scholar

366 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 38.Google Scholar

367 Van den gheesteliken tabernakel, Werken II, 295.Google Scholar

368 Vanden VII sloten, Werken III, 114.Google Scholar

369 Vanden XII beghinen, Werken IV, 102.Google Scholar

370 Ibid. 103.Google Scholar

371 Vanden blinkenden Steen, Werken III, 8.Google Scholar

372 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 200.Google Scholar

373 Llama de amor viva, Obras II, 394.Google Scholar

374 De gheestelijke brulocht, Werken I, 116–17.Google Scholar

375 Ruusbroec, Werken II, Woordenlijst.Google Scholar

376 Het rijcke der ghelieven, Werken I, 85.Google Scholar

377 Ibid. 8889.Google Scholar