Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T16:55:32.126Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Mozarabic Hymns in Relation to Contemporary Culture in Spain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 July 2017

Ruth E. Messenger
Ruth E. Messenger*
Affiliation:
Hunter College of the City of New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

While the Mozarabic Rite has been the subject of numerous and important studies, the riches of its hymnody have never been adequately displayed. Abounding in interest for the inquirer in the field of early medieval religious poetry, it is equally rewarding to the historian who would be acquainted to some extent with ways of thinking familiar to Visigothic and Moslem Spain. The English scholar, Frederic Raby, was aware of this when he wrote of Mozarabic hymns, ‘They form the raw material for an important research which would help to elucidate the state of religious and intellectual culture during the obscure centuries of the early Middle Ages.’ Clemens Blume, the great Jesuit hymnologist, a generation earlier had reached the same conclusion when he published his edition of Hymnodia Gothica in the twenty-seventh volume of the Analecta hymnica medii aevi.

Type
Articles
Information
Traditio , Volume 4 , 1946 , pp. 149 - 177
Copyright
Copyright © 1946 by Cosmopolitan Science & Art Service Co., Inc. 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Raby, F. J. E., A History of Christian-Latin Poetry (Oxford 1927) 128 (quoted by permission of the author).Google Scholar

2 Leipzig 1897. This volume will be referred to hereafter as A.H. 27.Google Scholar

3 A.H. 27, Introd. 6.Google Scholar

4 Ortiz, Alphonzo, Missale mixtum etc. (Toledo 1500); Breviarium etc. (Toledo 1502).Google Scholar

5 Lesley, A. S. J., Missale mixtum (Rome 1775) = Liturgica mozarabica secundum regulam beati Isidori, pars prior; PL 85 (Paris 1850).Google Scholar

Lorenzana, A., Breviarium gothicum (Madrid 1775) = Liturgica mozarabica, pars posterior; PL 86 (Paris, 1850).Google Scholar

6 Among others, Morin, Dom G., Liber comicus in Anecdota Maredsolana, I (Maredsous 1893); Férotin, Dom M., Liber ordinum and Liber mozarabicus sacramentorum in Monumenta ecclesiae liturgica, V, VI (Paris 1904, 1912); Antiphonarium mozarabicum de la catedral de León, editado por los Padres benedictines de Silos (León 1928).Google Scholar

7 Cod. Matritensis 1005 (Hh 60).Google Scholar

8 A.H. 27, 6–19.Google Scholar

9 For the list of manuscripts used by Blume see A.H. 27, 21–32.Google Scholar

10 A.H. 27, Introd. 20.Google Scholar

11 Lynch, C. H., St. Braulio, Bishop of Saragossa (Washington, D. C. 1938) 112.Google Scholar

12 Simonet, F. J., Historia de los Mozárabes de España (Madrid 1897, 1903) 712.Google Scholar

13 A.H. 27: Spania (Hispania), 139, 187; Hesperia, 153, 253, 254; partes occiduas, 173; occiduae partis, 253; occiduus populus, 243; claret occidens, 207.—PL 86: Terra Hibera stemmate, 1107; urbibus Iberis, 1055; terrarum Pyrinaearum, 1065.Google Scholar

14 A.H. 27: Rhodanus, 179; Arlatis oppidi, 178; Ninguidis saepta spatiis Tolosa, 230; fines Gallaeciae, 171, 173; Gerunda, 151, 177; Oscae, 227; Barcinon, 150, 167; civitas complutensis, 211; Accis, 253; Astigitanae urbi, 150; Olisipona, 255.—PL 86: Tarraco, 1062.—Perist. iv, 3, Saragossa; iv, 31, Calahorra; iii, 3, Merida; iv, 19, Cordova .Google Scholar

A.H. 27: urbis Tasciae, 152; civitas Scillitana, 151; Caesarea, 177; Carthago, 243.—Perist. iv, 45, Tingis .Google Scholar

15 In notes to hymns for saints, Blume occasionally cites the appropriate acts, e.g. Torquatus, S., Acta SS, May III, 442. Elsewhere he refers to the Mozarabie rites.— Tertullian, , Adv. Judaeos vii, PL 2, 610.Google Scholar

16 Garcia Villada, Z., Historia eclesiástica de España (Madrid 1929–36) I, 1, cap. V, ‘San Cipriano y la Iglesia española en 254,’ 185–194, especially p. 194. Gams, P. B., Die Kirchengeschichte von Spanien (Regensburg 1862–79) I, 270. For Cyprian's letter, CSEL 3, 1–2: S. Thasci Caecili Cypriani omnia opera , ed. Hartel, G. (Vindobonae 1868) 735.Google Scholar

17 Harnack, A., Expansion of Christianity, translated by Moffatt, J. (N. Y. 1904) II, 439; Bouchier, E. S., Spain under the Roman Empire (Oxford 1914) 175; Leclercq, H., L'Espagne chrétienne (Paris 1906) 52, 53.Google Scholar

18 For Dacian, see Harnack, , ibid. 124; Bouchier, , ibid. 175; Leclercq, , ibid. 81. See also Braulio, , Acta de martyribus, PL 80, 719: ‘Tunc feralis ille ac tortuosissimus draco Datianus praeses.’ Google Scholar

19 Leclercq, , op. cit. 53, 61.Google Scholar

20 McKenna, S., Paganism and Pagan Survivals in Spain (Washington 1938) 13–23.Google Scholar

21 Cabrol, F., ‘Mozarabe (La Liturgie)’, DACL 12, 1, 489.Google Scholar

22 Wagner, P., ‘Der mozarabische Kirchengesang’ in Finke, H., Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Kulturgeschichte Spaniens (Münster 1928) I 1, 115.Google Scholar

23 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) II 2, 448–456.Google Scholar

24 Férotin, , Liber ordinum (see note 6) Appendix I, 449–496.Google Scholar

25 Formo, E., ‘El resumen del santoral del Culto mozárabe’ in Homenage a Menendez Pidal (Madrid 1925) III, 532–543. Reviewed in Jahrbuch f. Liturgiewissenschaft 7 (1927) 199; Porter, B. S., ‘A Note on the Mozarabic Kalendar,’ Jour. of Theol. Studies 34 (1933) 144–150.Google Scholar

26 Latin Hymns of the Anglo-Saxon Church, ed. Stevenson, J. (Surtees Soc. Pub. 23, Durham 1851). See also A.H. 51, 367 Index.Google Scholar

27 Attwater, D., Dictionary of Saints (London 1938) 268. See note 15.Google Scholar

28 ‘Origen de los himnos mozárabes,’ Bulletin hispanique 28 (Bordeaux 1926) 5–21, 113–139, 209–245, 305–320; p. 117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

29 De gloria martyrum 47, ed. Krusch, B., MGH Script.merov. 1 (Hannover 1884) 520; Carm. 2, 7 and 2, 8, ed. Leo, F., MGH Auct. ant. 4 (Berol. 1881) 35–37.Google Scholar

30 Attwater, , op. cit . 70.Google Scholar

31 Walpole, A. S., Early Latin Hymns (Cambridge 1922) 72–76.Google Scholar

32 PL 85, 946.Google Scholar

33 PL 85, 786–787, Inlatio; PWK II 1 s.v. ‘Salambo’, 1823–24.Google Scholar

34 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) I, 285.Google Scholar

35 Leclercq, , op. cit. (see note 17) xxvi-xxvii.Google Scholar

36 Leclercq, , ibid. 85.Google Scholar

37 For example, the supposed authorship by a bishop of Toledo.Google Scholar

38 Perist. xi, 1–4, 7–16. CSEL 61: Aurelii Prudentii dementis Carmina , ed. Bergman, Iohannes (Vindobonae-Lipsiae 1926) 412–13.Google Scholar

39 Wagner, , op. cit. (see note 22) 108; canon 9, First Council of Toledo (Mansi 3, 1000).Google Scholar

40 For the enumeration of hymns borrowed from Prudentius, see A.H. 27, Introd. 37–39.Google Scholar

41 A.H. 27, Introd. 39–40.Google Scholar

42 PL 86, 1179. As Blume does not reprint in his edition the selections from the works of Prudentius used as hymns, reference is made here and in similar cases directly to the Mozarabic text, instead of Bergman's edition of Prudentius (see note 38).Google Scholar

43 Walpole, , op. cit. (see note 31) 94–100.Google Scholar

44 PL 86, 1062, 1055.Google Scholar

45 PL 86, 1073.Google Scholar

46 Altamira, R., ‘Spain under the Visigoths,’ CMH 2, 163.Google Scholar

47 PL 86,1274.Google Scholar

48 Múnera, J., ‘Dos Santas españoles,’ Reseña ecles. 21 (1929) 5–13; ‘Eulaliana,’ Resena ecles. 22 (1930) 36–56, 152–163; 23(1931) 79–90, 120–124, 165–176; Paraula cristiana 14(1931) 303–311. All reviewed in Jahrbuch f. Liturgiewissenschaft 9 (1929) 252; 10(1930) 307; 11 (1931) 278. See also Villada, Garcia, op. cit. (see note 16) I 1, 282–300. This author argues for the existence of two saints.Google Scholar

49 Leclercq, , op. cit. (see note 17) 78; Férotin, M., Histoire de l'Abbaye de Silos (Paris 1897) I, 2.Google Scholar

50 De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 127–128, dates the hymns in the ninth century.Google Scholar

51 Perist. x; PL 86, 1219. See Baumstark, A., ‘Orientalisches in altspanischer Liturgie,’ Oriens Christianus 10 (1935) 22–23.Google Scholar

52 Pro Archia, x: ‘Qui (Metellus Pius) praesertim usque eo de suis rebus scribi cuperet ut etiam Cordubae natis poetis pingue quiddam sonantibus atque peregrinum, tamen auris suas dederet.’ Google Scholar

53 Bouchier, , op. cit. (see note 17) 196.Google Scholar

54 A.H. 27, 68, 187, 188, 93, 263.Google Scholar

55 The writer is indebted to the late Dr. Charles Knapp of Columbia University for this suggestion.Google Scholar

56 A.H. 27, 204, 266, 101, 89, 218, 153, 84, 217, passim; chalybs, 241; protoplaustus, 219.Google Scholar

57 Ter hagie, A.H. 27, 224; hagios, 116, etc. Google Scholar

58 Baumstark, , op. cit. (see note 51); Quasten, J., ‘Theodore of Mopsuestia on the Exorcism of the Cilicium,’ Harvard Theol. Rev. 35 (1942) 214.Google Scholar

59 In 554 Liberius entered Spain. In 629 Swintila finally occupied the last of the Byzantine territory. Altamira, , op. cit. (see note 46) ch. VI, 163–175 passim ; Ziegler, A. K., Church and State in Visigothic Spain (Washington 1930) 11, 92. Respecting church and state, Dr. Ziegler points out that the throne sought the assistance of the church in the maintenance of government and that the resulting union of church and state evolved in the national councils. Ibid. 200–203.Google Scholar

60 Lévi-Provençal, E., La civilisation arabe en Espagne (Le Caire 1938) 134–136; Gomez-Moreno, M., Iglesias Mozárabes (Madrid 1919) 2 vols. See vol. 2 for plates.Google Scholar

61 Trend, J. B., Music of Spanish History to 1600 (London 1926) 40–41; Wagner, P., op. cit. (see note 22) 111–112.Google Scholar

62 Mansi 9, 977ff.; Eisenhofer, L., Handbuch der katholischen Liturgik II (Freiburg 1933) 125.Google Scholar

63 Baudot, Dom, Dictionnaire d'hagiographie (Paris 1925) 622; De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 131–132.Google Scholar

64 Magnin, E., L'Eglise wisigothique au VII e siècle (Paris 1912) ch. III.Google Scholar

The councils of Toledo in question are III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, XII, XIII, XV, XVI, XVII; Mansi 9, 977; 10, 611, 653, 659, 763, 1205; 11, 1023, 1059; 12, 7, 59, 93.Google Scholar

65 Bishop, E., The Mozarabic and Ambrosian Rites (London 1924) 20; Wagner, , op. cit. (see note 22) 107.Google Scholar

66 Dozy, R. P. A., Spanish Islam, translated by Stokes, F. G. (London 1913) 337.Google Scholar

67 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) II 1, 489; II 2, 14; Ziegler, , op. cit. (see note 59) 12, 29. For the liturgical tradition see note 61.Google Scholar

68 De Urbel, , op. cit . 15.Google Scholar

69 Etym. 3, 15–23; 6, 19; De off. PL 83, 737–826.Google Scholar

70 Canon 2, Mansi 9, 778.Google Scholar

71 Canon 13, Mansi 10, 622–3.Google Scholar

72 The most convenient reference work for the literary activity of the Visigothic bishops is Manitius, M., Geschichte der Christlich-Lateinischen Poesie bis zur Mitte des 8. Jahrhunderts (Stuttgart 1891) 413–432.Google Scholar

73 Wagner, , op. cit. (see note 22) 112.Google Scholar

74 PL 80, 713.Google Scholar

75 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) I, 339.Google Scholar

76 See p. 154 and Blume's notes to this hymn, A.H. 27, 148.Google Scholar

77 De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 235–6.Google Scholar

78 Walpole, , op. cit. (see note 31) 398–401.Google Scholar

79 Férotin, , Liber ordinum (see note 6) 506–515; De Urbel, , op. cit. 234.Google Scholar

80 Férotin, , Liber ordinum, Appendix III, 506–515.Google Scholar

81 Making of Western Europe (London 1912–14) I, 155.Google Scholar

82 Heimbucher, M., Die Orden und Kongregationen der katholischen Kirche (3rd ed. Paderborn 1933) I, 101, 130, 132, 134, 152, 174; Leclercq, , op. cit. (see note 17) 209–10.Google Scholar

83 Canon 6, Mansi 3, 635; Canon 3, Mansi 12, 43.Google Scholar

84 Férotin, , op. cit. (see note 49) II, 2.Google Scholar

85 McKenna, , op. cit. (see note 20) 82.Google Scholar

86 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) II 2, 455. Villada, Garcia, op. cit. (see note 16) II 1, 313–17.Google Scholar

87 PL 87, 1097ff. Heimbucher, , op. cit. I, 152.Google Scholar

88 De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 241–44.Google Scholar

89 Bishop, , op. cit. (see note 65) 63–6; Baumstark, , op. cit. (see note 51) 5–6. It is suggested here that the 12 hours are derived from the Rule of Pachomius.Google Scholar

90 For a general account of the Moslem period see Altamira, R., ‘The Western Caliphate,’ CMH 3, 409–442.Google Scholar

91 Lévi-Provençal, , op. cit. (see note 60) ch. III. Simonet, , op. cit. (see note 12) may be consulted for details on this subject.Google Scholar

92 Farmer, H. A., Historical Facts for the Arabian Musical Influence (London 1930) 151; von Schack, A. F., Poesie und Kunst der Araber in Spanien und Sicilien (Stuttgart 1887) 98.Google Scholar

93 De Urbel, , ‘Los himnos mozárabes,’ Revista ecles. Silos 58 (1927) 56–61, reviewed in full in Jahrbuch f. Liturgiewissenschaft 7 (1927) 316.Google Scholar

94 Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) II 2, 304. Villada, Garcia, op. cit. (see note 16) V, 85.Google Scholar

95 PL 115, 731ff.Google Scholar

96 Dozy, , op. cit. (see note 66) ch. VI; Lévi-Provençal, , op. cit. 107.Google Scholar

97 Gams, , op. cit. II 2, 326–29. Villada, Garcia, op. cit. V, 107–14, 117–22.Google Scholar

98 Gams, , ibid. II 2, 336ff; Altamira, , op. cit. (see note 90) 416–7. The most recent account of Alvarus is given by Sage, Carleton M., Paul Albar of Cordova: Studies on his Life and Writings (Washington 1943).Google Scholar

99 Poetae latini aevi Carolini, ed. Traube, L., MGH Poetae lat. III 1 (Berol. 1892) 121ff. For other illustrations of Spanish influence, see Villada, Garcia, op. cit. (see note 16) V, cap. xxii, 389–401, ‘Influjo religioso y científico español en el imperio Carolingio.’ Google Scholar

100 Bishop, E., ‘Spanish Symptoms’ in Liturgica historica (Oxford 1918) 168.Google Scholar

101 De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 216–17, 311.Google Scholar

102 De Urbel, , ibid, 216.Google Scholar

103 ‘Bull-fighting,’ Enc. Brit. 4 (11th ed. 1943) 372.Google Scholar

104 Gams, , op. cit. II 2, 390. Villada, Garcia, op. cit. I 1, 92; V, 203–5.Google Scholar

105 Simonet, , op. cit. (see note 12) 713; Leclercq, , op. cit. (see note 17) 38; Gams, , op. cit. (see note 16) II 2, 368, 390–93; De Urbel, , op. cit. (see note 28) 125–27; King, G., The Way of St. James, 3 vols. (N. Y. 1920) passim .Google Scholar

106 Goussen, H., Die christlich-arabische Literatur der Mozaraber (Leipzig, 1909) 8, 9.Google Scholar

107 Altamira, R., History of Spanish Civilization, translated by Volkov, P. (London 1930) 56; Gomez-Moreno, M., Iglesias Mozárabes (Madrid 1919) vol. 2, plates.Google Scholar

108 Messenger, R., ‘Whence the Ninth Century Hymnal?’ Trans. Amer. Phil. Ass. 69 (1938) 446–64.Google Scholar

109 Bishop, , op. cit. (see note 100) 170.Google Scholar

110 Wiener, L., Contributions toward a History of Arabico-Gothic Culture (N. Y. 1917–1921) I, 60–73.Google Scholar

111 Trend, , op. cit. (see note 61) 32–6.Google Scholar

112 Wagner, , op. cit. (see note 22) 105–6.Google Scholar

113 Wagner, , ibid. 108–12.Google Scholar

114 Pierik, M., The Spirit of the Gregorian Chant (Boston 1939) 24.Google Scholar

115 German Prado, R. P., ‘Mozarabic Melodies,’ Speculum 3 (1928) 218–39; Ríano, J. F., Critical and Bibliographical Notes on Early Spanish Music (London 1887).Google Scholar

116 Farmer, , op. cit. (see note 92) 13–5; Riano, , op. cit. 109–21, showing 58 illustrations of instruments used in 13th-century Spain from the codex of the Cántigas de Santa Maria .Google Scholar

117 De musica, PL 82, 163–9, ch. xxi, xxii.Google Scholar

118 Wiener, , op. cit. (see note 110) 101.Google Scholar

119 Farmer, , op. cit. 23. Alvarus is quoted from Florez, , España Sagrada (Madrid 1754–1784) XI, 274.Google Scholar

120 Meyer, W., Gesammelte Abhandlungen zur mittellateinischen Rhythmik (Berlin 1905) I, 5–6.Google Scholar

121 Farmer, , op. cit. 151.Google Scholar

122 von Kremer, A., Culturgeschichte des Orients unter den Chalifen (Wien, 1875–77) II, 356–360; Altamira, , op. cit. (see note 107) 77.Google Scholar

123 For Arianism, see canons of the Third Council of Toledo, 589, in Mansi 9. For Priscillianism, Nestorianism and Adoptionism see Gams, , op. cit. (note 16) II 1, ch. 6, 7; II 2, 261–298; Villada, Garcia, op. cit. (see note 16) I, 2, 91–145; II, 2, 83–4.Google Scholar

124 Quoted by Wagner, , op. cit. (see note 22) 121.Google Scholar

125 For the history of the extinction of the Mozarabic Rites see Gams, , op. cit. I, 81–3; Cabrol, , op. cit. (see note 21) 395–97.Google Scholar