No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
No more ‘Standing the Session’: Gender and the End of Corporate Discipline in the Church of Scotland, c.1890-c.1930
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
Extract
In 1890, the General Assembly of the established Church of Scotland appointed a Commission on the Religious Condition of the People, with instructions to carry out a comprehensive review of the state of religion and morals in the country. The aim was to determine the reasons for non-attendance at church services and for the Church’s declining social influence. The Commission visited the presbyteries, and issued a series of reports between 1891 and 1896. These revealed widespread irreligion, non-attendance, intemperance, and vice. Among the most disturbing revelations, however, were the high levels of illegitimacy in many regions of the country. Sexual immorality, according to the report for the synod of Galloway, in the south west of Scotland, was ‘a rampant sin in the district, and makes a dark blot on the moral life of [the] community’. In the Presbytery of Strathbogie, in the north east, sexual misconduct ‘has so permeated family life, and is so prevalent in the community, that it is difficult to arouse a healthy and vigorous public opinion against it’. The problem seemed to lie in the nature of ecclesiastical discipline within Scottish Presbyterianism. The mode of administering discipline’, the Commission observed in its final report, in May 1896,
at present fails to impress the community; it fails to promote repentance in offenders; and it may be asked whether, thus failing, it is not a hindrance rather than a help to the cause of morality. To the more sensitive and delicate in feeling who have yielded to temptation there is a natural repugnance in being obliged to face the minister and elders. … To those who have no such delicacy, the ‘standing of the session’ is little regarded.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1998
References
1 Report of the Commission on the Religious Condition of the People’, in Reports on the Schemes of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland [hereafter Reports] (1895), pp. 746, 766.
2 Reports (1896), p. 817.
3 For accounts of kirk-session discipline in the Church of Scotland, see Clark, I. M, A History of Church Discipline in Scotland (Aberdeen, 1929), pp. 85–186 Google Scholar; Henderson, G. D., The Scottish Ruling Elder (Aberdeen, 1935), pp. 100–45 Google Scholar; Edgar, A., ‘The discipline of the Church of Scotland’, in Story, R. H., ed., The Church of Scotland, 5 vols (Edinburgh, nd), 5, pp. 427–556.Google Scholar
4 Edgar, ‘Discipline of the Church of Scotland’, p. 466.
5 Mitchison, R. and Leneman, L., Sexuality and Social Control: Scotland 1660–1780 (Oxford, 1989), p. 25.Google Scholar
6 di Folco, J., ‘Discipline and welfare in die mid-seventeenth century Scots parish’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society, 19 (1977), pp. 169–83.Google Scholar
7 Mitchison, and Leneman, , Sexuality and Social Control, p. 20.Google Scholar
8 Leneman, L. and Mitchison, R., ‘Acquiescence in and defiance of Church discipline in early-modern Scotland’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society, 25 (1993), pp. 20–1.Google Scholar
9 Clark, , History of Church Discipline, pp. 178–9.Google Scholar
10 Buchanan, R., The Ten Years’ Conflict, 2 vols, 2nd edn (Glasgow, 1852), 1, pp. 333–7 Google Scholar. I am grateful to Prof. Hugh McLeod for reminding me of this nineteenth-century revival.
11 E.g., Lorimer, J. G., The Eldership of the Church of Scotland (Glasgow, 1842)Google Scholar; King, D., Ruling Eldership of the Christian Church (Edinburgh, 1846)Google Scholar; McKerrow, J., Office of the Ruling Elder (Edinburgh, 1846).Google Scholar
12 MacLaren, A. A., Religion and Social Class. The Disruption Years in Aberdeen (London, 1974), pp. 128–30, 144 Google Scholar; Hillis, P., ‘Presbyterianism and social class in mid-nineteenth-century Glasgow: a study of nine churches’, JEH, 32 (1981), pp. 47–64 Google Scholar; Brown, C., The Social History of Religion in Scotland since 1730 (London, 1987), p. 152.Google Scholar
13 Mitchison and Leneman, Sexuality and Social Control, p. 10.
14 T. Chalmers, On the Christian and Economic Polity of a Nation, in Collected Works, 25 vols (Glasgow, 1835–42), 2, pp. 122–8.
15 Henderson, The Scottish Ruling Elder, p. 233; MacLaren, Religion and Social Class, pp. 150–1.
16 For a discussion of Scottish illegitimacy in the nineteenth century, see T. C. Smout, ‘Aspects of sexual behaviour in nineteenth century Scotland’, in A. A. MacLaren, ed., Social Class in Scotland: Past and Present (Edinburgh, 1976), pp. 55–85.
17 ‘Report on the Commission on the Religious Condition of the People’, in Reports (1894), pp. 734–5.
18 Reports (1894), p. 762; Reports (1895), pp. 751, 766, 788.
19 Reports (1895), pp. 788–9.
20 Reports (1896), p. 818.
21 Ibid., p. 816.
22 ‘Report of the Committee on Christian Life and Work’, Reports (1897), pp. 719–26.
23 Ibid., pp. 723–4.
24 ‘Report of the Committee on Christian Life and Work’, Reports (1897), p. 724.
25 Ibid., p. 723.
26 Ibid., pp. 725–6.
27 Reid, H.M.B., ed., The Layman’s Book of the General Assembly of 1900 (Edinburgh, 1900), p. 143 Google Scholar; idem, The Layman’s Book of the General Assembly of 1901 (Edinburgh, 1901), p. 187.
28 ‘Overture on the Form of Process’, Reports (1899), pp. 1092–4; Boyd, K. M, Scottish Church Attitudes to Sex, Marriage and the Family 1850–1014 (Edinburgh, 1980), p. 157.Google Scholar
29 Henderson, , The Scottish Ruling Elder, p. 289.Google Scholar
30 Clark, History of Church Discipline, p. 211.
31 Boyd, Scottish Church Attitudes, p. 158.
32 Bruce, W. S., ‘Decline of discipline’, in Paterson, W. P. and Watson, D., eds, Social Evils and Problems (Edinburgh, 1918), pp. 148, 155.Google Scholar