Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T03:49:14.608Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Eastern and western Christendom in late antiquity: a parting of the way

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Peter Brown
Peter Brown*
Affiliation:
University of London, Royal Holloway College
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

I must begin with the words of the clergyman: ‘My short sermon for today is divided into three parts. One: God. Two: Man. Three: The Universe.’ It will be impossible to do justice to the subject in hand in the short span of one lecture. This is not only because of the vast range of time and space involved in any consideration of the parting of the ways between eastern and western Christianity in the late antique period. To embark on such a theme involves holding up for scrutiny the very nature of ecclesiastical history. For what we have to deal with is not merely what happened in the relations between east and west, but why what happened happened as it did. Once the ecclesiastical historian asks why, he will find himself sooner or later forced to grapple with the whole quality of men’s lives in the past—that is, with how they lived the full twenty-four hours of the day, not only in their books, but in their churches, not only in their churches, but in the most intimate and most monotonous rhythms of their life.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 13: The Orthodox Churches and the West , 1976 , pp. 1 - 24
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1976

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Gibbon, Edward, The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, notes to the second edition, introduction, p xxxvi Google Scholar.

2 Mazzarino, S., Stilicone e la crisi imperiale dopo Teodosio (Rome 1942)Google Scholar and Demougeot, E., De l’unité à la division de l’empire romain (Paris 1951)Google Scholar.

3 Wes, M., Das Ende des Kaisertums im Westen des römischen Reichs (The Hague 1967)Google Scholar and Goffart, W., ‘Zosimus, the first historian of Rome’s fall’, AHR 76 (1971) pp 412–41 Google Scholar; see Brown, [P.], Religion and Society [in the Age of Saint Augustine] (London 1972)pp 229-30Google Scholar.

4 See Brown, Peter, ‘Mohammed and Charlemagne by Henri Pirenne’, Daedalus 102 (Cambridge, Mass., 1973) pp 25–33 Google Scholar.

5 Murray, Robert, Symbols of Church and Kingdom. A Study in the Early Syrian Tradition (Cambridge 1975)Google Scholar and Chesnut, Roberta, Three Monophysite Christologies: Severus of Antioch, Philoxenus of Mabbug, and Jacob of Sarug (Oxford 1975)Google Scholar. See also, de Matons, José Grosdidier, Romanos le Mélode et les origines de l’hymnographie byzantine (Lille 1974) pp 23–43 Google Scholar.

6 Dix, [Gregory], [The Shape of the Liturgy] (London 1945) p 178 Google Scholar.

7 Diaconus, Johannes, Vita Gregorii II, 7, PL 75, col 91Google Scholar.

8 Notker, , Life of Charlemagne cap 32, transi Lewis Thorpe, Two Lives of Charlemagne (Pelican, Harmondsworth 1969) p 130 Google Scholar.

9 Barnes, [T. D.], [Tertullian] (Oxford 1971) pp 67-9Google Scholar.

10 Brown, Peter, ‘The Patrons of Pclagius’, JTS ns 21 (1970) pp 56–72 CrossRefGoogle Scholar in Religion and Society pp 208-26.

11 Rousseau, Philip, ‘Cassian, Contemplation and the Coenobitic Life’, JEH 26 (1975) pp 113-26Google Scholar.

12 Llewellyn, Peter, ‘The Roman Church in the Seventh Century: the Legacy of Gregory I’, JEH 25 (1974) pp 363-80Google Scholar and Patlagean, Evelyne, ‘Les armes et la cité à Rome du viième au ixème siécle’, Mèlanges de l’École francaise de Rome 86 (Rome 1974) pp 25–62 Google Scholar.

13 Boba, Imre, Moravia’s History Reconsidered (The Hague 1971)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. If the author is right in placing Moravia in the region of Sirmium, then the mission of Constantine and Methodius took place not in the depths of eastern central Europe, but within the traditional orbit of Romania.

14 Leyser, K., ‘The Tenth Century in Byzantine-Western Relations’, Relations between East and West in the Middle Ages, ed Baker, Derek (Edinburgh 1973) pp 29–63, at pp 44-5Google Scholar.

15 B. Hamilton, ‘The Monastery of S. Alessio and the Religious and Intellectual Renaissance in 10th century Rome’ Studies in Medieval and Renaissance History (1965) pp 265-310.

16 Hubert, J., ‘Les relations artistiques entre les diverses parties de l’ancien empire romain pendant de haut moyen âge,’ Settimane di Studi sull’Alto Medio Evo 11 (Spoleto 1964) pp 453-77•Google Scholar.

17 Brown, Religion and Society p 230. H. G. Beck, ‘Res Publica Romana Vom Staatsdenken der Byzantinern’, ABAW, PhK (1970) pp 7-41, in Das Byzantinische Herrscherbild, Wege der Forschung 341 (Darmstadt 1975) pp 379-414. Rosenthal, E., The Illumination of the Virgilius Romanus (Zurich, 1972) p 98 Google Scholar, assumes an east Roman origin for a Vergil manuscript of the sixth century.

18 Meslin, M., La fête des kalendes de janvier dans l’empire romain, Collection Latomus 115 (Brussels 1970)Google Scholar.

19 Riché, P., Education et culture dans l’Occident barbare (Paris 1962) p 149 Google Scholar.

20 Freire, J. G., A versâo latina por Pascasio de Dume dos Apophthegmata Patrum (Coimbra 1971) I p 17 Google Scholar.

21 Gregory of Tours, Lib[ri] Hist[oriarum] VIII, 15, ed Krusch, B., MCH, SRM, I, 2, p 380 Google Scholar.

22 Gregory of Tours, de virt[utibus sancti] Mart[ini] I, 15a, ed. Krusch, B., MCH, SRM I, I, p 147 Google Scholar.

23 Frend, W. H.C., Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church (Oxford 1965)Google Scholar. See Brown, Peter, ‘Approaches to the Religious Crisis of the Third Century A.D.’ EHR 83 (1968) pp 542-58 in Religion and Society esp pp 91-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Markus, R. A., Christianity in the Roman World (London 1975)Google Scholar.

25 Justin, , Dialogus cum Tryphone viii, 4, PG 6, col 493B Google Scholar.

26 Martyrium Polycarpi, 13 3d, and transl. Musurillo, H., The Acts of the Christian Martyrs (Oxford 1972) p 13 Google Scholar.

27 Bieler, L., θEΙΟΣ ANHP Das Bild des ‘göttlichen Menschen’ in Spätantike und Frühchristentum (Vienna 1935)Google Scholar and Neusner, J., A History of the Jews in Babylonia, 4 (Leiden 1969) pp 297–402.Google Scholar See now Urbach, E., Hazal: pirqe emunoth we de ‘oth [The Sages: Their concepts and beliefs] (Jerusalem 1969)Google Scholar.

28 L’Orange, H. P., Apotheosis in Ancient Portraiture (Oslo 1947)Google Scholar and von Heintze, H., ‘ Vir gravis et sanctus. Bildniskopf eines spätantiken Philosphen’, JAC 6 (1963) pp 35–53.Google Scholar

29 Euripides, Hippolytus, lines 1437-8.

30 Eunapius of Sardis, Lives of the Sophists 472, ed and transl Wright, W.C., Loeb Classical Library (London 1061) p 425 Google Scholar.

31 Klauser, T., ‘Christliche Märtyrerkult, heidnische Heroenkult und spätjüdische Heiligenverehrung’, Gesammelte Arbeiten zur Liturgiegeschichte, Kunstegeschichte und christlichen Archäologie, ed Dassmann, E., JAC Ergänzungsband 3 (1974) pp 221-9Google Scholar.

32 Jerome, , Contra Vigilantium 8, PL 23, col 346 Google Scholar.

33 see now the important studies of [Sabine MacCormack, G.], [‘Change and Continuity in Late Antiquity]: the Ceremony of Adventus’, Historia 31 (Wiesbaden 1972) pp 721-52Google Scholar; ‘Latin Prose Panegyrics’ Empire and Aftermath. Silver Latin 2, ed Dorey, T. A. (London 1975) pp 143–205 Google Scholar; ‘Latin Prose Panegyrics: Tradition and Discontinuity in the Later Roman Empire,’ Revue des études augustiniennes (Paris 1975) pp 1-49; ‘Roma, Constantinopolis, [the Emperor and his Genius,’] C[lassical] Q[uarterly] 25 (London 1975) pp 131-50.

34 Brown, [Peter], [‘The Rise and Function of the] Holy Man’, JRS 61 (1971) pp 80-101 at pp 85-7Google Scholar.

35 Speigl, J., ‘Cyprian über das judicium bei der Bischofseinsetzung’, Römische Quartalschrift 69 (Rome/Freiburg/Vienna) (1974) pp 30–45 Google Scholar.

36 Dix p 116 on Cyprian and the consecration of the eucharist: ‘that sort of logical directness and unity which has always appealed to Western theologians’. For the possible influence of Roman pagan attitudes to religion, the most suggestive treatment is by Nock, A. D., ‘A Feature of Roman Religion’ HTR 32 (1939) p 96 CrossRefGoogle Scholar in Essays [on Religion and the Ancient World], ed Stewart, Zeph (Oxford 1972) 1 pp 491-2Google Scholar. To go further by ascribing to classical Roman attitudes and to the study of Roman law a ‘legalism’ which distinguished western Christianity, is to import into our understanding of men of whose background we know little—see Barnes pp 22-9 (‘Still less can “Tertullian the jurist” be invoked to explain the later development of Latin Christendom’), and Clarke, G. W., ‘The Secular Profession of Saint Cyprian of Carthage’, Latomus 24 (Brussels 1965) pp 633-8Google Scholar—writing in a late classical milieu of uncertain nature, a dizzy continuity with the world of Cicero. I have no head for such heights; but they must be considered, more especially on points of religious practise: for one example, see Dölger, F., Der Exorzismus im altchristliche Taufritual (Paderborn 1906) p 97 Google Scholar.

37 Brown, ‘Holy Man’ pp 95-6.

38 Wiessner, G., ‘Christlicher Heiligenkult im umkreis eines sassanisischen Grosskönigs’ Festgabe deutscher Iranisten zum 2500 Jahrfeier Irans, ed Eilers, W. (Stuttgart 1971) pp 141-55. esp p 149Google Scholar.

39 John of Ephesus, [Lives of the Eastern Saints] ed and transl Brooks, E. W., PO 17, pp 1-304, 18, pp 513-697, 19, pp 153-273Google Scholar, and HE, transl Brooks, E. W., CSCO, Script Syr 55 (Louvain 1936)Google Scholar. A strictly religious commentary exists neither for Gregory nor John.

40 Gregory’s isolation from the eastern mediterranean has been exaggerated by Baynes, N. H., ‘M. Pirenne and the Unity of the Mediterranean’, Byzantine Studies (London 1960) pp 310-14Google Scholar.

41 Gregory of Tours, de gloria martyrum, cap 32, pp 57-8.

42 Ibid cap 96, p 103.

43 Peeters, P., ‘L’ex voto de Khusro Aparwez à Sergiopolis’, An Bol 65 (1947) pp 5-56Google Scholar.

44 Brown, ‘Holy Man’ pp 85-91. These views have been modified and placed in a wider context by Price, R. M., ‘The Role of Military Men in Syria and Egypt from Constantine to Theodosius II’, unpublished Oxford D Phil thesis 1974 Google Scholar.

45 John of Ephesus, PO 17, p 72.

46 Nagel, P., Die Motivierung der Askese, Texte und Untersuchungen 95 (Berlin 1966) pp 34–48 Google Scholar.

47 Kittel, G., see under ἒρημος, Theologisches Wörtebuch zum Neuen Testament, 2 (Stuttgart 1935) pp 634-57Google Scholar and Vielhauer, Philipp, ‘Tracht und Speise Johannes des Täufers’, Aufsätze zum Neuen Testament (Munich 1965) pp 47–54 Google Scholar.

48 This became a prominent issue in the iconoclastic controversy: Brown, Peter, ‘A Dark Age Crisis: aspects of the Iconoclastic Controversy’ EHR 88 (1973) pp 1-34 at p 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

49 Brown, ‘The Holy Man’ pp 91-2.

50 John of Ephesus, PO 17 p 9.

51 Durnont, L., ‘World Renunciation in Indian Religions’ Religion, Politics and History in India (Paris and the Hague 1970) pp 33–60, ASR 7 (1959) pp 45-69Google Scholar.

52 Festugière, A. J., La révélation d’Hermès Trismégiste (Paris 1950) pp 33-7 and 44-66Google Scholar, Nock, A. D., ‘A Vision of Mandulis Aion,’ HTR 27 (1934) pp 68–74 in Essays 1, pp 368-74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar See Kirchmeyr, J., under ‘Grecque (‘Eglise)’, Dictionnaire de la spiritualité 6 (Paris 1965) col 848 Google Scholar. In the sixth century a pagan at the shrine of saints Cosmas and Damian in Constantinople knew exactly what he wanted: ##άξιώσαι ccCrròv óirraaias TI vos кссі всіоч έκλάμψεως. Deubner, A., Kosmas and Damian (Leipzig 1907) 10, 22–23, p 118Google Scholar.

53 Dodds, E. R., Pagan and Christian in an Age of Anxiety (Cambridge 1965) pp 38-9CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For a later period, the patriarch Germanus confesses his debt to icons for ##σΐ καθ’ ϋττνου? ττολλάκΐξ τών γΕγραμμένων έπιφάυειαι Mansi, 13, col 125A.

54 Moschus, John, Pratum Spirituale, 25, PG 87, cols 3, 2872 Google Scholar.

55 Well expressed by Veilleux, A., La liturgie dans le cénobitisme pachômien au ivème siècle (Rome 1968) pp 203-4 and esp p 363Google Scholar: ‘Dans la pensée orientale, il s’agit plutôt d’une descente, d’une manifestation et d’une présence de choses célestes à travers les sacrements’.

56 Dix pp 163, 168: for the same ideas surrounding the arrival of the emperor, see MacCormack, ‘the Ceremony of Adventus’, pp 727-8.

57 Brown, Peter and MacCormack, Sabine, ‘Artifices of Eternity’, New York Review of Books, 22 (2 February 1975) pp 19–32 Google Scholar.

58 Brown, ‘The Holy Man’ p 95 for this and further evidence.

59 Vita Symeonis ASB July I (Paris/Rome 1865) cols 121-51.

60 Vita Symeonis 33, col 136E.

61 John of Nikiu, Chronicle, transl Charles, R. H. (London 1916) p 89 Google Scholar and the commentary of S. MacCormack, ‘Roma, Constantinopolis’ p 146.

62 Graus, F., Volk, Herrscher and Heiliger im Reich der Mexowinger (Prague 1965) pp 103-4Google Scholar.

63 Ordericus Vitalis, HE 6, 2, ed and transl Chibnall, M., The Ecclesiastical History of Ordericus Vitalis 3 (Oxford 1972) p 217 Google Scholar.

64 Albern, V. H., ‘HIC SCS SYMION. Eine vorkarolingische Kultstatue des Symeons Stylites in Poitiers,’ CA 16 (1966) pp 23–38 Google Scholar.

65 Gregory of Tours, Lib Hist VIII, 15, p 381.

66 Ibid IX, 6, p 417.

67 See the evidence in Delehaye, H., Sanctus (Brussels 1927) p 114 Google Scholar.

68 Gregory of Tours, Vitae Patrum 8, 5, p 246 Google Scholar; compare Lib Hist IV, 36, p 169.

69 In the epitaph of Priscus, iurgia conponens more serenifero (Corpus 1, Scriptionum Latinarum 13, 2399, 8) may echo the iurgia despiciens suscipiensque Deum of Nicetius (ibid 2400, 20).

70 There is room for a reconsideration of the structure of the sixth century aristocracy of Gaul. Its tensions and areas of fragility have received less attention than its supposed homogeneity and continuity with the Roman past. Brown, Peter, ‘Sorcery, Demons and the Rise of Christianity,’ Witchcraft Confessions and Accusations, Association of Social Anthropologists Monographs, 9 (London 1970) p 27 Google Scholar, in Religion and Society p 131 certainly exaggerates: ‘In the West, the triumph of the great landowners ensured that senatorial blood, episcopal office and sanctity presented a formidable united front.’ Such exaggeration is widespread.

71 Eustathius, , Vita Eutychii, PG 86, 2, cols 2273-402Google Scholar.

72 John of Ephesus, HE II, 31-7 pp 71-4 and III, 18, p 107.

73 Prinz, F., Frühes Mönchtum im Frankenreich (Munich 1965) pp 489–502 Google Scholar. The function of such hagiography is already clearly adumbrated in Gregory; there is therefore less discontinuity between the hagiography of the sixth and that of the seventh century than Prinz would allow.

74 Gregory of Tours, de gloria martyrum 1, p 38 Google Scholar; 5, p 4; 27, p 54; 31, p 56; 54, p 76; 85, pp 95-6.

75 Gregory of Tours, de gloria martyrum 12, p 46.

76 Miracula Sanctae Theclae 18 PG 85, cols 597AB: ##έφ’ ύψηλοθ TIVOS καΐ χρυσηλάτου καΐ έττηρμένου θρόνου” διανέμειν δέ екаегтсо τώυ σννεληλυθότων κοτά τήν ττανήγυριν τά ύττέρ αύτη5 τή5 πανηγύρεω5 δωρα λαμπρά те κα πολλά, καΐ αύτή5 Tfļs παρεχούσηΐ αξισ. This power extends to ‘the poor and artisans’: cap 7, col 576B.

77 Miracula Sancti Demetrii, PG 116, col 1232A: ##¿¡>j τινα ϋπατον τταρά βασιλέωΐ έξουσίαν λαβόντα, διανεΐμαι τφ δήμω таѕ xápiTccs Ιρχόμενον.

78 Deubner, , Kosmas und Damian, 24, pp 162-4Google Scholar.

79 Ibid 34, pp 184-7.

80 de gloria martyrum 41, p 66—on Aredius of Limoges. For the reverse, see Lib Hist VII, 31, p 351: ‘and Mummolus taking one of them [a fragment of the relic of saint Sergius], departed, though not with the favour of the martyr, as the sequel shall declare.’

81 MacCormack, ‘the Ceremony of Aventus’ pp 721-39, ‘Latin Prose Panegyric’ pp 154 seq, 178 seq and 184, and ‘Adventus and Consecratio: Roman Imperial Art and Panegyric from the Late Third to the Sixth Century’, unpublished Oxford D Phil thesis 1974. The adventus of relics is shown for Vienne: Bulletin de la Société des amis de Vienne 67 (1971) pl 2 on p 31. See Gregory of Tours, de virt Mart II, 25, p 167, II, 28, p 169, and de gloria martyrum 89, pp 97-8.

82 Claude, D., ‘Die Bestellung der Bischöfe im merowingischen Reiche’, ZRG 80, KA 49 (1963) pp 1-75, esp p 23Google Scholar.

83 Claude, D., Die byzantinische Stadt im 6 Jahrhundert, Byzantinisches Archiv 13 (Munich 1969) p 95 Google Scholar.

84 A. Grabar, ‘La mosaique de pavement de Qasr el-Lebya,’ Comptes rendus de l’Académie d’Inscriptions et de Belles Lettres (June 1969) pp 264-82.

85 Hubert, J.. ‘Evolution de la topographie et de l’aspect des villes de Gaule de vème aux xème siècle, Settimane di Studio sull’Alto Medio Evo 6 (Spoleto 1959) pp 529-58Google Scholar.

86 Gregory of Tours, Vitae Patrum 8, 5, p 245 Google Scholar—Nicetius had been expected to leave a legacy to the basilica in which his tomb lay. See also Lib Hist X, 12, p 495 on Ingytrudis: ‘Haec vero cum filia discordiam tenens, pro eo quod res suas ei abstulerit, obtestaretque, ut neque in monasterio, quod institutt, neque super sepulchrum eius permitteretur orare.’

87 Gregory of Tours, de virt Mart 1, 23, p 150 Google Scholar.

88 Gregory of Tours, de gloria confessorum 72, p 341 Google Scholar.

89 Gregory of Tours, Vitae Patrum 1, praef p 213 Google Scholar.

90 John of Ephesus, HE 1, 3, p 1 Google ScholarPubMed; Gregory of Tours, Lib Hist 1, praef p 2 Google Scholar.

91 La Piana, G., Le rappresentazioni sacre nella letteratura bizantina (Grottaferrata 1912, Variorum Reprints 1971)Google Scholar; Mathews, T.F., The Early Churches of Constantinople: Architecture and Liturgy (Pennsylvania 1971)Google Scholar; and MacCormack, Sabine, EHR 88 (1973) pp 366-8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Libri Carolini, I, 19 ed Bastgen, H., MGH Leg sectio III, concilia ii (Berlin 1924) p 79 Google Scholar.

93 Gregory of Tours, de gloria martyrum 12, p 46 Google Scholar. See Brown, [Peter], ‘Society and the Supernatural[: a Medieval Change’], Daedalus 104 (1975) pp 133-51 at p 141Google Scholar.

94 For example Gregory of Tours, de virt Mart II, 4, p 161; II, 58, p 178; II, 59. P 179; III, 46, p 193; IV, 46, p 211; de gloria confessorum 67, p 338.

95 Gregory of Tours, Lib Hist VII, 29, p 347 Google Scholar.

96 For example Gregory of Tours, Lib Hist VII, 6, p 329 and VII, 14, p 336Google Scholar.

97 Steinleitner, F., Die Beicht im Zusammenhang mit der sakralen Rechtsgang in der Antike (Leipzig 1913), p 99 Google Scholar and Robert, L., Nouvelles Inscriptions des Sardes (Paris 1964) p 26 Google Scholar.

98 Brown, ‘The Holy Man’ p 89.

99 John of Ephesus, PO 17, pp 229-47.

100 Prinz, H., ‘Die bischöfliche Stadtherrshaft im Frankenreich’, HZ 217 (1973) pp 1-35 exaggerates for the sixth centuryGoogle Scholar.

101 Gregory of Tours, Lib Hist V, 18, p 219 Google Scholar. On the use of acclamations, see Liebeschütz, W., Antioch (Oxford 1972) pp 209-13Google Scholar.

102 Michelet, J., Tableau de la France (Paris 1949) p 29 Google Scholar.

103 Hegel, G. W.F., Philosophy of History, transl Sibree, J., (New York 1944) p 338 Google Scholar.

104 Baynes, N. H., ‘Some Aspects of Byzantine Civilisation’, Byzantine Studies (London 1960) p 75 Google Scholar ‘The law of Islam was fashioned by the religious consciousness of Islam: religion and law were inextricably intertwined . . . But the Christian Church, professing a creed of altruism, accepted a code of law which, as Mitteis has shown, is logically so completely satisfying because consistently based on the pre-suppositions of an egoism untroubled by humanitarian scruples’. For the ordeal in western Europe and the conditions under which sacred and profane were mingled and later disentangled, see Brown, ‘Society and the Supernatural’ pp 135-43 and Colman, Rebecca V., ‘Reason and Unreason in Early Medieval Law’, JIntH 4 (1974) pp 571-91Google Scholar.