Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-07T15:24:57.205Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Desecration of the Host: The Birth of an Accusation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Miri Rubin
Miri Rubin*
Affiliation:
University of Oxford Pembroke College, Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A New tale entered the circle of commonplace narratives about Jews which were known to men and women in the thirteenth century: the tale of Host desecration. This new narrative habitually unfolded (i) an attempt by a Jewish man to procure (buy, steal, exchange) a consecrated Host in order to (2) abuse it (in re-enactment of the Passion, in ridicule of bread claimed to be God), (3) only to be found out through a miraculous manifestation of the abused Host, which leads to (4) punishment (arrest and torture unto death, lynching by a crowd). The tale was a robust morality story about transgression and its punishment, and it always ended with the annihilation of the abusing Jew and often of his family, neighbours, or the whole local Jewish community. It was a bloody story, both in the cruelty inflicted on the Host/God and in the tragic end of the accused abuser and those related to him. This basic narrative was open to myriad interpretations and combinations, elaborations at every stage of its telling. It is a particularly interesting narrative inasmuch as it was often removed from the context of preaching and teaching, of exemplification, into the world of action and choice. The Host-desecration tale was not only a poignant story about Jews, it was also a blueprint for action whenever the circumstances of abuse suggested themselves in the lives of those who were reared on the tale. The story’s fictionality was masked from the very beginning of its life: it was always told as a report about a real event, with no irony or explicit elaboration. It was a concrete, new tale, which provided tangible knowledge about Jews, and through the actions of Jews, about the Eucharist.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 29: Christianity and Judaism , 1992 , pp. 169 - 185
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For a general survey of the Host-desecration accusation see Browe, P., ‘Die Hostienschändungen der Juden im Mittelalter’, Römische Quartalschrift, 34 (1926), pp. 167–97.Google Scholar

2 For accounts of this event see ‘De miraculo hostiae a Judaeo Parisiis anno Domini MCCXC myitis ignominiis effectatae’, Recueil des historiens des Gaules el de la France [hereafter RHCF], 22, pp. 32–3; ‘Ex brevi chronico Ecclesiae S. Dyonisii ad cyclos paschales’, RHGF, 23, p. 145; ‘Extrait d’une chronique anonyme finissant en MCCCLXXX’, RHGF, 21, pp. 123–30; ‘Extrait d’une chronique anonyme française, finissant en MCCCVIII’, RHGF, 21, pp. 132–3; ‘Chroniques de Saint-Denis depuis 1285 jusqu’en 1328’, RHGF, 20, pp. 654–724; Les Grandes chroniques de France, ed. Viard, J. (Paris, 1934), 8, pp. 144–5.Google Scholar On the case see Jordan, W. C.. The French monarchy and the Jews: from Philip Augustus to the Last Capetians (Philadelphia, Pa., 1989), pp. 192–4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 ‘Extrait d’une chronique … MCCCVIII’, p. 133.

4 The descriptions in the ‘Grandes chroniques’, pp. 144–5, the ‘Extrait d’une chronique … MCCCLXXX’, p. 127, and the ‘Chroniques de Saint-Denis’, p. 658, give very similar versions of the tale. A Latin account claims that a group of Jews had perpetrated desecration: ‘Quidam Judaei hostiam sacram a quodam pessimo habuerunt’, anno 1289. It also places the piercing with knives before the boiling in water: ‘Ex brevi chronico’, pp. 145-6.

5 On the imputation of intentions or beliefs to the Jews in cases of Host-desecration see Roth, C., ‘The mediaeval conception of the Jew’, in I. Davidson, ed., Essays and Studies in Memory of Linda R. Miller (New York, 1938), pp. 171–90, at pp. 180–2.Google Scholar

6 ‘De miraculo hostiae’, p. 32.

7 Ibid., ‘Frustra in ecclesia illa Christianos Deum suum quaerere ait, quern flagellatum injuriis affectum et male tractatum, modo pater suus occidisset.’

8 ‘Extrait d’une chronique … MCCCVIII’, p. 133.

9 ‘Chroniques de Saint-Denis’, p. 658.

10 Les Registres de Boniface VIII, 4 vols (Paris, 1884-93), 1, no. 441. See also ‘De miraculo hostiae’, p. 32, and S. Simonsohn, ed., The Apostolic See and the Jews. Documents: 402-1404 (Toronto, 1988), no. 175, pp. 283-4.

11 ‘lohannis de Thilrode Chronicon’, MCH.SS, 25, ed. Heller, J. (Hanover, 1880); or in RHGF, 23, pp. 145–6.Google Scholar

12 Saige, G., Les Juifs du Languedoc antérieurement au XIVe siècle (Paris, 1881), no. 20, pp. 235–6, at p. 236.Google Scholar See Menache, S., ‘Faith, myth, and politics—the stereotype of the Jews and the expulsion from England and France’, JQR, 75 (1984–5), pp. 351–74, p. 364.Google Scholar See also Chazan, R., Medieval Jewry in Northern France: a Political and Social History (Baltimore, Md., 1973). pp. 182–3.Google Scholar

13 Told in the Viaticum narrationum of Herman of Bologna, Beiträge zur lateinische Erzdhlungs-literatur des Mittelalters: III. Das Viaticum narrationum des Hermannus Bononiensis, ed. Hilka, A. (Berlin, 1935), no. 72, pp. 100–2.Google Scholar

14 The sequence is enshrined in the stained-glass windows of the abbey church of St Die of c.1280, described to me by Professor Meredith Lillich, whom I warmly thank.

15 See document on foundation of chapel in Brilling, B. and Richtering, H., eds, Westfalia judaica: Urkunden und Regesten zur Geschichte der Juden in Westfalen und Lippe (Sruttgart, 1967), no. 31, p. 56(1292 Google Scholar).

16 Hefele, C.-J. and Leclercq, H., Histoire des conciles (Paris, 1914), 6, 1, p. 138.Google Scholar

17 ‘Heinrici de Heimberg Annales’, MGH.SS, 17, ed. Pertz, G. H. (Hanover, 1861), p. 717.Google Scholar

18 Register of Bishop Godfrey Giffard, ed. Bund, J. W. Willis (Oxford, 1902), 1, p. 71.Google Scholar

19 On the story and its development and dissemination see Pelizaeus, T., Beiträge zur Geschichte der Legende vom Judenknabe (Halle, 1914 Google Scholar); Nissen, T.. ‘Zu den ältesten Fassungen der Legende vom Judenknabe’, Zeilschrift für französische Sprache und Lileratur, 62 (1938-9), pp. 393–403.Google Scholar

20 Southern, R. W., ‘The English origins of the “Miracles of the Virgin”‘, Mediaeval and Renaissance Studies, 4 (1958), pp. 176–216.Google Scholar

21 Rubin, M., Corpus Christi: the Eucharist in Late Medieval Culture (Cambridge, 1991), pp. 109–29.Google Scholar

22 Rivalto, Giordano da, Prediche del B. Giordano da Rivalto recitate in Firenze, ed. Moreni, D., 2 vols (Florence, 1831), 2, pp. 227–8 Google Scholar; on this report see Cohen, J., The Friars and the Jews: the Evolution of Medieval Anti-Judaism (Ithaca, NY, 1982), pp. 239–40.Google Scholar On Giordano see Lesnick, D. R., Preaching in Medieval Florence: the Social World of Franciscan and Dominican Spirituality (Athens, Ga., 1989), pp. 103–8, 111–33, 257–8.Google Scholar

23 Rudolf of Schlettstadt, Historiae memorabile, ed. Kleinschmidt, E. (Cologne, 1974); on the author, pp. 9–12.Google Scholar

24 Rivalto, Giordano da, Prediche, 2, pp. 231–2.Google Scholar On the introduction of the inquisition into Jewish matters in France see Kriegel, M., ‘La Jurisdiction inquisitoriale sur les juifs à l’époque de Philippe le Hardi et Philippe le Bel’, in Les Juifs dans l’histoire de France: premier colloque inter national, ed. Yardeni, M. (Leiden, 1980), pp. 70–7.Google Scholar

25 Croniche di Giovanni, Matteo e Filippo Villani–Bibliotheca classica italiana secolo xiv, 21 (Trieste, 1857), c. 143, p. 166.

26 Lavin, M. A., ‘The altar of Corpus Christi in Urbino: Paolo Uccello, Joos Van Ghent, Piero della Francesca’, Art Bulletin (1967), pp. 1–24 Google Scholar, at pp. 1–10.

27 ‘Continuatio Zwetlensis terna’, MGH.SS, 9, ed. A. Wattenbach (Hanover, 1851), p. 658.

28 On the massacres see Lotter, F., ‘Hostienfrevelvorwurf und Blutwunderfälschung bei den Judenverfolgungen von 1298 (“Rintfleisch”) und 1136-1338 (“Armleder”)’, in Fälschungen im Mittelalter (Hanover, 1988), 5, pp. 533–83, at pp. 548–60 Google Scholar; Lotter, F., ‘Die Judenverfolgung des “König Rintfleisch” in Franken um 1298. Die endgültige Wende in den christlich-jüdischen Beziehungen im Deutschen Reich des Mittelalters’, Zeitschrift für historische Forschung, 15 (1988), pp. 385–422.Google Scholar For a map of the massacres see Avneri, Z., ed., Germania judaica (Tubingen, 1968), 2, 1 Google Scholar, at end. See the Jewish sources in Salfeld, S., ed., Das Martyrohgium des Nürnberger Memorhuches (Berlin, 1898), pp. 162–200, 231–6.Google Scholar

29 Rudolf of Schlettstadt, Historiae memorabiles, c. 6, pp. 49–51.

30 Ibid.: ‘(Iudei) furati sunt plus quam centum hostias consecratas, que postea in domibus eorum in destructione cum nequciia eorum palefacta fuerat, illese hinc inde inventa sunt. Nam in pluribus locis acramentum Christi diversis modis obtinuerint.’

31 See the report of the chronicle of St Peter’s, Erfurt: ‘Christiani … post interfecrionem ipsorum ipsa secreciora eorundem purgantes invenerunt corpus Christi plurimis locis confossum’: Chronica S. Petri Erfordiensis, ed. O. Holder-Egger, MGH.SRG, 42 (Hanover, 1899), p. 319.

32 Thomas Ebendorfer, Chronica austria, MGH.SS, ns 13, ed. A. Lhotsky (Hanover, 1967), bk 3, pp. 370–1. Such a pattern also falls in with the economy of the ritual murder, which in the Norwich version imputed to the European Jewry an annual rotating schedule of child-murder by which a community was chosen annually to murder and provide the blood for the Paschal ritual; on this myth see Langmuir, G. I., ‘Thomas of Monmouth: detector of ritual murder’, in Towards a Definition of Antisemitism (Berkeley, 1990), pp. 209–36.Google Scholar

33 William the Proctor Chronicon comitum et nobilium Hollandiae ah 1206–1332, ed. A. Matthaeus (The Hague, 1738), 2, pp. 496-718, at p. 611.

34 Paris, BN, MS nouv. acq. 4857, fol. Q262. On this case see Weill, J., ‘Un Juif brulé à Metz vers 1385 pour profanation d’hostie’, REJ, 53 (1907), pp. 270–2.Google Scholar

35 Simonsohn, ed., The Apostolic See, pp. 372-4.

36 Vienna, Austrian National Library, MS 350, fols 1ra-17vb.

37 Urbkundenbuch des Stiftes Klosterneuburg bis zum Ende des vierzehnten Jahrhunderts, ed. Zeibig, H., Fontes rerum austriacaum, Diplomataria et acta, 28 (Vienna, 1868), pp. 172–5.Google Scholar

38 On the case of Korneuburg see Lohrmann, K., Judenrecht und Judenpolitik im mittelalterlichen Oslerreich (Cologne, 1990), p. 105 Google Scholar; see also the case of St Pölten, p. 106; see also with a reproduction of the altar-piece Die Zeit der frühen Habsburger. Dome una Klöster 1279-1379 (Vienna, ‘979). no. 119. p. 364; Lotter, ‘Hostienfrevelvorwurf, pp. 559-60.

39 Simonsohn, ed., The Apostolic See, p. 372.

40 Die Chronik Johanns von Winterthur, ed. Brun, C. and Bathgen, F., MCH.SRG, ns, 3 (Berlin, 1924), pp. 142–3 Google Scholar: ‘Iudeorum tribulatio orta et propter quendam sacerdotis nimia inopiam oppressum, qui hostiam sangwine aspersoit et a se proiectum iuxta ipsos ipsos suspectos reddidit et graviter infamavit.’

41 On which see Arnold, K., ‘Die Armledererhebung in Franken 1336’, Mainfränkisches Jahrbuch für Geschichte una Kunst, 26 (1974), pp. 35–62.Google Scholar

42 Arnold, , ‘Die Armledererhebung’, pp. 44–53.Google Scholar

43 In the fifteenth century Alfonso da Spina claimed that the tale decorated many a French chapel, Fortalitium fidei (Lyons, 1511), bk 3, consideratio 9; L. Muir, ‘The mass on the medieval stage’, Comparative drama, 23 (1989-90), pp. 314-30, at pp. 317-18.

44 On the English version of the drama of Host-desecration see Beckwith, S., ‘Ritual, Church and Theatre: medieval dramas of the sacramental body’, in Aers, David, ed., Culture and History, 1350-1660: Essays on English Communities, Identities and Writings (London, 1992), pp. 65–89.Google Scholar

45 For a short account and a bibliographical survey see Stengers, J., Les Juifs dans le Pays-Bas au moyen-âge (Brussels, 1950), pp. 24–7, 132–47.Google Scholar

46 Sans, J. Miret y, ‘El procès de les hosties contra ls Jueus d’Osca en 1377’, Annuari d’Estudis Catalanas, 4 (1911-12), pp. 59–80 Google Scholar; Bruyn, J., Van Eyck Problemen (Utrecht, 1957), pp. 143–4.Google Scholar

47 Graus, F., Struktur uttd Geschiclte. Drei Volksaufstände im mittelalterliclien Prag (Sigmaringen, 1971), PP. 50–60.Google Scholar

48 On the process of expulsion from late fifteenth-century Imperial territories see Wenninger, M.J., Man bedarf keiner Juden mehr. Ursachen und Hintergründe ihrer Vertreibung aus den deutschen Reichsstädten im 14. Jahrhundert (Vienna, 1981 Google Scholar).

49 Eckert, W. P., ‘Beatus-Simoninus—aus den Akten des Trienter Judenprozesses’, in Judenhass—Schuld des Christen?!, ed. Eckert, W. P. and Ehrlich, E. L. (Essen, 1964), pp. 329–58 Google Scholar; Eckert, W. P., ‘Aus den Akten des Trienter Judenprozesses’, in Judentum im Mittelalter, ed. Wilpert, P. (Berlin, 1966), pp. 283–336.Google Scholar Professor R. Po-chia Hsia is currently investigating afresh the contents and influence of the Trent affair.

50 In the words of a local chronicler, ‘Cives tamen Ratisponenses suam volentes honorare civitatem ipsos ludeos absque iudicio occidi et destrui vetuerunt’, ‘Eberhardi archidiaconi Rarisponensis annales’: MGH.SS, 17, ed. G. H. Pertz (Hanover, 1861), p. 597.