No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
On Prophecy and Politics: Some Pragmatic Reflections*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 February 2016
Extract
Prophecy is inescapably controversial; tension is always in the air. Prophetic utterance, no doubt properly, is apt to make many historians irritable and uncomfortable. Preoccupied with the past, the last thing they want to be saddled with is any responsibility for discerning the future or even seeking to make sense of the present. When Hugh Trevor-Roper, as he then was, attacked the writings of Arnold Toynbee in a savage article in Encounter in 1957, the gravamen of his charge was that Toynbee was not a historian at all, but a prophet, and, for good measure, a false one at that. Decent historians should not bother with the ten volumes of A Study of History because they were not history. The charges, in detail, may well have been justified, but the asperity went deeper. The caste of mind of historians, if they were truly professional, should make ‘prophetic history’ an impossibility. Prophets were indifferent to ‘facts’, or cavalier in their treatment of them, in pursuit of a grand vision. Historians, on the other hand, were obsessively fussy about details and were relatively unconcerned about grand theory. Indeed, historiography had ‘come of age’ precisely to the extent that it emancipated itself from prophecy.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1990
Footnotes
*
I am grateful to Dr R. P. Carroll, Mr G. B. A. M. Finlayson, and Professor G. Newlands for their advice and comments on an earlier draft.
References
1 McNeill, W. H., ‘Toynbee and the Historical Profession’, in Burton, J. K., ed., Essays in European History (New York and London, 1989), pp. 77–84Google Scholar; Trevor-Roper, H. R., ‘The Prophet’, New York Review of Books, 12 Oct. 1989Google Scholar. Trevor-Roper was reviewing McNeill’s biography of Toynbee.
2 Ward, W. R., Theology, Sociology and Politics: the German Protestant Social Conscience, 1890–1933 (Bern, 1979), pp. 208–16Google Scholar.
3 Skinner, Q., ‘Meaning and understanding in the history of ideas’, History and Theory, 8 (1969), and the debate and discussion in Tully, J., ed., Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and his Critics (Cambridge, 1988)Google Scholar.
4 Barton, J., People of the Book? The Authority of the Bible in Christianity (London, 1988), pp. 12–23, 76–8Google Scholar; Morgan, R. and Barton, J., Biblical Interpretation (Oxford, 1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Vidler, A. R., Prophecy and Papacy: a Study of Lamennais: the Church and the Revolution (London, 1954), pp. 275–8Google Scholar.
6 Parry, J. P., Democracy and Religion: Gladstone and the Liberal Party 1867–1875 (Cambridge, 1986), p. 205CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Oliver, W. H., Prophets and Milennialists: the Uses of Biblical Prophecy in England from the 1790s to the 1840s (Auckland, 1978)Google Scholar; Korshin, P.J., Typologies in England 1650–1820 (Princeton, 1982)Google Scholar, particularly ‘Typology and Prophecy’, pp. 328–68.
8 Gilley, S., ‘Newman and Prophecy, Evangelical and Catholic’, Journal of the United Reformed Church History Society, 3, 5 (March 1985), pp. 160–88Google Scholar.
9 Rosman, D., Evangelicals and Culture (London, 1984), pp. 24–6Google Scholar; Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in Modem Britain (London, 1989), pp. 85–6Google Scholar.
10 Finlayson, G. B. A. M., The Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, 1801–1885 (London, 1981)Google Scholar, esp. cap. 7, ‘Prophecy and Protestantism, 1841–1846’.
11 Shannon, R. T., Gladstone and the Bulgarian Agitation 1876 (London, 1963), pp. 161–2Google Scholar.
12 Harrison, J.F.C., The Second Coming: Popula Millenarianism 1769–1850 (London, 1979), p. 230Google Scholar.
13 Cited in Rogerson, J. W., Old Testament Criticism in the Nineteenth Century: England and Germany (London, 1984), p. 127Google Scholar.
14 Cited in Rogerson, Old Testament Criticism, p. 241.
15 Black, J. S. and Chrystal, G. W.. eds, The Life of William Robertson Smith (London, 1917), pp. 96–7Google Scholar; Smith, William Robertson, The Prophets of Israel and their Place in History to the Close of the Eighth Century BC (London, 1882)Google Scholar; Riesen, R. A., Criticism and Faith in late Victorian Scotland (London, 1985)Google Scholar.
16 Of course, prophecy came to be seen in many quarters as capable of purely ‘secular’ interpretation, and there were many contemporary Victorians who were anxious to be regarded, or were regarded, as ‘prophets’. Froude described Carlyle as ‘a prophet, in the Jewish sense of the word’ and Matthew Arnold, in his Introduction to Culture and Anarchy did not like to be referred to as an ‘elegant Jeremiah’. Ruskin similarly springs to mind. See Landow, G., Elegant Jeremiahs: the Sagefrom Carlyle to Mailer (Ithaca, 1986)Google Scholar, and his Victorian Types, Victorian Shadows: Biblical Typology in Victorian Literature, Art and Thought (Boston and London, 1980). Keating, P., The Victorian Prophets (London, 1981)Google Scholar.
17 Glover, W. B., Evangelical Nonconformity and Higher Criticism in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1954)Google Scholar.
18 Cameron, N. M. de S., Biblical and Higher Criticism and the Defense of Tnfallibilism in Nineteenth Century Britain (Lewiston, N.Y., 1987)Google Scholar; Smith, D. C., Passive Obedience and Prophetic Protest: Social Criticism in the Scottish Church 1830–1945 (New York, 1987), pp. 254–5Google Scholar, explicitly suggests that the greatest contribution of Old Testament criticism was to awaken the Church to the ‘central message of the great prophets’.
19 Shannon, , Gladstone and the Bulgarian Agitation, p. 163Google Scholar.
20 Parry, , Religion and Democracy, p. 451Google Scholar; Matthew, H. C. G., ed., The Gladstone Diaries IX 1875–1880 (Oxford, 1986), pp. 330, 539Google Scholar. Hilton, Boyd, ‘Gladstone’s Theological Polities’, in Bentley, M. and Stevenson, J., eds, High and how Politics in Modem Britain (Oxford, 1983), p. 53Google Scholar speaks of Gladstone’s ‘prophetic admonitions’.
21 Robbins, K. G., John Bright (London, 1979)Google Scholar and ‘John Bright—Quaker politician: A Centenary Appreciation’, Journal of the Friends’ Historical Society, 55 (1989), pp. 238–49.
22 Bebbington, D. W., The Nonconformist Conscience: Chapel and Politics 1870–1914 (London, 1975), p. 107Google Scholar.
23 Koss, S. E., Nonconformity in Modern British Politics (London, 1975), p. 107Google Scholar.
24 Cited in Wilkinson, A., Dissent or Conform? War, Peace and the English Churches, 1900–1945 (London, 1986), p. 24Google ScholarPubMed.
25 Wilkinson, , Dissent or Conform, p. 30Google Scholar.
26 Wallace, S., War and the Image of Germany: British Academics 1914–1918 (Edinburgh, 1988), pp. 172–3Google Scholar; Smith, L. Adam, George Adam Smith (London, 1943), pp. 169–76Google Scholar.
27 Baldwin, S., On England (Harmondsworth, 1937), pp. 208–9Google Scholar.
28 Lindsay, A. D., The Churches and Democracy (London, 1934)Google Scholar.
29 Wilkinson, , Dissent or Conform?, p. 127Google Scholar.
30 Robbins, K. G., Appeasement (Oxford, 1988)Google Scholar.
31 Robbins, K. G., ‘Britain, 1940, and Christian Civilization’, in Beales, D. and Best, G., eds, History, Society and the Churches: Essays in Honour of Owen Chadwick (Cambridge, 1985), pp. 279–99Google Scholar.
32 Gill, R., Prophecy and Praxis (London, 1981)Google Scholar; Ambler, R. and Haslam, D., eds, Agenda for Prophets (London, 1980)Google Scholar.
33 Bowden, J., What about the Old Testament? (London, 1964), pp. 86–90Google Scholar; Sawyer, J. F. A., New Perspectives in Old Testament Study (London, 1977)Google Scholar; Newlands, G., ‘The Old Testament and Christian Doctrine’, The Modern Churchman (1973), pp. 238–44Google Scholar.
34 Ling, T., Prophetic Religion (London, 1966)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
35 Preston, R. H., Church and Society in the Late Twentieth Century: the Economic and Political Task (London, 1983), p. 107Google Scholar.
36 Habgood, J., Church and Nation in a Secular Age (London, 1983), p. 105Google Scholar.
37 McCaughey, J. Davis, ‘Imagination in the Understanding of the Prophets’ in Mackey, J. P., ed., Religious Imagination (Edinburgh, 1986), pp. 161–73Google Scholar.
38 Carroll, R. P., ‘From Amos to Anderton: Reflections on being a prophet’, Ttieology (July 1987), pp. 256–63Google Scholar.
39 McKane, W., Prophets and Wise Men (London, 1965), pp. 128–30Google Scholar.