Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T03:34:51.826Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “Glorious” Revolution’s Inglorious Religious Commitment: Why Parliamentary Rule Failed to Secure Religious Liberty

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 July 2022

Parashar Kulkarni Open the ORCID record for Parashar Kulkarni [Opens in a new window]  and
Steven Pfaff Open the ORCID record for Steven Pfaff [Opens in a new window]
Parashar Kulkarni
Affiliation:
Political Science, Yale-NUS College, Singapore
Steven Pfaff
Affiliation:
Department of Sociology, University of Washington, Seattle, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many scholars contend that the “Glorious” Revolution of 1688 restrained governmental abuses in Britain by preventing the Crown from engaging in irresponsible behavior. However, the question of whether it imposed similar restraints on Parliament has received limited scrutiny. This oversight applies in particular to the religious sphere and outside of England. Rather than create the general conditions for liberty, we contend that the institutional legacy of the Revolution of 1688 was biased toward those in the winning coalition and that its positive effect on liberty is overstated. Analyzing the institutional legacy of the Glorious Revolution on religion in Scotland, we use narrative evidence and systematic evaluation of legislation to show that, rather than establishing the conditions for religious liberty in Britain, the revolution transferred power from one denomination to the other. The arbitrary religious repression symptomatic of the prerevolutionary Crown persisted because the religious liberties enshrined in the Revolution depended largely on whether a group was a member of its winning coalition. Whereas the Crown and the Episcopalians suppressed the Presbyterians prior to 1688, afterward an alliance between the Scottish Presbyterians and the English Parliament reinstated Presbyterianism as the established Scottish Church. This reversal allowed the Presbyterians to suppress the Episcopalians. Religious tolerance and attendant civil rights expanded only with secularization in the nineteenth century when the political representation of other denominations and religions increased and factionalism undercut Presbyterian monopoly.

Keywords

governmentinstitutionscommitmentreligious freedomrevolution
Type
Research Article
Information
Social Science History , Volume 46 , Issue 4 , Winter 2022 , pp. 693 - 718
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Social Science History Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Becker, S. O., Pfaff, S., and Rubin, J. (2016) “Causes and consequences of the Protestant Reformation.” Explorations in Economic History 62: 1–25.Google Scholar
Brathwaite, R., and Bramsen, A. (2011) “Reconceptualizing church and state: A theoretical and empirical analysis of the impact of separation of religion and state on democracy.” Religion and Politics 4: 229–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, Keith M., Mann, Alastair J., and Tanner, Roland J., eds. (2007–14) Records of the Parliaments of Scotland to 1707. https://www.rps.ac.uk/static/historicalintro8.html (accessed May 10).Google Scholar
Bruce, S. (1986) “A house divided: Protestant schisms and the rise of religious tolerance.” Sociological Analysis 47: 21–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bueno de Mesquita, B., Smith, A., Siverson, R. M., and Morrow, J. D. (2003) The Logic of Political Survival. MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Butterfield, H. (1931) The Whig Interpretation of History. Bell.Google Scholar
Carruthers, B. (1990) “Politics, popery, and property: A comment on North and Weingast.” The Journal of Economic History 50: 693–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, J. C. D. (2000) English Society, 1660–1832: Religion, Ideology and Politics during the Ancien Regime. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Clark, J. C. D. (2012) “Secularization and modernization: The failure of a ‘Grand Narrative.’” The Historical Journal 55: 161–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, T. (1990) “The Williamite Episcopalians and the Glorious Revolution in Scotland.” Records of the Scottish Church History Society 24: 33–51.Google Scholar
Cox, G. (2012) “Was the Glorious Revolution a constitutional watershed?” The Journal of Economic History 72: 567–600.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cox, G. (2018) “British state development after the Glorious Revolution.” European Review of Economic History 24: 24–45.Google Scholar
Davies, G., and Hardacre, P. (1962) “The restoration of the Scottish Episcopacy, 1660–1661.” Journal of British Studies 1: 32–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Driessen, M. (2010) “Religion, state and democracy: Analyzing two dimensions of church-state arrangements.” Politics and Religion 3: 55–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Field, C. D. (2008) “A shilling for Queen Elizabeth: The era of state regulation of church attendance in England, 1552–1969.” Journal of Church and State 50: 213–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Finke, R., Martin, R. R., and Fox, J. (2017) “Explaining discrimination against religious minorities.” Politics and Religion 10: 1–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, J. (2004) “Religion and state failure: An examination of the extent and magnitude of religious conflict from 1950 to 1996.” International Political Science Review 25: 55–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, J., and Flores, D. (2009) “Religions, constitutions, and the state: A cross-national study.” The Journal of Politics 71: 1499–1513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fukuyama, F. (2015) Political Order and Political Decay, 2nd ed. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar
Gallagher, M. E., and Hanson, J. K. (2015) “Power tool or dull blade? Selectorate theory for autocracies.” Annual Review of Political Science 18: 367–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gill, A. (2008) Political Origins of Religious Liberty. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Glassey, L. K. J. (2013) “In the search of the mot juste: Characterizations of the revolution of 1688–89,” in Harris, T. and Taylor, S. (eds.) The Final Crisis of the Stuart Monarchy. Boydell Press: 1–32.Google Scholar
Gregory, B. S. (2012) The Unintended Reformation: How a Religious Revolution Secularized Society. Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greif, A., and Rubin, J. (2015) “Endogenous political legitimacy: The English Reformation and the institutional foundations of limited government.” https://economics.yale.edu/sites/default/files/greif_and_rubin_-_sept_2015.pdf (accessed May 10).Google Scholar
Grim, B., and Finke, R. (2011) The Price of Freedom Denied: Religious Persecution and Violence. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Harris, T. (1993) Politics under the Later Stuarts: Party Conflict in Divided Society, 1660–1715. Longman.Google Scholar
Harris, T. (1999) “The people, the law, and the constitution in Scotland and England: A comparative approach to the Glorious Revolution.” The Journal of British Studies 38: 28–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, T. (2006) Revolution: The Great Crisis of the British Monarchy, 1685–1720. Penguin.Google Scholar
Harris, T., and Taylor, S., eds. (2013) The Final Crisis of the Stuart Monarchy: The Revolutions of 1688–91 in their British, Atlantic and European Contexts. Boydell Press.Google Scholar
Hempton, D. (1996) Religion and Political Culture in Britain and Ireland: From the Glorious Revolution to the Decline of Empire. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Iannaccone, L. R. (1998) “Introduction to the economics of religion.” Journal of Economic Literature 36: 1465–95.Google Scholar
Johnson, N. D., and Koyama, M. (2019) Persecution and Toleration: The Long Road to Religious Freedom. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnston, N. (2013) “The history of the parliamentary franchise.” Research Paper 13/14. House of Commons Library: 1–61.Google Scholar
Katz, D. (1996) The Jews in the History of England, 1485–1850. Clarendon Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Landemore, H. (2017) “Inclusive constitution making and religious rights: Lessons from the Icelandic experiment.” The Journal of Politics 79: 762–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lizzeri, A., and Persico, N. (2004) “Why did the elite extend the suffrage? Democracy and the scope of government, with an application to Britain’s age of reform.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 119: 707–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Macinnes, A. (1999) Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stuart, 1603–1788. Tuckwell.Google Scholar
Macinnes, A. (2007) “Jacobitism in Scotland: Episodic cause or national movement?” The Scottish Historical Review 86(2): 225–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miller, J. (1997) The Glorious Revolution, 2nd ed. Routledge.Google Scholar
Mullan, D. G. (1986) Episcopacy in Scotland. Humanities Press.Google Scholar
North, D., and Weingast, B. (1989) “Constitutions and commitment: The evolution of institutions governing public choice in seventeenth-century England.” The Journal of Economic History 49: 803–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ogilvie, S., and Carus, A. W. (2014) “Institutions and economic growth in historical perspective,” in Aghion, Philippe and Durlauf, Steven N. (eds.) Handbook of Economic Growth, Vol. 2: 403–513. Elsevier.Google Scholar
Piatonni, S. (2012) Clientelism, Interests, and Democratic Representation. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Pincus, S. (2009) 1688: The First Modern Revolution. Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Pincus, S., and Robinson, J. (2014) “What really happened during the Glorious Revolution? Institutions, property rights, and economic growth,” in Galiani, Sebastian and Sened, Itai (eds.) The Legacy of Douglass North. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Pittcock, M. (1998) Jacobitism. Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pocock, J. G. A. (2005) The Discovery of Islands: Essays in British History. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raffe, A. (2010a) “Presbyterians and Episcopalians: The formation of confessional cultures in Scotland, 1660–1715.” The English Historical Review 514: 570–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raffe, A. (2010b) “Presbyterianism, secularization, and Scottish politics after the revolution of 1688–1690.” The Historical Journal 53: 317–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raffe, A. (2012) “Scotland restored and reshaped: Politics and religion, c. 1660–1712,” in T. M. Devine and J. Wormald (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Modern Scottish History. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199563692.013.0013 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raffe, A. (2015) “James VII’s multiconfessional experiment and the Scottish Revolution of 1688–1690.” History 100(341): 354–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raffe, A. (2018) Scotland in Revolution, 1685–1690. Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Reynolds, A. (1912) The Churchman’s Guide. Longman, Green and Company.Google Scholar
Riley, P. W. J. (1979) King William and the Scottish Politicians. Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Rogers, B. (2020) “The House of Lords and religious toleration in Scotland: James Greenshield’s appeal, 1709–11.” Studies in Church History 56: 3520–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubin, J. (2017) Rulers, Religion and Riches: Why the West Got Rich and the Middle East Did Not. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scott, W. (2003[1815]) Guy Mannering. Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Stark, R. (2017) Reformation Myths. SPCK.Google Scholar
Stasavage, D. (2002) “Credible commitment in early modern Europe: North and Weingast revisited.” The Journal of Law, Economics and Organization 18: 155–86.Google Scholar
Stephen, J. (2010) “Defending the revolution: The Church of Scotland and the Scottish Parliament, 1689–95.” Scottish Historical Review 89(1): 19–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stewart, L. (2007) “The political repercussions of the Five Articles of Perth: A reassessment of James VI’s religious policies in Scotland.” The Sixteenth Century Journal 38: 1013–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strong, R. (2002) Episcopalians in Nineteenth-Century Scotland. Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Szechi, D. (1994) The Jacobites: Britain and Europe, 1688–1788. Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Troost, W. (2005) William III the Stadholder-king: A Political Biography. Routledge.Google Scholar
Van Bavel, B. (2016) The Invisible Hand: How Market Economies Have Emerged and Declined since AD 500. Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Webley-Parry, E. (1879) An Epitome of Anglican Church History. Griffin and Farran.Google Scholar
Whatley, C. (2006) The Scots and the Union. Edinburgh University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Whatley, C. (2013) “Reformed religion, regime change, Scottish Whigs and the struggle for the ‘Soul’ of Scotland, c. 1688–1788.” The Scottish Historical Review 92(1): 66–99.Google Scholar