Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T10:22:56.313Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Does Egalitarianism Come at a Price? Inequality and Economic Performance in Late-Nineteenth-Century Ontario

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 October 2017

Abstract

The relationship between economic performance and wealth inequality at a regional level is examined using county-level wealth for Ontario in 1892 and 1902. The results find that after controlling for confounding factors, declining wealth inequality was generally accompanied by slower economic performance as measured by changes in wealth levels and manufacturing output over time. This suggests that a more egalitarian wealth distribution came perhaps at the price of less robust economic performance.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Social Science History Association, 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aghion, Phiippe, Caroli, Eve, and García-Peñalosa, Cecilia (1999) “Inequality and economic growth: The perspective of the new growth theories.” Journal of Economic Literature 37 (4): 1615–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, Alberto, and Perotti, Roberto (1996) “Income distribution, political instability, and investment.” European Economic Review 40 (6): 1203–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, Alberto, and Rodrik, Dani (1994) “Distributive politics and economic growth.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 109 (2): 465–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altman, Morris (1987) “A revision of Canadian economic growth: 1870–1910 (a challenge to the gradualist interpretation).” Canadian Journal of Economics 20 (1): 86113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altman, Morris (1992) “Revised real Canadian GNP estimates and Canadian economic growth, 1870–1926.” Review of Income and Wealth, Series 38, 4 (December): 455–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ankli, Robert (1980) “The growth of the Canadian economy, 1896–1920: Export led and/or neoclassical growth.” Explorations in Economic History 17 (3): 251–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ashton, Thomas S. (1948) The Industrial Revolution, 1760–1830. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Atack, Jeremy, and Bateman, Fred (1981) “Egalitarianism, inequality, and age: The rural north in 1860.” Journal of Economic History 41 (1): 8593.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkinson, Anthony B., and Harrison, Alan J. (1978) “Wealth,” in Maunder, W. F. (ed.) Reviews of United Kingdom Statistical Sources: Volume 6. Oxford: Economic and Social Research Council.Google Scholar
Banerjee, Abhijit V., and Duflo, Esther (2003) “Inequality and growth: What can the data say?Journal of Economic Growth 8 (3): 267–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barro, Robert J. (2000) “Inequality and growth in a panel of countries.” Journal of Economic Growth 5 (1): 532.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barro, Robert J. (2008). “Inequality and growth revisited.” ADB Working Paper Series on Regional Economic Integration, No. 11, hdl.handle.net/11540/1762.Google Scholar
Baskerville, Peter (1999) “Women and investment in late nineteenth century urban Canada: Victoria and Hamilton, 1880–1901,” Canadian Historical Review 80 (2): 191218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benabou, Roland (2000) “Unequal societies: Income distribution and the social contract.” American Economic Review 90 (1): 96129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolton, Charles S. (1982) “Inequality on the southern frontier: Arkansas County in the Arkansas Territory.” The Arkansas Historical Quarterly 41 (1): 5166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bouchard, Gerard (1998) “Economic inequalities in Saguenay Society, 1879–1949: A descriptive analysis.” Canadian Historical Review 79 (4): 660–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bourbeau, Robert, and Légaré, Jaques (1982) Evolution de la mortalite au Canada et au Quebec 1831–1931. Montreal: Presses de l'Universite de Montreal.Google Scholar
Buckley, Kenneth (1955) Capital Formation in Canada, 1896–1930. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Burchell, Robert A. (1987) “Opportunity and the frontier: Wealth-holding in twenty-six northern Californian counties 1848–1880.” The Western Historical Quarterly 18 (2): 177–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Canaday, Neil (2008) “The accumulation of property by southern blacks and whites: Individual-level evidence from a South Carolina cotton county, 1910–1919.” Explorations in Economic History 45 (1): 5175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carlos, Ann, and Lewis, Frank (1992) “The profitability of early Canadian railroads: Evidence from the Grand Trunk and Great Western railway companies,” in Goldin, C. and Rockoff, H. (eds.) Strategic Factors in Nineteenth Century American Economic History: A Volume to Honor Robert W. Fogel. Chicago: University of Chicago Press: 401–26.Google Scholar
Castello-Climent, Amparo (2010). “Inequality and growth in advanced economies: an empirical investigation.” Journal of Economic Inequality 8 (3): 293321.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clay, Karen, and Jones, Randall (2008) “Migrating to riches? Evidence from the California Gold Rush.” Journal of Economic History 68 (4): 9971027.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cowell, Frank A. (1977) Measuring Inequality: Techniques for the Social Sciences. New York: Halsted Press, John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Cowell, Frank A., and Flachaire, Emmanuel (2007) “Income distribution and inequality measurement: The problem of extreme values.” Journal of Econometrics 141 (2): 1044–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dahlby, Bev, and Ferede, Ergete (2013) Income Inequality, Redistribution and Economic Growth. SPP Research Paper 6:25, School of Public Policy, University of Calgary.Google Scholar
Darroch, Gordon (1983) “Early industrialization and inequality in Toronto, 1861–1899.” Labour/Le Travailleur 11 (Spring): 3161.Google Scholar
Darroch, Gordon, and Soltow, Lee (1994) Property and Inequality in Victorian Ontario Structural Patterns and Cultural Communities in the 1871 Census. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Davies, James (1996) “Wealth inequality and age.” Research Report 9613, Department of Economics, University of Western Ontario.Google Scholar
Deaton, Angus (2013) The Great Escape: Health, Wealth and the Origins of Inequality. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio (1997) “The determinants of wealth and asset holding in nineteenth-century Canada: Evidence from microdata.” The Journal of Economic History 57 (4): 907–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio (2001) “Patterns of inequality in late 19th century Ontario: Evidence from census-linked probate data.” Social Science History 25 (3): 347–80.Google Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio (2008) “Wealth accumulation motives: Evidence from the probate records of Ontario, 1892 and 1902.” Cliometrica 2 (July): 143–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio (2012) “Land and inequality in Canada, 1870–1930,” Scandinavian Economic History Review 60 (3): 309–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio (2016) “All equal in the sight of God: Economic inequality and religion in the early twentieth century.” European Review of Economic History 20 (1): 2345.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Di Matteo, Livio, and George, Peter (1992) “Canadian wealth inequality in the late nineteenth century: A study of Wentworth County, Ontario, 1872–1902.” Canadian Historical Review 73 ( 4 ) 453–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Drummond, Ian M. (1987) Progress without Planning: The Economic History of Ontario from Confederation to the Second World War. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Escosura, Leandro P. De La (2008) “Inequality, poverty and the Kuznets curve in Spain, 1850–2000.” European Review of Economic History 12 (3): 287324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fernandez, Eva (2014) “Trust, religion and cooperation in western agriculture, 1880–1930.” Economic History Review 67 (3): 678–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferrie, Joseph (1994) “The wealth accumulation of antebellum European Immigrants to the U.S., 1840–1860.” Journal of Economic History 54 (1): 133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forbes, Kristin J. (2000) “A reassessment of the relationship between inequality and growth.” American Economic Review 90 (4): 869–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galenson, David W., and Pope, Clayne L. (1989) “Economic and geographic mobility on the farming frontier: Evidence from Appanoose County, Iowa, 1850–1870.” Journal of Economic History 49 (3): 635–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallman, Robert E. (1978) “Professor Pessen on the ‘egalitarian myth.’Social Science History 2 (2): 194207.Google Scholar
Galt, Margaret (1983) “Wealth and income in New Zealand c. 1870 to c. 1939.” PhD diss., Victoria University of Wellington.Google Scholar
Green, Alan G. (1967) “Regional aspects of Canada's economic growth, 1890–1929.” The Canadian Journal of Economics 33 (2): 232–45.Google Scholar
Green, Alan G. (1968/69) “Regional inequality, structural change, and economic growth in Canada.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 17 (4): 567–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green, Alan G. (1971) Regional Aspects of Canadian Economic Growth. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green, Alan G., and Urquhart, Malcom C. (1987) “New estimates of output growth in Canada: Measurement and interpretation,” in McCalla, D. (ed.) Perspectives on Canadian Economic History. Toronto: Copp Clark: 182–99.Google Scholar
Green, Alan G., and Urquhart, Malcom C. (1994) “New estimates of output growth in Canada: Measurement and Interpretation,” in McCalla, D. and Huberman, M. (eds.) Perspectives on Canadian Economic History, 2nd ed. Toronto: Copp Clark Longman Ltd.: 158–75.Google Scholar
Green, Alan G., MacKinnon, Mary, and Minns, Chris (2002) “Dominion or republic? Migrants to North America from the United Kingdom, 1870–1910.” Economic History Review 55 (4): 666–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greenwood, Daphne T. (1987) “Age, income, and household size: Their relation to wealth distribution in the United States,” in Wolff, Edward N. (ed.) International Comparisons of the Distribution of Household Wealth. New York: Oxford University Press: 121–40.Google Scholar
Gregson, Mary E. (1996) “Wealth accumulation and distribution in the Midwest in the late nineteenth century.” Explorations in Economic History 33 (4): 524–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gwyn, Julian, and Siddiq, Fazley K. (1992) “Wealth distribution in Nova Scotia during the Confederation Era, 1851 and 1871.” Canadian Historical Review 73 (4): 435–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herscovici, Steve (1993) “The distribution of wealth in nineteenth century Boston: Inequality among natives and immigrants, 1860.” Explorations in Economic History 30 (3): 321–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Higgins, Matthew, and Williamson, Jeffrey G. (2002) “Explaining inequality the world round: Cohort size, Kuznets curves, and openness.” Southeast Asian Studies 40 (3): 268302.Google Scholar
Hora, Roy (2012) “Argentina's top fortunes, 1750s–1940s.” Paper prepared for presentation at the World Economic History Association Meetings, Stellenbosch, South Africa, July 9–13.Google Scholar
Huberman, M. (2004) “Working hours of the World Unite? New international evidence of worktime, 1870–1913.” Journal of Economic History 64 (4): 9641001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Inwood, Kris, and Chamard, J. (1986) “Regional industrial growth during the 1890s: The case of missing artisans.” Acadiensis 16 (1): 101–16.Google Scholar
Inwood, Kris, and Chamard, J. (1998) “Extending the Green hypothesis: Regional aspects of Canada's economic growth 1870–90.” Paper presented at the conference Regions in Canadian Growth: A Gathering in Honour of Alan G. Green, Queen's University, Kingston, March 6–7.Google Scholar
Inwood, Kris, and Irwin, Jim (2002) “Land, income and regional inequality: New estimates of provincial income and growth in Canada, 1871–1891.” Acadiensis 31 (2): 157–84.Google Scholar
Jackson, G. E. (1923) “Emigration of Canadians to the United States,” in Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 107, Social and Economic Conditions in the Dominion of Canada: 25–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnston, Louis, and Williamson, Samuel H. (2016) “The annual real and nominal GDP for the United States, 1790–2014.” Measuring Worth, www.measuringworth.com/usgdp/.Google Scholar
Jones, Alice H. (1980) Wealth of a nation to be: The American colonies on the eve of the revolution. New York: Columbia Press.Google Scholar
Jones, Alice H. (1984) “Wealth and growth of the thirteen colonies: Some implications.” Journal of Economic History 44 (2): 239–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaldor, Nicholas (1957) “A model of economic growth.” Economic Journal 67 (268): 591624.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keay, Ian (2000a) “Scapegoats or responsive entrepreneurs: Canadian manufacturers, 1907–1990.” Explorations in Economic History 37 (3): 217–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keay, Ian (2000b) “Canadian manufacturers’ relative productivity performance, 1907–1990.” Canadian Journal of Economics 33 (4): 1049–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Khan, Zorina (2005) The Democratization of Invention: Patents and Copyrights in American Economic Development, 1790–1920. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
King, W. I. (1915) The Wealth and Income of the People of the United States. New York: MacMillan.Google Scholar
Kuznets, Simon (1955) “Economic growth and income inequality.” American Economic Review 45 (1): 128.Google Scholar
Kuznets, Simon (1966) Modern Economic Growth Rate, Structure and Spread. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Lemon, James T. (1972) The Best Poor Man's Country: A Geographical Study of Early Southeastern Pennsylvania. Baltimore: John Hopkins Press.Google Scholar
Lindert, Peter H. (1986) “Unequal English wealth since 1670.” Journal of Political Economy 94 (6): 1127–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lindert, Peter H. (1991) “Toward a comparative history of income and wealth,” in Brenner, Y. S., Kaelble, H., and Thomas, M. (eds.) Income Distribution in Historical Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 212–31.Google Scholar
Lindert, Peter H., and Williamson, Jeffrey G. (1985) “Growth, equality and history.” Explorations in Economic History 22 (4): 341–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lindert, Peter H., and Williamson, Jeffrey G. (2016) Unequal Gains: American Growth and Inequality since 1700. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Magee, Lonnie, Burbidge, John B., and Robb, A. Les (1991) “Computing kernel-smoothed conditional quantiles from many observations.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 86 (415): 673–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Main, Gloria L. (1975) “Probate records as a source for early American history.” William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser. 32 (1): 8999.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Main, Gloria L. (1977) “Inequality in early America: The evidence from probate records of Massachusetts and Maryland.” Journal of interdisciplinary History 8 (4): 559–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McAloon, James (2002) No Idle Rich: The Wealthy in Canterbury and Otago 1840–1914. Dunedin, NZ: University of Otago Press.Google Scholar
McInnis, Marvin (2007) “Canadian economic development in the wheat boom era: A reassessment.” Queen's University Economics Department. Mimeo.Google Scholar
McLean, Ian W. (2004) “Australian economic growth in historical perspective.” The Economic Record 80 (250): 330–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Milanovic, Branko, Lindert, Peter H. and Williamson, Jeffrey G. (2010) “Pre-industrial inequality.” The Economic Journal 121 (March): 255–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Minns, Chris (2000) “Income, cohort effects and occupational mobility: A new look at immigration to the United States at the turn of the 20th century.” Explorations in Economic History 37 (4): 326–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newell, William H. (1980) “The wealth of testators and its distribution: Butler County Ohio, 1803–65,” in Smith, James D. (ed.) Modelling the Distribution and Intergenerational Transmission of Wealth. NBER Studies in Income and Wealth. Vol. 46. Chicago: University of Chicago Press: 95138.Google Scholar
Newell, William H. (1986) “Inheritance on the maturing frontier: Butler County Ohio, 1803–1865,” in Engerman, S. L. and Gallman, R. E. (eds.) Long-Term Factors in American Economic Growth. NBER Studies in Income and Wealth. Vol. 51. Chicago: University of Chicago Press: 261303.Google Scholar
Officer, Lawrence H. (2016) “What was the U.K. GDP then?” Measuring Worth, http://www.measuringworth.com/ukgdp/.Google Scholar
Ohlsson, Henry, Roine, Jesper, and Waldenstrom, Daniel (2008) “Long-run changes in the concentration of wealth: An overview of recent findings,” in Davis, J. B. (ed.) Personal Wealth from a Global Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 42–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Osberg, Lars, and Siddiq, Fazley K. (1988) “The inequality of wealth in Britain's North American Colonies: The importance of the relatively poor.” Review of Income and Wealth, Series 34 (2): 143–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Osberg, Lars, and Siddiq, Fazley K. (1992) “The acquisition of wealth in Nova Scotia in the late nineteenth century,” in Wolff, E. N. (ed.) Research in Economic Inequality 4 (December): 181202.Google Scholar
Owens, Alastair, Green, David R., Bailey, Craig, and Kay, Alison C. (2006) “A measure of worth: Probate valuations, personal wealth and indebtedness in England, 1810–40.” Historical Research 79 (205): 383403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perotti, Roberto (1993). “Political equilibrium, income distribution and economic growth.” Review of Economic Studies 60 (4): 755–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Persson, Torsten, and Tabellini, Guido (1994) “Is inequality harmful for growth?American Economic Review 84 (3): 600–21.Google Scholar
Piketty, Thomas (2014) Capital in the 21st Century. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pope, Clayne L. (1980) “Household wealth in a settlement economy: Utah, 1850–1870.” Journal of Economic History 40 (3): 477–96.Google Scholar
Roine, Jesper, and Waldenstrom, Daniel (2014) “Long run trends in the distribution of income and wealth.” Uppsala Center for Fiscal Studies, Working Paper 5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubinstein, William D. (1977) “The Victorian middle classes: Wealth, occupation and geography.” Economic History Review 30 (4): 602–23.Google Scholar
Rubinstein, William D. (1979) “The distribution of personal wealth in Victoria 1860–1974.” Australian Economic History Review 19: 2641.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubinstein, William D. (1987) “The Victorian middle classes: Wealth, occupation and geography,” in Rubinstein, W. D. (ed.) Elites and the Wealthy in Modern British History: Essays in Social and Economic History. Sussex, UK, and New York: The Harvester Press: x–383.Google Scholar
Rubinstein, William D. (1988) “The size and distribution of the English middle classes in 1860.” Historical Research 61 (144): 6589.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ruggles, Steven, J. Alexander, Trent, Genadek, Katie, Goeken, Ronald, Schroeder, Matthew B., and Sobek, Matthew (2010) Integrated Public Use Microdata Series: Version 5.0 [machine-readable data set]. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.Google Scholar
Shanahan, Martin P. (2001) “Personal wealth in South Australia.” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 32 (1): 5580.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shanahan, Martin P., and Correll, Margaret (1997) “In search of Kuznet's curve: A reexamination of the distribution of wealth in the United States between 1650 and 1950.” Paper presented at the Third World Congress of Cliometrics, Munich, July 10–13.Google Scholar
Shanahan, Martin P., and Correll, Margaret (2000) “How much more unequal? Consistent estimates of the distribution of wealth in the United States between 1774 and 1860.” Journal of Income Distribution 9 (1): 2737.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shorrocks, Anthony F. (1975a) “The age-wealth relationship: A cross-section and cohort analysis.” Review of Economics and Statistics 57 (2): 155–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shorrocks, Anthony F. (1975b) “On stochastic models of size distribution.” Review of Economic Studies 42 (4): 631–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Siddiq, Fazley K. (1988) “The size distribution of probate wealthholdings in Nova Scotia in the late 19th century.” Acadiensis 18 (1): 136–47.Google Scholar
Siddiq, Fazley K., and Gwyn, Julian (1991) “The importance of probate inventories in estimating the distribution of wealth.” Nova Scotia Historical Review 11 (1): 103–17.Google Scholar
Soltow, Lee (1975) Men and Wealth in the United States 1850–1870. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Soltow, Lee (1979) “Inequality amidst abundance: Land ownership in early 19th century Ohio.” Ohio History 88 (2): 133–51.Google Scholar
Soltow, Lee (1989) Distribution of Wealth and Income in the United States in 1798. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Canada, Statistics (1999) Historical Statistics of Canada. 11-516-X, www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/11-516-x/sectiona/4147436-eng.htm.Google Scholar
Steckel, Richard H. (1990) “Poverty and prosperity: A longitudinal study of wealth accumulation, 1850–1860.” Review of Economics and Statistics 72 (2): 275–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steckel, Richard H., and Moehling, Carolyn M. (2001) “Rising inequality: Trends in the distribution of wealth in industrializing New England.” Journal of Economic History 61 (1): 160–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stewart, J. I. (2006) “Migration to the agricultural frontier and wealth accumulation, 1860–1870.” Explorations in Economic History 43 (4): 547–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stewart, James I. (2009) “Economic opportunity or hardship? The causes of geographic mobility on the agricultural frontier.” The Journal of Economic History 69 (1): 238–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stigliz, Joseph (2012) The Price of Inequality. New York: W. W. Norton.Google Scholar
Urquhart, Malcolm C. (1993) Gross National Product, Canada 1870–1926. Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vedder, Richard K., and Gallaway, Lowell E. (1970) “Settlement patterns of Canadian emigrants to the United States, 1850–1960.” Canadian Journal of Economics 3 (3): 476–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, Thomas R. (2000) “Economic opportunity on the urban frontier: Wealth and nativity in early San Francisco.” Explorations in Economic History 37 (3): 258–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williamson, Jeffrey G. (1965) “Regional inequality and the process of national development.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 13 (4, part 2): 1–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williamson, Jeffrey G. (1996) “Globalization and inequality then and now: The late 19th and late 20th centuries compared.” National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 5491.Google Scholar
Williamson, Jeffrey G. (1998) “Growth, distribution and demography: Some lessons from history.” Explorations in Economic History 35 (3): 241–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williamson, Jeffrey G., and Lindert, Peter H. (1980) American Inequality: A Macroeconomic History. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Wolff, Edward N. (1991) “The distribution of household wealth: Methodological issues, time trends, and cross-sectional comparisons,” in Osberg, L. (ed.) Economic Inequality and Poverty: International Perspectives. New York: M. E. Sharpe: 92133.Google Scholar