Article contents
Appealing for a Car: Consumption Policies and Entitlement in the USSR, the GDR, and Romania, 1950s-1980s
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 January 2017
Abstract
In this article, I analyze the correspondence between state authorities and citizens in the USSR, the GDR, and Romania. As the consumerist turn spread across the eastern bloc, an important focus of the populations' appeals to the authorities concerned the appropriate levels and conditions of consumption. Their letters display growing consumer aspirations, and from the mid-1960s onward a significant number of these petitions expressed the desire to buy a car. However, when state authorities failed to deliver enough cars, they also shaped a new attitude toward consumption. On the one hand, the population asked for automobiles as favors. On the other, a new discourse of entitlement and even “consumer rights” surfaced. Citizens started to expect a certain lifestyle; moreover, they even believed themselves to be entitled to it. As a consequence, their new sense of entitlement diluted the culture of favors and privilege, thereby contributing to the crisis of legitimacy in late socialism.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Association for Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies. 2016
References
I thank Jan Plamper, Svetlana Suveica, Eszter Varsa, Stefano Petrungaro, and the anonymous reviewers for Slavic Review for their useful comments and suggestions. I am also grateful to Mark Hatlie for language editing.
1. “Hape Kerkeling—Der letzte Trabi,” YouTube video, 6:01, an episode of Daruber lacht die Welt, televised by Sat. 1, posted by “tschakaa51,” August 26, 2006, at youtu.be/ dfoT8K706e4 (last accessed September 11,2015; no longer available).
2. Siegelbaum, Lewis H., Cars for Comrades: The Life of the Soviet Automobile (Ithaca, 2008), 173.Google Scholar
3. Bren, Paulina and Neuburger, Mary, introduction to Paulina Bren and Mary Neuburger, eds., Communism Unwrapped: Consumption in Cold War Eastern Europe (Oxford, 2012), 8 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Smith, Mark B., Property of Communists: The Urban Housing Program from Stalin to Khrushchev (DeKalb, 2010), 12 Google Scholar; Reid, Susan E. and Crowley, David, “Style and Socialism: Modernity and Material Culture in Post-War Eastern Europe,” in Reid, Susan E. and Crowley, David, eds., Style and Socialism: Modernity and Material Culture in Post-War Eastern Europe (Oxford, 2000), 4-7 Google Scholar; and Landsman, Mark, Dictatorship and Demand: The Politics of Consumerism in East Germany (Cambridge, Mass., 2004), 130-36.Google Scholar
4. Neuburger, Mary, Balkan Smoke: Tobacco and the Making of Modern Bulgaria (Ithaca, 2013), 8-9 Google Scholar; Merkel, Ina, Utopie und Bedurfnis: Die Geschichte der Konsumkultur in der DDR (Cologne, 1999), 24-27 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Chernyshova, Natalya, Soviet Consumer Culture in the Brezhnev Era (London, 2013), 43-70.Google Scholar
5. Smith, , Property, 69-99 Google ScholarPubMed; Harris, Steven E., Communism on Tomorrow Street: Mass Housing and Everyday Life after Stalin (Washington, D.C., 2013), 4-9 Google Scholar; Siegelbaum, Lewis H., “Cars, Cars and More Cars: The Faustian Bargain of the Brezhnev Era,” in Siegelbaum, Lewis H., ed., Borders of Socialism: Private Spheres of Soviet Russia (Basingstoke, 2006), 83-106, 84-88 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Betts, Paul, “The Politics of Plenty: Consumerism in Communist Societies,” in Smith, Stephen A., ed., The Oxford Handbook of the History of Communism (Oxford, 2014), 427-28.Google Scholar
6. Matthews, Mervyn, Privilege in the Soviet Union: A Study of Elite Life-Styles under Communism (London, 1978), 17-35 Google Scholar; Bren, Paulina and Neuburger, Mary, introduction to part 1, “Living Large,” in Bren, and Neuburger, , eds., Communism Unwrapped, 21-25 Google Scholar; and Siegelbaum, , Cars, 235-42.Google Scholar
7. Hoffmann, David L., Stalinist Values: The Cultural Norms of Soviet Modernity, 1917-1941 (Ithaca, 2003), 119-21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8. Fitzpatrick, Sheila, “Becoming Cultured: Socialist Realism and the Representation of Privilege and Taste,” in Sheila, Fitzpatrick, ed., The Cultural Front: Power and Culture in Revolutionary Russia (Ithaca, 1992), 216 Google Scholar; Gronow, Jukka, Caviar with Champagne: Common Luxury and the Ideals of the Good Life in Stalin's Russia (Oxford, 2003), 12-14 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Osokina, Elena A., Our Daily Bread: Socialist Distribution and the Art of Survival in Stalin's Russia, 1927-1941, ed. Transchel, Kate, trans. Transchel, Kate and Bucher, Greta (Armonk, 2000), 82-98 Google Scholar; Hoffmann, , Stalinist Values, 137-45Google Scholar; and Gronow, Jukka and Zhuravlev, Sergei, “Soviet Luxury from Champagne to Private Cars,” in Crowley, David and Reid, Susan, eds., Pleasures in Socialism: Leisure and Luxury in the Eastern Bloc (Evanston, 2010), 121-46.Google Scholar
9. Brooks, Jeffrey, Thank You, Comrade Stalin! Soviet Public Culture from Revolution to Cold War (Princeton, 2000), 83-105 Google Scholar; Smith, , Property, 175.Google ScholarPubMed
10. Hoffmann, , Stalinist Values, 137 Google Scholar; Osokina, , Daily Bread, 94-97.Google Scholar
11. Davies, Sarah, Popular Opinion in Stalin's Russia: Terror, Propaganda, and Dissent, 1934-1941 (Cambridge, Eng., 1997), 138-44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12. Fitzpatrick, Sheila, “Supplicants and Citizens,” in Fitzpatrick, Sheila, ed., Tear Off the Masks! Identity and Imposture in Twentieth-Century Russia (Princeton, 2005), 155-81.Google Scholar
13. Bren and Neuburger, introduction, 14.
14. Besides official retail, citizens of the eastern bloc had several other options for acquiring cars, either legally, through hard currency, or in the “second economy.” But as I am mainly interested in the communication process between state authorities and citizens, I am focusing here on official retail plans and the citizens’ responses to them. Certainly, one reaction to official retail policies was to find alternative ways to purchase cars, and I also do not deny that these alternatives helped stabilize official distribution. Nevertheless, citizens took official consumption policies seriously and measured their needs and expectations against what the state offered. Also, when voicing complaints, they took official discourses and practices as a point of reference. On alternative ways of buying goods, see Zatlin, Jonathan B., The Currency of Socialism: Money and Political Culture in East Germany (Cambridge, Eng., 2007), 243-85Google Scholar; Ledeneva, Alena V., Russia's Economy of Favours: Blat, Networking, and Informal Exchange (Cambridge, Eng., 1998)Google Scholar; and Mazurek, Malgorzata, “Filling the Gap Between Plan and Needs: Social Networks in the Local Government System in Communist Poland,” in Schuhmann, Annette, ed., Vernetzte Improvisationen: Gesellschaftliche Subsysteme in Ostmitteleuropa und in der DDR (Cologne, 2008), 103-20.Google Scholar
15. Mark B. Smith argues that the ubiquity of moving into new apartments and certain rules on how living space was distributed made citizens believe that they actually had the “right” to a separate apartment, although this was not stipulated in any law or contract. Smith, Property, 170-71.
16. To name just a few examples: Bren and Neuburger, eds., Communism Unwrapped; Reid and Crowley, eds., Style; Reid and Crowley, eds., Pleasures; and Angela Romano and Federico Romero, “European Socialist Regimes Facing Globalisation and European Co-operation: Dilemmas and Responses—Introduction,” in “European Socialist Regimes Facing Globalisation and European Cooperation: Dilemmas and Responses,” ed. Angela Romano and Federico Romero, special issue, European Review of History/Revue europeenne d'histoire 21, no. 2 (2014): 157-64.
17. Keck-Szajbel, Mark, “Shop around the Bloc: Trader Tourism and Its Discontents on the East German-Polish Border,” in Bren, and Neuburger, , eds., Communism Unwrapped, 374-92Google Scholar; Gorsuch, Anne E., All This Is Your World: Soviet Tourism at Home and Abroad after Stalin (Oxford, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Stola, Dariusz and Keck-Szajbel, Mark, “Crossing the Borders of Friendship: Mobility across Communist Borders,” East European Politics and Societies 29, no. 1 (2015): 92-95.Google Scholar
18. Patterson, Patrick Hyder, “Risky Business: What Was Really Being Sold in the Department Stores of Socialist Eastern Europe?,” in Bren, and Neuburger, , eds., Communism Unwrapped, 116-39.Google Scholar
19. Stokes, Gale, The Walls Came Tumbling Down: The Collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe (Oxford, 1993), 150-59Google Scholar; Merkel, , Utopie, 310-27.Google Scholar
20. Reid, and Crowley, , “Style,” 4-7.Google ScholarPubMed
21. Recent literature on historical comparison recommends an approach that combines a “classical” comparison, which weighs similarities and differences between the case studies, and an entangled history, which traces different influences on the case studies. Cohen, Deborah and O'Connor, Maura, “Introduction: Comparative History, Cross- National History, Transnational History—Definitions,” in Cohen, Deborah and O'Connor, Maura, eds., Comparison and History: Europe in Cross-National Perspective (New York, 2004), x-xvi CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard and Kocka, Jiirgen, “Comparison and Beyond: Traditions, Scope and Perspectives of Comparative History,” in Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard and Kocka, Jiirgen, eds., Comparative and Transnational History: Central European Approaches and New Perspectives (New York, 2012), 1-31 Google Scholar; and Werner, Michael and Zimmermann, Benedicte, “Beyond Comparison: Histoire Croisee and the Challenge of Reflectivity,” History and Theory 45 (February 2006): 30-50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
22. Todorova, Maria, Imagining the Balkans (Oxford, 2009)Google Scholar; Kocka, Jiirgen, “Asymmetrical Historical Comparison: The Case of the German Sonderweg ,” History and Theory 38 (February 1999): 40-51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
23. Betts, , “The Politics of Plenty,” 426 Google Scholar; Mazurek, Malgorzata and Hilton, Matthew, “Consumerism, Solidarity and Communism: Consumer Protection and Consumer Movement in Poland,” Journal of Contemporary History 42, no. 2 (2007): 315-43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
24. One exception to the prevailing negative assessment of consumption policies in Romania is Jill Massino, “From Black Caviar to Blackouts: Gender, Consumption, and Lifestyle in Ceauescus's Romania,” in Bren and Neuburger, eds., Communism Unwrapped, 226-53.
25. Jones, Polly, ed., The Dilemmas of De-Stalinization: Negotiating Cultural and Social Change in the Khrushchev Era (London, 2006), 6-9.Google Scholar
26. Castillo, Greg, Cold War on the Home Front: The Soft Power of Midcentury Design (Minneapolis, 2009)Google Scholar; Reid, Susan E., “Cold War in the Kitchen: Gender and the De-Stalinization of Consumer Taste in the Soviet Union under Khrushchev,” Slavic Review 61, no. 2 (Summer 2002): 228-35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
27. Harris, , Communism, 5.Google Scholar
28. Pence, Katherine and Betts, Paul, introduction to Katherine Pence and Paul Betts, eds., Socialist Modern: East German Everyday Culture and Politics (Ann Arbor, 2008), 8 Google Scholar; Stitziel, Judd, Fashioning Socialism: Clothing, Politics, and Consumer Culture in East Germany (Oxford, 2005), 23-24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
29. Landsman, , Dictatorship, 129-32Google Scholar; Rubin, Eli, Synthetic Socialism: Plastics and Dictatorship in the German Democratic Republic (Chapel Hill, 2008), 10.Google Scholar
30. Crew, David F., “Consuming Germany in the Cold War: Consumption and National Identity in East and West Germany, 1949-1989, an Introduction,” in Crew, David F., ed., Consuming Germany in the Cold War (Oxford, 2003), 3-8 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Landsman, , Dictatorship, 180-86Google Scholar; and Fulbrook, Mary, The People's State: East German Society from Hitler to Honecker (New Haven, 2005), 23-48.Google Scholar
31. Reid, and Crowley, , “Style,” 9-12 Google ScholarPubMed; Bren and Neuburger, introduction, 9; and Betts, , “Politics of Plenty,” 428.Google Scholar
32. Tismaneanu, Vladimir, Stalinism for All Seasons: A Political History of Romanian Communism (Berkeley, 2003), 142-48Google Scholar; Massino, , “Black Caviar,” 229-30.Google Scholar
33. Chernyshova, , Soviet Consumer, 18-24 Google Scholar; Landsman, , Dictatorship, 213-15Google Scholar; and Massing, “Black Caviar,” 231-36.Google Scholar
34. Bren, Paulina, “Weekend Getaways: The Chata, the Tramp, and the Politics of Private Life in Post-1968 Czechoslovakia,” in Crowley, David and Reid, Susan E., eds., Socialist Spaces: Sites of Everyday Life in the Eastern Bloc (Oxford, 2002), 123-24Google Scholar; Siegelbaum, , Cars, 242-47Google Scholar; Millar, James R., “The Little Deal: Brezhnev's Contribution to Acquisitive Socialism,” Slavic Review 44, no. 4 (Winter 1985): 694-706.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
35. Bren and Neuburger, introduction, 12.
36. Chernyshova, , Soviet Consumer, 31-32.Google Scholar
37. Sywottek, Arnold, “Gewalt-Reform-Arrangement: Die DDR in den 60er Jahren,” in Schildt, Axel, Siegfried, Detlef, and Lammers, Karl Christian, eds., Dynamische Zeiten: Die 60erjahre in den beiden deutschen Gesellschaften (Hamburg, 2000), 55-57 Google Scholar; Steiner, Andre, Von Plan zu Plan: Eine Wirtschaftsgeschichte derDDR (Munich, 2004), 142-50.Google Scholar
38. Steiner, , Plan, 191-94Google ScholarPubMed; Landsman, , Dictatorship, 215 Google Scholar; and Zatlin, , Currency, 90-93.Google Scholar
39. Massino, , “Black Caviar,” 236-37.Google Scholar
40. Kotkin, Stephen, Armageddon Averted: The Soviet Collapse, 1970-2000 (Oxford, 2001), 10-19 Google Scholar; Bren and Neuburger, introduction, 13.
41. Cook, Linda J., The Soviet Social Contract and Why It Failed: Welfare Policy and Workers'Politics from Brezhnev to Yeltsin (Cambridge, Mass., 1993)Google Scholar; Brown, Archie, Seven Years That Changed the World: Perestroika in Perspective (Oxford, 2007).Google Scholar
42. Zatlin, , Currency, 198-99Google Scholar; Betts, , “Politics of Plenty,” 8.Google Scholar
43. Verdery, Katherine, National Ideology under Socialism: Identity and Cultural Politics in Ceausescu's Romania (Berkeley, 1991), 197-208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
44. Massino, , “Black Caviar,” 241-43Google Scholar; Cioroianu, Adrian, Pe umerii lui Marx: 0 indroducere in istoria comunismul romdnesc (Bucharest, 2005), 467-88Google Scholar; Stan, Marius, “Cu sacosa spre comunism: Programul stiintific de alimentatie rajionala in Romania socialista,” in Ivan, Ruxandra, ed., “Transformarea socialist“: Politici ale regimului communist intre ideologic si administrate (Iasi, 2009), 139-43Google Scholar; and Verdery, Katherine, “The ‘Etatization’ of Time in Ceausescu's Romania,” in Verdery, Katherine, ed., What Was Socialism and What Comes Next? (Princeton, 1996), 39-57.Google Scholar
45. Siegelbaum, , Cars, 224-25.Google Scholar
46. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv noveishei istorii (RGANI), f. 5, op. 42, d. 115, 1.102.
47. Ibid., 1. 109. The situation was similar in other parts of the Soviet Union. See RGANI, f. 5, op. 42, d. 99; and RGANI, f. 5, op. 42, d. 100.
48. Siegelbaum, , Cars, 226-27.Google Scholar
49. Bundesarchiv Berlin (BArchB), DEI/14979; Zatlin, , Currency, 224-25Google Scholar; and Merkel, Ina, “Der Trabant,” in Sabrow, Martin, ed., Erinnerungsorte der DDR (Munich, 2009), 363-73.Google Scholar
50. Crew, , “Consuming Germany,” 3 Google Scholar; Zatlin, , Currency, 206 Google Scholar; and Rubin, Eli, “The Trabant: Consumption, Eigen-Sinn, and the Movement,” History Workshop Journal 68, no. 1 (2009): 28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
51. Tracy Nichols-Busch, ‘“A Class on Wheels': Avtodor and the ‘Automobilization’ of the Soviet Union, 1927-1935” (PhD diss., Georgetown University, 2003); Konig, Wolfgang, Volkswagen, Volksempfanger, Volksgemeinschaft: “Volksprodukte” im Dritten Reich. Vom Scheitern einer nationalsozialistischen Konsumgesellschaft (Paderborn, 2004), 151-90.Google Scholar
52. Konig, , Volkswagen, 158.Google Scholar
53. Zatlin, , Currency, 204 Google Scholar; Sonke, Friedrich, Autos bauen im Sozialismus: Arbeit und Organisationskultur in der Zwickauer Automobilindustrie nach 1945 (Leipzig, 2008), 565.Google Scholar
54. Barchb, Stiftung Archiv der Parteien und Massenorganisationen der DDR im Bundesarchiv (SAPMO), DY30/JIV 2/2 234,19; BArchB, SAPMO, DY30/JIV 2/3 323, 5.
55. BArchB, DEI/17275, o. S.
56. Car production rose steadily in the GDR, from 35,597 units in 1957 to 64,071 in 1960 and 159,147 in 1975. See Statistisches Jahrbuch der Deutschen Demokratischen Republik (Berlin, 1980), 121.
57. Pucher, John, “Capitalism, Socialism, and Urban Transportation Policies, and Travel Behavior in the East and West,” Journal of the American Planning Association 56, no. 3 (1990): 281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
58. On this process of convergence inside the eastern bloc, see Gatejel, Luminita, “The Common Heritage of the Socialist Car Culture,” in Siegelbaum, Lewis, ed., The Socialist Car: Automobility in the Eastern Bloc (Ithaca, 2011), 145-47.Google Scholar
59. Siegelbaum, , Cars, 39-40.Google Scholar
60. Reid, , “Cold War,” 223-25Google Scholar; Hixson, Walter L., Parting the Curtain: Propaganda, Culture, and the Cold War, 1945-1961 (Basingstoke, 1997), 180.Google Scholar
61. Siegelbaum, , Cars, 86.Google Scholar
62. Ibid., 88-102.
63. Pavelescu, Alina, “Charles de Gaulle si ‘marile ambitii’ ale comunistilor romani, mai 1968,” Arhivele Totalitarismului, nos. 1-2 (2005): 191-208 Google Scholar; Cioroianu, , Pe umerii, 319-60.Google Scholar
64. Arhivele Nationale Istorice Centrale (ANIC), Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Cancelarie, dosar nr. 105/1966, 12-30.
65. Vasiliu, Chiriac, Automobilul in Romania: Istorie si Tehnica (Bucharest, 1994), 62.Google Scholar
66. Petrescu, Dragos, “Conflicting Perceptions of (Western) Europe: The Case of Communist Romania, 1958-1989,” in Faraldo, Jose M., ed., Europe in the Eastern Bloc: Imaginations and Discourses (1945–1991) (Cologne, 2008), 208.Google Scholar
67. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Sectfa Gospodarie de Partid, dosar nr. 3/1957; ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Secjia Gospodarie de Partid, dosar nr. 4/1960; and Vasiliu, Automobilul, 177.
68. For a broader discussion of these exchanges across the Iron Curtain, see Luminita Gatejel, Warten, hoffen und endlich fahren: Auto und Sozialimus in der Sowjetunion, in Rumdnien und der DDR (1956-1989/91) (Frankfurt am Main, 2014), 137-156.
69. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv ekonomiki (RGAE), f. 465, op. 1, d. 1606,1. 65.
70. BArchB, SAPMO, DY30/9064 (21.08.1981). Berlin and Bucharest were not only the political and administrative capitals but also had the highest concentration of consumption goods per capita. On this, see Kaminsky, Annette, Wohlstand, Schonheit, Gliick: Kleine Konsumgeschichte der DDR (Munich, 2001), 149-51Google Scholar; Merkel, , Utopie, 147 Google Scholar; and Petrescu, , “Conflicting Perceptions,” 211.Google Scholar
71. BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S.
72. Vainer, Aurel, “Parcul de Autoturisme: Caracteristici, Evolutie, Implicatii,” Comer( ul modern, no. 9 (1970): 27-34 Google Scholar; Zatlin, , Currency, 229.Google Scholar
73. BArchB, SAPMO, DY30/JIV 2/2J/7847.
74. RGANI, f. 5, op. 67, d. 369,1. 84.
75. Zatlin, , Currency, 238-39.Google Scholar
76. The main difference in this area between prewar Stalinism and later times was that private car consumption was limited to about 1 percent of the overall distributed number. Even the cars that the nomenklatura received were state cars used for personal purposes. Ordinary citizens had only one legal option to obtain a car: to win it in one of the national lotteries. Lazarov, Valery and Gregory, Paul R., “The Wheels of the Command Economy: Allocating Soviet Vehicles,” Economic History Review 55, no. 2 (May 2002): 324-48CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Siegelbaum, , Cars, 189-91.Google Scholar On privilege in state socialism, see Filtzer, Donald, “Privilege and Inequality in Communist Society,” in Smith, , ed., Oxford Handbook, 506-22.Google Scholar
77. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Cancelarie, dosar nr. 141/1973,15-16.
78. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Cancelarie, dosar nr. 103/1976, 23-15.
79. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1401,1. 74
80. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 848,1. 75. On similar practices restricting car access for state officials in Hungary, see Peteri, Gyorgy, “Alternative Modernity? Everyday Practicesof Elite Mobility in Communist Hungary, 1956-1980,” in Siegelbaum, , ed., Socialist Car, 49-54.Google Scholar
81. BArchB, SAPMO, DY30/9171, 22-23.
82. Edele, Mark, “Soviet Veterans as an Entitlement Group, 1945-1955,” Slavic Review 65, no. 1 (Spring 2006): 111-37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
83. RGAE, f. 195, op. 1. d. 81,11.102-3.
84. Edele, Mark, Soviet Veterans of World War II: A Popular Movement in an Authoritarian Society, 1941-1991 (Oxford, 2008), 211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
85. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 634,11.137-39.
86. Bucur, Maria, Heroes and Victims: Remembering War in Twentieth-Century Romania (Bloomington, 2009), 183-84Google Scholar; Biess, Frank, Homecomings: Returning POWs and the Legacies of Defeat in Postwar Germany (Princeton, 2006), 148-50.Google Scholar
87. Hoffmann, Dierk, Aufbau und Krise der Planwirtschaft: Die Arbeitskrdftelenkung in derSBZ/DDR, 1943-1963 (Munich, 2002), 206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
88. BArchB, SAPMO, DY42/1159, o. S.
89. Hiibner, Peter, “Reformen in der DDR der sechziger Jahre: Konsum- und Sozialpolitik,” in Boyer, Christoph, ed., Sozialistische Wirtschaftsreformen, Tschechoslowakei und DDR im Vergleich (Frankfurt am Main, 2006), 529.Google Scholar
90. Wilczek, Annette, Einkommen—Karrierre—Versorgung: Der DDR-Kombinat und die Lebenslage seiner Beschaftigten (Berlin, 2004), 138-45Google Scholar; Scholze, lana, “Ausgezeichnete Hochstleistungen: Leistungsstimulierungen in der DDR,” in Ludwig, Andreas, ed., Fortschritt, Norm und Eigensinn: Erkundungen im Alltag der DDR (Berlin, 1999), 98.Google Scholar
91. Voronov, V. V. and Smirnov, I. P., “Zakreplenie molodezhi v zone BAMa,” Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniia, no. 2 (1982): 16 Google Scholar; BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S, 10.05.1977; BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S, 12.11.1976.
92. BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S.
93. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 842.
94. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1579,1. 56.
95. Crowley, Stephen, Hot Coal, Cold Steel: Russian and Ukrainian Workers from the End of the Soviet Union to the Post-Communist Transformations (Ann Arbor, 1997), 64.Google Scholar
96. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1581,1.130; RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1577,1. 75; and RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1579,1.130. See also Zezina, Maria R., “The Introduction of Motor Vehicles on a Mass Scale in the USSR: From Idea to Implementation,” in Grieger, Manfried, Gutzmann, Ulrike, and Schlinkert, Dirk, eds., Towards Mobility: Varieties of Automobilism in East and West (Wolfsburg, 2009), 52.Google Scholar
97. Verdery, , National Ideology, 100-106.Google Scholar
98. On socialist welfare provision and its limitations, see Hering, Sabine, ed., Social Care understate Socialism (1945–1989): Ambitions, Ambiguities, and Mismanagement (Opladen, 2009)Google Scholar; and Rasell, Michael and Iarskaia-Smirnova, Elena, eds., Disability in Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union: History, Policy, and Everyday Life (London, 2013).Google Scholar
99. RGAE, f. 195, op. 1, d. 81; BArchB, DL1/22953.
100. BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S. 13.03.1977.
101. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Secjia Economica, 227/1984, 6.
102. BArchB, DL 1/22953, o. S.
103. BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S, 22.06.1977; BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S, 13.04.1977; and BArchB, DL1/22952, o. S., 25.05.1977.
104. BArchB, DL1/22953, o. S, 16.06.1977.
105. On petitions regarding cars in the GDR, see Zatlin, , Currency, 236 Google Scholar. On petitions in the Soviet Union after Stalin's death, see Dobson, Miriam, Khrushchev's Cold Summer: Gulag Returnees, Crime, and the Fate of Reform after Stalin (Ithaca, 2009), 50-78.Google Scholar
106. Stitziel, Judt, “Shopping, Sewing, Networking, Complaining: Consumer Culture and the Relationship between State and Society in the GDR,” in Pence, and Betts, , eds., Socialist Modern, 271-72.Google Scholar
107. Zatlin, , Currency, 288-92Google Scholar
108. This practice of Soviet institutions and organizations asking for cars out of turn goes back to the 1930s, when regular planning was disrupted by ad hoc decrees. Special allocations were undermining the existing rules. Car distribution was already a matter of bargaining and not of planned rationality. The same holds true for the postwar years, with the significant difference that institutions were also involved in mitigating private consumption in the name of their members and employees. Lazarov, and Gregory, , “The Wheels of the Command Economy,” 327-28Google Scholar; Lazarov, Valery and Gregory, Paul R., “Commissars and Cars: A Case Study in the Political Economy of Dictatorship,” Journal of Comparative Economics 31, no. 1 (March 2003): 16-18.Google Scholar
109. RGAE, f. 465, op. 1, d. 1581,1.171.
110. RGANI, f. 5, op. 66, d. 275.
111. RGANI, f. 5, op. 64, d. 275,1.31.
112. BArchB, DL1/22953 (6.6.1977).
113. Marius Jastrzab found similar claims for the Polish case. See Jastrzqb, Marius, “Cars as Favors in People's Poland,” in Siegelbaum, , ed., Socialist Car, 39 Google Scholar
114. BArchB, DL1/22953 (16.5.1977).
115. BArchB, DG7/170, o. S.
116. BArchB, DL1/22953 (20.6.1977).
117. BArchB, DG7/616 (22.07.1980).
118. BArchB, DL1/22953 (22.6.1977).
119. Cioroianau, , Pe umerii, 467-68.Google Scholar
120. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.P., Sectia Cancelarie, dosar nr. 191/1972,169.
121. In Romania and the other state socialist countries, cars were very expensive, costing as much as a two-room apartment. This is why cheaper cars like the Trabant or the Zaporozhets were quite popular among lower-income employees. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.R., Sec﹛ia Economics, 10/1974, 7-11; Vainer, Aurel, “Inzestrarea populajiei cu autoturisme si unele caracteristici ale parcului,” Comertul modern, no. 10 (1970): 10-16.Google Scholar
122. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.P., Sectia Cancelarie, dosar nr. 191/1972, 223.
123. ANIC, Fond C.C. al P.C.P., Secjia Cancelarie, dosar nr. 157/1977.
124. Discussion of Gorbachev's reforms is beyond the scope of this article, as they repudiated his predecessor's approach for comprehensive consumption provisions and general well-being. Measures like layoffs, wage and price reforms, and privatization that aimed at dismantling Brezhnev's welfare state also established a different scale against which one could measure entitlement. Cook, , Soviet Social Contract, 90-93.Google Scholar
- 5
- Cited by