Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T20:29:11.204Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Is Providence Credible Today?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 February 2009

Norman H. G. Robinson
Affiliation:
St Mary's CollegeSt Andrews KY16 9JU

Extract

Much of the recent debate about religion has concerned itself either with the bare existence of God or with the fact of Jesus Christ, and has not directly brought into the discussion the question of providence and the allied topic of prayer. It is as if the whole area were so problematic that thought has tended to polarise around these two points, God in heaven and Jesus of Nazareth in history, and as a result has virtually by-passed this subject, although one would have thought that it lay very close to the living core of religion. Yet this neglect is not without precedent in the past. It is worth recalling that Immanuel Kant, although he was profoundly critical of the traditional ways in which the existence of God had been proved and the foundation of religion laid, none the less believed himself that there is a legitimate foundation for religious belief in man's consciousness of value, in his awareness of what Kant called the categorical imperative; and this more practical, this less severely theoretical approach to the reality of religion, may well be regarded as an important pointer towards the truth. None the less the fact remains that Kant himself held that ‘the purpose of prayer can only be to induce in us a moral disposition. … To wish to converse with God is absurd: we cannot talk to one we cannot intuit; and as we cannot intuit God, but can only believe in him, we cannot converse with him.’

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Scottish Journal of Theology Ltd 1977

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 215 note 1 Our Knowledge of God, p. 159.

page 216 note 1 Op. tit., pp. 59–63.

page 218 note 1 Bultmann, Rudolf, Jesus Christ and Mythology, pp. 36, 37Google Scholar.

page 218 note 2 Flew, A. and Maclntyre, A., New Essays in Philosophical Theology, p. 97Google Scholar.

page 218 note 3 Jesus Christ and Mythology, p. 40; cf. pp. 40–43.

page 220 note 1 The Concept of Prayer, pp. 41, 50f., 59, 120.

page 220 note 2 Phillips, D. Z., Faith and Philosophical Enquiry, p. 51Google Scholar.

page 223 note 1 Objective Knowledge, pp. 117, 147.

page 228 note 1 Science and Human Behavior, p. 258

page 229 note 1 The World and God, pp. 160f, 6.