Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T09:18:26.207Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Early Reception of Karl Barth's Theology in Britain: A Supplementary View

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 January 2009

D. Densil Morgan
D. Densil Morgan
Affiliation:
School of Theology and Religious Studies, University of Wales, Bangor, Gwynedd, LL57 2DG
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

One of the axioms of modern church history in Britain is that whereas Anglo-Saxon thought was on the whole impervious to the appeal and achievement of Karl Barth, it was among the Scots alone that the Swiss theologian's theories found any real resonance and creative response. Stephen Sykes in a 1979 volume of studies in Barth's theological method, mentions the somewhat bewildered response to his publications in Britain and the United States between 1925 and the mid-1980s and goes on to say that ‘from now onwards it is in Scotland that Barth is taken with the greatest seriousness in the English speaking world’. In a later volume of centenary essays, R. H. Roberts traced the reception of the theology of Karl Barth ‘in the Anglo-Saxon world’ by quoting the evidence of such late 1920s and early 1930s figures as J. H. Morrison, John McConnachie, H. R. Mackintosh, Norman Porteous and A. J. MacDonald to claim that ‘it is clear from an early stage that enthusiasm for Barth's work … was primarily a Scottish attribute’. In another essay in the same volume, Colin Gunton contrasted the usual English attitude to Barth with that of theologians from other lands: ‘For the most part and despite exceptions’, he claimed, ‘the English find it difficult to come to terms with the theology of Karl Barth’, while in a companion volume Geoffrey Bromiley noted that this was hardly the case for theologians and pastors ‘in such diverse lands as Switzerland, Germany, France, Holland, Hungary, and Scotland’. Again and again, it is Scotland which is emphasised as being the place within the British Isles where Barth's ideals took root.

Type
Research Article
Information
Scottish Journal of Theology , Volume 54 , Issue 4 , November 2001 , pp. 504 - 527
Copyright
Copyright © Scottish Journal of Theology Ltd 2001

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘The study of Barth’ in Sykes, S. (ed.), Karl Barth: Studies of his Theological Method (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979), 6Google Scholar.

2 ‘The reception of the theology of Karl Barth in the Anglo-Saxon world: history, typology and prospect’, in Sykes, S. (ed.), Karl Barth: Centenary Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 124Google Scholar.

3 ‘No other foundation: an Englishman's reading of Church Dogmatics chapter iv’, in ibid., 61.

4 ‘The influence of Barth after World War II’, in Biggar, Nigel (ed.), Reckoning with Barth: Essays in Commemoration of the Centenary of Karl Barth's Birth (Oxford: Mowbray's, 1989), 11Google Scholar.

5 McGrath, Alister E., T. F. Torrance: an Intellectual Biography (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1999), 115Google Scholar.

6 Ibid.

7 Ibid., 116–117

8 ‘Diwinyddiaeth Karl Barth’, Yr Efrydydd 3 (1927), 254Google Scholar.

9 Ibid., 254–8, 281–7.

10 Ibid., 281.

11 Keri Evans, formerly holder of the chair of philosophy in the University of North Wales, Bangor, and by then minister of the Priory Street Congregational Church in Carmarthen, was equally impressed by the young Barth and, due to his first-hand knowledge of current continental thought, well-placed to complement Lewis' contribution; see his ‘Karl Barth: y proffwyd’, Y Tyst, 16 August 1928, ‘Karl Barth: ydiwinydd a'r athronydd’, ibid., 23 August 1928, and ‘Cenadwri Karl Barth’, Yr Efengylydd (1931), 6.

12 See Jones, R. Tudur, Hanes Annibynwyr Cymru (Swansea: John Penry Press, 1966), 301–302Google Scholar; Davies, Dewi Eirug, ‘Yr ymagwedd cynnar I ddiwinyddiaeth Karl Barth yng Nghymru (1)’, Diwinyddiaeth 34 (1983), 52–76Google Scholar.

13 See Morgan, D. Densil, Torri'r Seiliau Sicr: Detholiad O Ysgrifau J. E. Daniel (Llandysul: Gomer Press, 1993)Google Scholar.

14 ‘Gair Duw a Gair Dyn’, Yr Efiydydd 5 (1929), 251–255 (255)Google Scholar.

15 Edwards, D. Miall, Bannau'r Ffydd (Wrexham: Hughes & Son, 1929), xiiiGoogle Scholar.

16 Ibid., 374; for an analysis of Edwards' theology see Pope, Robert, Seeking God's Kingdom: the Nonconformist Social Gospel in Wales, 1906–39 (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 1999), 38–55Google Scholar.

17 Daniel, J. E., ‘Diwinyddiaeth Cymru’, YrEJrydydd 5 (1929), 118–122, 173–5, 197–203 (174)Google Scholar.

18 Ibid., 197.

19 Ibid., 198.

20 Ibid., 121.

21 ‘Eglwys Crist yn hanfodol i efengyl Crist’, Adroddiad Undeb Caernarfon (Swansea: Llyfrfa'r Annibynwyr, 1930), 107–111Google Scholar.

22 Daniel, J. E., Dysgeidiaeth yr Apostol Paul (Swansea: Llyfrfa'r Annibynwyr, 1933), iiiGoogle Scholar.

23 Ibid., 74.

24 For the general background including the theological changes of the time, see Morgan, D. Densil, The Span of the Cross: Christian Religion and Society in Wales, 1914–2000 (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 1999), 130–137, 172–80Google Scholar.

25 University of Wales, Bangor, Ivor Oswy Davies MSS., ‘Schleiermacher in relation to the modern theological movement in Germany’, 1–72 (3–4).

26 Ibid., 41.

27 Ibid., 54, 56.

28 Ibid., 72–6.

29 Ibid., 77.

30 ‘Adlais o'r Swistir’, Y Goleuad, 17 January 1934, 8.

31 ‘Yr Athro Karl Barth: y Dyn’, Y Goleuad, 21 November 1934, 2.

32 Ibid.

33 University of Wales, Bangor, Ivor Oswy Davies MSS., ‘Karl Barth’, 3.

34 Ibid., 9. for Davies' reflections on this whole episode see Morgan, D. Densil, ‘Tyst ymhlith y Tystion: Profiad Cymro yn Almaen Hitler’, Transactions of the Honourable Society of Cymmrodorion NS 2 (1996), 156–166Google Scholar.

35 ‘Mudiad Karl Barth’, Y Goleuad, 22 September 1937, 10.

36 Ibid.

37 Ibid., 11.

38 Roberts, ‘Reception’.

39 ‘Yr Athro Karl Barth: y Dyn’, Y Goleuad, 21 November 1934, 2.

40 E.g. the series of articles ‘Karl Barth’ by Breeze, George E. in Yr Eurgrawn 127 (1935), 63–66, 85–9, 144–8, 187–92, 247–51Google Scholar, and Jones, T. Ivon, ‘Pregethu'r Gair yn Ôl Karl Barth’, Y Traethodydd 3rd series 5 (1936), 18–27Google Scholar, cf. Hoyle, R. Birch, The Teaching of Karl Barth: An Exposition (London: SCM Press, 1930)Google Scholar; McConnachie, JohnThe Significance of Karl Barth (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1931)Google Scholar.

41 Edwards, Bannau'r Ffydd, 387.

42 Ibid., 388.

43 Ibid., 389.

44 Jenkins, J. Gwili, Hanfod Duw a Pherson Crist (Liverpool: Hugh Evans, 1931), 423Google Scholar.

45 ‘The New Orthodoxy—A Criticism’, The Welsh Outlook 18 (1931), 180–182 (180)Google Scholar.

46 Ibid., 181.

47 Ibid.

48 Ibid., 182.

49 Murray, Iain (ed.), D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones: Utters 1919–81 (Edinburgh: Banner of Truth, 1994), 46Google Scholar.

50 Murray, Iain, D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones: The Fight of Faith, 1939–81 (Edinburgh: Banner of Truth, 1990), 137Google Scholar.

51 Murray, , Letters, 61Google Scholar.

52 Its ‘grotesque’ nature was challenged forcefully by the von Balthasarin, Catholic Hans UrsThe Theology of Karl Barth (1951) (ET, San Francisco, CA: Ignatius Press, 1992), 61–62Google Scholar, and by the Berkouwer, Reformed G. C. in The Triumph of Grace in the Theology of Karl Barth (1954) (ET, Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1956), 385–393Google Scholar.

53 Lloyd-Jones, Martyn, Crefydd Heddiw ac Yfory (Llandybie: Llyfrau'r Dryw, 1947), 11–12Google Scholar.

54 See Morgan, , Span of the Cross, pp. 107–180Google Scholar.

55 University of Wales, Bangor, Ivor Oswy Davies MSS., ‘God in History’, 3.

56 Knox, R. Buick, Voices from the Past: a History of the English Conference of the Presbyterian Church of Wales, 1889–1938 (Llandysul: Corner Press, 1969), 54Google Scholar.

57 Roberts, John Wyn (ed.), Sylfeini'r Ffydd Ddoe a Heddiw (London: SCM Press, 1942), 7Google Scholar.

58 Ibid., 81.

59 For the texts see Morgan, , Torri'r Seiliau Sicr, 149–170Google Scholar, and for an analysis of their content and impact, Introduction, 65–82.

60 ‘Karl Barth’, Y Dysgedydd (1945), 7–10 (10).

61 See Morgan, D. Densil, ‘Y proffwyd ymhlilh y praidd: bywyd a gwaith Lewis Valentine (1893–1986)’, Transactions of the Honourable Society of Cymmrodorion NS 4 (1998), 187–215Google Scholar; Jones, J. Ithel, ‘Diwinyddiaeth Karl Barth’, Seren Gomer 43 (1950), 97–103, 130–8Google Scholar; 44 (1951), 5–14; Powell, W. Eifion, Gwilym Bowyer (Swansea: John Penry Press, 1966)Google Scholar; Thomas, Isaac et al. Yr Efengyl yng Nghymru (Swansea: Llyfrfa'r Annibynwyr, 1945)Google Scholar; Griffiths, W. B., Yr Epistolat y Rhufeiniaid, (Caernarfon, Llyfrfa'r Methodistiaid Calfinaidd, 1954)Google Scholar.

62 McGrath, , T. F. Torrance: an Intellectual Biography, 123Google Scholar.

63 See Jones, R. Tudur, Grym y Gair a Fflam y Ffydd (Bangor: Centre for Advanced Study of Religion in Wales, 1998), 234–254Google Scholar.

64 Cf. University of Wales, Bangor, Ivor Oswy Davies MSS., ‘The meaning of preaching: its centrality to the Protestant concept of the church’, as well as Daniel's, J. E. claim ‘You cannot do theology with any degree of seriousness without it creating in you the compulsion to preach’, ‘Hanfodion Diwinyddiaeth’, Adroddiad Undeb Caemarfon (Swansea: Llyfrfa'r Annibynwyr, 1949), 76–78 (76)Google Scholar.

65 Lewis, J. D. Vernon, Diwinyddiaeth a Phregethu Heddiw (London: BBC, 1955), 8, emphasis addedGoogle Scholar.

66 Jenkins, Daniel T., ‘Mr Demant and Karl Barth’, Theology 39 (1939), 412–420 (412)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 Cf. Davies, Dewi Eirug, ‘Yr ymagweddiad cynnar i Barth yng Nghymru (II)’, Diwinyddiaeth 38 (1986), 53–87Google Scholar.