Article contents
Pluralism or Relativism?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 September 2008
Extract
Elkana's paper “Two-Tier Thinking” (1978) contains the thesis that became the foundation of all his later work. This thesis is best summarized by the author himself:
The thesis of this paper is that this distinction [between realists and relativists] is not a logical necessity but a historical situation in Western scientific culture. It is claimed here that the distinction is spurious: every problem has a realist and a relativist dimension, and the two views can be, and are actually being, held simultaneously. Once a frame of reference has been selected, in it realism prevails. With respect to selection of an appropriate framework the approach has to be relativist since there is no absolute, external-to-all framework which would fit absolute realism. (Elkana 1978, 309)
- Type
- Homage to Yehuda Elkana
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1996
References
- 3
- Cited by