Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T10:50:17.311Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Counter-populist performances of (in)security: Feminist resistance in the face of right-wing populism in Poland

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 December 2021

Bohdana Kurylo Open the ORCID record for Bohdana Kurylo [Opens in a new window]
Bohdana Kurylo*
Affiliation:
School of Slavonic and East European Studies, University College London, United Kingdom
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

IR scholarship has recently seen a burgeoning interest in the right-wing populist politics of security, showing that it tends to align with the international ultraconservative mobilisation against ‘gender ideology’. In contrast, this article investigates how local feminist actors can resist right-wing populist constructions of (in)security by introducing counter-populist discourses and aesthetics of security. I analyse the case of Poland, which presents two competing populist performances of (in)security: the Independence March organised by right-wing groups on Poland's Independence Day and the Women's Strike protests against the near-total ban on abortion. The article draws on Judith Butler's theory of the performative politics of public assembly, which elucidates how the political subject of ‘the people’ can emerge as bodies come together to make security demands through both verbal and non-verbal acts. I argue that the feminist movement used the vehicle of populist performance to subvert the exclusionary constructions of (in)security by right-wing populists. In the process, it introduced a different conception of security in the struggle for a ‘livable life’. The study expands the understanding of the relationship between populism, security and feminism in IR by exploring how the populist politics of security is differently enacted by everyday agents in local contexts.

Keywords

FeminismJudith ButlerPerformancePolandPopulismSecurity
Type
Research Article
Information
Review of International Studies , Volume 48 , Issue 2 , April 2022 , pp. 262 - 281
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the British International Studies Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Korolczuk, Elżbieta and Graff, Agnieszka, ‘Gender as “ebola from Brussels”: The anticolonial frame and the rise of illiberal populism’, Signs, 43:4 (2018), pp. 797–821CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Maiguashca, Bice, ‘Resisting the “populist hype”: A feminist critique of a globalising concept’, Review of International Studies, 45:5 (2019), pp. 768–85 (p. 768)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Agius, Christine, Rosamond, Annika B., and Kinnvall, Catarina, ‘Populism, ontological insecurity and gendered nationalism: Masculinity, climate denial and Covid-19’, Religion & Ideology, 21:4 (2020), pp. 432–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Bojanic, Sanja, Abadía, Mónica C., and Moro, Valentina, ‘Feminist responses to populist politics’, European Journal of English Studies, 25:2 (2021), pp. 113–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Agnieszka Graff, ‘Angry women: Poland's Black Protests as “populist feminism”’, in Gabriele Dietze and Julia Roth (eds), Right-Wing Populism and Gender (Bielefeld, Germany: Transcript-Verlag, 2020), pp. 231–50; Julia Roth, Can Feminism Trump Populism? Right-Wing Trends and Intersectional Contestations in the Americas (New Orleans, LA: University of New Orleans Press, 2021).

4 Mona Lilja, ‘Pushing resistance theory in IR beyond “opposition”: The constructive resistance of the #MeToo movement in Japan’, Review of International Studies (2021), pp. 1–22.

5 Jenny Gunnarsson Payne, ‘Women as “the people”: Reflections on the Black Protests as a counter-force against right-wing and authoritarian populism’, Baltic Worlds, XIII:1 (2020), pp. 6–20; Graff, ‘Angry women’.

6 Ibid.

7 Cas Mudde and Cristobal R. Kaltwasser, ‘Populism and (liberal) democracy: A framework for analysis’, in Cas Mudde and Cristobal R. Kaltwasser (eds), Populism in Europe and the Americas: Threat or Corrective for Democracy? (Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press, 2012), pp. 1–26.

8 In order to preserve the anonymity of respondents, all of them have been assigned pseudonyms.

9 Judith Butler, Notes Toward a Performative Theory of Assembly (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2015).

10 Béland, Daniel, ‘Right-wing populism and the politics of insecurity: How President Trump frames migrants as collective threats’, Political Studies Review, 18:2 (2020), pp. 162–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Homolar, Alexandra and Scholz, Ronny, ‘The power of Trump-speak: Populist crisis narratives and ontological security’, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32:3 (2019), pp. 344–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bohdana Kurylo, ‘The discourse and aesthetics of populism as securitisation style’, International Relations (2020), pp. 1–21; Wojczewski, Thorsten, ‘“Enemies of the people”: Populism and the politics of (in)security’, European Journal of International Security, 5:1 (2020), pp. 5–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Kurylo, ‘Discourse and aesthetics of populism’.

12 Benjamin Moffitt, The Global Rise of Populism: Performance, Political Style, and Representation (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2016); Ostiguy, Pierre, ‘The socio-cultural, relational approach to populism’, Partecipazione e Conflitto, 13:1 (2020), pp. 29–58Google Scholar; Peetz, Julia, ‘Legitimacy as a zero-sum game: Presidential populism and the performative success of the unauthorised outsider’, Contemporary Political Theory, 19:4 (2019), pp. 642–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Ciută, Felix, ‘Security and the problem of context: A hermeneutical critique of securitisation theory’, Review of International Studies, 35:2 (2009), pp. 301–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nyman, Jonna, ‘What is the value of security? Contextualising the negative/positive debate’, Review of International Studies, 42:5 (2016), pp. 821–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Doug McAdam, Sidney Tarrow, and Charles Tilly, Dynamics of Contention (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2001).

15 Bice Maiguashca, ‘Governance and resistance in world politics’, Review of International Studies, 29 (2003), pp. 3–28; Juha Vuori, ‘Contesting and resisting security in post-Mao China’, in Thierry Balzacq (ed.), Contesting Security: Strategies and Logics (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2015), pp. 29–43.

16 Mudde and Kaltwasser, ‘Populism and (liberal) democracy’, p. 8.

17 Dean, Jonathan and Maiguashca, Bice, ‘Did somebody say populism? Towards a renewal and reorientation of populism studies’, Journal of Political Ideologies, 25:1 (2020), pp. 11–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar (p. 13).

18 Maiguashca, ‘Resisting the “populist hype”’, p. 776.

19 Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe, Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics (London, UK: Verso, 2001), p. xiii.

20 Chantal Mouffe, For a Left Populism (London, UK: Verso, 2018), p. 24.

21 Mudde and Kaltwasser, ‘Populism and (liberal) democracy’, p. 7.

22 Moffitt, Global Rise of Populism, p. 38.

23 Pierre Ostiguy, Francisco Panizza, and Benjamin Moffitt, ‘Introduction’, in Pierre Ostiguy, Francisco Panizza, and Benjamin Moffitt (eds), Populism in Global Perspective: A Performative and Discursive Approach (London, UK: Routledge, 2020), pp. 1–18 (p. 2).

24 Ostiguy, ‘Socio-cultural, relational approach to populism’.

25 Ibid., p. 34.

26 Moffitt, The Global Rise of Populism.

27 Ibid., p. 16.

28 Annick Wibben, Feminist Security Studies: A Narrative Approach (London, UK: Routledge, 2010).

29 Judith Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 8.

30 Ibid., p. 58.

31 Ibid., p. 5.

32 Diana Taylor, ‘Animating politics’, in Adrian Kear and Jenny Edkins (eds), International Performance and Politics: Critical Aesthetics and Creative Practice (London, UK: Routledge, 2013), pp. 84–95 (p. 84).

33 Jonathan Dean and Bice Maiguashca, ‘Gender, power and left politics: From feminisation to “feministisation”’, Politics & Gender, 14:3 (2018), pp. 376–406 (p. 396).

34 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, pp. 129–30.

35 Shirin Rai, ‘Political performance: A framework for analysing democratic politics’, Political Studies, 63:5 (2015), pp. 1179–97 (p. 1183).

36 Ibid.

37 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 19.

38 Ibid., p. 9.

39 Ibid., p. 157.

40 Ibid., p. 127.

41 Ibid., p. 71.

42 Mona Lilja, ‘Dangerous bodies, matter and emotions: Public assemblies and embodied resistance’, Journal of Political Power, 10:3 (2017), pp. 342–52 (p. 347).

43 Ibid., pp. 346–7.

44 Dean and Maiguashca, ‘Gender, power and left politics’, p. 398.

45 Alexandra Homolar and Georg Löfflmann, ‘Populism and the affective politics of humiliation narratives’, Global Studies Quarterly, 1:1 (2021), pp. 1–11.

46 Rai, ‘Political performance’, pp. 1188–9.

47 Ibid., p. 1187.

48 Marta Kotwas and Jan Kubik, ‘Symbolic thickening of public culture and the rise of right-wing populism in Poland’, East European Politics and Societies and Cultures, 33:2 (2019), pp. 435–71.

49 Author's interview with Tomasz, member of the All-Polish Youth, Warsaw, 19 July 2019.

50 Author's interview with Paweł, member of the National Radical Camp, Warsaw, 16 July 2019.

51 Robert Bąkiewicz, Twitter post (2 November 2020), available at: {https://twitter.com/RBakiewicz/status/1323211751287066631} accessed 27 April 2021.

52 Robert Bakiewicz quoted in ‘Far-right Polish Independence Day march draws thousands despite ban’, Reuters (11 November 2020), available at: {https://www.reuters.com/article/us-poland-independence-march-idUSKBN27R2PY} accessed 27 April 2021.

53 Democ., Twitter post (11 November 2020), available at: {https://twitter.com/democ_de/status/1326529502046941184} accessed 27 April 2021.

54 Kotwas and Kubik, ‘Symbolic thickening’.

55 Agnieszka Pasieka, ‘Who is afraid of fascists? The Polish Independence March and the rise of the (far?) right’, FocaalBlog (12 December 2018), available at: {www.focaalblog.com/2018/12/12/who-is-afraid-of-fascists-the-polish-independence-march-and-the-rise-of-the-far-right} accessed 14 August 2021.

56 Jarosław Kaczyński, quoted in ‘LGBTQ rights an import that threatens nation, Polish leader says’, NBC News (25 April 2019), available at: {https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/lgbtq-rights-import-threatens-nation-polish-leader-says-n998436} accessed 18 July 2021.

57 Weronika Grzebalska and Andrea Pető, ‘The gendered modus operandi of the illiberal transformation in Hungary and Poland’, Women's Studies International Forum, 68:May–June (2018), pp. 164–72.

58 Ibid., p. 167.

59 Andrey Makarychev and Alexandra Yatsyk, ‘Biopolitics and national identities: Between liberalism and totalisation’, Nationalities Papers, 45:1 (2017), pp. 1–7.

60 Jarosław Kaczyński, quoted in ‘Oświadczenie prezesa PiS, wicepremiera Jarosława Kaczyńskiego’ (27 October 2020), available at: {http://pis.org.pl/aktualnosci/oswiadczenie-prezesa-pis-wicepremiera-jaroslawa-kaczynskiego} accessed 27 April 2021.

61 Ibid.

62 Jennifer Ramme and Claudia Snochowska-Gonzalez, ‘(Nie)zwykłe kobiety: Populizm prawicy, wola ludu a kobiecy suweren’, in Elżbieta Korolczuk et al. (eds), Bunt Kobiet (Gdańsk, Poland: Europejskie Centrum Solidarności, 2019), pp. 83–117 (pp. 99–100).

63 Marta Lempart, ‘LIBE – FEMM Joint Meeting’ (24 February 2021), available at: {https://multimedia.europarl.europa.eu/en/libe-femm-joint-meeting_20210224-1345-COMMITTEE-LIBE-FEMM_vd?start=20210224125448&end=20210224144117} accessed 26 April 2021.

64 All-Poland Women's Strike, Facebook post (1 November 2020), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/ogolnopolskistrajkkobiet/posts/5319905698035385} accessed 6 September 2021.

65 Maria Wilczek, ‘Miners, farmers and taxi drivers unite behind protests against Poland's abortion laws’, The Times (27 October 2020), available at: {https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/pro-choice-and-far-right-protest-together-against-polands-abortion-laws-xk373px8q} accessed 6 September 2021.

66 Graff, ‘Angry women’, p. 241.

67 Author's interview with Teresa, member of Gals for Gals, Wroclaw, 10 July 2019.

68 Author's interview with Amelia, member of Gals for Gals, Warsaw, 19 July 2019.

69 Gunnarsson Payne, ‘Women as “the people”’, p. 18.

70 Marta Lempart, ‘Marta Lempart on leading Poland's abortion rights protests’, Financial Times (2 December 2020), available at: {https://www.ft.com/content/b6012449-0c11-419a-b439-6e3320f47e86} accessed 12 July 2021.

71 Marc Santora and Joanna Berendt, ‘Poland overhauls courts, and critics see retreat from democracy’, New York Times (20 December 2017), available at: {https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/20/world/europe/eu-poland-law.html?action=click&module=RelatedLinks&pgtype=Article} accessed 1 September 2021.

72 International Planned Parenthood Federation, ‘Polish Ruling Party Exploits the Current Health Crisis to Undermine Women and Young People's Safety’ (14 April 2020), available at: {https://www.ippfen.org/news/polish-ruling-party-exploits-current-health-crisis-undermine-women-and-young-peoples-safety} accessed 2 September 2021.

73 Quoted in ‘“Sex is not a crime”: The women protesting Poland's new abortion law’, The Guardian (13 November 2020), available at: {https://www.theguardian.com/world/video/2020/nov/13/sex-is-not-a-the-women-protesting-polands-new-abortion-law} accessed 27 April 2021.

74 ‘Żandarmeria Wojskowa pomoże policji. Zarządzenie premiera’, Rzeczpospolita (26 October 2020), available at: {https://www.rp.pl/Wojsko/201029457-Zandarmeria-Wojskowa-pomoze-policji-Zarzadzenie-premiera.html} accessed 27 April 2021.

75 Marta Lempart, ‘Lempart o działaniach policji: Najgorsze jest to, jak strasznie kłamią co do praw obywatelskich. Nie tylko tchórze, ale i łgarze’, Wyborcza (29 November 2020), available at: {https://wyborcza.pl/7,162657,26559344,lempart-o-dzialaniach-policji-najgorsze-jest-to-jak-strasznie.html} accessed 19 April 2021.

76 Kaczyński, ‘Oświadczenie prezesa PiS’.

77 Zuzanna Krzątała, ‘“You will never walk alone”: Polish women strike back’, Humanity in Action, available at: {https://www.humanityinaction.org/knowledge_detail/you-will-never-walk-alone-polish-women-strike-back/} accessed 27 April 2021.

78 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 151.

79 Lempart, ‘LIBE – FEMM Joint Meeting’.

80 Klementyna Suchanow, quoted in Anita Karwowska, ‘Strajk Kobiet odtajnia tajniaków. Zbiera nagrania z protestów’, Wyborcza (20 November 2020), available at: {https://wyborcza.pl/7,162657,26530516,strajk-kobiet-odtajnia-tajniakow-zbiera-nagrania-z-protestow.html} accessed 27 April 2021.

81 Ibid.

82 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 83.

83 Author's interview with Marlena, Women's Strike participant, Warsaw, 14 January 2021.

84 Agnieszka Czerederecka, quoted in Anita Karwowska, ‘Grudzień będzie gorący: Jak zawsze w ostatnich latach. Mamy nadzieję, że to koniec tej władzy’, Wyborcza (20 November 2020), available at: {https://wyborcza.pl/7,162657,26531798,grudzien-bedzie-goracy-jak-zawsze-w-ostatnich-latach-mamy.html} accessed 27 April 2021.

85 Kurylo, ‘Discourse and aesthetics of populism’, p. 13.

86 Ibid., p. 15.

87 Ibid., p. 7.

88 Agnieszka Graff, ‘Claiming the shipyard, the cowboy hat and the anchor for women: Polish feminism's dialogue and struggle with national symbolism’, East European Politics and Societies and Cultures, 33:2 (2019), pp. 472–96.

89 Ibid., p. 482.

90 Jarek Kubicki, Facebook post (26 October 2020), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=10221508566575353&set=pcb.10221500225686836} accessed 27 April 2020.

91 Ewa Majewska, ‘Słaby opór i siła bezsilnych: #Czarnyprotest kobiet w Polsce 2016’ (10 November 2016), available at: {https://www.praktykateoretyczna.pl/artykuly/ewa-majewska-saby-opor-i-sia-bezsilnych-czarnyprotest-kobiet-w-polsce-2016/} accessed 19 July 2021.

92 Polish Masters of Art, Facebook post (30 October 2020), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/PolishMastersofArt/photos/a.1526688624261610/2729223614008099} accessed 27 April 2021.

93 Gunnarsson Payne, ‘Women as “the people”’, p. 11.

94 All-Poland Women's Strike, Facebook post (31 January 2021), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/ogolnopolskistrajkkobiet/photos/pcb.5730873760271908/5730873416938609/} accessed 27 April 2021.

95 Graff, ‘Angry women’, p. 231.

96 The video is available at: {https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=49pBuXM4mYs}.

97 ‘Szkoda, że Maryja nie zrobiła aborcji. Kolejny atak obrażający uczucia religijne’, TVP Info (26 October 2020), available at: {https://www.tvp.info/50508346/protest-trybunal-konstytucyjny-aborcja-gliwice-szkoda-ze-maryja-nie-zrobila-aborcji-kolejny-atak-obrazajacy-uczucia-religijne-wieszwiecej} accessed 5 September 2021.

98 Author's interview with Gabriela, member of the Women's Strike, Klodzko, 11 February 2021.

99 The video is available at: {https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3gde1BSmp8}.

100 Kurylo, ‘Discourse and aesthetics of populism’, p. 15.

101 Author's interview with Michał, member of the Pro-Right to Life Foundation, Warsaw, 17 July 2019.

102 Author's interview with Marlena, Women's Strike participant, Warsaw, 14 January 2021.

103 Author's interview with Paulina, Women's Strike participant, Krakow, 12 February 2021.

104 Ibid.

105 Author's interview with Zuzanna, Women's Strike participant, Gdynia, 10 February 2021.

106 All-Poland Women's Strike, Facebook post (25 November 2020), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/ogolnopolskistrajkkobiet/posts/5429823133710307/} accessed 16 April 2021.

107 Author's interview with Giovanna, Women's Strike participant, Warsaw, 28 January 2021.

108 Butler, Notes toward a Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 33.

109 Ibid.

110 Interview with Paulina, Women's Strike participant, Kraków, 12 February 2021.

111 Federation for Women and Family Planning, ‘Polish Constitutional Tribunal Publishes Justification for the Abortion-Banning Ruling’, available at: {https://en.federa.org.pl/polish-constitutional-tribunal-publishes-justification-for-the-abortion-banning-ruling/} accessed 27 April 2021.

112 Judith Butler, Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence (London, UK: Verso, 2004), p. 20.

113 Lena, member of the Abortion Dream Team from Warsaw, 30 May 2021.

114 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 209.

115 Judith Butler, Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? (London, UK: Verso, 2009).

116 Ibid., p. 19.

117 Kathryn McNeilly, ‘From the right to life to the right to livability: Radically reapproaching “life” in human rights politics’, Australian Feminist Law Journal, 41:1 (2015), pp. 141–59.

118 Interview with Eliza, Gals for Gals Wroclaw, Wroclaw, 20 July 2019.

119 Interview with Gabriela.

120 Strajk Kobiet Kłodzko i Powiat, Facebook post (14 January 2021), available at: {https://www.facebook.com/StrajkKobietKlodzko/photos/pcb.2879358735681771/2879358559015122} accessed 27 April 2021.

121 Butler, Precarious Life.

122 Author's interview with Ada, member of Gals for Gals, Lodz, 15 June 2021.

123 Maiguashca, ‘Resisting the “populist hype”’, p. 769.

124 Ibid., p. 784.

125 Ibid., p. 772.

126 Butler, Performative Theory of Assembly, p. 58.

127 Ibid.

128 Birte Siim, Anna Krasteva, and Aino Saarinen (eds), Citizens’ Activism and Solidarity Movements: Contending with Populism (Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan, 2019).

129 Frank Stengel, David MacDonald, and Dirk Nabers, ‘Introduction: Analysing the nexus between populism and International Relations’, in Frank Stengel, David MacDonald, and Dirk Nabers (eds), Populism and World Politics: Exploring Inter- and Transnational Dimensions (London, UK: Palgrave, 2019), pp. 1–22 (p. 4).