Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T02:43:22.109Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Proto, Early Dynastic Egypt, and Early Bronze I-II of the Southern Levant: Some Uneasy 14C Correlations

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 July 2016

Eliot Braun
Eliot Braun*
Affiliation:
Israel Antiquities Authority, P.O. Box 21, Jerusalem 91004. Email: [email protected].
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

A number of recent radiocarbon determinations from several sites in Israel suggest advancing, by some considerable period of time, both the onset of the cultural horizon known as Early Bronze I and the appearance of its latest phases. The logical outcome of the acceptance of these new dates puts such a strain on chronological correlations between the 14C data and the archaeological record that the entire system would no longer be tenable if they were accepted. This paper examines in detail the problematic nature of these “uneasy correlations.”

Type
Near East Chronology: Archaeology and Environment
Information
Radiocarbon , Volume 43 , Issue 3: Proceedings of the 17th International Radiocarbon Conference (Part 3 of 3) , 2001 , pp. 1279 - 1295
Copyright
Copyright © 2001 The Arizona Board of Regents on behalf of the University of Arizona 

References

Aardsma, GE. 2001. New radiocarbon dates for the reed mat from the Cave of the Treasure, Israel. Radiocarbon. This volume.Google Scholar
Amiran, R. 1969. Ancient Pottery of the Holy Land. Massada, Jerusalem.Google Scholar
Amiran, R. 1974. An Egyptian Jar Fragment with the Name of Narmer from Arad. Israel Exploration Journal 24:4–12.Google Scholar
Amiran, R 1978. The Date of the End of the EB II City of Arad. Israel Exploration Journal 28:182–4.Google Scholar
Amiran, R, Gophna, R. 1992. The correlation between lower Egypt and southern Canaan during the EB I Period. In: van den Brink, ECM, editor. The Nile delta in transition: 4th–3rd millennium BC. Tel Aviv. p 357–60.Google Scholar
Ben-Tor, A. 1992. The Early Bronze age. In: Ben-Tor, A, editor. The archaeology of ancient Israel. New Haven: Yale University Press. p 81–124.Google Scholar
Brandl, B. 1992. Evidence for Egyptian colonization in the southern coastal plain and lowlands of Canaan during the EB I Period. In: van den Brink, ECM, editor. The Nile delta in transition: 4th–3rd millennium BC. Tel Aviv. p 441–77.Google Scholar
Braun, E. 1989. The transition from the Chalcolithic to the Early Bronze age in northern Israel and Transjordan: is there a missing link? In: de Miroschedji, P, editor. L'urbanisation de la Palestine à l'âge du Bronze ancien: bilan et perspectives des recherches actuelles. [Actes du Colloque d'Emmaüs: 20–24 Octobre 1986]. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports. p 7–28.Google Scholar
Braun, E. 1996. Cultural diversity and change in the Early Bronze I of Israel and Jordan: towards an understanding of the chronological progression and patterns of regionalism in Early Bronze society. [PhD thesis]. Tel Aviv University.Google Scholar
Braun, E. 2000. Area G at Afridar, Palmahim Quarry 3, and the earliest pottery of Early Bronze age I: Part of the missing link. In: Philip, G, Baird, D, editors. Ceramics and change in the Early Bronze age of the southern Levant. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press. p 113–28.Google Scholar
Braun, E, Gophna, R. Forthcoming. Excavations at Afridar, Ashqelon, Area G. 'Atiqot.Google Scholar
Braun, E, van den Brink, ECM. 1998. Some comments on the Late EB I sequence of Canaan and the relative dating of tomb U-j at Umm el Ga'ab and graves 313 and 787 from Minshat Abu Omar with imported ware: views from Egypt and Canaan. Egypt and the Levant 7:71–94.Google Scholar
Callaway, JA, Weinstein, JM. 1977. Radiocarbon dating of Palestine in the Early Bronze age. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 225:1–16.Google Scholar
Clédat, J. 1913. Les vases de El-Beda. Annales des Service des Antiquities de l'Egypte 13:115–24.Google Scholar
DHKPRP [The David H Koch Pyramids Radiocarbon Project]. 1999. Dating the pyramids. Archaeology September/October: 25–33.Google Scholar
Dreyer, G. 1992. Recent discoveries in the U-cemetery at Abydos. In: van den Brink, ECM, editor. The Nile delta in transition: 4th–3rd millennium BC. Proceedings of the seminar held in Cairo, 21–24 October, 1990. The Netherlands Institute of Archaeology and Arabic Studies. Tel Aviv. p 293–300.Google Scholar
Dreyer, G. 1998. Umm el-Qaab I: Das prädynastische Königsgrab U-j und seine frühen Schriftzeugnisse. Mainz: Verlag Philipp von Zabern. In German.Google Scholar
Emery, WB. 1961. Archaic Egypt. Harmondsworth-Middlesex: Pelican.Google Scholar
Fischer, PM. 2000. The Early Bronze age at Tell Abu al-Kharaz, Jordan Valley: a study of pottery typology, and provenance. radiocarbon dates and the synchronization of Palestine and Egypt during Dynasty 0–2. In: Phillip, G, Baird, D, editors. Breaking with the past: ceramics and change in the Early Bronze age of the southern Levant. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press. p. 201–32.Google Scholar
Gardiner, A. 1973. Egyptian grammar. Third edition, revised. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Gibson, S, Ibbs, B, Kloner, A. 1991. The Sataf Project of landscape archaeology in the Judaean Hills: a preliminary report on four seasons of survey and excavation (1987–89). Levant XXIII:29–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Golani, A. 1997. New salvage excavations of the Early Bronze I Period in the region of the Ashqelon Marina. In: 23rd Archaeological Conference in Israel: abstracts of lectures. Jerusalem: The Israel Exploration Society. p 16.Google Scholar
Golani, A, Segal, D. Forthcoming. Redefining the onset of the Early Bronze age in southern Canaan: new evidence of 14C dating from Ashkelon Afridar. Festschrift in honor of Ram Gophna.Google Scholar
Gilead, I. 1994. The history of the Chalcolithic settlement in the Nahal Beer Sheva area: the radiocarbon aspect. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 296:1–13.Google Scholar
Greenberg, R, Porat, N. 1996. A third millennium pottery production center: typology, petrography, and provenance of the metallic ware of northern Israel and adjacent regions. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 301:5–24.Google Scholar
Hassan, F, Robinson, SW. 1987. High-precision radiocarbon chronology of ancient Egypt and comparisons with Nubia, Palestine, and Mesopotamia. Antiquity 61:119–35.Google Scholar
Hendrickx, S. 1996. The relative chronology of the Naqada culture: problems and possibilities. In: Spencer, J, editor. Aspects of early Egypt. London: British Museum Press. p 36–69.Google Scholar
Hendrickx, S. 1999. La chronologie de la préhistoire tardive et des débuts de l'histoire de l'Egypte. Archéo-Nil 9:13–81, 99–107.Google Scholar
Hennessy, JB. 1967. The foreign relations of Palestine during the Early Bronze Age. London: Quaritch.Google Scholar
Joffe, A H, Dessel, JP. 1995. Redefining chronology and terminology for the Chalcolthic of the southern Levant. Current Anthropology 36(3):507–18.Google Scholar
Kaiser, W. 1957. Zur inneren Chronologie der Nakadakultur. Archaeologia Geographica 6:69–77.Google Scholar
Kantor, HJ. 1992. The relative chronology of Egypt and its foreign correlations before the First Intermediate Period. In: Ehrich, RW, editor. Chronologies in Old World archaeology. Third edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. p 3–21.Google Scholar
Kempinski, A, Gilead, I, 1991. New excavations at Tel Erani: a preliminary report of the 1985-1988 seasons. Tel Aviv 18:164–192.Google Scholar
Kempinski, A, Niemeier, W-D. editors. 1990. Excavations at Kabri: preliminary report of 1989: season 4. Tel Aviv: Tel Kabri Expedition.Google Scholar
Khalaily, H. Forthcoming. Site F: an Early Bronze age site at Ashqelon. 'Atiqot.Google Scholar
Levy, TE, van den Brink, ECM, Goren, Y, Alon, D. 1995. New light on king Narmer and the protodynastic Egyptian presence in Canaan. Biblical Archaeologist 58:26–35.Google Scholar
Mazar, A. 1990. Archaeology of the Land of the Bible: 10,000 to 586 BCE. New York: Doubleday Google Scholar
Mazar, A, de Miroschedji, P. 1996. Hartuv, an aspect of the Early Bronze culture of southern Israel. Bulletin of American Schools of Oriental Research 302:1–40.Google Scholar
de Miroschedji, P. 1976. Contribution à l'etude de l'urbanisation en Palestine à l'age du bronze ancien. Thèse présentée à l'Université de Paris I en vue du doctorat de 3e cycle (specialité: archéologie orientale).Google Scholar
O'Brien, A. 1996. The Serekh as an aspect of the iconography of early kingship. Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 33:123–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oren, ED, Yekutieli, Y. 1992. Taur Ikhbeineh: earliest evidence for Egyptian interconnections. In: van den Brink, ECM, editor. The Nile delta in transition: 4th–3rd millennium BC. Proceedings of the seminar held in Cairo, 21–24 October, 1990. The Netherlands Institute of Archaeology and Arabic Studies. Tel Aviv. p 361–84.Google Scholar
Petrie, WFM. 1953. Corpus of Proto-dynastic pottery. London: British School of Archaeology in Egypt.Google Scholar
Porat, N. 1987. Trade of pottery between Egypt and Cana'an in ancient times. Bulletin of the Israeli Academic Center in Cairo 8:2–4.Google Scholar
Redford, DB. 1992. Egypt, Canaan, and Israel in ancient times. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Segal, D, Carmi, I. 1996. Rehovot radiocarbon date List V. 'Atiqot XXIX. Supplement:79–106.Google Scholar
Stager, L. 1992. The periodization of palestine from the Neolithic through Early Bronze times. In: Ehrich, RW, editor. Chronologies in Old World archaeology. Third edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. p 22–60.Google Scholar
Stuiver, M, Reimer, PJ. 1993. University of Washington Quarternary Isotope Lab radiocarbon calibration program Rev. 3.0. Radiocarbon 35(2):215–30.Google Scholar
Stuiver, M, Reimer, PJ. 2000. Radiocarbon Calibration Program 2000, Rev 4.3. University of Washington Quarternary Isotope Lab (based on Stuiver and Reimer 1993).Google Scholar
Tutundzic, SP. 1989. Relations between Late Predynastic Egypt and Palestine: some elements and phenomena. In: de Miroschedji, P, editor. L'urbanisation de la Palestine à l'âge du Bronze ancien: bilan et perspectives des recherches actuelles. [Actes du Colloque d'Emmaüs: 20–24 Octobre 1986]. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports. p 423–32.Google Scholar
van den Brink, ECM. 1996. The incised serekh-signs of Dynasties O-1, Part I: complete vessels. In: Spencer, J, editor. Aspects of early Egypt. London: British Museum Press.Google Scholar
Ward, WA. 1991. Early contacts between Egypt, Canaan, and Sinai: remarks on the paper by Amnon Ben-Tor. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 281:11–26.Google Scholar
Wignall, SJ. 1998. The identification of the Late Prehistoric Serekh. Göttinger Miszellen 162:93–105.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, RH. 1985. The Horus name and the form and significance of the Serekh in the royal Egyptian titulary. The Journal for the Society of the Study of Egyptian Antiquities 25:99–104.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, TA. 1999. Early Dynastic Egypt. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Yeivin, S. 1960. Early contacts between Canaan and Egypt. Israel Exploration Journal 10:193–203.Google Scholar