Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-g7gxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T00:51:56.416Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Investigating death in Moreton Bay: Coronial inquests and magisterial inquiries

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 June 2019

Lee Butterworth
Lee Butterworth*
Affiliation:
[email protected]
Get access

Abstract

English common law was applied in the New South Wales penal colony when it was founded by Governor Arthur Phillip in 1788. Phillip’s second commission granted him sole authority to appoint coroners and justices of the peace within the colony. The first paid city coroner was appointed in 1810 and only five coroners served the expanding territory of New South Wales by 1821. To relieve the burden on coroners, justices of the peace were authorised to conduct magisterial inquiries as an alternative to inquests. When the Moreton Bay settlement was established, and land was opened up to free settlers, justices were relocated from New South Wales to the far northern colony. Nonetheless, the administration of justice, along with the function of the coroner, was hindered by issues of isolation, geography and poor administration by a government far removed from the evolving settlement. This article is about death investigation and the role of the coroner in Moreton Bay. By examining a number of case studies, it looks at the constraints faced by coroners, deaths due to interracial violence and deaths not investigated. It concludes that not all violent and unexplained deaths were investigated in accordance with coronial law due to a paucity of legally qualified magistrates, the physical limitations of local conditions and the denial of justice to Aborigines as subjects of the Crown.

Type
Harry Gentle Resource Centre special section
Information
Queensland Review , Volume 26 , Issue 1 , June 2019 , pp. 53 - 70
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Burns, , Justice of the peace and parish officer, Vol. 2, 29th edition (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1845), p. 30 Google Scholar.

2 Burns, Justice of the peace and parish officer, p. 30.

3 The ancient office of justice of the peace was commonly known as magistrate. Gordon, Dean, Here comes the judge: The Queensland magistrate (Brisbane: Department of Justice and Attorney-General, 2008), pp. 5–6 Google Scholar; Hilary, Golder, High and responsible office: A history of the NSW magistracy (Sydney: Sydney University Press in association with Oxford University Press, 1991), p. 117 Google Scholar.

4 Raymond, Evans, ‘Racial assaults 1849’, in Evans, Raymond, Radical Brisbane (Melbourne: Vulgar Press, 2004), pp. 33–4Google Scholar; Raymond, Evans, ‘The Mogwi Take Mi-an-jin’, in Evans, Raymond, Fighting words: Writing about race (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1999), pp. 75–6Google Scholar. See also Kerkhove, in this volume.

5 Hunnisett, R. F., The medieval coroner (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1961), pp. 197–9.Google Scholar

6 Ian, Freckelton and David, Ranson, Death investigation and the coroner’s inquest (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 2006), p. 11 Google Scholar; Hunnisett, The medieval coroner, pp. 190–9.

7 County Coroners Act 1860, 23 & 24 Vict, c. 116.

8 Freckelton and Ranson, Death investigation, pp. 11–15.

9 Alex, Castles, Australian legal history (Sydney: Law Book Company, 1982), p. 69 Google Scholar; Dean, Here comes the judge, pp. 7–8; Golder, High and Responsible Office, pp. 2–7.

10 Burns, , Justice of the peace and parish officer, Heather Douglas and Mark Finnane, Indigeneous crime and settler law: White sovereignty after empire (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), p. 37 Google Scholar.

11 Dean, Here comes the judge, pp. 7–8; Golder, High and responsible office, p. 2.

12 Golder, High and responsible office, p. 2.

13 Castles, Australian legal history, p. 83.

14 Golder, High and responsible office, pp. 117–18.

15 Freckelton and Ranson, Death investigation, p. 36.

16 Local Government Act, 51 & 52 Vic c. 41.

17 Castles, Australian legal history, p. 84; Golder, High and responsible office, pp. 117–18.

18 Castle, Australian legal history, pp. 67–8; Golder, High and responsible office, p. 117.

19 Golder, High and responsible office, p. 41.

20 An Act to Define the Qualifications of Medical Witnesses at Coroners’ Inquests and Inquiries Held Before Justices of the Peace in the Colony of New South Wales 1838, 2 Vic. no. 22.

21 An Act to Provide for Attendance of Medical Witnesses at Coroners’ Inquests and Inquiries Held Before Justices of the Peace, 1838, 2 Vic no. 22.

22 Medical Witnesses at Inquests Act 1844, 8 Vic no. 8.

23 An Act to Define the Qualifications of Medical Witnesses at Coroners’ Inquests 1845, 9 Vic. no. 12.

24 New South Wales Government Gazette, 15 March 1845, p. 300.

25 Golder, High and responsible office, pp. 117–18.

26 Dean, Here comes the judge, p. 12; Raymond, Evans, A history of Queensland (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2007), pp. 30–3Google Scholar.

27 Steele, John G., Brisbane town in convict days 1824–1842 (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1975), pp. 49 Google Scholar, 125, 154, 270; Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser 1830, p. 2.

28 Evans, Fighting words, p. 75.

29 New South Wales Government Gazette, 11 February 1842.

30 Evans, Radical Brisbane, pp. 33–4.

31 Steele, Brisbane town.

32 Evans, Radical Brisbane, pp. 33–5.

33 William Ross Johnston, ‘A study of the relationship between the law, the state and the community in colonial Queensland’, MA thesis, University of Queensland, 1965, pp. 8, 11. For the Redcliffe settlement, see Keys, this volume.

34 Offenders Punishment and Justices Summary Jurisdiction Act 1832, 3 Wm 4, no. 3.

35 Bruce, Kercher, An unruly child: A history of law in Australia (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1995), pp. 60–1Google Scholar. Samuel Frederick Milford was appointed as the first resident judge for the Moreton Bay district.

36 Johnston, ‘A study of the relationship’, pp. 6–7.

37 Johnston, ‘A study of the relationship’, p. 7.

38 Douglas and Finnane, Indigenous crime and settler law, p. 73.

39 Lord Glenelg to Sir Richard Bourke, Historical Records of Australia, Series 1, Governors’ Despatches to and from England, Volume XIX, July; 1837 to January, 1839, p. 47.

40 Lord Glenelg to Sir Richard Bourke, Historical Records of Australia.

41 Mark, Finnane, and Jonathan, Richards, ‘“You’ll get nothing out of it?”: The inquest, police and Aboriginal deaths in colonial Queensland’, Australian Historical Studies 35(123) (2004), 86 Google Scholar.

42 Douglas and Finnane, Indigenous crime and settler law, pp. 51–2.

43 Moreton Bay Courier, 28 July 1849, p. 2.

44 Moreton Bay Courier, 28 July 1849, p. 2.

45 Moreton Bay Courier, 28 July 1849, p. 2.

46 NSW Legislative Assembly, Report from the Select Committee on Murders by the Aborigines on the Dawson River, 1858, pp. 5–7.

47 Ross, Patrick, History of health & medicine in Queensland 1824–1960 (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1987), pp. 26 Google Scholar, 30.

48 Moreton Bay Courier, 28 April 1855, p. 2.

49 QSA Series ID: 13337, Item ID: 19604, Instructions to Coroners, Inwards Correspondence – Crown Law Office.

50 William, Ross Johnston, ‘The growth of the lower courts’, Queensland Heritage (1978), 15–16 Google Scholar; Dean, Here comes the judge, p. 10.

51 Johnston, ‘A study of the relationship’, p. 19.

52 North Australian, Ipswich and General Advertiser, 6 April 1858, p. 2.

53 Golder, High and responsible office, p. 72.

54 Golder, High and responsible office, p. 73.

55 Barry, Wright, ‘Self-governing codifications of English criminal law and empire: The Queensland and Canadian examples’, University of Queensland Law Journal, 26(1) (2007), 39–65 Google Scholar.

56 Lee Butterworth, ‘What good is a coroner: The transformation of the Queensland Office of Coroner’, unpublished PhD thesis, Griffith University, 2012.

57 Act for Registering Births, Deaths and Marriages, 19 Vic no. 34.

58 North Australian, Ipswich and General Advertiser, 12 October 1858, p. 3.

59 Johnston, ‘The growth of the lower courts’, p. 15.

60 Moreton Bay Courier, 8 January 1859, p. 2

61 Maurice French, Pubs, ploughs and ‘peculiar people’: Towns, farms and social life (Toowoomba: USQ Press, 1991), pp. 232–3Google Scholar.

62 Sydney Herald, 23 January 1841, p. 2.

63 Moreton Bay Courier, 17 July 1847, p. 2.

64 North Australian, Ipswich and General Advertiser, 14 October 1856, p. 3.

65 Moreton Bay Courier, 15 April 1848, p. 3.

66 Burns, Justice of the peace and parish officer.

67 Moreton Bay Courier, 25 November 1848, p. 2.

68 Finnane and Richards, ‘“You’ll get nothing out of it?”’.

69 QSA Series ID: 13338, Item ID: 19645, Inwards Correspondence – Attorney-General’s Office, letter from Henry Challinor, coroner for Ipswich, to the Attorney-General, 22 April 1861.

70 Dennis Cryle, The press in colonial Queensland: A social and political history 1845–1875 (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1989), pp. 67–9.

71 Lieutenant Frederick Wheeler, Report from the Select Committee on the Native Police Force and the Condition of Aboriginals Generally, Queensland Legislative Assembly 1861. The word ‘disperse’ became a euphemism for the killing of Aboriginal people. See Jonathan, Richards, A secret war: A true history of Queensland’s Native Police (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 2008), pp. 76–81 Google Scholar.

72 QSA Series ID: 36, Item ID: 348602, Inquest File - Evidence of Francis Lucas MD.

73 QSA Series ID: 36, Item ID: 348602, Inquest File - Evidence of Edward Quinn, Chief Constable, Ipswich Police.

74 QSA Series ID: 36, Item ID: 348602, Inquest File.

75 Letter from H. Challinor to Attorney-General, QSA, Series ID: 5253, Item ID: 846742, Correspondence Inwards, 01/01/1861-31/01/1861.

76 Letter from Attorney-General to H. Challinor, QSA, Series ID: 5253, Item ID: 846742, Correspondence Inwards, 01/01/1861-31/01/1861.

77 Moreton Bay Courier 1861, 15 January, 17 January.

78 Brisbane Courier, 3 June 1861; Moreton Bay Courier, 21 February, 27 July 1861.

79 Moreton Bay Courier, 7 May 1861.

80 Cryle, The press in colonial Queensland, p. 69.

81 Cryle, The press in colonial Queensland, pp. 7–8; Bruce, Kercher, ‘Repugnant legislation’, in Kercher, Bruce, An unruly child: A history of law in Australia (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1995), pp. 103–23Google Scholar.

82 Report from the Select Committee on the Native Police Force and the Condition of the Aborigines Generally together with the proceedings of the Committee and minutes of evidence (Brisbane: Fairfax and Belbridge, 1861), p. 2.

83 Report from the Select Committee on the Native Police Force and the Condition of the Aborigines Generally together with the proceedings of the Committee and minutes of evidence (Brisbane: Fairfax and Belbridge, 1861), p. 3.

84 Finnane and Richards, ‘“You’ll get nothing out of it?”’, p. 23.

85 Courier, 4 October 1862, p. 2.

86 Courier, 16 September 1861.

87 Brisbane Courier, 16 September 1861.

88 Jonathan Richards, ‘The Native Police of Queensland’, History Compass, 6 (2008).

89 Richards, A secret war, pp. 42, 43.

90 Raymond, Evans, Kay Saunders and Kathryn Cronin, Exclusion, exploitation and extermination: Race relations in colonial Queensland (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1978), p. 51 Google Scholar; Reid, Gordon S., ‘Black justice’, in Reid, Gordon S., A nest of hornets: The massacre of the Fraser family on Hornet Bank Station, Central Queensland 1857 and relative events (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1982), pp. 51–67 Google Scholar.

91 QSA Series ID: 12758, Item ID: 17619, Correspondence Inwards – letters addressed to the Government Resident by the Colonial Secretary Sydney and by the Inspector-General Police, on native police matters.

92 John Oxley Library, Cardew, P., Letter enclosed with correspondence of John Wickham, Government Resident, to the Secretary for Lands and Public Works, dated 23 March 1858, Heritage Collection, A2.47/674.

93 North Australian, Ipswich and General Advertiser, 29 December 1857, p. 4.

94 NSW Legislative Assembly, Report from the Select Committee on Murders by the Aborigines on the Dawson River, 1858, pp. 5–7.

95 Greg, De Moore, ‘The pride of Queensland’, Tom Wills: His Spectacular Rise and Tragic Fall (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 2008), pp. 116–18Google Scholar; Evans et al., Exclusion, exploitation and extermination, pp. 28, 52; Richards, A secret war, pp. 23, 66.

96 Douglas, Gordon, ‘Cannan, Kearsey (1815–1894)’, Australian dictionary of biography (Canberra: National Centre of Biography, Australian National University)Google Scholar.

97 Queensland Votes and Proceedings (1859), Statistical Register of Queensland for the Month of December.

98 Freckelton and Ranson, Death investigation, p. 36. Queensland Votes and Proceedings (1860), Statistical Register of Queensland for the Month of December. The six coroners were: Kearsey Cannan (Brisbane); Henry Challinor (Ipswich); William Armstrong (Drayton); Samuel W. Aldred (Warwick); Elias S. Rutherford (Rockhampton); W. H. Stevenson (Gayndah): Blue Book 1860, p. xi.