Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T05:55:58.476Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Historical precedents for the DSM-III bereavement exclusion criteria for major depression

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 March 2018

Kenneth S. Kendler
Kenneth S. Kendler*
Affiliation:
Department of Psychiatry, Virginia Institute of Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, and Medical College of Virginia/Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, USA
*
Author for correspondence: Kenneth S.Kendler, E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Background

I review the historical antecedents of the two key features of the bereavement exclusion (BE) for major depression (MD) criteria initially proposed in DSM-III: (i) a context-dependent approach to the evaluation of MD which required that the diagnosis be given only when course, symptoms and signs are ‘out of proportion’ to experienced adversities, and (ii) bereavement is the sole adversity for which this context-dependent approach should be utilized.

Methods

A review of 49 textbook and review articles on depression or melancholia published 1880–1960.

Results

Seventeen (35%) of the 49 texts advocated for a context-dependent approach to the diagnosis of MD. Most advocates relied on an intuitive clinical understanding of when the depressive features were v. were not commensurate with the experienced adversities. Several authors suggested that specific symptoms or course of illness could differentiate MD from ‘normative’ sadness. Others noted that patient reports of psychological causes of their depression should be treated skeptically. While death of loved ones was the most frequently noted specific adversity associated with MD, no author considered it qualitatively different from other stressors or suggested that it alone should be considered when diagnosing MD in a context-dependent manner.

Conclusions

A key underlying assumption of the BE criteria – a context-dependent approach to the diagnosis of MD– was advocated by a significant minority of earlier psychiatric diagnosticians, although problems in its clinical implementation were sometimes noted. No historical precedent was found for the application of the context-dependent approach only to bereavement, as proposed in DSM-III.

Keywords

Bereavement exclusion criteriadepressionDSM-IIIhistory
Type
Original Articles
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 48 , Issue 16 , December 2018 , pp. 2794 - 2803
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

American Psychiatric Association (1980) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd edn., Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.Google Scholar
American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn., Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.Google Scholar
Berkley, HJ (1900) A Treatise on Mental Diseases. New York: D. Appleton and Company.Google Scholar
Blandford, GF (1886) Insanity and Its Treatment Lectures on The Treatment, Medical and Legal, of Insane Patients, 3rd edn., New York: William Wood and Company.Google Scholar
Bleuler, E (1976) Textbook of Psychiatry. New York: Arno Press: A New York Times Company.Google Scholar
Brown, GW, Sklair, F, Harris, TO and Birley, JL (1973) Life-events and psychiatric disorders. 1. Some methodological issues. Psychological Medicine 3, 74–87.Google Scholar
Buckley, AC (1920) The Basis of Psychiatry (Psychological Medicine) A Guide to the Study of Mental Disorders, for Students and Practitioners. Forgotten Books 2013, originally published 1920, Philadelphia and London: JB Lippincott Company.Google Scholar
Bucknill, JC and Tuke, DH (1858) A Manual of Psychological Medicine: The History, Nosology, Description, Statistics, Diagnosis, Pathology, and Treatment of Insanity. Philadelphia: Blanchard and Lea.Google Scholar
Burr, CB (1894) A Primer of Psychology and Mental Disease. Detroit, MI: George S. Davis.Google Scholar
Chapin, JB (1898) A Compendium of Insanity. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.Google Scholar
Church, A and Peterson, F (1900) Nervous and Mental Diseases, 2nd edn., Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.Google Scholar
Clark, AC (1897) Clinical Manual of Mental Diseases: For Practitioners and Students. London, Baillière: Tindall and Cox.Google Scholar
Clark, D (1892) Notes on Mental Diseases: By A Student. Toronto: Toronto University Medical College.Google Scholar
Cole, RH (1913) Mental Diseases: A Text-Book of Psychiatry for Medical Students and Practitioners. 1st edn., London: University of London Press.Google Scholar
Craig, M (1912) Psychological Medicine: A Manual on Mental Diseases for Practitioners and Students. Forgotten Books 2013, originally published 1912, London: J & A Churchill.Google Scholar
Curran, D and Guttmann, E (1945) Psychological Medicine: A Short Introduction to Psychiatry, 2nd edn., Edinburgh: E. & S. Livingstone LTD.Google Scholar
Dana, CL (1904) Text-Book of Nervous Diseases and Psychiatry: For the use of Students and Practitioners of Medicine, 6th rev. and enl.ed. ed. New York, NY: William Wood and Company.Google Scholar
De Fursac, R (1905) Manual of Psychiatry. Forgotten Books 2013, originally published 1905, New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Dercum, FX (1913) A Clinical Manual of Mental Diseases. Philadelphia and London: W.B. Saunders Company.Google Scholar
Farquharson, WF (1895) Melancholia, with special reference to its characteristics in Cumberland and West-Morland. The Lancet 146, 722–726.Google Scholar
Folsom, CF (1886) Mental Diseases, vol. 5. Boston: American System of Medicine.Google Scholar
Frank, E, Anderson, B, Reynolds, CF III, Ritenour, A and Kupfer, DJ (1994) Life events and the research diagnostic criteria endogenous subtype. A confirmation of the distinction using the Bedford college methods. Archives of General Psychiatry 51, 519–524.Google Scholar
Gordon, RG, Harris, NG and Rees, JR (1936) An Introduction to Psychological Medicine. London: Oxford University Press, Oxford Medical Publications.Google Scholar
Gray, LC (1893) A Treatise on Nervous and Mental Diseases for Students and Practitioners of Medicine. Philadelphia: Lea Brothers & Company.Google Scholar
Hammond, WA (1883) A Treatise on Insanity in its Medical Relations. New York: D. Appleton and Company.Google Scholar
Henderson, DK and Gillespie, RD (1944) A Text-Book of Psychiatry for Students and Practitioners, 6th edn., London: Oxford University Press; Oxford Medical Publications.Google Scholar
Horwitz, AV, Wakefield, JC and Spitzer, RL (2007) The Loss of Sadness: How Psychiatry Transformed Normal Sorrow Into Depressive Disorder. USA: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Jelliffe, SE and White, WA (1923) Diseases of the Nervous System: A Text-Book of Neurology and Psychiatry, 4th edn., revised, rewritten and enlarged ed. Philadelphia and New York: Lea & Febiger.Google Scholar
Kellogg, TH (1897) A Text-Book on Mental Diseases for the use of Students and Practitioners of Medicine. New York, NY: William Wood & Company.Google Scholar
Kendler, KS (2008) Kendler book review of: the loss of sadness: how psychiatry transformed normal sorrow into depressive disorder (authors: Allan V. Horwitz and Jerome C. Wakefield). Psychological Medicine 38, 148–150.Google Scholar
Kendler, KS (2016) The phenomenology of major depression and the representativeness and nature of DSM criteria. American Journal of Psychiatry 173, 771–780.Google Scholar
Kendler, KS (2017) The genealogy of major depression: symptoms and signs of melancholia from 1880-1900. Molecular Psychiatry 22, 1539–1553.Google Scholar
Kirchhoff, T (1893) Handbook of Insanity for Practitioners and Students. New York: William Wood & Company.Google Scholar
Kraepelin, E (1990) In Quen J (ed). Psychiatry, A Textbook for Students and Physicians (Translation of the 6th Edition of Psychiatrie-Translator Volume 2-Sabine Ayed). Canton, MA: Science History Publications.Google Scholar
Krafft-Ebing, Rv (1903) Text-Book of Insanity: Based on Clinical Observations (for Practitioners and Students of Medicine); Translator: Charles Gilbert Chaddock, MD. Philadelphia, PA: F.A. Davis Company, Publishers.Google Scholar
Lewis, AJ (1934) Melancholia: a clinical survey of depressive states. Journal of Mental Science 80, 277–378.Google Scholar
Lewis, WB (1889) A Text-Book of Mental Diseases: With Special Reference to the Pathological Aspects of Insanity. London: Charles Griffin & Company.Google Scholar
Macpherson, J (1899) Mental Affections: An Introduction to the Study of Insanity. London: Macmillan and Company, Limited.Google Scholar
Maudsley, H (1895) The Pathology of Mind: A Study of Its Distempers, Deformities, and Disorders. London: Macmillan and Company.Google Scholar
Mayer-Gross, W, Slater, E and Roth, M (1954) Clinical Psychiatry, 1st edn., London: Cassell and Company LTD.Google Scholar
Mercier, C (1890) Sanity and Insanity. London: Walter Scott.Google Scholar
Muncie, W (1939) Psychobiology and Psychiatry: A Textbook of Normal and Abnormal Human Behavior, 1st edn/1st Printing edn (1939) ed. St Louis: C.V. Mosby.Google Scholar
Noyes, AP (1936) A Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn., New York: The Macmillan Company.Google Scholar
Paton, S (1905) Psychiatry: A Text-Book for Students and Physicians. Forgotten Books 2014, originally published 1905, Philadelphia and London: JB Lippincott Company.Google Scholar
Paykel, ES, Myers, JK, Dienelt, MN, Klerman, GL, Lindenthal, JJ and Pepper, MP (1969) Life events and depression. A controlled study. Archives of General Psychiatry 21, 753–760.Google Scholar
Potts, CS (1900) Nervous and Mental Diseases: A Manual for Students and Practitioners. Philadelphia: Lea Brothers & Company.Google Scholar
Punton, J (1898) Incipient melancholia: its diagnosis, prognosis and treatment. Alienist and Neurologist 19, 560–572.Google Scholar
Régis, E (1895) A Practical Manual of Mental Medicine, 2nd edn., Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, Son & Company.Google Scholar
Russell, I (1881) Melancholia. Alienist and Neurologist 2, 195–207.Google Scholar
Sadler, WS (1936) Theory and Practice of Psychiatry. St Louis: The C.V. Mosby Company.Google Scholar
Savage, GH (1884) Insanity and Allied Neuroses: Practical and Clinical. Philadelphia: Henry C. Lea's Son & Company.Google Scholar
Scull, A, MacKensie, C and Hervey, N (1996) Masters of Bedlam, 1st edn. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Shaw, JC (1894) Essentials of Nervous Diseases and Insanity: Their Symptoms and Treatment. A Manual for Students and Practitioners, 2nd edn., revised ed. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.Google Scholar
Spitzka, EC (1883) Insanity: Its Classification, Diagnosis and Treatment, A Manual for Students and Practitioners of Medicine, 1st edn., New York, NY: Bermingham & Company.Google Scholar
Stearns, HP (1893) Lectures on Mental Diseases: Designed Especially for Medical Students and General Practitioners. Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, Son & Company.Google Scholar
Trede, K, Salvatore, P, Baethge, C, Gerhard, A, Maggini, C and Baldessarini, RJ (2005) Manic-depressive illness: evolution in Kraepelin's textbook, 1883–1926. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 13, 155–178.Google Scholar
Tuke, DH (1892) A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine: Giving the Definition, Etymology and Synonyms of the Terms Used in Medical Psychology. Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, Son & Company.Google Scholar
Ulett, GA and Goodrich, DW (1956) A Synopsis of Contemporary Psychiatry. St Louis: C.V. Mosby Company.Google Scholar
Wakefield, JC (2013) The DSM-5 debate over the bereavement exclusion: psychiatric diagnosis and the future of empirically supported treatment. Clinical Psychology Review 33, 825–845.Google Scholar
White, WA (1907) Outlines of Psychiatry. New York, NY: The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Worcester, S (1882) Insanity and Its Treatment: Lectures on the Treatment of Insanity and Kindred Nervous Diseases. New York: Boericke & Tafel.Google Scholar
Yellowlees, H (1932) Clinical Lectures on Psychological Medicine. Baltimore, MD, J. & A. Churchill.Google Scholar
Zachar, P, First, M and Kendler, KS (2017) The bereavement exclusion debate in the DSM-5: a history. Clinical Psychological Science 5, 890–906.Google Scholar
Ziehen, T (1898) The diagnosis and treatment of melancholia. American Journal of Insanity 54, 543–587.Google Scholar