1. Wilson, Woodrow to Axson, Ellen, 11 2, 1884Google Scholar, in The Papers of Woodrow Wilson, ed. Link, Arthur S., 35 vols. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1966–1986), vol. 3, p. 396.Google Scholar

2. Hawkins, Hugh, Pioneer: A History of The Johns Hopkins University, 1874–1889 (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1960), p. 281Google Scholar. See also Graybar, Lloyd J., Albert Shaw of the Review of Reviews: An Intellectual Biography (Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1974), p. 32Google Scholar; and McFarland, Gerald W., Mugwumps, Morals, and Politics, 1884–1920 (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1975), p. 46.Google Scholar

3. Herbert B. Adams to Clarence W. Bowen, December 3, 1894, Treasurer's File: American Historical Association Papers (Manuscript Division, Library of Congress); Record of the Johns Hopkins University Historical and Political Science Association (Historical Seminary) 1 (November 14, 1884): 70 (Ferdinand Hamburger, Jr., Archives, Milton S. Eisenhower Library, Johns Hopkins University); and Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Greek Politics, Herbert Baxter Adams Papers (Special Collections, Milton S. Eisenhower Library, Johns Hopkins University).

4. Wilson, to Axson, , 11 5, 1884Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 3, pp. 404–5Google Scholar; and Wilson, to Shaw, Albert B., 03 7, 1885Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 4, p. 341.Google Scholar

5. This is the opinion of Marvin E. Gettleman, who kindly permitted me to read the introductory essay to his forthcoming complete edition of the minutes of the Johns Hopkins seminar of history and politics from 1877 to 1912.

6. Hawkins, , Pioneer, p. 173.Google Scholar

7. Brief sketches of Adams's life are readily accessible. See, for example, Vincent, John M., “Herbert B. Adams,” in American Masters of Social Science, ed. Odum, Howard W. (New York: H. Holt and Company, 1927), pp. 99–127Google Scholar; Bassett, John Spencer, “Adams, Herbert Baxter,” in Dictionary of American Biography, 20 vols. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1943), vol. 1, pp. 69–71Google Scholar; and Cunningham, Raymond J., “Herbert Baxter Adams,” in Dictionary of Literary Biography: American Historians, 1866–1912, ed. Wilson, Clyde N., 47 vols. (Detroit: Gale, 1978–1986), vol. 47, pp. 28–34.Google Scholar

8. Adams, Herbert B., “Reminiscences of H. B. Adams Begun After His Mother's Death, Oct. 1, 1892,” Adams Papers (Special Collections), p. 15Google Scholar. See also LeDuc, Thomas, Piety and Intellect at Amherst College, 1865–1912 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1946), p. 43Google Scholar; and McLachlan, James, “American Colleges and the Transmission of Culture: The Case of the Mugwumps,” in The Hofstadter Aegis: A Memorial, ed. Elkins, Stanley and McKitrick, Eric (New York: Random House, 1974), pp. 184–206.Google Scholar

9. Adams, Herbert B., Bluntschli's Life-Work (Baltimore, 1884), pp. 8, 15Google Scholar. On Bluntschli's place in German liberalism, see Sheehan, James J., German Liberalism in the Nineteenth Century (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1978), pp. 87, 99, 106, 150, 155.Google Scholar

10. Adams, Herbert B., “Frauen emancipation von den Standpunkt der Amerikanischer Staatsidee,”Google Scholar Adams Papers (Special Collections); Emil Otto, testimonial for Herbert B. Adams, April 14, 1876, in Historical Scholarship in the United States, 1876–1901: As Revealed in the Correspondence of Herbert B. Adams, ed. Holt, W. Stull (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1938), p. 29.Google Scholar

11. Daniel Coit Gilman, quoted in Hawkins, , Pioneer, p. 68; see also pp. 55, 171.Google Scholar

12. White, Andrew D., Education in Political Science: An Address Delivered in the Academy of Music, Baltimore, on the Third Anniversary of The Johns Hopkins University, February 22, 1879 (Baltimore, 1879), pp. 4–6, 13, 15–18, 27Google Scholar. For related statements by President Eliot of Harvard, see Eliot, Charles W., “What Is A Liberal Education?” Century Magazine 28 (06 1884): 207–8Google Scholar; and by President William W. Folwell of the University of Minnesota, see Bledstein, Burton J., The Culture of Professionalism: The Middle Class and the Development of Higher Education in America (New York: Norton, 1976), p. 284.Google Scholar

13. Adams, Herbert B., Is History Past Politics? (Baltimore, 1895), p. 67.Google Scholar

14. Adams, Herbert B., “History and Politics,” Johns Hopkins University Annual Report: 1888, p. 40.Google Scholar

15. Adams, Herbert B., The Germanic Origin of New England Towns (Baltimore, 1882), p. 8Google Scholar. On the role of Anglo-Saxonism in American historiography, see Saveth, Edward N., American Historians and European Immigrants, 1875–1925 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1948), pp. 13–31Google Scholar; Herbst, Jurgen, The German Historical School in A merican Scholarship: A Study in the Transfer of Culture (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1965), pp. 120–22Google Scholar; Higham, John, with Krieger, Leonard and Gilbert, Felix, History (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1965), pp. 160–62Google Scholar; and Loewenberg, Bert J., American History in American Thought: Christopher Columbus to Henry Adams (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1972), pp. 370–72.Google Scholar

16. Gettleman, Marvin E., “More and Less Than ‘Scientific History’: The Johns Hopkins University Seminar of Historical and Political Science, 1877–1901”Google Scholar (unpublished paper presented at the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Organization of American Historians, April 4, 1981, Detroit, Michigan), p. 11. The durability of the Anglo-Saxon hypothesis (“germ theory”) as a theoretical starting point for American social thinkers has been demonstrated by Jean B. Quandt for an influential group of Progressive “communitarian” intellectuals. See Quandt, Jean B., From the Small Town to the Great Community: The Social Thought of Progressive Intellectuals (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1970), pp. 48, 168 n. 92, 184 n. 74.Google Scholar

17. Historical Seminary Records 1 (December 19, 1877): iii. On the relationship of the seminar to the association, see Adams, Herbert B., Methods of Historical Study (Baltimore, 1884), p. 103Google Scholar; and Hawkins, , Pioneer, pp. 215, 228.Google Scholar

18. French, John C., A History of the University Founded by Johns Hopkins (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1946), p. 47.Google Scholar

19. Gilman continued to be listed as “president” of the association through 1882–83, after which Adams appears as “director,” but control of the proceedings had actually fallen to Adams before this. See Hopkins, JohnsUniversity Register: 1882–3, p. 42Google Scholar; Register: 1883–4, p. 47Google Scholar; and Adams, , Methods of Historical Study, p. 103Google Scholar. See also, Rader, Benjamin G., The Academic Mind and Reform: The Influence of Richard T. Ely in American Life (Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1966), pp. 16–18.Google Scholar

20. Hawkins, , Pioneer, p. 228Google Scholar; and Vincent, , “Adams,” p. 108.Google Scholar

21. JHU Report: 1881, p. 22Google Scholar; and Civil Service Record 1 (07 1881): 1Google Scholar. The Maryland association was the state counterpart of the National Civil Service Reform League.

22. Lambert, John R., Arthur Pue Gorman (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1953), pp. 239, 122, 17Google Scholar; and Crooks, James B., Politics and Progress: The Rise of Urban Progressivism in Baltimore, 1895 to 1911 (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1968), p. 48.Google Scholar

23. Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Nineteenth-Century Europe, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Civil Service Reform Association of Maryland membership certificate issued to Herbert B. Adams, March 3, 1882, Adams Papers (Special Collections); “The Annual Meeting of the Civil-Service Reform Association of Maryland,” Civil-Service Reformer 1 (06 1885): 68Google Scholar; “The Fifth Annual Meeting of the Civil-Service Reform Association of Maryland,” Civil Service Reformer 2 (06 1886): 96Google Scholar; and Historical Seminary Records, 1 (October 24, 1884): 65.

24. “The Death of President Garfield,” Johns Hopkins University Circular 1 (12 1881): 168Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, Ari, Outlawing the Spoils: A History of the Civil Service Reform Movement, 1865–1883 (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1961), pp. 209–12Google Scholar; and Herbert B. Adams, incomplete typescript translation of Johann Caspar Bluntschli's Staatslehre für Gebildete, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

25. [Adams, Herbert B.,] “An Appeal to the People of Maryland,” Civil Service Record 4 (12 1884): 57Google Scholar. This paper was presented to the seminar as “The Progress of Civil Service Reform in the United States” (“Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 4 [12 1884]: 28).Google Scholar

26. See, for example, “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 8 (04 1889): 65Google Scholar; 17 (March 1898): 49; 13 (February 1894): 32; 16 (January 1897): 22; and 5 (May 1886): 96. See also Historical Seminary Records 1 (October 24, 1884): 65; and Adams, , “History and Politics,” JHU Report: 1889, p. 59.Google Scholar

27. Adams, , Methods of Historical Study, p. 16Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., Cooperation in University Work (Baltimore, 1883), p. 50Google Scholar. On municipal affairs at the seminar, see, for example, “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 3 (04 1884): 96Google Scholar; 4 (December 1884): 28; 6 (August 1887): 93; 8 (February 1889): 27; 8 (September 1889): 105; 14 (February 1895): 29; 14 (April 1895): 68; and 19 (March 1900): 16.

28. Teaford, Jon C., The Unheralded Triumph: City Government in America, 1870–1900 (Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1984), pp. 193–98Google Scholar; and Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 9–11Google Scholar; Lambert, , Gorman, p. 30.Google Scholar

29. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 13Google Scholar; and “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 2 (02 1883): 56Google Scholar; 3 (April 1884): 30; and 4 (December 1884): 28.

30. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 15, 25Google Scholar; and Wilson, to Shinn, Charles H., 10 25, 1884Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 3, p. 373.Google Scholar

31. Rose, John C., “Municipal Politics in Baltimore” (abstract), JHU Circular 2 (02 1883): 56Google Scholar. See also “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 2 (08 1883): 156Google Scholar; 4 (December 1884): 26; and 6 (August 1887): 93; and Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 15–16, 35–36, 38.Google Scholar

32. Lambert, , Gorman, pp. 91–92Google Scholar; Johns Hopkins Half-Century Directory: A Catalogue of the Trustees, Faculty, Holders of Degrees, and Students, Graduates and Non-Graduates, 1876–1926 (Baltimore, 1926), pp. 39, 321Google Scholar; Baltimore Sun, 10 26, 28, 1882Google Scholar; and John Franklin Jameson, Diary, October 27, 1882, John Franklin Jameson Papers (Manuscript Division, Library of Congress).

33. Lambert, , Gorman, pp. 122, 127.Google Scholar

34. Hawkins, , Pioneer, pp. 5–6, 105, 172Google Scholar; “Judge George William Brown,” JHU Circular 10 (11 1890); 6–8Google Scholar; and Brown, to Adams, , 02 17, 1882Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

35. Historical Seminary Records 1 (October 23, 1883): 128; and Lambert, , Gorman, pp. 126–28.Google Scholar

36. Quoted in Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 13Google Scholar; and Herbert B. Adams, Cash Book: May 1899–July 1901, Adams Papers (Special Collections), pp. 6, 18. The Baltimore Reform League and similar organizations elsewhere are located within the context of late-19th-Century urban government in Teaford, , Unheralded Triumph, pp. 193–98.Google Scholar

37. Adams, , Methods of Historical Study, p. 102Google Scholar; Adams, , Cooperation in University Work, p. 52Google Scholar; Hawkins, , Pioneer, p. 108Google Scholar; and “New Publications,” Civil-Service Reformer 3 (02 1887): 22–23Google Scholar; and 4 (April 1888): 46–47. On the place of the Studies in late-19th-Century scholarship, see Hawkins, , Pioneer, pp. 108–9Google Scholar; Kraus, Michael, The Writing of American History (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1953), p. 171Google Scholar; Higham, et al. , History, p. 11Google Scholar; and Loewenberg, , American History, p. 369.Google Scholar

38. Levermore, Charles H., The Town and City Government of New Haven (Baltimore, 1886), p. 59Google Scholar. For other representative examples, see Ingle, Edward, Local Institutions of Virginia (Baltimore, 1885), pp. 118–20Google Scholar; Wilhelm, Lewis W., Local Institutions of Maryland (Baltimore, 1885), p. 129Google Scholar; Porter, John A., The City of Washington: Its Origin and Administration (Baltimore, 1885), pp. 44–45Google Scholar; Howe, William W., Municipal History of New Orleans (Baltimore, 1889), pp. 32–33Google Scholar; Allinson, Edward P. and Penrose, Boies, The City Government of Philadelphia (Baltimore, 1887), pp. 70–71Google Scholar; Bugbee, James M., The City Government of Boston (Baltimore, 1887), pp. 131–33Google Scholar; Snow, Marshall S., The City Government of Saint Louis (Baltimore, 1887), p. 174Google Scholar; Thomas, Thaddeus P., The City Government of Baltimore (Baltimore, 1896), pp. 44–45Google Scholar; and Hollander, Jacob H., The Financial History of Baltimore (Baltimore, 1899), p. ix.Google Scholar

39. Bryce, to Adams, , 12 5, 1883Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); see also, Bryce, to Adams, , 06 23 [1886]Google Scholar, Adams Papers; and Bryce to Daniel Coit Gilman, April 10 [1884], Daniel Coit Gilman Papers (Special Collections, Milton S. Eisenhower Library, Johns Hopkins University). An account of this second visit of Bryce to Hopkins is given in Ions, Edmund S., James Bryce and American Democracy, 1870–1922 (London: Macmillan, 1968), pp. 118–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

40. Hammack, David C., “Elite Perceptions of Power in the Cities of the United States, 1800–1900: The Evidence of James Bryce, Moisei Ostrogorski, and Their American Informants,” Journal of Urban History 4 (08 1978): 366CrossRefGoogle Scholar; see also, Ions, , Bryce, pp. 136–38.Google Scholar

41. Bryce, to Adams, , 10 11, 1886Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); see also, Bryce, to Adams, , 11 2, 1882Google Scholar; November 13, [1883?]; and June 2, 16, 1887, Adams Papers; Ions, , Bryce, p. 101Google Scholar; and Hammack, , “Elite Perceptions,” pp. 367–68Google Scholar. The Studies cited and/or quoted in The American Commonwealth include Adams, , German OriginsGoogle Scholar; Bemis, Edward W., Local Government in Michigan and the Northwest (Baltimore, 1883)Google Scholar; Gould, Elgin R. L., Local Government in Pennsylvania (Baltimore, 1883)Google Scholar; Shaw, Albert B., Local Government in Illinois (Baltimore, 1883)Google Scholar; Ingle, , VirginiaGoogle Scholar; Wilhelm, , MarylandGoogle Scholar; Davis, Horace, American Constitutions (Baltimore, 1885)Google Scholar; Allinson, Edward P. and Penrose, Boies, Philadelphia, 1681–1887: A History of Municipal Development (Baltimore, 1887)Google Scholar; Jameson, J. Franklin, An Introduction to the Study of the Constitutional and Political History of the States (Baltimore, 1886)Google Scholar; Bugbee, , BostonGoogle Scholar; and Snow, , Saint LouisGoogle Scholar. Adams later declared, “James Bryce's book on the ‘American Commonwealth’ was probably suggested by the ‘Johns Hopkins University Studies’ and was certainly wrought out in some measure by their aid” (Herbert B. Adams, “An Address to the Old Town Merchants and Manufacturers Association on the Relation of the Johns Hopkins University to Baltimore,” Adams Papers [Special Collections], p. 8).

42. Bryce, James, The American Commonwealth (London and New York, 1891 [1888]), vol. 1, p. 583Google Scholar n. 2; and vol. 1, pp. 648–49, 295.

43. Bremner, Robert H., From the Depths: The Discovery of Poverty in the United States (New York: New York University Press, 1956), pp. 50–57.Google Scholar

44. Carey, F. K., “On Plans for Organizing Charity” (abstract), JHU Circular 1 (03 1881): 130Google Scholar. On Carey's background, see Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 148, 225.Google Scholar

45. Franklin, Fabian, The Life of Daniel Coit Gilman (New York: Dodd, Mead and Co., 1910), pp. 89, 274, 268Google Scholar; Pumphrey, Muriel W., “Mary Richmond and the Rise of Professional Social Work in Baltimore: The Foundation of a Creative Career” (D.S.W. thesis, Columbia University, 1956), pp. 109–11, 106–7Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., “Calendar-Diary: 1881–2, 11 17, 1881Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Hamburger Archives). Gilman was president of the Baltimore COS from 1890 to 1901 (Franklin, , Gilman, p. 268.)Google Scholar

46. Adams, Herbert B., The College of William and Mary: A Contribution to the History of Higher Education, With Suggestions for Its National Promotion (Washington, D.C., 1887), p. 68Google Scholar; see also Historical Seminary Records 1 (January 14, 1887): 237.

47. Adams, Herbert B., “A Plea of the Organization of the Department of History and Political Science, May 29, 1886,”Google Scholar Adams Papers (Special Collections), [p. 2].

48. Adams to Wilson, January 25, 1887, in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, p. 436Google Scholar; Adams, , William and Mary, pp. 76–83Google Scholar; and Dawson, N. H. R., Report of the Commissioner of Education for the Year 1886–87 (Washington, DC., 1888), pp. 19–21.Google Scholar

49. Adams, Herbert B., “Defence of a Civil Academy,” Science: An Illustrated Journal 9 (05 20, 1887): 485.Google ScholarPubMed

50. Ely, Richard T., “A Sketch of the Life and Services of Herbert Baxter Adams,” in Herbert B. Adams: Tributes of Friends; With a Bibliography of the Department of History, Politics and Economics of the Johns Hopkins University, 1876–1901 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1902), p. 38Google Scholar; Adams to Gilman, March 4, 1887, Adams Papers (Special Collections); and Adams to Shaw, May 5, 1887, Albert Shaw Papers (Manuscript Division, New York Public Library).

51. See, for example, Higham, et al. , History, pp. 8–11Google Scholar; Wiebe, Robert H., The Search for Order, 1877–1920 (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1967), p. 121Google Scholar; Haskell, Thomas L., The Emergence of Professional Social Science: The American Social Science Association and the Nineteenth Century Crisis of Authority (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1978), pp. 65–68, 74–77, 235–40Google Scholar; and Veysey, Laurence, “The Plural Organized World of the Humanities,” in The Organization of Knowledge in Modern America, 1860–1920, ed. Oleson, Alexandra and Voss, John (Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979), pp. 67–68.Google Scholar

52. Adams, to Gilman, , 04 4, 1887Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Ely, , “Adams,” p. 38Google Scholar; Gould, Elgin to Adams, , 04 27, 1887Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Clark, John Bates to Adams, , 05 10, 1887Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); and Wilson, to Adams, , 05 16, 1887Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, p. 504.Google Scholar

53. Adams, to Gilman, , 04 4, 1887Google Scholar; Gilman, to Adams, , 05 25, 1890Google Scholar, Gilman Papers (Special Collections); Gilman, Daniel Coit, “The Johns Hopkins University from 1873 to 1893,” JHU Circular 13 (02 1894): 18Google Scholar; and Hawkins, , Pioneer, pp. 317–21.Google Scholar

54. Adams, to Gilman, , 05 13, June 6, December 13, 1890Google Scholar; and March 20, 1901, Adams Papers (Special Collections); and Historical Seminary Records 1 (April 3, 1891): 595.

55. Adams, to Gilman, , 04 6, 1887Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

56. Ely, Richard T., Ground Under Our Feet: An Autobiography (New York: Macmillan, 1938), p. 114Google Scholar; Keller, Morton, Affairs of State: Public Life in Late Nineteenth Century America (Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1977), p. 296CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Caiden, Gerald E., “In Search of an Apolitical Science of Public Administration,” in Politics and Administration: Woodrow Wilson and American Public Administration, ed. Rabin, Jack and Bowman, James S. (New York and Basel: Marcel Dekker, 1984), pp. 53, 55–56.Google Scholar

57. Wilson, Woodrow, “The Study of Administration,” in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, pp. 359, 375Google Scholar; and Bragdon, Henry W., Woodrow Wilson: The Academic Years (Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1967), pp. 154–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

58. Adams, Herbert B., “History, Politics, and Economics,” JHU Report: 1897, p. 58Google Scholar; Wilson, to Reid, Edith Gittings, 10 3, 1897Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 10, p. 322Google Scholar; Bragdon, , Wilson, p. 192Google Scholar. Wilson's lecture notes are published in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, pp. 668–69Google Scholar; vol. 6, pp. 86–87, 90–92, 482–521; vol. 7, pp. 114–58, 381–436; and vol. 8, pp. 81–116.

59. Ely, Richard T. and Finley, John H., “Social Science in Colleges,” Christian Union 38 (11 8, 1888): 145Google Scholar; Gettleman, Marvin E., “John H. Finley and the Academic Origins of American Social Work, 1887–1892,” Studies in History and Society 2 (Fall 1969–Spring 1970): 13–16Google Scholar; Broadhurst, Betty P., “The Johns Hopkins University: Training Center for Social Scientists,” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 14 (07 1978): 213–22.3.0.CO;2-Y>CrossRefGoogle Scholar

60. Adams, to Wilson, , 02 9, 1888Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, p. 665Google Scholar; Adams, Herbert B., “History and Politics,” JHU Report: 1888, p. 73Google Scholar; JHU Report: 1889, p. 58Google Scholar; JHU Report: 1892, p. 56Google Scholar; JHU Report: 1893, pp. 55–56Google Scholar; JHU Report: 1895, p. 56Google Scholar; Adams, Herbert B., “History, Economics, and Politics,” JHU Report: 1896, p. 41Google Scholar; and JHU Report: 1897, p. 59Google Scholar. For a biographical sketch of Gould, see Woodbury, Helen Sumner, “Gould, Elgin Ralston Lovell,” in Dictionary of American Biography (hereafter cited as DAB), vol. 7, pp. 449–50.Google Scholar

61. Adams, , “History and Politics,” JHU Report: 1889, p. 58Google Scholar; JHU Report: 1893, pp. 55–56Google Scholar; “Charities and Their Administration,” JHU Circular 12 (05 1893): 73–77Google Scholar; Adams, Herbert B., The Study of History in American Colleges and Universities (Washington, D.C., 1887), p. 163Google Scholar. For a biographical sketch of Warner, see Coolidge, Mary R., “Warner, Amos Griswold,” DAB, vol. 19, pp. 400–1Google Scholar. Adams himself engaged in field investigations which he described in Adams, Herbert B., “Boys' Clubs in Baltimore,” Christian Union 37 (06 21, 1888): 776–77Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., Work Among Working-Women in Baltimore: A Social Study (Baltimore, 1889)Google Scholar. For an account of typical social science field work at Hopkins, see Green, David I., “Visits to the Public Institutions of Maryland,” JHU Circular 12 (05 1893): 82–83.Google Scholar

62. JHU Report: 1878, p. 56Google Scholar; “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 6 (04 1887): 86Google Scholar; 8 (February 1889): 27; 19 (June 1899): 62; 15 (March 1896): 55; and 18 (March 1899): 43.

63. Adams, , “Boys' Clubs,” pp. 776–77Google Scholar; and Historical Seminary Records, 1 (April 20, 1888): 379–80. Adams knew and admired Charles Loring Brace, founder of the New York Children's Aid Society, whose newsboys' lodging houses were widely imitated. See Adams, Herbert B., “Personal Philanthropy Illustrated by the Life of Charles Loring Brace,” Charities Review 1 (04 1892), pp. 239–50.Google Scholar

64. “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 3 (01 1884): 46Google Scholar; 8 (February 1889): 27; 9 (December 1889): 23; 7 (April 1888): 80; and 12 (January 1893): 34.

65. Adams, Herbert B., “History and Politics,” JHU Report: 1891, p. 61.Google Scholar

66. Hirschfeld, Charles, Baltimore, 1870–1900: Studies in Social History (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1941), p. 143Google Scholar; Smith, Zilpha, “Report of the Committee on the Organization of Charity,” Proceedings of the National Conference on Charities and Correction at the Fifteenth Annual Session Held in Buffalo, N.Y., July 5–11, 1888 (Boston, 1888), p. 128Google Scholar; and Franklin, , Gilman, p. 275.Google Scholar

67. Broadhurst, , “Training Center,” pp. 216–17Google Scholar; Pumphrey, , “Richmond,” p. 178Google Scholar; and Hirschfeld, , Baltimore, p. 146Google Scholar. For a biographical sketch of Brackett, see Coll, Blanche D., “Brackett,1 Jeffrey Richardson,” DAB, Supplement 5, pp. 100–1.Google Scholar

68. Finley, John H. to Adams, , 02 7, May 6, November 11, 1891Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Ayres, Philip W. to Adams, , 10 2, 1891Google Scholar; February 17, 1894; Adams Papers; Green, David I. to Adams, , 03 10, 18, 1894Google Scholar, Adams Papers; Richmond, Mary E. to Adams, , 03 10, 1894Google Scholar, Adams Papers; Gardner, Henry B. to Adams, , 07 9, 1895, Adams PapersGoogle Scholar; and Tolman, William H. to Adams, , 09 24, 1897, Adams Papers.Google Scholar

69. Adams, Herbert B., The Church and Popular Education (Baltimore, 1900), p. 63.Google Scholar

70. Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction at the Fourteenth Annual Session Held in Omaha, Neb. August 25–31, 1887 (Boston, 1887), p. xiGoogle Scholar; Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction at the Fifteenth Annual Session Held in Buffalo, N.Y., July 5–11, 1888 (Boston, 1888), pp. xi, 441Google Scholar; Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction at the Sixteenth Annual Session Held in San Francisco, Col., September 11–18, 1889 (Boston, 1889), p. xiGoogle Scholar; Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction at the Seventeenth Annual Session Held in Baltimore, Md., May 14–21, 1890 (Boston, 1890), pp. 458, 467Google Scholar; Glenn, John to Gilman, , 07 13, 1888Google Scholar; and May 31, 1890, Gilman Papers (Special Collections).

71. Report of a Conference on Charities and Other Subjects Pertaining to the Prevention of Suffering, Pauperism, and Crime, Held in Baltimore, April 15 and 16, 1887, Under the Auspices of the Charity Organization Society of Baltimore (Baltimore, 1887), p. 88Google Scholar; Adams, Herbert B., “Notes on the Literature of Charities,” Report of a Conference on Charities, p. 7Google Scholar; Pumphreys, “Richmond,” pp. 115–16.Google Scholar

72. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” pp. 22–28, 32–36, 38Google Scholar. See Mann, Arthur, “British Social Thought and American Reformers of the Progressive Era,” Mississippi Valley Historical Review 42 (03 1956): 672–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

73. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” p. 31Google Scholar; see also, Report, pp. 27, 40Google Scholar. Adams expressed misgivings about the wisdom of providing clothes and books to indigent schoolchildren (Historical Seminary Records 1 [February 13, 1891], p. 586).

74. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” pp. 28–31Google Scholar. Adams spoke in class of “the much-governed, over-lorded town of ‘Pulman’” (Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Nineteenth-Century Europe, Adams Papers [Special Collections]).

75. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” pp. 43–44, 16–22.Google Scholar

76. Turner, to Allen, William F., 10 8, 1888Google Scholar, in Jacobs, Wilbur R., The Historical World of Frederick Jackson Turner: With Selections from His Correspondence (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1968), p. 75Google Scholar. Toynbee's social and economic thought is examined in Lagana, Loretta, “Toynbee Hall: Its Ideological Origins and Development” (Ph.D. diss., City University of New York, 1980), pp. 51–81.Google Scholar

77. Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Popular Education, Adams Papers (Special Collections). Adams published the narrative in the Studies. (See Montague, F. C., Arnold Toynbee: With an Account of the Work of Toynbee Hall in East London, by Phillip Lyttleton Gell, MA. Also an Account of the Neighborhood Guild in New York, by Charles B. Stover, AB. (Baltimore, 1889).Google Scholar

78. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” p. 21.Google Scholar

79. Adams, Herbert B., “Arnold Toynbee,” Chautauqua Assembly-Herald, 08 4, 1888Google Scholar; “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 8 (02 1889): 27Google Scholar. Adams, like his colleague Ely, had been won to historical economics at Heidelberg, where both studied with Karl Knies, a leader of the school. (Cunningham, Raymond L., “The German Historical World of Herbert Baxter Adams, 1874–1876,” Journal of American History 68 [09 1981]: 272CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rader, , Academic Mind and Reform, p. 13Google Scholar. See also Herbst, , German Historical School, pp. 129–52.)Google Scholar

80. Rogers, Daniel T., The Work Ethic in Industrial America, 1850–1920 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1978), p. 224.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

81. Howe, Frederick C., The Confessions of a Reformer (1925; rept. Chicago: Quadrangle Books, 1967), p. 8Google Scholar; see also, Historical Seminary Records 1 (November 8, 1889): 459. Hugh Hawkins goes so far as to say that, during the 1890s, political, social, and economic reform “set the dominant tone of the institution” (Hawkins, , Pioneer, p. 307)Google Scholar. This was true at least of Adams's department.

82. Adams, Herbert B., Public Educational Work in Baltimore (Baltimore, 1899), pp. 8–9.Google Scholar

83. Historical Seminary Records 1 (April 16, 1887): 279. Adams called George a “brilliant agitator” (Adams, , “Toynbee,” p. 5)Google Scholar. The seminar discussed George's theories on various occasions. See “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 1 (12 1880): 83Google Scholar; 8 (September 1889): p. 105; and 10 (March 1891): p. 84; and “News of a Fortnight,” (Johns Hopkins) News-Letter, 03 10, 1898.Google Scholar

84. Adams, , Methods of Historical Study, p. 56Google Scholar; and Rader, , Academic Mind and Reform, p. 23Google Scholar. Ely later presented an account of Most's talk to the seminar (p. 23, n. 46).

85. Adams, Herbert B., “Political Education in Baltimore,” Civil-Service Reformer 4 (07 1888): 81.Google Scholar

86. Adams, , “Political Education”Google Scholar; Ely, , “Adams,” p. 37Google Scholar; and Adams, , “Public Educational Work,” pp. 11–12.Google Scholar

87. Historical Seminary Records 1 (February 10, 1888): 349; and Adams, Herbert B., “University Extension in America,” Forum 14 (07 1891): 515.Google Scholar

88. Historical Seminary Records 1 (February 13, 1891): 586. Papers on labor issues were presented to the seminar throughout the 1880s and 1890s. See, for example, “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 3 (03 1884): 58Google Scholar; 6 (January 1887): 61; (August 1887): 93; 7 (April 1888): 80; 10 (March 1891): 84; 14 (January 1895): 29; 16 (January 1897): 22; and 17 (March 1898): 49.

89. Quandt, , Small Town to Great Community, p. 7.Google Scholar

90. Adams, , “University Extension in America,” pp. 511–12.Google Scholar

91. Thelen, David P., “Rutherford B. Hayes and the Reform Tradition in the Gilded Age,” American Quarterly 22 (Summer 1970): 152, 165.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

92. Adams, Lecture Notes: Nineteenth-Century Europe; and Adams to Bryce, November 17, 1892, James Bryce Papers (Bodleian Library, Oxford University).

93. Adams, Herbert B. et al. , “The Government of Cities,” The (Boston) Beacon, 02 12, 1887Google Scholar; Adams, , Working-Women in Baltimore, p. 1Google Scholar; Adams, Lecture Notes: Nineteenth-Century Europe; and Adams, Herbert B., “Educational Extension in the United States,” in Report of the Commissioner of Education, 1899–1900 (Washington, D.C., 1901), pp. 282–83.Google Scholar

94. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” pp. 23, 24.Google Scholar

95. Adams, , Working-Women in Baltimore, p. 8.Google Scholar

96. Adams, , “Toynbee,” p. 4.Google Scholar

97. Hayes, Alice to Adams, , 03 10, 1889Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); and Addams, Jane to Adams, , 10 10, 1897, Adams Papers.Google Scholar

98. Adams, , “Toynbee,” p. 5Google Scholar. Settlement work was discussed on numerous occasions at the seminar. See “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 7 (04 1888): 80Google Scholar; 8 (February 1889): 27; 10 (March 1891): 84; (January 1891): 56; 11 (February 1892): 50; (June 1892): 109; 13 (February 1894): 32; 14 (February 1895): 52; and 19 (June 1899): 62.

99. Adams, , Church and Popular Education, pp. 63–64Google Scholar; Woods, Katherine Pearson to Adams, , 03 18, April 3, 1894Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections). For a biographical sketch of Sherwood, see Koudelka, Janet Brock, “Sherwood, Mary,” in Notable American Women: A Biographical Dictionary, 4 vols., ed. James, Edward T. et al. (Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1971–1980), vol. 3, pp. 283–84.Google Scholar

100. Lawrence, Margaret Woods, Reminiscences of the Life and Work of Edward A. Lawrence, Jr. (New York, 1900), pp. 441–43, 509, 349, 516–17Google Scholar; Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 162Google Scholar; and Requardt, Cynthia H., “Alternative Professions for Goucher Graduates, 1892–1910,” Maryland Historical Magazine 74 (09 1979): 279Google Scholar. For accounts of Baltimore settlement work, see Montgomery, Caroline W., Bibliography of College, Social, University and Church Settlements (New York, 1900), pp. 42–43Google Scholar; Hirschfeld, , Baltimore, pp. 156–57Google Scholar; and Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 162–64.Google Scholar

101. Adams, , Church and Popular Education, pp. 62–63Google Scholar. Adams's interest in Lawrence House is revealed in his financial contributions and correspondence with Lawrence's mother. See Welsh, John A. to Adams, , 10 8, 1897Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Adams, Cash Book, p. 36, Adams Papers; and Lawrence, Margaret W. to Adams, (11 1893)Google Scholar in Lawrence, , Lawrence, pp. 508–9.Google Scholar

102. Adams, , William and Mary, p. 64.Google Scholar

103. Bemis, Edward W., “What England Owes to Protection” (abstract), JHU Circular 1 (05 1882): 205Google Scholar. For other seminar papers on the tariff, see “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 2 (08 1883): 156Google Scholar; and 3 (March 1884): 70.

104. Adams, Herbert B., “Hopeful Words to the Y.M.C.A. Evening Institutes” (unpublished paper, 10 1897), p. 1Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

105. Adams, , Study of History in American Colleges, pp. 95–96.Google Scholar

106. Harter, to Gilman, , 02 16, 1892Google Scholar, in Holt, , Historical Scholarship, pp. 181–12Google Scholar; and Harter, to Adams, , 03 9, 1892Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

107. Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Educational History, Adams Papers (Special Collections). Adams was actually referring here to the 1900 election campaign. There were two theses on the currency question: Woodford, Arthur B., “On the Use of Silver as Money in the United States,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 4 (07 1893): 91–149CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Takaki, Masayashi, The History of Japanese Paper Currency: 1868–1890 (Baltimore, 1903)Google Scholar. The subject was also discussed in the seminar. See “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 1 (07 1881): 149Google Scholar; and 17 (December 1897): 32.

108. See, for example, Sato, Shosuke, History of the Land Question in the United States (Baltimore, 1886), pp. i–ii, 181Google Scholar; Warner, Amos G., Three Phases of Cooperation in the West (Baltimore, 1888), pp. 367–8Google Scholar; and Bentley, Arthur F., The Condition of the Western Farmer as Illustrated by the Economic History of a Nebraska Township (Baltimore, 1893), pp. 86–87.Google Scholar

109. Historical Seminary Records 1 (October 15, 1886): 199.

110. Adams, Herbert B., “National Problems-The Land Question,” Boston Times, 09 5, 1886Google Scholar. The evil of land engrossment was a matter to which Adams seems to have returned again and again. See Adams, Herbert B., Village Communities of Cape Anne and Salem (Baltimore, 1883), pp. 33, 42Google Scholar; and Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Roman History, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

111. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 13.Google Scholar

112. Adams, to Wilson, , 01 6, 1888Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 5, p. 652Google Scholar. The reference is to ten public lectures on “The Problems of Modern Cities” given during the spring semester (“Lectures in Hopkins Hall at 5 P.M.,” JHU Circular 7 [03 1888]: 51).Google Scholar

113. Adams, to Vincent, John M., 04 30, 1892Google Scholar, John Martin Vincent Papers (Huntington Library). On the conversion of the Baltimore press to reform, see Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 17–23, 33–4Google Scholar; and Lambert, , Gorman, pp. 240–42.Google Scholar

114. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 23–24Google Scholar; and Klapp, William H. to Adams, , 01 18, 1894Google Scholar (invitation attached), Adams Papers (Special Collections). Adams's name does not appear in Proceedings of the National Conference for Good City Government Held at Philadelphia - January 25 and 26, 1894 (Philadelphia, 1894).Google Scholar

115. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 25–26, 28–29Google Scholar; and Crooks, James B. to author, 03 16, 1984.Google Scholar

116. “Commemoration Day,” JHU Circular 14 (04 1895): 56Google Scholar; and Fredman, L. E., “Seth Low: Theorist of Municipal Reform,” Journal of American Studies 6, no. 21 (1972): 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For Adams's views on urban universities, see Adams, Herbert B. et al. , “A Symposium - Where Should a College Be Located?” Chautauquan 12 (07 1891): 469–70.Google Scholar

117. Adams, Herbert B., quoted in Baltimore Sun, 02 26, 1895Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 9, p. 231Google Scholar; see also Baltimore American, 02 26, 1895Google Scholar, Wilson Papers, vol. 9, pp. 227–28.Google Scholar

118. “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 14 (02 1895): 52Google Scholar; (April 1895): 68; (June 1895): 83; Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 29Google Scholar; and Baltimore News, 06 8, 1895.Google Scholar

119. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 32–39, 93–94Google Scholar; Lambert, , Gorman, p. 250Google Scholar; and Baltimore News, 10 16, 1895.Google Scholar

120. Maryland: A Guide to the Old Line State - Compiled by the Workers of the Writers' Program of the Works Progress Administration in the State of Maryland (New York, 1940), pp. 197, 212Google Scholar; Lambert, , Gorman, p. 249Google Scholar; Merriam, Lucius to Ross, Edward A., 11 10, 1892Google Scholar, Edward A. Ross Papers (State Historical Society of Wisconsin); Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 39Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., “Relation of Science to Good Government,” Baltimore Sun, 11 11, 1895Google Scholar. Several versions of this address (including Adams's typescript) are extant; citations indicate the version(s) used.

121. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 40–41Google Scholar; and Lambert, , Gorman, p. 251Google Scholar. Gorman lost his Senate seat in 1898 (Lambert, , Gorman, p. 263).Google Scholar

122. Adams, , “Relation” (Sun)Google Scholar; and Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 41, 86.Google Scholar

123. Historical Seminary Records 2 (November 15, 1895): 197.

124. Adams, et al. , “Government of Cities.”Google Scholar

125. Adams, , “Relation” (Sun)Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., [“The Relation of Science to Good Government”]Google Scholar, (typescript, irregular pagination), Adams Papers (Special Collections).

126. See Baltimore Sun, 11 11, 1895Google Scholar; and December 18, 1895.

127. Adams, [“Relation”]Google Scholar, (typescript); Schiesl, Martin J., The Politics of Efficiency: Municipal Administration and Reform in America, 1880–1920 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1977), pp. 6–10, 23Google Scholar; and Keller, , Affairs of State, pp. 527–28Google Scholar. At least three Johns Hopkins Studies preferred a limited franchise in municipal elections: Porter, , Washington, p. 45Google Scholar; Levermore, Charles H., The Republic of New Haven: A History of Municipal Evolution (Baltimore, 1886), pp. 323–24Google Scholar; and Howe, , New Orleans, p. 29.Google Scholar

128. Adams, , “Relation” (Sun)Google Scholar; Adams, [“Relation”]Google Scholar, (typescript); and Schiesl, , Politics of Efficiency, p. 76Google Scholar. In these addresses, Adams drew substantially on Shaw, Albert's Municipal Government in Continental Europe (1895)Google Scholar and Municipal Government in Britain (1895)Google Scholar. See also Graybar, , Shaw, pp. 75–83.Google Scholar

129. Wilson, to Adams, , 01 13, 1896Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 9, p. 380Google Scholar; Adams, , “History, Economics, and Politics,” JHU Report: 1896, pp. 34–35, 41–42Google Scholar. Courses open to the public included Frederick H. Wines on social problems, Davis R. Dewey on unemployment, and Woodrow Wilson on urban government. This procedure was followed in 1896–97 and 1899–1900. See JHU Report: 1897, pp. 58–59Google Scholar; and JHU Report: 1900, p. 74.Google Scholar

130. Baltimore News, 02 26, 1896Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 9, p. 449Google Scholar. Wilson had given public lectures on urban government in the 1887–88 spring semester. See Adams, , “History and Politics,” JHU Report: 1888, p. 73.Google Scholar

131. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 87, 18Google Scholar; and Adams, , “History, Economics, and Politics,” JHU Report: 1896, p. 35Google Scholar. On Wilson's 1896 public lectures, see Bragdon, , Wilson, pp. 195–98Google Scholar; the Baltimore News reports are published in Wilson Papers, vol. 9, 411–12, 437, 449–54, 461–65, 468–73, 477–80, 482–83Google Scholar. On the Baltimore News and reform, see Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 17–23.Google Scholar

132. Baltimore News, 02 28, March 4, 1896Google Scholar, in Wilson Papers, vol. 9, pp. 463, 483–86Google Scholar; Baltimore Sun, 03 4, 1896Google Scholar; and Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 87–88.Google Scholar

133. Marburg, to Adams, , 01 7, 1893Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections); Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 92–93, 131Google Scholar; and Marburg, to Johns Hopkins Trustees, 05 22, 1900, Adams Papers (Special Collections).Google Scholar

134. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 88–89, 94–95Google Scholar; Pumphrey, , “Richmond,” p. 414Google Scholar; and Ballagh, James C., “Baltimore and Municipal Reform” (abstract), JHU Circular 18 (03 1899): 40Google Scholar. The sections on education and charities were Gilman's work.

135. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, p. 96.Google Scholar

136. “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 18 (03 1899): 43Google Scholar; and Ballagh, , “Baltimore,” pp. 39–40.Google Scholar

137. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 97–100Google Scholar; and Coll, , “Brackett,” p. 101.Google Scholar

138. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 128–29Google Scholar; and Schiesl, , Politics of Efficiency, p. 59Google Scholar. “I appreciate your wisdom in turning the attention of your students to the higher institutional life of cities rather than toward the more thoroughly exploited questions of municipal administration” (Spiers, Frederic W. to Adams, , 11 11, 1897Google Scholar, Adams Papers [Special Collections]).

139. Schiesl, , Politics of Efficiency, p. 83.Google Scholar

140. Olson, Sherry H., Baltimore: The Building of an American City (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980), p. 235.Google Scholar

141. Adams, Lecture Notes: Greek Politics. These notes have probably been misfiled.

142. Adams, , “Address to Old Town Merchants,” p. 12Google Scholar; Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 165, 182, 171–72, 132–36, 183Google Scholar; Adams, , “Relation” (Sun)Google Scholar; and Adams, Herbert B., “Free Municipal Baths” (unpublished manuscript, 1899)Google Scholar, Adams Papers (Special Collections).

143. [Adams, Herbert B.], “Why Not Be Generous?” Baltimore Sun, 01 9, 1893Google Scholar. Adams held strong opinions on building construction and building codes. See Adams, to Shaw, , 12 11, 1889Google Scholar, Shaw Papers; and Herbert B. Adams, Lecture Notes: Jewish History, Adams Papers (Special Collections). On the “city beautiful,” see Peterson, Jon A., “The City Beautiful Movement: Forgotten Origins and Lost Meanings,” Journal of Urban History 2 (08 1976): 415–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

144. Crooks, , Politics and Progress, pp. 130–31Google Scholar; and Marburg, Theodore, The Municipal Art Society of Baltimore: Its Activities, Aims, and Hopes (Baltimore, 1902)Google Scholar. On the origin and scope of municipal- art societies, see Peterson, , “City Beautiful Movement,” pp. 416–20.Google Scholar

145. Adams, , Cash Book, p. 3Google Scholar; and Adams, , “Educational Extension,” pp. 339, 344.Google Scholar

146. Boyer, Paul S., Urban Masses and Moral Order in America, 1820–1920 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978), p. 236.Google Scholar

147. Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” p. 32Google Scholar. These remarks are an expansion of his more brief seminar comments. See Historical Seminary Records 1 (May 6, 1887): 365.

148. Adams, Herbert B., “City Parks” (unpublished manuscript, ca. 1899), Adams Papers (Special Collections).Google Scholar

149. Adams, Herbert B., “Free Music” (unpublished manuscript, ca. 1899), Adams Papers (Special Collections)Google Scholar. See also Adams, , “Literature of Charities,” p. 32Google Scholar; and Adams, , “Educational Extension,” p. 353.Google Scholar

150. Adams, , Church and Popular Education, pp. 76–78Google Scholar. A shorter version of this paper was given to the seminar in April, 1899. See “Proceedings of the Societies,” JHU Circular 19 (06 1899): 62Google Scholar. On the relation of mugwumpism to progressivism, see McFarland, , Mugwumps, pp. 125–48.Google Scholar

151. Adams, , “Educational Extension,” pp. 337–79, 333–34.Google Scholar

152. Hammack, , “Elite Perceptions,” pp. 365, 386Google Scholar; McFarland, , Mugwumps, pp. 173–74Google Scholar; Hall, David D., “The Victorian Connection,” in Victorian America, ed. Howe, Daniel Walker (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1976), pp. 82, 94Google Scholar; Keller, , Affairs of State, pp. 550–52Google Scholar; and Schiesl, , Politics of Efficiency, pp. 12, 23–24.Google Scholar

153. Adams, to Shaw, , 04 7, 1886Google Scholar, Shaw Papers; Adams, Lecture Notes: Roman History.

154. Ross, Edward A., Seventy Years of It: An Autobiography (New York and London: D. Appleton-Century Co., 1936), p. 42Google Scholar; and Adams, to Adams, Henry C., 08 23, 1884Google Scholar, Henry Carter Adams Papers (Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan).

155. The view of the mugwumps as a patrician class displaced by a status revolution was first advanced in Hofstadter, Richard, The Age of Reform: From Bryan to F.D.R. (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1959), pp. 137–43Google Scholar; It is also found in Hoogenboom, , Outlawing the Spoils, pp. viii–ixGoogle Scholar; Sproat, John G., “The Best Men”: Liberal Reformers in the Gilded Age (New York: Oxford University Press, 1968), pp. vii, 273–81Google Scholar; Tomsich, John, A Genteel Endeavor: American Culture and Politics in the Gilded Age (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1971), pp. 76–78, 82–83, 87, 92, 111–12, 188Google Scholar; and Dobson, John M., Politics in the Gilded Age: A New Perspective on Reform (New York: Praeger, 1972), p. 76Google Scholar. For a historiographical overview, see Blodgett, Geoffrey, “The Mugwump Reputation, 1870 to the Present,” Journal of American History 66 (03 1980): 867–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

156. Robert Wiebe's perspective sheds more light on Adams's motivation than does Hofstadter's: “Moving near the mainstream of urban-industrial development, they [‘new professionals’] welcomed i t.… At the minimum it provided outlets never before available for their talents. Usually it offered them respectable and profitable positions as well.… Outgoing and enthusiastic, they were self-conscious pioneers” (Wiebe, , Search for Order, p. 112).Google Scholar

157. Sproat, , “The Best Men”, p. 272.Google Scholar