Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T12:20:33.908Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Dialogues with the Self: New Thoughts on Marsden Hartley's Self-Portraits

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 July 2009

Janice Coco
Get access

Extract

Scholars have long acknowledged the crucial role biography plays in Marsden Hartley's oeuvre, as many have used his autobiography Somehow a Past and his homosexuality to interpret his recurring motifs. As a recognized writer and painter, he figured prominently in American modernism and was among the first to explore abstraction as his prime expression. Heavily influenced by European models, he forged a mature style drawn from German expressionism and his affinity for the mystic transcendentalism of writers such as Ralph Waldo Emerson, William James, and Walt Whitman. A lifelong transient, he stood apart from those in the Alfred Stieglitz circle (Figure 1), spending more time outside the United States than in, returning at the end of his life to become “the painter of Maine.” General consensus allows that Hartley's early life influenced his images directly; but, more specifically, art historian Bruce Robertson suggests that Hartley turned to self-portraiture in his last years to work through childhood issues of loss and abandonment. Following suit, this essay considers these tender issues further with a reading of four late paintings, of which two are not yet recognized as self-portraits.

The paintings themselves are treated as sites to explore and define the self, in the words of the psychoanalyst D. W. Winnicott, as a “potential space” in which the artist reengages with and attempts to resolve past issues. More specifically, Winnicott describes a psychological transition, a buffer zone between mind and reality, used to cope with maturational issues. In this metaphorical space, one creates symbols and forms object relationships, meaning, a personal language with which to negotiate the real world and one's place in it. All cultural production, Winnicott argues, results from this interim process, which acts as a defensive filter to mitigate harsh truths — in Hartley's case, the loss of both parents and feelings of rejection. From this perspective, I focus narrowly on the symbolic arrangement by which identity issues merge with metaphysics, sex, and death. Although much has been written on these themes, I interpret the paintings' usefulness to Hartley, the ways that they functioned as tools, moving him toward personal integration. In dealing with issues of loss and mourning, I necessarily reflect on dark subject matter; even so, this study is not meant to represent the whole of Hartley's character. A complex person, he was not in a constant state of turmoil and, as Jonathan Weinberg, Donna Cassidy, and many others have demonstrated, Hartley was driven by much more than psychological angst. However, the lens of psychoanalysis (in this case, psychobiography and object relations) provides an additional way to interpret these late images.

Type
Research Article
Information
Prospects , Volume 30 , October 2005 , pp. 623 - 649
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

I thank Sue Taylor and Hugh Caffey for their careful reading and comments.

1. Robertson, Bruce, “Marsden Hartley and Self-Portraiture,” in Marsden Hartley, exhibition catalog, ed. Kornhauser, Elizabeth Mankin (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003), 156–57Google Scholar. See also Ryan, Susan Elizabeth, introduction (1995) to Marsden Hartley, Somehow a Past: The Autobiography of Marsden Hartley, ed. Ryan, S. E. (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1997), 28–32Google Scholar.

2. Another important self-portrait, Young Seadog With Friend Billy (1942), not treated in this essay, is discussed in Robertson, , “Self-Portraiture,” 156–57, 162Google Scholar.

3. Winnicott, Donald W. (1896–1971) represents the British independent tradition of object relations theory (Playing and Reality [London: Tavistock, 1971], 41, 100–103)Google Scholar.

4. Sustained Comedy has been interpreted extensively by art historians who have come to a consensus as to the meaning of Hartley's symbols. Among these scholars are Robertson, , “Self-Portraiture,” 153–64Google Scholar; Weinberg, Jonathan, Speaking for Vice: Homosexuality in the Art of Charles Demuth, Marsden Hartley, and the First American Avant-Garde (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993), 185–90Google Scholar; Ryan, , introduction, 28–32Google Scholar; and Cassidy, Donna M., Marsden Hartley: Race, Region, and Nation (Hanover, N.H.: University Press of New England, 2005), 6, 8Google Scholar.

5. Ludington, Townsend, Marsden Hartley: The Biography of an American Artist (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1992), 32Google Scholar.

6. For example, Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 158Google Scholar. I draw on Robertson, , “Self-Portraiture”Google Scholar; Weinberg, , Speaking for ViceGoogle Scholar; Ryan, , introductionGoogle Scholar; and Cassidy, , Marsden HartleyGoogle Scholar, for my interpretation thus far.

7. Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 190Google Scholar.

8. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the term “coming out” was used in this context throughout the 1930s and 1940s (O.E.D., 2nd ed. [1989], s.v. “coming”Google Scholar).

9. Craig, David (1847), quoted in Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. “Adam's apple.”Google Scholar

10. Kandinsky, Wassily, Concerning the Spiritual in Art (1914), trans. Sadler, M. T. H. (New York: Dover, 1977), 6–18Google Scholar.

11. Robertson, “Self-Portraiture,” 164 n. 8Google Scholar.

12. Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 33Google Scholar. Weinberg, discusses this passage as well (Speaking for Vice, 124–25)Google Scholar.

13. Phyllis Greenacre notes that a creative person sometimes assumes an “impostured character so far surpassing in interest … his ordinary ‘other self’ that one is tempted to say that he is his own work of art.” See Greenacre, , “The Relation of the Impostor to the Artist” (1958), in Emotional Growth (New York: International Universities Press, 1971), 2:533Google Scholar.

14. Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. “Gem, n.,” s.v. “gem, v.”

15. de la Mare, Walter John, “The Moth,” in Flora: A Book of Drawings, by Pamela Bianco and Walter de la Mare (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1919)Google Scholar.

16. Kreymborg, Arthur, Troubadour (New York: Sagamore, 1957), 84–85Google Scholar.

17. Susan Elizabeth Ryan rightly interprets this picture of “ritual blinding” as linked to Hartley's mourning the deaths of Alty and Donny Mason (introduction, 28, 32).

18. Hartley quoted in Cassidy, , Marsden Hartley, 6Google Scholar.

19. Ryan, , introduction, 32Google Scholar.

20. Bob, Petr, “Subliminal Processes, Dissociation and the ‘I’,” Journal of Analytical Psychology 48 (2003): 309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

21. Ibid., 310. See also Janet, Pierre, L'Automatisme Psychologique (Paris: Félix Alcon, 1890)Google Scholar. See also Havens, L. L., “Pierre Janet,” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 143 (1967): 383–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22. Bob, “Subliminal Processes,” 309–10Google Scholar. For Hilgard's theory, see Hilgard, Ernest R., Divided Consciousness: Multiple Control in Human Thought and Action (New York: John Wiley, 1986)Google Scholar.

23. Hartley, quoted in Ryan, , introduction, 7Google Scholar.

24. Ibid.

25. Weinberg, Speaking for Vice, 188Google Scholar.

26. Hartley, , Somehow, 48Google Scholar.

27. Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 16Google Scholar.

28. Ibid.

29. Quoted in ibid., 16–17.

30. Hartley, , Somehow, 48Google Scholar.

31. Ryan notes, “His mother is barely mentioned in the autobiographical poem, ‘The Red Plush Family Album,’ published in 1940” (introduction, 36).

32. Whether Hartley refers to Garfield's assassination or to his inauguration is not clear (Ryan, , introduction, 34, 36Google Scholar).

33. Ibid., 36.

34. According to Winnicott, a “transitional object” is the child's first “not-me” possession. At some point, he or she becomes attached to a comforting object — a blanket, a doll, a pillow — that, through fantasy, is instilled with the child's own illusory sense of mother. In her absence, the object shores up the child's sense of wholeness, an integrity that is reinforced by mother's return (see Deri, Susan, “Vicissitudes of Symbolization and Creativity,” in Between Reality and Fantasy: Transitional Objects and Phenomena, ed. Grolnick, Simon A. and Barkin, Leonard [New York: Jason Aronson, 1978], 46–47, 50–55)Google Scholar.

35. Hartley, , Somehow, 48Google Scholar.

36. Quoted in Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 17Google Scholar.

37. Ibid., 17–18.

38. Haskell, Barbara, Marsden Hartley, exhibition catalog, Whitney Museum of American Art (New York: New York University Press, 1980), 10Google Scholar.

39. Freud, Sigmund, “Totem and Taboo” (1913), trans. Strachey, James (New York: W. W. Norton, 1950), 156–57Google Scholar.

40. Hartley, Marsden, “This Piece of Eucharist,” in Selected Poems: Marsden Hartley, ed. Wells, Henry W. (New York: Viking, 1945), 132Google Scholar.

41. Voorhies, James Timothy, ed., My Dear Stieglitz: Letters of Marsden Hartley and Alfred Stieglitz 1912–1915 (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2002)Google Scholar. Ronald Paulson identifies the young German officer Karl von Freyburg as Hartley's paternal substitute. See “Marsden Hartley's Search for the Father(land),” in Marsden Hartley and Nova Scotia, exhibition catalog, ed. Ferguson, Gerald (Halifax: Press of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, 1987), 21Google Scholar.

42. Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 246–47Google Scholar.

43. Emphasis mine.

44. Freud, Sigmund, “Mourning and Melancholia” (1917), in The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, trans. Strachey, James (London: Hogarth and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis, 1986), 14:245–53Google Scholar.

45. Scott, Gail R., “Cleophas and His Own: The Making of a Narrative,” in Ferguson, , Marsden Hartley and Nova Scotia, 58–59Google Scholar.

46. Ryan, also says that Hartley seeks a reconciliation of inner and outer self (introduction, 9)Google Scholar.

47. Quoted in ibid., 32.

48. Quoted in Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 240 (emphasis mine)Google Scholar.

49. Quoted in Robertson, Bruce, Marsden Hartley (New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1995), 103Google Scholar.

50. Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 240–41Google Scholar.

51. Quoted in ibid., 242.

52. Ibid., 244.

53. Ibid., 257–66.

54. Elkins, James, The Object Stares Back (New York: Harcourt Brace, 1996), 86Google Scholar.

55. Elkin's theoretical construction is compatible with Hartley's mystic leanings (ibid.).

56. Writing about art in a “Letter Never Sent,” Hartley mentions “the conflict between fact and the imagination, of intellect and intuition” (quoted in Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 248Google Scholar).

57. Robertson, “Self-Portraiture,” 158Google Scholar.

58. “Marsden Hartley's Journal Entries, Nova Scotia, 1936,” in Ferguson, , Marsden Hartley and Nova Scotia, 75Google Scholar.

59. Hartley's poem “He Too Wore a Butterfly” describes Sustained Comedy: “and down his midrib the image of Christ, the feet / and the nails, touching his navel” (Wells, , Selected Poems, 95Google Scholar).

60. Kuspit, Donald, “The Modern Fetish,” in Signs of Psyche in Modern and Postmodern Art (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 151Google Scholar.

61. Greenacre, Phyllis, “The Fetish and the Transitional Object,” in The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child (New York: International Universities Press, 1969), 24:150Google Scholar.

62. Ibid., 160–62.

63. Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 121Google Scholar.

64. Weber, Bruce, The Heart of the Matter: The Still Lifes of Marsden Hartley, exhibition catalog (New York: Berry-Hill Galleries, 2003), 73Google Scholar.

65. Scott, Gale R., Marsden Hartley (New York: Abbeville, 1988), 144Google Scholar.

66. Hartley's letter to W. G. Constable is in the curatorial files of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston (see Esielonis, Karyn, Still-life Painting in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston [Boston: Museum, 1994], 128Google Scholar).

67. Bent, Arthur Cleveland, Life Histories of North American Wild Fowl (1923; rept. New York: Dover, 1951), 1:56Google Scholar.

68. Esielonis, , Still-life Painting, 128Google Scholar.

69. Ratcliff, Carter, John Singer Sargent (New York: Abbeville, 1982), 87Google Scholar.

70. Ralph Curtis, quoted in ibid., 84.

71. William Sharpe of the Art Journal, quoted in ibid., 91.

72. Houssaye, Henri, “Le Salon de 1884,” Revue des deux mondes 63 (06 1, 1884): 589Google Scholar.

73. Ratcliff, , John Singer Sargent, 91Google Scholar.

74. Hartley, , Somehow, 183Google Scholar.

75. Ratcliffe, , John Singer Sargent, 91Google Scholar.

76. My thanks to Rob Fergus, Science Coordinator at the National Audubon Science Office, for identifying the Eider's markings and pointing out the color discrepancies (personal correspondence, June 13, 2005).

77. Ludington, , Marsden Hartley, 268Google Scholar.

78. Kim Mawhinney of the Canadian Wildlife Service, in her study of Common Eiders in Maine, notes that “the body condition of ducks is a determining factor in parental care and that females in poor condition more readily abandon their young…;. ‘Aunties’ are females without young which assist brood-caring females in defending a brood. Females that were in good condition and hatched and lost their own ducklings became aunties” (“The Effect of Body Condition on Subsequent Creche Attendance in Common Eiders” [Canada: University of New Brunswick, 1999], http://www.seaducks.org/docs/common_eider.htm [accessed July 7, 2005]). See also Bent, , Life Histories, 2:94–107Google Scholar.

79. Hartley, Marsden, “Finding the Bones,” in Wells, , Selected Poems, 72Google Scholar.

80. Rowland, Beryl, Birds with Human Souls (Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1978), 10Google Scholar.

81. Although Bent lamented the hunters'; “slaughter” and overall disregarded for this valuable bird, he was relieved that the Audubon Society intervened to remedy the situation (Life Histories, 2:94–95Google Scholar).

82. H. Gary Gillespie, quoted in Weber, , Heart of the Matter, 74Google Scholar.

83. Haskell, , Marsden Hartley, 111Google Scholar.

84. Paulson, , “Marsden Hartley's Search,” 20–21Google Scholar.

85. Griffey, Randall R., “Encoding the Homoerotic: Marsden Hartley's Late Figure Paintings,” in Kornhauser, , Marsden Hartley, 209Google Scholar.

86. Chauncey, George, Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, 1890–1940 (New York: Basic, 1994), 333–39Google Scholar. For further discussion of stereotyping and regulation of homosexuality in the United States at this time, see Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 1–14Google Scholar.

87. Both quoted in Griffey, , “Encoding the Homoerotic,” 210–11Google Scholar.

88. Ibid., 212–17.

89. Ibid., 214.

90. Cassidy, , Marsden Hartley, 266–74Google Scholar.

91. Ibid., 274.

92. Griffey, , “Encoding the Homoerotic,” 207Google Scholar.

93. Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 190–92Google Scholar.

94. See Gill, M. M., “The Primary Process,” Psychological Issues 5 (1967): 259–98Google ScholarPubMed. See also Graves, Pirkko M. L., “Developmental Aspects of the Primary Process,” Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic 55 (1991): 505–13Google ScholarPubMed.

95. The merging of Christ with his fishermen and lumberjacks in images, such as Christ Held by Half-Naked Men (1940–41) and related drawings, has been discussed by various art historians, including Weinberg, , Speaking for Vice, 180–85Google Scholar; and Paulson, , “Marsden Hartley's Search,” 22Google Scholar.

96. Bob, , “Subliminal Processes,” 312–13Google Scholar.

97. Freud, Sigmund, “On Dreams” (1901), in The Freud Reader, ed. Gay, Peter (New York: W. W. Norton), 154Google Scholar.

98. I thank Sue Taylor for this reference. See Rank, Otto, The Myth of the Birth of the Hero and Other Writings, ed. Freund, Philip (New York: Vintage, 1959), 75Google Scholar.

99. Paulson, , “Marsden Hartley's Search,” 19Google Scholar.

100. Sigmund, Freud, “Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality” (1905), SE 7 (1986): 222Google Scholar.