Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T11:56:41.874Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

On the Curious Date of the Rylstone Log-Coffin Burial

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 June 2016

Nigel D. Melton ,
Janet Montgomery ,
Benjamin W. Roberts ,
Gordon Cook  and
Susanna Harris
Nigel D. Melton
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
Janet Montgomery
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
Benjamin W. Roberts
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
Gordon Cook
Affiliation:
Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre, Rankine Avenue, East Kilbride, G75 0QF, UK Email: [email protected]
Susanna Harris
Affiliation:
Archaeology, School of Humanities, Gregory Building, Lilybank Gardens, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, G12 8QQ, UK Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Radiocarbon dates have been obtained from a log-coffin burial excavated in 1864 by Canon William Greenwell from a ditched round barrow at Scale House, near Rylstone, North Yorkshire. The oak tree-trunk coffin had contained an extended body wrapped in a wool textile. The body had entirely decayed and there were no other extant grave goods. In the absence of other grave goods, Greenwell attributed the burial to the Bronze Age because it lay under a ditched round barrow and had similarities with log-coffin burials from Britain and Denmark. This attribution has not been questioned since 1864 despite a number of early medieval log-coffin burials subsequently being found in northern Britain. Crucially, the example excavated near Quernmore, Lancashire in 1973, was published as Bronze Age but subsequently radiocarbon dated to ad 430–970. The Rylstone coffin and textile were radiocarbon dated to confirm that the burial was Early Bronze Age and not an early medieval coffin inserted into an earlier funerary monument. Unexpectedly, the dates were neither Early Bronze Age nor early medieval but c. 800 bc, the cusp of the Bronze Age–Iron Age transition in Britain. The burial at Rylstone is, therefore, one of only two sites in Britain, and is unparalleled elsewhere in north-western Europe at a time when disposal of the dead was primarily through dispersed cremated or unburnt disarticulated remains.

Résumé

De la curieuse datation de l’inhumation à cercueil de bois de Rylstone, de Nigel D. Melton, Janet Montgomery, Benjamin W. Roberts, Gordon Cook, et Susanna Harris

Des datations au C14 ont été obtenues d’une inhumation à cercueil de bois excavée par le Chanoine William Greenwell d’un tertre rond à fossé à Scale House, près de Rylstone, North Yorkshire. Le cercueil creusé dans un tronc de chêne avait recelé un cadavre en position allongée enveloppé dans un tissu de laine. Le corps était complètement décomposé et il ne subsistait pas d’autre mobilier funéraire. En l’absence d’autre mobilier funéraire, Greenwell a attribué l’inhumation à l’âge du bronze parce qu’elle se trouvait sous un tertre rond à fossé et avait des similarités avec des inhumations dans des cercueils de bois de Grande-Bretagne et du Danemark. Depuis 1864, cette attribution de date n’a jamais été remise en question malgré le fait qu’on a par la suite découvert un certain nombre d’inhumations du début du moyen-âge dans des cercueils de bois dans le nord de la Grande-Bretagne. Point crucial, un exemple provenant de Quernmore, Lancashire fut publié comme étant de l’âge du bronze mais une datation au C14 ultérieure donna une date de 430–970 ap.J.-C..Le cercueil et le tissu de Rylstone furent datés au C14 afin de confirmer que l’inhumation datait bien de l’âge du bronze ancien et n’était pas un cercueil du début du moyen âge inséré dans un monument funéraire plus ancien. Contre toute attente, les dates tournent autour d’environ 800 av. J.-C., à la pointe de la transition âge du bronze-âge du fer en Grande-Bretagne. L’inhumation de Rhylstone n’a donc de parallèle ni en Grande-Bretagne, ni en Europe du nord-ouest à un moment où la disposition des morts se faisait essentiellement par la dispersion de restes désarticulés, incinérés ou non.

Zussamenfassung

Zum sonderbaren Datum der Baumsarg-Bestattung von Rylstone, von Nigel D. Melton, Janet Montgomery, Benjamin W. Roberts, Gordon Cook, und Susanna Harris

Radiokarbondaten wurden von einer Baumsarg-Bestattung genommen, die im Jahr 1864 von Canon William Greenwell in einem Rundhügel mit umgebendem Graben in Scale House bei Rylstone, North Yorkshire, ausgegraben wurde. Der aus einem Eichenstamm gefertigte Sarg hatte einen ausgestreckten Körper enthalten, der in einen Wollstoff eingewickelt worden war. Der Körper war nahezu vollständig verfallen und es gab keine weiteren erhaltenen Grabbeigaben. Mangels anderer Grabbeigaben wies Greenwell die Bestattung der Bronzezeit zu, da sie unter einem Rundhügel mit Graben lag und Ähnlichkeiten mit Baumsarg-Bestattungen aus Großbritannien und Dänemark hatte. Diese zeitliche Zuweisung wurde seit 1864 nicht in Frage gestellt, trotz einer Reihe frühmittelalterlicher Bestattungen in Baumsärgen, die in der Folge im nördlichen Großbritannien gefunden wurden. Äußerst wichtig war ein Exemplar aus Quernmore, Lancashire, das als bronzezeitlich publiziert, aber anschließend nach ad 430–970 C14-datiert wurde. Der Sarg und das Textil von Rylstone wurden ebenfalls radiokarbondatiert, um zu bestätigen, dass die Bestattung in die Frühbronzezeit gehört und kein frühmittelalterlicher Sarg ist, der in ein älteres Grabmonument eingetieft worden war. Unerwarteterweise liegen die Datierungen um ca. 800 bc, also am Scheitelpunkt des Übergangs von der Bronze- zur Eisenzeit. Die Bestattung von Rylstone ist demnach ohne Parallelen in Großbritannien, aber auch in ganz Nordwesteuropa, zu einer Zeit als die Entsorgung der Toten vor allem in Form zerstreuten Leichenbrands oder disartikulierter Knochen geschah.

Resumen

La curiosa datación del enterramiento en ‘ataúd de tronco de madera’ de Rylstone, por Nigel D. Melton, Janet Montgomery, Benjamin W. Roberts, Gordon Cook y Susanna Harris

Se han obtenido dataciones de radiocarbono de un enterramiento en ‘ataúd de tronco de madera’ excavado en 1864 por Canon Willian Greenwell en un túmulo circular con foso en Scale House, cerca de Rylstone, en el norte de Yorshire. El ataúd de tronco de roble contenía un cuerpo envuelto en un tejido lana. El cuerpo se había descompuesto por completo y no existía ningún elemento de ajuar. Debido a la ausencia de elementos de ajuar, Greenwell atribuyó el enterramiento a la Edad del Bronce ya que se encontraba debajo del túmulo con foso y presentaba similitudes con los enterramientos ‘en tronco’ de Bretaña y Dinamarca. Esta atribución cronológica no ha sido cuestionada desde 1864 a pesar de que posteriormente se han hallado varios enterramientos en ataúdes de tronco de época altomedieval en el norte de Bretaña. Significativamente, un ejemplo de Quernmore, Lancashire fue publicado como de la Edad del Bronce, pero posteriormente se dató en 430–970 ad. Tanto el ataúd como el tejido de Rylstone fueron datados, lo que permitió confirmar su cronología del Bronce Antiguo y que no se trataba de un enterramiento medieval introducido en un monumento funerario anterior. Inesperadamente, las dataciones se situaron en torno al 800 bc, el umbral de transición entre la Edad del Bronce y la del Hierro en Bretaña. El enterramiento de Rylstone, por lo tanto, no tiene paralelos en Bretaña ni en otro lugar del noroeste de Europa, en un momento en el que los tratamientos funerarios consisten en cremaciones esparcidas o en restos desarticulados no quemados.

Keywords

Log-coffin burialradiocarbon datesBronze Age–Iron Age traditiontextile
Type
Shorter Contribution
Information
Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society , Volume 82 , December 2016 , pp. 383 - 392
Copyright
© The Prehistoric Society 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Arabaolaza, I., Ballin Smith, B., Clarke, A., Ramsay, S. & Walton Rogers, P. 2013. ARO5: Spinning the yarn: a cist at Keas Cottage, Spinningdale. Glasgow: GUARD Archaeology Google Scholar
Armit, I., Schulting, R., Knüsel, C.J. & Shepherd, I. 2011. Death, decapitation and display? The Bronze and Iron Age human remains from the Sculptor’s Cave, Covesea, north-east Scotland. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 77, 251–278 Google Scholar
Bender Jørgensen, L. 1992. North European Textiles until AD 1000. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press Google Scholar
Bender Jørgensen, L. & Rast-Eicher, A. 2015. Searching for the earliest wools in Europe. In K. Grömer & F. Pritchard (eds), Aspects of the Design, Production and Use of Textiles and Clothing from the Bronze Age to the Early Modern Era, NESAT XII, 67–72. Budapest: Archaeolingua Main Series 33 Google Scholar
Bergerbrant, S. 2007. Bronze Age Identities: costume, conflict and contact in northern Europe 1600–1300 bc . Lindholme: Bricoleur Press Google Scholar
Booth, T.J., Chamberlain, A.T. & Parker Pearson, M. 2015. Mummification in Bronze Age Britain. Antiquity 89, 1155–1173 Google Scholar
Boye, V. 1896. Fund af Egekister fra Bronzealderen i Danmark: et monografisk Bidrag til Belysning af Bronzealderens Kultur. Copenhagen: Høst Google Scholar
Bradley, R., Haselgrove, C., Webley, L. & Vander Linden, M. 2016. The Later Prehistory of Northwest Europe: the evidence of recent fieldwork. Oxford: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Bradley, R. & Gordon, K. 1988. Human skulls from the river Thames, their dating and significance. Antiquity 62, 503–509 Google Scholar
Breuning-Madsen, H. & Holst, M.K. 1995. Genesis of iron pans in Bronze Age mounds in Denmark. Journal of Danish Archaeology 11, 80–86 Google Scholar
Broholm, H.C. & Hald, M. 1940. Costumes of the Bronze Age in Denmark: Contributions to the Archaeology and Textile History of the Bronze Age. Copenhagen: NYT Nordisk/Arnold Busck Google Scholar
Brűck, J. 1995. A place for the dead: the role of human remains in Late Bronze Age Britain. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 61, 245–277 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Collard, M., Darvill, T. & Watts, M. 2006. Ironworking in the Bronze Age? Evidence from a 10th century bc settlement at Hartshill Copse, Upper Bucklebury, West Berkshire. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 72, 367–421 Google Scholar
Cronyn, J.M. 1992. The Elements of Archaeological Conservation. London: Routledge Google Scholar
Crowfoot, E. 1979. Rylston, Yorkshire. Bronze Age. Unpublished report in the British MuseumGoogle Scholar
Davis, J.B. 1865. Notice of the opening of a barrow at Scale House, in the West Riding of Yorkshire; and a comparison of that barrow with certain others in Jutland. Reliquary 6, 1–11 Google Scholar
Dent, J.S. 2010. The Iron Age in East Yorkshire. Oxford: British Archaeological Report 508Google Scholar
Edwards, B.J.N. 1973. Canoe burial near Lancaster. Antiquity 47, 298–301 Google Scholar
Elgee, F. & Elgee, H.W. 1933. The Archaeology of Yorkshire. London: Methuen Google Scholar
Elgee, H.W. & Elgee, F. 1949. An Early Bronze Age burial in a boat-shaped wooden coffin from north-east Yorkshire. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 15, 87–106 Google Scholar
Fenton-Thomas, C. 2010. Where Sky and Yorkshire and Water Meet: The Story of the Melton Landscape from Prehistory to the Present. York: Onsite Archaeology Google Scholar
Gabra-Sanders, T. 1994. Textiles and fibres from the Late Bronze Age hoard from St Andrews, Fife, Scotland. In K. Tidow & G. Jaacks (eds), Textilsymposium Neumünster, 4.–7. 5. 1993 (NESAT V), 34–42. Neumünster: Textilmuseum Neumünster Google Scholar
Giles, M. 2007. Making metal and forging relations: ironworking in the British Iron Age. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 26, 395–413 Google Scholar
Giles, M. 2012. A Forged Glamour: landscape, identity and material culture in the Iron Age. Oxford: Windgather Press Google Scholar
Glob, P.V. 1974. The Mound People: Danish Bronze-Age man preserved. London: Faber & Faber Google Scholar
Gomme, G.L. (ed.) 1886. The Gentleman’s Magazine Library: being a classified collection of the chief contents of the Gentleman’s Magazine from 1731 to 1868. London: Elliot Stock Google Scholar
Greenwell, W. 1865. Notices of the examination of ancient grave-hills in the North Riding of Yorkshire. Archaeological Journal 22, 241–264 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greenwell, W. 1877. British Barrows. Oxford: Clarendon Press Google Scholar
Greenwell, W. 1894. Antiquities of the Bronze Age in the Heathery Burn Cave, County Durham. Archaeologia 54, 87–114 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halkon, P. 2011. Iron landscape and power in Iron Age East Yorkshire. Archaeological Journal 168, 134–165 Google Scholar
Henshall, A.S. 1950. Textiles and weaving appliances in Prehistoric Britain. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 16, 130–162 Google Scholar
Holst, M.K., Breuning-Madsen, H. & Rasmussen, M. 2001. The south Scandinavian barrows with well-preserved oak-log coffins. Antiquity 75, 129–136 Google Scholar
Holst, M.K. & Rasmussen, M. (eds) 2013. Skelhøj and the Bronze Age Barrows of Southern Scandinavia: The Bronze Age Barrow Tradition and the Excavation of Skelhøj. Højbjerg: Jysk Arkæologisk Selskab Google Scholar
Kinnes, I. & Longworth, I. 1985. Catalogue of the Excavated Prehistoric and Romano-British Material in the Greenwell Collection. London: British Museum Press Google Scholar
Lawson, A. 2000. Potterne 1982–85: Animal Husbandry in Later Prehistoric Wiltshire. Salisbury: Wessex Archaeology Report 17Google Scholar
Leach, S. 2005. Heads, shoulders, knees and toes. Human skeletal remains from Raven Scar Cave in the Yorkshire Dales. In S. Zakrzewski & M. Clegg (eds), Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Conference of the British Association for Biological Anthropology and Osteoarchaeology, 59–68. Oxford: British Archaeological Report S1383Google Scholar
McKinley, J.I., Leivers, M., Schuster, J., Marshall, P., Barclay, A.J. & Stoodley, N. 2015. A Mortuary and Ritual Site of the Bronze Age, Iron Age and Anglo-Saxon Period with Evidence for Long-Distance Maritime Mobility. Salisbury: Wessex Archaeology Report 31Google Scholar
McOmish, D. 1996. East Chisenbury: ritual and rubbish at the British Bronze Age–Iron Age transition. Antiquity 70, 68–76 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Manby, T. 1986. The Bronze Age in western Yorkshire. In T. Manby & P. Turnbull (eds), Archaeology in the Pennines, 55–126. Oxford: British Archaeological Report 158Google Scholar
Manby, T., King, A. & Vyner, B.E. 2003. The Neolithic and Bronze Age in Yorkshire: a time of early agriculture. In T. Manby, S. Moorhouse & P. Ottaway (eds), The Archaeology of Yorkshire: an assessment at the beginning of the 21st century, 35–113. Leeds: Yorkshire Archaeological Society Occasional Paper 3 Google Scholar
Mannering, U., Gleba, M. & Bloch Hansen, M. 2012. Denmark. In M. Gleba & U. Mannering (eds), Textiles and Textile Production in Europe from Prehistory to ad 400, 89–118. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
Melton, N., Montgomery, J., Knüsel, C., Batt, C., Needham, S., Parker-Pearson, M., Sheridan, A., Heron, C., Horsley, T., Schmidt, A., Evans, A., Carter, E., Edwards, H., Hargreaves, M., Janaway, R., Lynnerup, N., Northover, P., O’Connor, S., Ogden, A., Taylor, T., Wastling, V. & Wilson, A. 2010. Gristhorpe Man: an Early Bronze Age log-coffin burial scientifically defined. Antiquity 84, 796–815 Google Scholar
Melton, N.D., Montgomery, J. & Knüsel, C.J. (eds) 2013. Gristhorpe Man: a life and death in the Bronze Age. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
Mortimer, J.R. 1905. Forty Years’ Researches in British and Saxon Burial Mounds of East Yorkshire. London: A. Brown & Sons Google Scholar
Mowat, R.J.C. 1996. The Logboats of Scotland. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
Needham, S.P. 2007. 800BC. The great divide. In C. Haselgrove & R. Pope (eds), The Earlier Iron Age in Britain and the Near Continent, 39–63. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M., Chamberlain, A., Craig, O., Marshall, P., Mulville, J., Smith, H., Chenery, C., Collins, M., Cook, G., Craig, G., Evans, J., Hiller, J., Montgomery, J., Schwenninger, J.-L., Taylor, G. & Wess, T. 2005. Evidence for mummification in prehistoric Britain. Antiquity 79, 529–546 Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M., Sheridan, A. & Needham, S. 2013. Bronze Age tree-trunk coffin graves in Britain. In Melton et al. (eds) 2013, 29–66Google Scholar
Pitts, M. 2016. Oldest iron-smelting site found by Tata Plant. British Archaeology 146, 6–7 Google Scholar
Randsborg, K. & Kristensen, K. 2006. Bronze Age Oak-Coffin Graves: archaeology and dendro-dating. Copenhagen: Acta Archaeologica 77. Supplement 7Google Scholar
Roberts, B.W., Boughton, D., Dinwiddy, M., Doshi, N., Fitzpatrick, A., Hook, D., Meeks, N., Woodward, A. & Woodward, P. 2015. Collapsing commodities or lavish offerings? Understanding massive metalwork deposition at Langton Matravers, Dorset during the Bronze Age–Iron Age transition. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 34(4), 365–395 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roth, N.M. 2012. Regional Patterns and the Cultural Implications of Late Bronze Age and Iron Age Burial Practices in Britain. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of SheffieldGoogle Scholar
Savage, R. 2013. Salt End to Aldbrough: the archaeology of a high-voltage underground electricity cable route. East Riding Archaeologist 14, 65–104 Google Scholar
Schulting, R.J. & Bradley, R. 2013. ‘Of human remains and weapons in the neighbourhood of London’: new AMS 14C dates on Thames ‘river skulls’ and their European context. Archaeological Journal 170, 30–77 Google Scholar
Snagge, T.W. 1873. Some account of ancient oaken coffins discovered on the lands adjoining Featherstone Castle, near Haltwhistle, Northumberland. Archaeologia 44, 8–16 Google Scholar
Stead, I.M. 1968. An Iron Age hillfort at Grimthorpe, Yorkshire. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 34, 148–190 Google Scholar
Thomson, A. 2011. What happened to the dead in Late Bronze Age Scotland? Unpublished BA dissertation, Durham UniversityGoogle Scholar
Wallace, T. 1832. Accounts of some ancient wooden coffins discovered not far from Haltwhistle, in the County of Northumberland. Archaeologia Aeliana (1st ser 2), 177–178 Google Scholar
Warden, K., Caswell, E. & Roberts, B. W. forthcoming. Funerary fragments between the rivers: analysing the evidence for the dead in the Tyne–Forth region during the Late Bronze Age (c. 1150–800bc). In R. Crellin, C. Fowler & R. Tipping (eds), Prehistory without Borders: the prehistoric archaeology of the Tyne-Forth region, 150–67. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
White, A.J. 2001. The Quernmore Burial Mystery (pamphlet). Lancaster: Lancaster City and Museums Google Scholar
Whiting, C.E. 1937. Ancient log coffins in Britain. Transactions of the Architectural & Archaeological Society of Durham & Northumberland 8, 80–105 Google Scholar
Williamson, W.C. 1834. Description of the Tumulus, lately opened at Gristhorpe, near Scarborough. Scarborough: C. R. Todd Google Scholar
Wincott Heckett, E. 1998. A Late Bronze Age horsehair ornament from Cromaghs, Armoy in Ireland. In L. Bender Jørgensen & C. Rinalso (eds), Textiles in European Archaeology. Report from the 6th NESAT symposium, 29–37. Göteborg: Göteborg University Google Scholar
Wincott Heckett, E. 2007. Late Bronze Age textiles, hair and fibres remains, and spindle whorls from Killymoon, Co. Tyrone, Northern Ireland. In A. Rast-Eicher & R. Windler (eds), Archäologische Textilfunde: Archaeological Textiles. NESAT IX, 28–34. Ennenda: Archeo Tex Google Scholar
Wincott Heckett, E. 2012. Scotland and Ireland. In M. Gleba & U. Mannering (eds), Textiles and Textile Production in Europe. From Prehistory to ad 400, 428–442. Oxford: Oxbow Books Google Scholar
Wright, T. 1857. On some curious forms of sepulchral interment found in East Yorkshire. Gentleman’s Magazine 3, 114–119 Google Scholar