Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-07T05:21:15.119Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Shades of Springsteen: Politics, Love, Sports, and Masculinity. By John Massaro. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2021. 255 pp. ISBN 978-1-9788-1616-9

Review products

Shades of Springsteen: Politics, Love, Sports, and Masculinity. By John Massaro. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2021. 255 pp. ISBN 978-1-9788-1616-9

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 May 2023

Tim Strangleman*
Affiliation:
University of Kent, UK
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Review
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press

Some of the worst feedback I have ever had as an academic came from a student who left an anonymous comment having completed my Sociology of Work module. In answer to the boilerplate question ‘What did you least like about the course?’, they wrote: ‘The playing of Bruce Springsteen’. And in response to the prompt ‘How could this course be improved?’, they simply suggested: ‘Stop playing Bruce Springsteen’. I was a little crestfallen. The object of the student's complaint was my use of Springsteen's track ‘Youngstown’ during a lecture on deindustrialisation. As I'd explained to my class when I teed it up on my PowerPoint presentation that day, the near 4 minute track beautifully describes the arc of industrialisation, through boom and bust to the loss of industry in the 1970s and 1980s. Although obviously about Youngstown Ohio, the track nonetheless stands for a far wider shared story of the process of industrial ruination and economic decline. Indeed, Youngstown itself transitioned from the booming Steeltown USA in the 1950s to becoming a longstanding poster child for the ravages of deindustrialisation and its half-life. Needless to say, I ignored the student's critical feedback.

This anecdote was front and centre in my mind reading John Massaro's Shades of Springsteen: Politics, Love, Sports, and Masculinity. The book is a wonderful portmanteau collection of the author's writing, thinking and teaching about The Boss. This is a deeply personal book for Massaro. He relates how he became a Springsteen fan having been gifted the album Bruce Springsteen & the E Steet Band Live 1975–1985 while suffering from depression and experiencing a bout of unemployment. Later in his career, Massaro began to teach a course to students on Springsteen and the politics and meaning of his lyrics.

Shades of Springsteen is, then, part account of Springsteen's career and personal life, part reflection on the meaning Springsteen has exerted over popular culture, and part autobiography of Massaro, now a retired academic in his late seventies. Massaro is not alone as an academic in using Springsteen to explore North American society and his own personal life. Why is this? Well, Springsteen acts a bridge in several senses. Firstly, he spans a variety of genres of music – folk, soul, country and most obviously rock ’n’ roll. He also links the 1960s and 1970s through to the current day. Indeed, his drawing on folk icons Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger traces influences back to the 1930s, if not before. In part then, Springsteen is so important because his longevity has allowed him to think with a critical intelligence about the changing world around him – his masculinity, his class position, his politics. As an artist he thinks and sings about the lives of others caught up in the industrial change of the last half-century or so. His poetic sensibility captures the hopes and dreams, the desire of unrequited loves, the losses and reality of working life of those seeking their version of the American Dream. Springsteen, after all, began his career at the end of the long post-war boom which had seen most working class lives transformed by full employment and rising living standards; his first album, Greetings From Asbury Park, N.J. of 1973, was coterminous with the year widely accepted as the end of an era. Springsteen's work reflects the gradual coming to terms with the fact that those ‘Glory Days’ for many were a collective experience of the past, one that new generations only related to through absence and loss. If there is a romanticism in Springsteen's art, it is a nostalgia for industrial work which allowed it participants some measure of dignity and self-respect, a nostalgia not blind to the ill effects of labour on the bodies of individuals and their communities.

One of the striking things in Massaro's narrative is how he uses Springsteen's work to explore his own early life – especially growing up in that long boom era. His account of High School loves emphasises, for this reviewer, just how distinct and long lasting this period of education is for the American psyche. This type of reflection is both endearing and yet distracting as to the scholarly purpose of the book. Conversely, Shades of Springsteen would act as a useful and engaging text for a module or as part of a course on The Boss. The volume is arranged in five sections or chapters – Biography, Politics, Love and Relationships, Masculinity and Sports, and finally a conclusion entitled ‘Loose Ends’. Each of these sections is further divided into much shorter essays – 34 in all – exploring themes through individual albums, songs and lyrics. These sections and chapters allow teachers to discuss a range of contemporary topics while placing these in their historical contexts, reflecting on societal change and continuity across Springsteen's life and career. The most interesting for me were those early ones on class and work, reflecting my own teaching and research interests. The obvious tension in the book, apart from the already mentioned autobiographical interventions, is the difficult balance between breadth and depth. This makes me wonder about an audience for it. I would have liked more on the reception on the part of students learning through the work of Springsteen. How relevant to the lives of those born in the 1990s and after is the life of one born in the immediate post-war period? There are many books on Springsteen, including his own autobiographical reflections. There are countless journal articles where the musician's work and impact are explored. At its most successful, Shades of Springsteen is one man's reflection on his life through the work of a long-lived artist. In turn this tells us much about the USA and its process of self-examination through the six decades after the ‘Glorious Thirty’.