Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T03:56:11.203Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Inaccuracy and Bias in Textbooks Reporting Psychiatric Research: The Case of the Schizophrenia Adoption Studies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Jay Joseph
Jay Joseph*
Affiliation:
California School of Professional Psychology, Alameda, USA
Get access

Abstract

Mental health textbooks sometimes provide inaccurate information, typically supporting common beliefs in the field. Psychiatry and psychology textbooks' discussion of the schizophrenia adoption studies is examined. Particular attention is paid to the earlier studies, which helped pave the way for the current widespread acceptance of the importance of genetic factors influencing psychological trait differences. This article compares the accounts of 30 textbooks to the original studies they reviewed. Generally, problems with these textbooks' accounts include (1) the failure to critically assess the original researchers' methods and conclusions, (2) some textbooks' reliance on secondary sources, (3) the failure to discuss published critiques of the schizophrenia adoption studies, (4) inaccuracy in reporting the original findings, (5) the claim that studies finding nonsignificant results support the genetic position, and (6) a failure to discuss the potentially invalidating environmental confounds in the schizophrenia adoption studies (through the selective placement of adoptees). It is concluded that, in general, these textbooks have served to rubber-stamp mainstream psychiatry's questionable claims about the schizophrenia adoption studies at the expense of a thorough critical analysis.

Type
Paradigms, Textbooks, and Psychiatric Research
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 19 , Issue 1 , March 2000 , pp. 89 - 99
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adelman, G., ed. (1987). Encyclopedia of Neuroscience. Vol. 2. Boston: Birkhäuser.Google Scholar
American Psychiatric Association [APA]. (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th ed.Washington, DC: APA. Referred to as DSM-IV.Google Scholar
Bellack, L., ed. (1979). Disorders of the Schizophrenic Syndrome. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Benjamin, L.S. (1976). “A Reconsideration of the Kety and Associates Study of Genetic Factors in the Transmission of Schizophrenia.” American Journal of Psychiatry 133:1129–33.Google Scholar
Black, D.W. and Andreasen, N.C. (1999). “Schizophrenia, Schizophreniform Disorder, and Delusional (Paranoid) Disorders.” In Hales, R., Yudofsky, S., and Talbott, J. (eds.), The American Psychiatric Press Textbook of Psychiatry. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.Google Scholar
Boyle, M. (1990). Schizophrenia: A Scientific Delusion? New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Breggin, P.R. (1991). Toxic Psychiatry. New York: St. Martin's Press.Google Scholar
Byerley, W. and Coon, H. (1995). “Strategies to Identify Genes in Schizophrenia.” In Oldham, J. and Riba, M. (eds.), Review of Psychiatry, Vol. 14. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.Google Scholar
Carson, R.C. and Sanislow, C.A. III (1993). “The Schizophrenias.” In Sutker, P. and Adams, H. (eds.), Comprehensive Handbook of Psychopathology, 2nd ed.New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Cassou, B., Schiff, M., and Stewart, J. (1980). “Génétique et Schizophrénie: Réévaluation d'un Consensus [Genetics and Schizophrenia: Re-evaluation of a Consensus].” Psychiatrie de I'enfant 23:87–201.Google Scholar
Coleman, J.C., Butcher, J.N., and Carson, R.C. (1984). Abnormal Psychology and Modern Life. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman.Google Scholar
Davidson, G.C. and Neale, J.M. (1990). Abnormal Psychology. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Gelder, M., Gath, D., Mayou, R., and Cowen, P. (1996). Oxford Textbook of Psychiatry. 3rd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Gottesfeld, H. (1979). Abnormal Psychology: A Community Mental Health Perspective. Chicago: Science Research Associates.Google Scholar
Gottesman, I.I. (1991). Schizophrenia Genesis. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company.Google Scholar
Gottesman, I.I. and Shields, J. (1982). Schizophrenia: The Epigenetic Puzzle. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Haier, R.J., Rosenthal, D., and Wender, P.H. (1978). “MMPI Assessment of Psychopathology in the Adopted-Away Offspring of Schizophrenics.” Archives of General Psychiatry 35:71–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hales, R.E., Yudofsky, S.S., and Talbott, J.A., eds. (1999). Textbook of Psychiatry. 3rd ed.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.Google Scholar
Hansen, B. (1996). “Something Rotten in the State of Denmark: Eugenics and the Ascent of the Welfare State.” In Broberg, G. and Roll-Hansen, N. (eds.), Eugenics and the Welfare State: Sterilization Policy in Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and Finland. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press.Google Scholar
van Hasselt, V.B. and Hersen, M. (1994) Advanced Abnormal Psychology New York: Plenum Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heston, L.L. (1966). “Psychiatric Disorders in Foster Home Reared Children of Schizophrenic Mothers.” British Journal of Psychiatry 112:819–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heston, L.L. and Denney, D.D. (1968). “Interactions Between Early Life Experience and Biological Factors in Schizophrenia.” In Rosenthal, D. and Kety, S. (eds.), The Transmission of Schizophrenia. New York: Pergamon Press.Google Scholar
Hill, P., Murray, R., and Thorley, A., eds. (1986). Essentials of Postgraduate Psychiatry. 2nd ed.London: Grune and Stratton.Google Scholar
Ingraham, L.J. and Kety, S.S. (1988). “Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders.” In Tsuang, M. and Simpson, J. (eds.), Handbook of Schizophrenia, Vol. 3: Nosology, Epidemiology and Genetics. New York: Elsevier Science Publishers.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. (1998a). A Critical Analysis of the Genetic Theory of Schizophrenia. Psy.D. diss. California School of Professional Psychology, Alameda.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. (1998b). “The Equal Environment Assumption of the Classical Twin Method: A Critical Analysis.” Journal of Mind and Behavior 19:328–53.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. (1999a). “A Critique of the Finnish Adoptive Family Study of Schizophrenia.” Journal of Mind and Behavior 20:133–54.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. (1999b). “The Genetic Theory of Schizophrenia: A Critical Overview.” Ethical Human Sciences and Services 1:119–45.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. (2000). “Not in Their Genes: A Critical View of the Genetics of Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.” Developmental Review 20:539–567.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Joseph, J. (2001). “Separated Twins and the Genetics of Personality Differences: A Critique.” American Journal of Psychology 114:1–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Joseph, J.(in press-a). “A Critique of the Spectrum Concept as Used in the Danish-American Schizophrenia Adoption Studies.” Ethical Human Sciences and Services.Google Scholar
Joseph, J.(in press-b). “The Danish-American Adoptees' Family Studies of Kety and Associates: Do They Provide Evidence in Support of the Genetic Basis of Schizophrenia?” Genetic, Social, and General Psychology Monographs.Google Scholar
Joseph, J. and Baldwin, S.(in press). “Four Editorial Proposals to Improve Social Sciences Research and Publication.” International Journal of Risk and Safety in Medicine.Google Scholar
Judd, L.L. and Groves, P.M., eds. (1986). Psychiatry: Psychobiological Foundations of Clinical Psychiatry. Vol. 4. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Kaplan, H.I., and Sadock, B.J., eds. (1995). Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry. 6th ed. Vol. 1. Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins.Google Scholar
Kazdin, A.E., Bellack, A.S., and Hersen, M. (1980). New Perspectives in Abnormal Psychology New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Keefe, R.S.E. and Harvey, P.B. (1994). Understanding Schizophrenia. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
Kendler, K.S. and Diehl, S.R. (1995). “Schizophrenia: Genetics.” In Kaplan, H. and Sadock, B. (eds.), Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry, 6th ed. Vol. 1. Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins.Google Scholar
Kendler, K.S. and Gruenberg, A.M. (1984). “An Independent Analysis of the Danish Adoption Study of Schizophrenia.” Archives of General Psychiatry 41:555–64.Google Scholar
Kety, S.S. (1974). “From Rationalization to Reason.” American Journal of Psychiatry 131:957–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kety, S.S. (1983). “Mental Illness in the Biological and Adoptive Relatives of Schizophrenia Adoptees: Findings Relevant to Genetic and Environmental Factors in Etiology.” American Journal of Psychiatry 140:720–27.Google Scholar
Kety, S.S. (1985). “Schizotypal Personality Disorder: An Operational Definition of Bleuler's Latent Schizophrenia?” Schizophrenia Bulletin 11:590–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kety, S.S. and Matthysse, S. (1988). “Genetic and Biological Aspects of Schizophrenia.” In Nicholi, A. (ed.), The New Harvard Guide to Psychiatry. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., and Schulsinger, F. (1968). “The Types and Prevalence of Mental Illness in the Biological and Adoptive Families of Adopted Schizophrenics.” In Rosenthal, D. and Kety, S. (eds.), The Transmission of Schizophrenia. New York: Pergamon Press.Google Scholar
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., and Schulsinger, F. (1976). “Studies Based on a Total Sample of Adopted Individuals and Their Relatives: Why They Were Necessary, What They Demonstrated and Failed to Demonstrate.” Schizophrenia Bulletin 2:413–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., Schulsinger, F., and Jacobsen, B. (1975). “Mental Illness in the Biological and Adoptive Families of Adopted Individuals Who Have Become Schizophrenic: A Preliminary Report Based on Psychiatric Interviews.” In Fieve, R., Rosenthal, D., and Brill, H. (eds.), Genetic Research in Psychiatry. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press.Google Scholar
Kety, S.S., Wender, P.H., Jacobsen, B., Ingraham, L.J., Jansson, L., Faber, B., and Kinney, D.K. (1994). “Mental Illness in the Biological and Adoptive Relatives of Schizophrenic Adoptees: Replication of the Copenhagen Study to the Rest of Denmark.” Archives of General Psychiatry 51:442–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kolb, L. and Brodie, H. K. (1982). Modern Clinical Psychiatry. 10th ed.Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Company.Google Scholar
Kuhn, T.S. (1996). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Third ed.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
LaFollette, M.C. (1992). Stealing Into Print: Fraud, Plagiarism, and Misconduct in Scientific Publishing. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laing, R.D. (1967). The Politics of Experience. New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
Lewontin, R.C., Rose, S., and Kamin, L.J. (1984). Not in Our Genes. New York: Pantheon.Google Scholar
Lidz, T. (1976). “Commentary on a Critical Review of Recent Adoption, Twin, and Family Studies of Schizophrenia: Behavioral Genetics Perspectives.” Schizophrenia Bulletin 2:402–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lidz, T. and Blatt, S. (1983). “Critique of the Danish-American Studies of the Biological and Adoptive Relatives of Adoptees Who Became Schizophrenic.” American Journal of Psychiatry 140:426–35.Google Scholar
Lidz, T., Blatt, S., and Cook, B. (1981). “Critique of the Danish-American Studies of the Adopted-Away Offspring of Schizophrenic Parents.” American Journal of Psychiatry 138:1063–68.Google Scholar
Lowing, P.A., Mirsky, A.F., and Pereira, R. (1983). “The Inheritance of Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders: A Reanalysis of the Danish Adoptee Study Data.” American Journal of Psychiatry 140:1167–71.Google Scholar
Lyons, M.J., Kendler, K.S., Provet, A., and Tsuang, M.T. (1991). “The Genetics of Schizophrenia.” In Tsuang, M., Kendler, K., and Lyons, M. (eds.), Genetic Issues in Psychosocial Epidemiology. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Martin, B. (1981). Abnormal Psychology: Clinical and Scientific Perspectives. 2nd ed.New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.Google Scholar
Mednick, S.A. and Hutchings, B. (1977). “Some Considerations in the Interpretation of the Danish Adoption Studies in Relation to Asocial Behavior.” In Mednick, S. and Christiansen, K. (eds.), Biosocial Bases of Criminal Behavior. New York: Gardner Press.Google Scholar
Murray, R. (1986). “Schizophrenia.” In Hill, P., Murray, R., and Thorley, A. (eds.), Essentials of Postgraduate Psychiatry. 2nd ed.London: Grune and Stratton.Google Scholar
Neale, J.M. and Oltmanns, T.F. (1980). Schizophrenia. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Nicholi, A.M., ed. (1988). The New Harvard Guide to Psychiatry. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Pam, A. (1995). “Biological Psychiatry: Science or Pseudoscience?” In Ross, C. and Pam, A. (eds.), Pseudoscience in Biological Psychiatry: Blaming the Body. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Pastore, N. (1949). The Nature-Nurture Controversy New York: King's Crown Press.Google Scholar
Paul, D.B. (1985). “Textbook Treatments of the Genetics of Intelligence.” Quarterly Review of Biology 60:317–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Paul, D.B. (1998). The Politics of Heredity: Essays on Eugenics, Biomedicine, and the Nature-Nurture Debate. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
van Praag, H.M., Lader, M.H., Rafaelsen, O.J., and Sachar, E.J. (1980). Handbook of Biological Psychiatry (Part III). New York: Marcel Dekker.Google Scholar
Price, R.H. and Lynn, S.J. (1986). Abnormal Psychology 2nd ed.Chicago: The Dorsey Press.Google Scholar
Plomin, R., DeFries, J.C., and McClearn, G.E. (1990). Behavioral Genetics: A Primer. 2nd ed.New York: W. H. Freeman.Google Scholar
Rieder, R.O. (1979). “Children at Risk.” In Bellack, L. (ed.), Disorders of the Schizophrenic Syndrome. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Rose, R.J. (1980). “Genetic Factors.” In Kazdin, A., Bellack, A., and Hersen, M. (eds.), New Perspectives in Abnormal Psychology. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D. (1970). Genetic Theory and Abnormal Behavior. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D. (1971). Genetics of Psychopathology. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D. (1975). “Discussion: The Concept of Schizophrenic Disorders.” In Fieve, R., Rosenthal, D., and Brill, H. (eds.), Genetic Research in Psychiatry. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D. (1980). “Genetic Aspects of Schizophrenia.” In van Praag, H., Lader, M., Rafaelsen, O., and Sachar, E. (eds.), Handbook of Biological Psychiatry (Part III). New York: Marcel Dekker.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., Kety, S.S., Schulsinger, F., Welner, J., and Østergaard, L. (1968). “Schizophrenics' Offspring Reared in Adoptive Homes.” In Rosenthal, D. and Kety, S. (eds.), The Transmission of Schizophrenia. New York: Pergamon Press.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., Kety, S.S., Welner, J., and Schulsinger, F. (1971). “The Adopted-Away Offspring of Schizophrenics.” American Journal of Psychiatry 128:307–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rowe, D.C. and Jacobson, K.C. (1999). “In the Mainstream.” In Carson, R. and Rothstein, M., (eds.), Behavioral Genetics: The Clash of Culture and Biology. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Sarason, I.G. and Sarason, B.R. (1984). Abnormal Psychology: The Problem of Maladaptive Behavior. 4th ed.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
Savan, B. (1988). Science Under Siege: The Myth of Objectivity in Scientific Research. Montreal: CBC Enterprises.Google Scholar
Schuckit, M.A. (1986). “Trait (and State) Markers of a Predisposition to Psychopathology.” In Judd, L. and Groves, P. (eds.), Psychiatry: Psychobiological Foundations of Clinical Psychiatry, Vol. 4. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Schulz, S.C. (1991). “Genetics of Schizophrenia: A Status Report.” In Tasman, A. and Goldfinger, S. (eds.), Annual Review of Psychiatry, Vol. 10. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.Google Scholar
Sutker, P.B. and Adams, H.E., eds. (1993). Comprehensive Textbook of Psychopathology. 2nd ed.New York: Plenum Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tasman, A., Kay, J., and Lieberman, J.A., eds. (1997). Psychiatry. Vol. 2. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.Google Scholar
Tienari, P., Sorri, A., Lahti, I., Naarala, M., Wahlberg, K., Moring, J., Pohjola, J., and Wynne, L. C. (1987). “Genetic and Psychosocial Factors in Schizophrenia: The Finnish Adoptive Family Study.” Schizophrenia Bulletin 13:477–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tienari, P., Wynne, L. C., Moring, J., Lahti, I., Naarala, M., Sorri, A., Wahlberg, K., Saarento, O., Seitamaa, M., Kaleva, M., and Läsky, K. (1994). “The Finnish Adoptive Family Study of Schizophrenia.” British Journal of Psychiatry 164 (supplement 23):20–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trimble, M. R. (1988). Biological Psychiatry. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Wender, P.H., Rosenthal, D., Kety, S.S., Schulsinger, F., and Welner, J. (1974). “Crossfostering: A Research Strategy for Clarifying the Role of Genetic and Experiential Factors in the Etiology of Schizophrenia.” Archives of General Psychiatry 30:121–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar