Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-lnqnp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T20:18:44.293Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Thriving or Dividing? The Women's Movement and the Independence Referenda in Scotland and Catalonia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 June 2018

Alba Alonso
Alba Alonso*
Affiliation:
University of Santiago de Compostela
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Territorial debates have recently shaken the political systems in Scotland and Catalonia, leading to referenda on independence. This article engages with questions concerning whether this extraordinary process has affected the women's movement and why. Specifically, feminist scholars have often expressed concern regarding how strong territorial identities and nationalist projects might prove detrimental to the movement's unity and success. Here, I look for indications of engagement and revival within the frames of the Scottish and Catalan referendum campaigns. A comparative approach revealed the mobilizing potential of these contexts when certain conditions were present. While the women's movement in Scotland has thrived in the last couple of years, territorial debates in Catalonia have not provided fertile ground for feminist campaigning and have shown divisive potential. The specific dynamics of the women's movement in each setting and the presence of political and discursive opportunity structures account for the different outcomes.

Type
Research Article
Information
Politics & Gender , Volume 14 , Issue 3 , September 2018 , pp. 460 - 482
Copyright
Copyright © The Women and Politics Research Section of the American Political Science Association 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

I wish to thank Tània Verge, Fiona Mackay, and Karen Celis for their support; the anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments; and all the people who kindly agreed to be interviewed for this research.

References

REFERENCES

Banaszak, Lee Ann, Beckwith, Karen, and Rucht, Dieter, eds. 2003. Women's Movements Facing the Reconfigured State. Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Beckwith, Karen. 2007. “Mapping Strategic Engagements: Women's Movement and the State.” International Feminist Journal of Politics 9 (3): 312–38.Google Scholar
Bell, Christine, and Mackay, Fiona. 2013. “Why Should Women Care about Constitutional Debates? And Why Aren't Their Voices Being Heard?” Gender Politics at Edinburgh (blog), February 20. https://genderpoliticsatedinburgh.wordpress.com/2013/02/20/why-should-women-care-about-constitutional-debates-and-why-arent-their-voices-being-heard/ (accessed May 3, 2018).Google Scholar
Boyd, Cat, and Morrison, Jenny. 2014. Scottish Independence: A Feminist Response. Edinburgh: Word Power.Google Scholar
Breitenbach, Esther, and Mackay, Fiona, eds. 2001. Women and Contemporary Scottish Politics: An Anthology. Edinburgh: Polygon.Google Scholar
Brown, Alice. 2001. “Deepening Democracy: Women and the Scottish Parliament.” In Women and Contemporary Scottish Politics: An Anthology, eds. Breitenbach, Esther and Mackay, Fiona. Edinburgh: Polygon, 197–212.Google Scholar
Brown, Alice, Donaghy, Tahyna Barnett, Mackay, Fiona, and Meehan, Elizabeth. 2002. “Women and Constitutional Change in Scotland and Northern Ireland.” Parliamentary Affairs 55 (1): 71–84.Google Scholar
Bustelo, María, and Ortbals, Candice D.. 2007. “The Evolution of Spanish State Feminism: a Fragmented Landscape.” In Changing State Feminism, eds. Outshoorn, Joyce and Kantola, Johanna. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 201–23.Google Scholar
Celis, Karen, Mackay, Fiona, and Meier, Petra. 2013. “Social Movement Organizations and Changing State Architectures: Comparing Women's Movement Organizing in Flanders and Scotland.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 43 (1): 44–67.Google Scholar
Celis, Karen, and Meier, Petra. 2011. “Activism in Asymmetric Federations: Women's and Sexual Minorities Advocacy in Belgium.” Presented at the European Consortium for Political Research Joint Sessions, University of Saint Gallen, April 12–17.Google Scholar
Cruells, Marta, and Ruiz, Sonia. 2014. “Political Intersectionality within the Indignados Social Movement.” In Intersectionality and Social Change, vol. 37, ed. Woehrle, Lynne M.. Bingley: Emerald Group, 3–25.Google Scholar
Dean, Jonathan, and Aune, Kristin. 2015. “Feminist Resurgent? Mapping Contemporary Feminist Activism in Europe.” Social Movements Studies 14 (4): 375–95.Google Scholar
Del Giorgio, Elena. 2010. “What Has Happened to the Women's Movement? Organisational Dynamics and Trajectories of Feminist Organisations in Milan and Berlin.” PhD diss., European University Institute.Google Scholar
Dobrowolsky, Alexandra. 2002. “Crossing Boundaries: Exploring and Mapping Women's Constitutional Interventions in England, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.” Social Politics 9 (2): 293–340.Google Scholar
Dufour, Pascale, and Traisnel, Christophe. 2014. “Nationalism and Protest.” In Group Politics and Social Movements in Canada, ed. Smith, Miriam. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 251–76.Google Scholar
Erk, Jan, and Swenden, Wilfried. 2010. “The New Wave of Federalism Studies.” In New Directions in Federalism Studies, ed. Erk, Jan and Swenden, Wilfried. London: Routledge, 1–15.Google Scholar
Franceschet, Susan, and Piscopo, Jennifer M.. 2013. “Federalism, Decentralization, and Reproductive Rights in Argentina and Chile.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 43 (1): 129–50.Google Scholar
García, Joana. 2015. “Feminismos en Tiempos de Resistencias a la Austeridad y Confluencias por la Ruptura con el 78” [Feminisms in times of resistance to austerity and political confluences for breaking with the 78 regime]. Anuario Movimientos Sociales 2014. http://fundacionbetiko.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Movimiento-feminista-2014.pdf (accessed May 3, 2018).Google Scholar
Gibernau, Montserrat. 2014. “Prospects for an Independent Catalonia.” International Journal of Political and Cultural Sociology 27 (1): 5–23.Google Scholar
Gray, Gwen. 2006. “Women, Federalism and Women Friendly Policies.” Australian Journal of Public Administration 65 (1): 25–45.Google Scholar
Grey, Sandra, and Sawer, Marian, eds. 2008. Women's Movements: Flourishing or in Abeyance? London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Haussman, Melissa, Sawer, Marian, and Vickers, Jill, eds. 2010. Federalism, Feminism and Multilevel Governance. Burlington, VT: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Institut de Ciències Politiques i Socials (ICPS). 2014. Sondeig D'Opinió Catalunya [Opinion poll of Catalonia]. Barcelona: ICPS/UAB.Google Scholar
Johns, Robert, Bennie, Lynn, and Mitchell, James. 2011. “Gendered Nationalism: The Gender Gap in Support for the Scottish National Party.” Party Politics 18 (4): 581–601.Google Scholar
Keating, Michael. 2012. “Rethinking Sovereignty. Independence-lite, Devolution-max and National Accommodation.” Revista d'Estudis Autonòmics i Federals 16: 9–29.Google Scholar
Keating, Michael, and Wilson, Alex. 2009. “Renegotiating the State of Autonomies: Statute Reform and Multi-level Politics in Spain.” West European Politics 32 (2): 536–58.Google Scholar
Kenny, Meryl. 2014. “Engendering the Independence Debate.” Scottish Affaires 23 (3): 323–31.Google Scholar
Kriesi, Hanspeter. 2004. “Political Context and Opportunity.” In The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, eds. Snow, David A., Soule, Sarah A., and Kriesi, Hanspeter. London: Blackwell, 67–90.Google Scholar
Liñeira, Robert. 2014. “Ha de ser Escócia un país independent? El debat a dos mesos del referéndum” [Should Scotland be an independent country? Debates two months before the referendum]. Cuaderns de l'ICPS 17, ICPS. https://www.icps.cat/archivos/Quaderns/q07_cat.pdf?noga=1 (accessed May 3, 2018).Google Scholar
Liñeira, Robert, and Cetrà, Daniel. 2015. “The Independence Case in Comparative Perspective.” Political Quarterly 86 (2): 257–64.Google Scholar
Liñeira, Robert, Muñoz, Jordi, and Rico, Guillem. 2014. “Voters’ Inference of Candidates’ Ideological Orientations across Issue Dimensions.” Presented at the European Consortium for Political Research General Conference, Glasgow, Scotland, September 3–6.Google Scholar
Mackay, Fiona. 2008. “The State of Women's Movement/s in Britain: Ambiguity, Complexity and Challenges from the Periphery.” In Women's Movements: Flourishing or in Abeyance?, eds. Grey, Sandra and Sawer, Marian. London: Routledge, 17–32.Google Scholar
Mackay, Fiona. 2010. “Gendering Constitutional Change and Policy Outcomes: Substantive Representation and Domestic Violence Policy in Scotland.” Policy & Politics 38 (3): 369–88.Google Scholar
Mackay, Fiona. 2014. “Nested Newness, Institutional Innovation and the Gender Limits of Change.” Politics & Gender 10 (4): 549–71.Google Scholar
Mackay, Fiona, and McAllister, Laura. 2012. “Feminising British Politics: Six Lessons from Devolution in Scotland and Wales.” Political Quarterly 83 (4): 730–34.Google Scholar
Macwhirter, Iain. 2014. Disunited Kingdom: How Westminster Won a Referendum but Lost Scotland. Edinburgh: Cargo Publishing.Google Scholar
Maillé, Chantal. 2007. “Réception de la théorie postcoloniale dans le féminisme Québécois” [The reception of postcolonial theory in Quebecois feminism]. Les féminismes 20 (2): 91–111.Google Scholar
McBride, Dorothy E., and Mazur, Amy. 2008. “Women's Movements, Feminism, and Feminist Movements.” In Politics, Gender and Concepts, eds. Goertz, Gary and Mazur, Amy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 219–43.Google Scholar
McEwen, Nicola. 2005. “The Territorial Politics of Social Policy Development on Multi-level States.” Regional and Federal Studies 15 (4): 537–54.Google Scholar
Mooney, Gerry, and Scott, Gill. 2016. “The 2014 Scottish Independence Debate: Questions of Social Welfare and Social Justice.” Journal of Poverty and Social Justice 23 (1): 5–16.Google Scholar
Morata, Carles, Ntutumu, Fernando, and Marta Soler, Enric Rodriguez Lleonart i. 2014a. “Parlament al ralentí, tot esperant el desellaç del la transició nacional” [Parliament idling, everyone waiting for the outcome of the national transition]. In Anuari Politic de Catalunya 2013, ed. Marcet, Joan. Barcelona: ICPS, 21–42.Google Scholar
Morata, Carles, Ntutumu, Fernando, and Marta Soler, Enric Rodriguez Lleonart i. 2014b. “Entre due aigües: el dret a decidir I el manteniment dels drets socials en temps de crisi” [Between two waters: The right to decide and the protection of social rights in times of crisis]. In Anuari Politic de Catalunya 2013, ed. Marcet, Joan. Barcelona: ICPS, 59–70.Google Scholar
Moreno, Luis. 2008. La federalización de España. Poder político y territorio [Federalizing Spain: Political power and territory]. Madrid: Siglo XXI.Google Scholar
Morrison, Jenny. 2015. “Feminist Radicalism? Feminism and the Radical Independence Campaign.” Presented at the Political Studies Association Annual Conference, Sheffield, March 30–April 1.Google Scholar
Muñoz, Jordi, and Guinjoan, Marc. 2013. “Accounting for Internal Variation in Nationalist Mobilization: Unofficial Referendums for Independence in Catalonia (2009–2011).” Nations and Nationalism 19 (1): 44–67.Google Scholar
Ormstron, Rachel. 2013. “Why Don't More Women Support Independence? Findings from the Scottish Social Attitudes Survey.” http://www.scotcen.org.uk/media/176043/gender-and-indep-paper-final-2012.pdf (accessed May 3, 2018).Google Scholar
Outshoorn, Joyce, and Kantola, Johanna, eds. 2007. Changing State Feminism. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Palomares, María, and García, Joana. 2012. Saberes y prácticas feministas. Una aproximación al movimiento feminista de Cataluña [Feminist knowledge and practices: An approach to the feminist movement in Catalonia]. Barcelona: ACSUR.Google Scholar
Rebouché, Rachel, and Fearon, Kate. 2005. “Overlapping Identities: Power Sharing and Women's Rights.” In Power Sharing: New Challenges for Divided Societies, eds. O'Flynn, Ian and Russell, David. London: Pluto Press, 155–71.Google Scholar
Rodó-de-Zárate, María. 2016. “Feminist and Queer Epistemologies beyond the Academia and the Anglophone World: Political Intersectionality and Transfeminism in the Catalan Context.” In The Routledge Research Companion to Geographies of Sex and Sexualities, eds. Brown, Gavin and Browne, Kath. Abingdon: Routledge, 155–64.Google Scholar
Rosie, Michael, and Bond, Ross. 2007. “Social Democratic Scotland?” In Scottish Social Democracy: Progressive Ideas for Public Policy, ed. Keating, Michael. Brussels: Peter Lang, 39–58.Google Scholar
Sawer, Marian. 2010. “Premature Obituaries: How Can We Tell If the Women's Movement is Over?” Politics & Gender 6 (4): 602–9.Google Scholar
Sawer, Marian, and Vickers, Jill. 2010. “Introduction: Political Architecture and its Gender Impact.” In Federalism, Feminism and Multilevel Governance, eds. Haussman, Melissa, Sawer, Marian, and Vickers, Jill. Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 3–18.Google Scholar
Thapar-Björkert, Suruchi. 2013. “Gender, Nations, and Nationalism.” In The Oxford Handbook of Gender and Politics, eds. Waylen, Georgina, Celis, Karen, Kantola, Johanna, and Weldon, S. Laurel. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 803–27.Google Scholar
Valiente, Celia. 2007. “Are Gender Equality Institutions the Policy Allies of the Feminist Movement? A Contingent ‘Yes’ in the Spanish Central State.” South European Society & Politics 12 (3): 315–34.Google Scholar
Vickers, Jill. 2006. “Bringing Nations In: Some Methodological and Conceptual Issues in Connecting Feminisms with Nationhood and Nationalism.” International Feminist Journal of Politics 8 (1): 84–109.Google Scholar
Vickers, Jill. 2010. “A Two-Way Street: Federalism and Women's Politics in Canada and the United States.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 40 (3): 412–35.Google Scholar
Vickers, Jill. 2011. “Gender and State Architectures: The Impact of Governance Structures on Women's Politics.” Politics & Gender 7 (2): 254–62.Google Scholar
Vickers, Jill. 2013. “Is Federalism Gendered? Incorporating Gender into Studies of Federalism.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 43 (1): 1–23.Google Scholar
Vickers, Jill, Chappell, Louise, and Meier, Petra, eds. 2013. Gendering Federalism. Special issue, Publius: The Journal of Federalism 43(1).Google Scholar
Verge, Tània. 2011. “Cuotas de género y reclutamiento político. Análisis del Parlament de Catalunya (1980–2010)” [Gender quotas and political recruitment. Analysis of the Parliament of Catalonia]. Revista Española de Ciencia Política 26: 87–104.Google Scholar
Verge, Tània, Guinjoan, Marc, and Rodon, Toni. 2015. “Risk Aversion, Gender and Constitutional Change.” Politics & Gender 11 (3): 499–521.Google Scholar
Walby, Sylvia. 2006. “Gender Approaches to Nation and Nationalism.” In The Sage Handbook of Nations and Nationalism, eds. Delanty, Gerard and Kumar, Krishan. London: Sage, 118–28.Google Scholar
Walby, Sylvia. 2011. The Future of Feminism. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar