Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T12:41:22.309Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Canada's Arctic sector claim in historical perspective: a response to Alan MacEachern

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2016

Janice Cavell
Janice Cavell*
Affiliation:
Historical Section, Global Affairs Canada, 125 Sussex Drive, Ottawa, ON KIA OG2, Canada ([email protected])
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Explorer Joseph Elzéar Bernier's famous 1909 sector claim on Melville Island is often described as a key moment in the evolution of Canada's sovereignty over the Arctic archipelago. Writers such as Yolande Dorion-Robitaille and Marjolaine Saint-Pierre have argued that Bernier was unfairly deprived of the credit he deserved for his sovereignty contributions. Alan MacEachern has recently stated in Polar Record that civil servants in the 1920s were to blame for this supposed unfair treatment. In particular, he sees Oswald Finnie of the Department of the Interior as a man who was determined at all costs to rewrite the historical record. This article contests MacEachern's depiction of Finnie and his colleagues, based on a range of primary source documents. It also emphasises the little-known but very significant role played by James White, who first placed the sector lines on an official map five years before Bernier's 1909 proclamation. The article thus clarifies the complicated relationship between White's 1904 map, Bernier's 1909 claim, an earlier sector claim made by Bernier in 1907, and the views on the sector theory held by influential members of the Canadian civil service at the time when an official sector claim was made by Ottawa in 1925.

Type
Research Article
Information
Polar Record , Volume 53 , Issue 2 , March 2017 , pp. 186 - 191
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bernier, J.E. 1907. Report to minister of marine and fisheries, 3 October 1907. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 179. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 259–261.Google Scholar
Bernier, J.E. 1909. Report on the Dominion government expedition to [the] Arctic islands and the Hudson Strait on board the C.G.S. ‘Arctic’, 1906-1907. Ottawa: King's Printer.Google Scholar
Bernier, J.E. 1930. Letter to G. Perley, 13 November 1930. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 525. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 788–789.Google Scholar
Bernier, J.E. 1933. Letter to R.B. Bennett, 21 November 1933. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG 25 vol. 1673 file 748-33.Google Scholar
Cavell, J. 2006. Arctic exploration in Canadian print culture, 1890-1930. Papers of the Bibliographical Society of Canada 44 (2): 7–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavell, J. 2007. Comparing mythologies: Twentieth-century Canadian constructions of Sir John Franklin. In: Hillmer, N. and Chapnick, A. (editors). 2007. Canadas of the mind: the making and unmaking of Canadian nationalisms in the twentieth century. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press: 15–45.Google Scholar
Cavell, J. 2010. ‘As far as 90 north’: Joseph Elzéar Bernier's 1907 and 1909 sovereignty claims. Polar Record 46 (239): 372–373. (Online publication date 26 February 2010.)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavell, J. 2011. ‘A little more latitude’: explorers, politicians, and Canadian Arctic policy during the Laurier era. Polar Record 47 (243): 289–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavell, J. 2013. Further evidence and reflections on Joseph Elzéar Bernier's 1907 and 1909 sovereignty claims. Polar Record 49 (251): 406–408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavell, J. 2014. Sector claims and counter-claims: Joseph Elzéar Bernier, the Canadian government, and Arctic sovereignty, 1898–1934. Polar Record 50 (254): 293–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada.Google Scholar
Cavell, J., and Noakes, J.. 2010. Acts of occupation: Canada and Arctic sovereignty, 1918–25. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
Coates, K., Lackenbauer, P.W., Morrison, W. and Poelzer, G.. 2008. Arctic front: defending Canada in the far north. Toronto: Thomas Allen.Google Scholar
Desbarats, G.J. 1914. Letter to V. Stefansson, 31 March 1914. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 207. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 318.Google Scholar
Desbarats, G.J. 1926. Letter to O.S. Finnie, 13 March 1926. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG 85 vol. 5 file 20-Bernier.Google Scholar
Dorion-Robitaille, Y. 1978. Captain J.E. Bernier's contribution to Canadian sovereignty in the Arctic. Ottawa: Department of Indian and Northern Affairs.Google Scholar
Finnie, O.S. 1928. Memorandum for R.A. Gibson, 24 April 1928. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 429. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 665.Google Scholar
Finnie, O.S. 1930a. Memorandum for R.A. Gibson, 25 April 1930. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 494. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 752.Google Scholar
Finnie, O.S. 1930b. Memorandum for W.W. Cory, 28 November 1930. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 526. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 789–790.Google Scholar
Finnie, O.S. 1930c. Memorandum for W.W. Cory, 28 November 1930. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 527. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 791.Google Scholar
Finnie, R.S. 1972. Letter to W. Choat, 3 February 1972. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, R.S. Finnie papers, vol. 8 file 6.Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, C. 1905. Letter to W. Laurier, 25 July 1905. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 156. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 201–202.Google Scholar
Holmden, H. 1921. Letter to J.D. Craig, 31 October 1921 In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 265. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 410.Google Scholar
Laurier, W. 1905. Letter to C. Fitzpatrick, 28 July 1905. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 157. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 203.Google Scholar
MacEachern, A. 2010. J.E. Bernier's claims to fame. Scientia Canadensis 33 (2): 43–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacEachern, A. 2016. J.E. Bernier and the historical record. Polar Record, FirstView Articles.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Poirier, P. 1907. Speech, 20 February 1907. In: Canada, Senate. 1907. Debates of the senate of the Dominion of Canada, 1906–7. Ottawa: S.E. Dawson: 266–274.Google Scholar
Saint-Pierre, M. 2009. Joseph-Elzéar Bernier: champion of Canadian Arctic sovereignty, 1852–1934. Montréal: Baraka Books.Google Scholar
Smith, G.W. 1966. Sovereignty in the north: the Canadian aspect of an international problem. In: Macdonald, R. St. J. (editor). The Arctic frontier. Toronto: University of Toronto Press: 194–255.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stefansson, V. 1914. Letter to G.J. Desbarats, 12 February 1914. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 206. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 317–318.Google Scholar
Stumbles, W.W. 1911. Report on the Dominion government expedition to the northern waters and Arctic archipelago of the D.G.S. ‘Arctic’ in 1910. Ottawa: King's Printer.Google Scholar
White, J. 1922. Enclosure in letter to W.L.M. King, 8 June 1922. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG 13 vol. 934 file 6A.Google Scholar
White, J. 1923. Memorandum [for O.S. Finnie?], 18 December 1923. In: Cavell, J. (editor). 2016. Documents on Canadian external relations: the Arctic, 1874–1949, doc. 315. Ottawa: Global Affairs Canada: 486–490.Google Scholar
Zaslow, M. 1971. The opening of the Canadian north, 1870–1914. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.Google Scholar