Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T14:36:24.142Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Richardson's Paradoxical Success

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 December 2020

Charlotte Lefever*
Affiliation:
University of Montana

Extract

Richardson, writer and printer of the eighteenth century, the center of a circle of admiring ladies, began his career (as is well known) in an inconspicuous manner by preparing love-letters for enamoured young women. Finding himself successful in this delicate mission, he responded to a demand for a volume called Familiar Letters, models for all occasions. But, being innoculated by the moral virus of the eighteenth century, he sensed the shallowness of these epistles and decided that they should contain moral as well as literary examples. His first book, Pamela, was a group of letters instructing a maidservant in manners and morals. But neither Richardson nor the women who were his constant critics were satisfied until he had prepared a volume of letters instructing a “lady.” This lady, called Clarissa, was created as an “examplar to her sex.” These two books were so popular, and the demand for an example of conduct for the perfect gentleman was so great that Richardson next wrote Charles Grandison. Since fiction without a moral purpose was disapproved by the eighteenth century, Richardson makes it clear that one should not look “upon the story as the sole end but as a vehicle to the instruction.” It is obvious that Richardson's first aim was to instruct in manners and morals; his secondary aim, begun as a writer of Familiar Letters, was to make model letters for all who needed instruction. There is no evidence that he abandoned this latter purpose; he simply subordinated it to a loftier one.

Type
Research Article
Information
PMLA , Volume 48 , Issue 3 , September 1933 , pp. 856 - 860
Copyright
Copyright © Modern Language Association of America, 1933

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Clarissa, “Preface,” by Richardson.

2 Ibid.

3 Austin Dobson, Samuel Richardson, Ch. ii, 40.

4 Ibid.

5 Pamela, Preface, by Thomas Archer. Clarissa, Preface, By Mrs. Harriet Ward.

6 Austin Dobson, Samuel Richardson, Ch. ii. 41.

7 Clarissa, ii, 84.

8 Clarissa, Postscript, by Richardson.

9 Ibid., Preface, by Richardson.

10 Charles Grandison, i, 34. “She (Harriet Byron) is called modest because she can blush —whenever she pleases.”

11 Pamela, ii, 342. (Lady Davers' letter) “Now that you are lifted to the rank of a lady you have nothing to do but give orders … be taskmistress over a common herd of female servants.”

12 Pamela relates all the praise she has received for her virtue, charm, and generosity in a letter to Lady Davers.

13 Pamela, iv, 177. “I am to be favored with the care of Miss Goodwin” (Mr. B—'s illegitimate daughter).

14 Clarissa, Preface, by Richardson.

16 Mrs. Barbauld's collection of his letters, mostly from women and to women, contains six vast folio volumes.

16 Pamela, ii, letter 3; iv, letters 7 and 14.

17 The main fault probably lies in Richardson's inability to reconcile the necessary coldness of letter writing form to his more or less sensational material.

18 Charles Grandison, i, 55.

19 Clarissa, i, 174, 178.

20 Ibid., ii, 17.

21 As shown both in the kind of letters they write and in the story.