Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T06:12:42.232Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Funeral Elegy: W[illiam] S[hakespeare]'s “Best-Speaking Witnesses”

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 October 2020

Donald W. Foster
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A Funeral Elegy was written in February 1612 by “W. S.,” a poet of “name and credit” closely familiar with Shakespearean texts. The pamphlet was registered by a stationer, Thomas Thorp, whose livelihood depended chiefly on the Shakespeare-Jonson theatrical circle and who had published Shakespeare's Sonnets in 1609. Privately issued and surviving in just two copies, A Funeral Elegy received scant notice until 1989, when I first presented archival, statistical, and literary evidence that WS could be William Shakespeare. Focusing on intertextual evidence derived in part from new electronic resources, this essay addresses a vexing conundrum: the elegy is aesthetically disappointing and yet distinctively Shakespearean—a paradox that raises larger questions about attributional methodology and canonical theory. An emerging scholarly consensus supports a Shakespearean attribution for the elegy, though the poem challenges prevailing notions of what it is that makes Shakespeare “Shakespeare.”

Type
Research Article
Information
PMLA , Volume 111 , Issue 5 , October 1996 , pp. 1080 - 1105
Copyright
Copyright © Modern Language Association of America, 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Works Cited

Abrams, Richard “‘Miracle in the Labor’; W.S.'s Funeral Elegy.” Shakespeare Assn. of Amer. research seminar on “the Shakespeare apocrypha.” Atlanta. April 1994.Google Scholar
Abrams, Richard “W[illiam] S[hakespeare]'s Funeral Elegy and the Turn from the Theatrical.” Studies in English Literature 36 (1996): 435–43.Google Scholar
Arber, Edward, ed A Transcript of the Registers of the Company of Stationers of London: 1554-1640. Vol. 3. London, 1876, 1894. 5 vols.Google Scholar
Barnfield, Richard. The Affectionate Shepheard. London, 1594. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Barnfield, Richard. Cynthia, with Certaine Sonnets and the Legend of Cassandra. London, 1595. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Bevington, David, ed The Complete Works of Shakespeare. 5th ed. New York: Harper, forthcoming.Google Scholar
Cary, Elizabeth. The Tragedie of Mariam, the Faire Queene of Jewry. By E. C. London, 1613. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Daniel, Samuel “The Complaint of Rosamond.” Daniel, Delia.Google Scholar
Daniel, Samuel “Delia.” Daniel, Delia.Google Scholar
Daniel, Samuel. Delia and Rosamond, Augmented. Cleopatra. London, 1594. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Daniel, Samuel. A Funerall Poeme uppon the Death of the … Earle of Devonshire. [London, 1606]. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Daniel, Samuel “Musophilus.” Daniel, Delia.Google Scholar
Dominik, Mark. William Shakespeare and The Birth of Merlin. New York: Philosophical Lib., 1985.Google Scholar
Drew, Mr. and Frank, Mrs. Letter to the author. 2 Jan. 1996.Google Scholar
Duncan-Jones, Katherine. Letter Times Literary Supplement 29 Mar. 1996: 17.Google Scholar
Duncan-Jones, Katherine Letter. Times Literary Supplement 14 June 1996: 17.Google Scholar
Evans, G. Blakemore, et al., eds The Riverside Shakespeare. 2nd ed. Boston: Houghton, forthcoming.Google Scholar
Exeter. City Chamber. Act books. Ms. vols. 2–7 (1508-1640). Devonshire Record Office. Exeter.Google Scholar
Ford, John (authorship attributed). Christes Bloodie Sweat. or the Sonne of God in his Agonie. By 1. F. 1613. London, 1616. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Ford, John. Fames Memorial!, or The Earle of Devonshire Deceased. London, 1606. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Ford, John (authorship attributed). The Golden Meane. London, 1613. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Ford, John (authorship attributed). Honor Triumphant, or The Peeres Challenge. By I. F. London, 1606. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Ford, John (authorship attributed). King lames his Welcome to London. By I. F. London, 1603. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W. Elegy by W. S.: A Study in Attribution. Cranbury: Assoc. UP, 1989.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W Introduction. Elégie funèbre par W[illiam] S[hakespectre]. Trans. Carrive, Lucien. Paris: Stock, 1996. 11–75.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W Letter. Times Literary Supplement 29 Mar. 1996: 17.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W Rev. of Shakespeare's Lost Play, by Eric Sams, and William Shakespeare and The Birth of Merlin, by Mark Dominik. Shakespeare Quarterly 39 (1988): 118–11.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W “‘Shall I Die’ Post Mortem: Defining Shakespeare.” Shakespeare Quarterly 38 (1987): 58–77.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W. ed “SHAXICON: A Lexical Database for Shakespeare Studies.” Online. World Wide Web. Available http://faculty.vassar.edu/~foster/shax.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W. “SHAXICON Update.” Shakespeare Newsletter 45.2 (1995): 1+.Google Scholar
Foster, Donald W, ed “Vassar Electronic Text Archive.” Online. World Wide Web. Available http://faculty.vassar.edu/~foster/veta.Google Scholar
Greenblatt, Stephen, et al., eds The Norton Shakespeare. New York: Norton, forthcoming.Google Scholar
Hill, Harry, reader. A Funeral Elegy for Master William Peter, by W.S. Dir. Paul Hawkins. Audiocassette and compact disc. Montreal: Concordia U; Targray, 1996.Google Scholar
Honan, William H “A Sleuth Gets His Suspect: Shakespeare.” New York Times 14 Jan. 1996: A1+.Google Scholar
Jonson, Benjamin. Every Man in his Humour. The Workes of Benjamin Jonson. London, 1616. A2v-GIv. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Jonson, Benjamin. Sejanus. London, 1605. The Workes of Benjamin Jonson. London, 1616. Gg4r-Oo3v. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Kennedy, Richard. Postings. Shaksper (1 Feb.-2 Apr. 1996): n. pag. Online. Internet.Google Scholar
Knowles, James “WS M.S.” Times Literary Supplement 29 Apr. 1988: 472+.Google Scholar
Leishman, J. B., ed “The First Part of the Return from Parnassus.” The Three Parnassus Plays. Ed. Leishman. London: Nicholson, 1949. 25–75.Google Scholar
Levi, Peter. The Life and Times of William Shakespeare. New York: Holt, 1989.Google Scholar
Malone, Edmond, ed Supplement to the Edition of Shakespeare's Plays Published in 1778 by Samuel Johnson and George Steevens. London. 1780.Google Scholar
Marlowe, Christopher, and Chapman, George. Hero and Leander. Begun by Christopher Marlowe and finished by George Chapman. London, 1598. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Martyn, William “Deposicons and examynacons of Wittnesses.” Book 60B, letter 145. Exeter City Archives. Devon Record Office. Folios 110–11.Google Scholar
Metz, G. Harold. Sources of Four Plays Ascribed to Shakespeare. Columbia: U of Missouri P. 1989.Google Scholar
Middleton, Thomas (authorship attributed) The Second Maiden's Tragedy. Ms. Lansdowne 807. British Lib., London. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd ed. CD-ROM. 1992.Google Scholar
Partridge, A. C. A Substantive Grammar of Shakespeare's Non-dramatic Texts. Charlottesville: UP of Virginia. 1976.Google Scholar
Puttenham, George (authorship attributed). The Arte of English Poesie. London, 1589. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Rasmussen, Eric. “Shakespeare's Hand in The Second Maiden's Tragedy.” Shakespeare Quarterly 40 (1989): 1–26.Google Scholar
Rollins, Hyder Edward, ed A New Variorum Edition of Shakespeare: The Poems. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1938.Google Scholar
Rollins, Hyder Edward, ed A New Variorum Edition of Shakespeare: The Sonnets. 2 vols. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1944.Google Scholar
Sams, Eric. Shakespeare's Lost Play. New York: St. Martin's, 1985.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William (authorship attributed). A Funerall Elegye in memory of the late vertuous Maister William Peeler. By W. S. London, 1612. Foster, Elegy 24-67. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William. Mr. William Shakespeares Comedies. Histories, and Tragedies. London, 162.3. Shakespeare, Riverside.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William [et al.] The Passionate Pilgrime. Sonnets to Sundrey Notes of Music. London, 1599 (two eds.). London, 1612. Shakespeare, Riverside.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William [and George Wilkins?]. Pericles. London, 1609. Shakespeare, Riverside.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William (authorship attributed) [and Christopher Marlowe?]. The Raigne of King Edward III. London. 1596. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William. The Riverside Shakespeare. Ed. Evans, G. Blakemore. Boston: Houghton, 1974. Diskette. Provo: Electronic Text, 1990.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William. Shake-speares Sonnets. London, 1609. Shakespeare, Riverside.Google Scholar
Shakespeare, William. The Two Noble Kinsmen. London, 1634. Shakespeare, Riverside.Google Scholar
Sidney, Philip. The Counresse of Pembrokes Arcadia. With Sundry New Additions. Certaine Sonets. London, 1598. Extracts. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Sobran, Joseph. Column. Universal Press Syndicate. 16 Feb. 1996.Google Scholar
Sobran, Joseph “The Problem of The Funeral Elegy.” Online. World Wide Web. 11 July 1996. Available http://www.shakespeare-oxford.com/sobran.htm.Google Scholar
Suckling, John. Brennoralt. A Tragedy. London, 1646.Google Scholar
Taylor, Gary “A New Shakespeare Poem? The Evidence.” Times Literary Supplement 20 Dec. 1985: 1447–14.Google Scholar
Taylor, Gary “Shakespeare's New Poem.” New York Times Book Review 15 Dec. 1985: 11–14.Google Scholar
Theobald, Lewis. Double Falsehood. London, 1728. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Vickers, Brian “Whose Thumbprints?” Times Literary Supplement 8 Mar. 1996: 16–18.Google Scholar
Wallace, Charles William. Shakespeare and His London Associates As Revealed in Recently Discovered Documents. Univ. Studies 10.4. Lincoln: U of Nebraska P, 1910.Google Scholar
Wastell, Simon (authorship attributed). The Muses Thankfulnesse. [London, 1627]. Normalized ed. Ed. Donald W. Foster. Online. Vassar Electronic Text Archive. Vassar Internet.Google Scholar
Weller, Barry, and W, Margaret Ferguson. Introduction. The Tragedy of Mariam, the Fair Queen of Jewry. By Elizabeth Cary. Ed. Weller and Ferguson. Berkeley: U of California P, 1994. 1–59.Google Scholar
Wells, Stanley. Letter “Shall I Die?” Times Literary Supplement 10 Jan. 1986:37.Google Scholar
Wright, George T “Hendiadys and Hamlet.” PMLA 96 (1981): 168–16Google Scholar