Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T11:59:21.375Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

FUNERARY TRANSFORMATIONS IN AN ETRUSCO-ITALIC COMMUNITY: SOCIAL DISPLAY AND AUSTERITY IN HELLENISTIC CHIUSI

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 July 2017

Alexis Daveloose
Get access

Abstract

From the end of the third century BC on, the funerary culture of the Etruscan city of Chiusi saw the gradual disappearance of the most expensive containers and tombs. At the same time, there was first a dramatic increase in the number of such monuments, followed by an equally sharp decline in the first century BC. The qualitative development has traditionally been explained using sumptuary laws, which should have constrained funerary expenditure. However, a close examination of the local evidence reveals that this is not only unlikely, but also does not explain the quantitative development and why there was a social and cultural need to constrain these funerary objects in the first place. Using the concepts of distinction and habitus developed by Bourdieu, this paper analyses the developments in Chiusine funerary practice by focusing on social interactions within and between élites and non-élites. This gives both groups agency in a complex social, cultural and political process that caused the criteria for distinction to change, ultimately making funerary culture less important for status differentiation in the rapidly changing context of Hellenistic Italy.

A partire dalla fine del III sec. a.C. si può registrare nella cultura funeraria della città etrusca di Chiusi la graduale scomparsa dei cinerari e delle strutture tombali di maggiore impegno economico. Allo stesso tempo si può riconoscere un aumento considerevole nel numero di questi monumenti, seguito poi da un declino, ugualmente netto, nel corso del I sec. a.C. Questo tipo di fenomeno è stato tradizionalmente spiegato con l'introduzione di leggi suntuarie, mirate a contenere il lusso funerario. Tuttavia, un'attenta disamina delle testimonianze locali mostra come questa interpretazione sia non solo improbabile, ma in ultima analisi non contribuisca a chiarire neppure lo sviluppo dal punto di vista quantitativo e i motivi per i quali vi fu una necessità sociale e culturale di limitare l'uso proprio di questi oggetti funerari. Utilizzando i concetti di distinzione e di habitus sviluppati da Bourdieu, il presente articolo analizza gli sviluppi nella pratica funeraria chiusina, mettendo l'accento sulle interazioni sociali all'interno dell’élite e tra quest'ultima e le non-élite. Questo approccio riconosce a entrambi i gruppi la capacità di agency in un processo complesso che ha interessato gli ambiti sociale, culturale e politico e che è stato alla base dei criteri per la distinzione che ha portato al cambiamento, rendendo in ultima analisi la cultura funeraria meno importante in rapporto alla manifestazione della differenziazione di status nel contesto in rapido cambiamento dell'Italia di età ellenistica.

Type
Articles
Information
Papers of the British School at Rome , Volume 85 , October 2017 , pp. 37 - 69
Copyright
Copyright © British School at Rome 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1

This paper originated from my master's dissertation, completed at Ghent University under the guidance of prof. Dr Koenraad Verboven, to whom I owe many thanks. I am also grateful to Prof. Dr Christian Laes, Dr Saskia Roselaar and Dr Theresa Huntsman for proofreading this paper and for offering many useful suggestions.

References

REFERENCES

Adams, J.N. (2003) Bilingualism and the Latin Language. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aigner-Foresti, L. (1998) (ed.) Die Integration der Etrusker und das Weiterwirken Etruskischen Kulturgutes im Republikanischen und Kaiserzeitlichen Rom. Vienna, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften.Google Scholar
Barni, E. and Paolucci, G. (1985) Archeologia e antiquaria a Chiusi nell'Ottocento. Milan, Electa.Google Scholar
Bayet, J. (1960) Idéologie et plastique. II: La sculpture funéraire de Chiusi. Mélanges d'Archéologie et d'Histoire 72: 35–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benelli, E. (1994) Le iscrizioni bilingui etrusco-latine. Firenze, Leo S. Olschki Editore.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2001) Le iscrizioni funerarie chiusine di età ellenistica. Studi Etruschi 64: 225–63.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2008) Alla ricerca delle aristocrazie chiusine. In Haack, M.-L. (ed.), Écritures, cultures, sociétés dans les nécropoles d'Italie ancienne: 135–59. Bordeaux, Ausonius.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2009) La società chiusina fra la guerra annibalica e l'età di Augusto. Osservazioni archeologiche ed epigrafiche. Ostraka 18: 303–22.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2010) Inscriptions on tiles from Chiusi: archaeological and epigraphical notes. Etruscan Studies 13: 123–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benelli, E. (2011) ‘Vornamengentilizia’. Anatomia di una chimera. In Maras, D.F. (ed.), Corollari. Scritti di antichità etrusche e italiche in omaggio all'opera di Giovanni Colonna: 193–8. Pisa, Fabrizio Serra Editore.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2012) Matrimoni misti e identità in cambiamento: Chiusi da città etrusca a municipio romano. In Marchesini, S. (ed.), Matrimoni misti: una via per l'integrazione tra i popoli. Atti del convegno (Verona–Trento 2011): 103–9. Trento, Alteritas.Google Scholar
Benelli, E. (2013) Slavery and manumission. In Turfa, J. MacIntosh (ed.), The Etruscan World: 447–56. London/New York, Routledge.Google Scholar
Berrendonner, C. (2002) Les cultures épigraphiques de l'Italie républicaine: Les territoires de langue étrusque et les territoires de langue osque. Mélanges de l’École Française de Rome. Antiquité 114: 817–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berrendonner, C. (2004–7) La società di Chiusi ellenistica e la sua immagine: il contributo delle necropoli alla conoscenza delle strutture sociali. Etruscan Studies 10: 67–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berrendonner, C. (2008) L'invention des épitaphes dans la Rome médio-républicaine. In Haack, M.-L. (ed.), Écritures, cultures, sociétés dans les nécropoles d'Italie ancienne: 181–201. Bordeaux, Ausonius.Google Scholar
Bianchi Bandinelli, R. (1925) Clusium. Ricerche archeologiche e topografiche su Chiusi e il suo territorio in età etrusca. Monte Antichi 30: 209–578.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, P. (1984) Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (trans. Nice, R.). Cambridge, Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Bradley, G.J., Isayev, E. and Riva, C. (2007) (eds) Ancient Italy: Regions without Boundaries. Exeter, University of Exeter Press.Google Scholar
Briguet, M.F. (2002) Les urnes cinéraires étrusques de l’époque hellénistique. Paris, Éditions de la Réunion des musées nationaux.Google Scholar
Bruschetti, P. (2011–12) La tomba etrusca di Vaiano-Paradiso. Aspetti particolari di architettura funeraria ellenistica. Annuario. Accademia Etrusca di Cortona 34: 225–37.Google Scholar
Caccioli, D.A. (1999) Elements of Romanization in Hellenistic Etruscan Banquet Scenes. Iowa City, University of Iowa.Google Scholar
Cannon, A., Bartel, B., Bradley, R., Chapman, R.W., Curran, M.L., Gill, D.W.J., Humphreys, S.J., Masset, C., Morris, I., Quilter, J., Rothschild, N.A. and Runnels, C. (1989) The historical dimension in mortuary expressions of status and sentiment. Current Anthropology 30: 437–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Capdeville, G. (2002–3) Social mobility in Etruria. Etruscan Studies 9: 177–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cherici, A. (2002) Per una storia sociale di Perugia etrusca: le tombe con armi. Annali della Fondazione per il Museo ‘Claudio Faina’ 9: 95–138.Google Scholar
Cherici, A. (2005) Dinamiche sociali a Vulci: le tombe con armi. In Paoletti, O. and Camporeale, G. (eds), Dinamiche di sviluppo delle città nell'Etruria meridionale: 531–49. Roma/Pisa, Istituti Editoriali e Poligrafici Internazionali.Google Scholar
Colonna, G. (1985) Per una cronologia della pittura etrusca di età ellenistica. Dialoghi di Archeologia 3: 1–24.Google Scholar
Colonna, G. (1993) I sarcofagi chiusini di età ellenistica. In Olschki, L.S. (ed.), La civiltà di Chiusi e del suo territorio: atti del XVII convegno di studi etruschi ed italici (Chianciano Terme, 28 maggio–1 giugno 1989): 337–74. Firenze, Leo S. Olschki Editore.Google Scholar
Cornell, T. (1996) Hannibal's legacy: the effects of the Hannibalic War on Italy. In Cornell, T., Rankov, B. and Sabin, P. (eds), The Second Punic War: A Reappraisal: 97–117. London, Institute of Classical Studies.Google Scholar
Cristofani, M. (1978) L'arte degli Etruschi: produzione e consumo. Turin, Einaudi.Google Scholar
de Cazanove, O. (2000) Some thoughts on the religious Romanization of Italy before the Social War. In Bispham, E. and Smith, C.J. (eds), Religion in Archaic and Republican Rome and Italy: Evidence and Experience: 71–6. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
De Marrais, E., Castillo, L.J. and Earle, T. (1996) Ideology, materialization, and power strategies. Current Anthropology 37: 15–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engels, J. (1998) Funerum Sepulcrorumque Magnificentia. Begräbnis- und Grabluxusgesetze in der Griechisch-römischen Welt mit Einigen Ausblicken auf Einschränkungen des Funeralen und Sepulkralen Luxus im Mittelalter und in der Neuzeit. Stuttgart, Franz Steiner Verlag.Google Scholar
Flower, H.I. (2002) Were women ever ‘ancestors’ in Republican Rome? In Munk, H. (ed.), Images of Ancestors: 159–84. Aarhus, Aarhus University Press.Google Scholar
Foster, S.W. (1986) Reading Pierre Bourdieu. Cultural Anthropology 1: 103–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gartman, D. (1991) Culture as class symbolization or mass reification? A critique of Bourdieu's distinction. American Journal of Sociology 97: 421–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guldager Bilde, P., Nielsen, I. and Nielsen, M. (1993) Introduction. In Guldager Bilde, P., Nielsen, I. and Nielsen, M. (eds), Aspects of Hellenism in Italy: Towards a Cultural Unity?: 7–12. Copenhagen, Museum Tusculanum Press.Google Scholar
Hadas-Lebel, J. (2004) Le bilinguisme étrusco-latin: contribution à l’étude de la romanisation de l’Étrurie. Leuven/Paris, Peeters.Google Scholar
Hammarström, M. (1929) Etruskische Inschriften aus Chiusi. Studi Etruschi 3: 333–6.Google Scholar
Harris, W.V. (1971) Rome in Etruria and Umbria. Oxford, Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Harris, W.V. (1977) Economic conditions in northern Etruria in the second century B.C. In Martelli, M. and Cristofani, M. (eds), Caratteri dell'ellenismo nelle urne etrusche: 56–63. Firenze, Centro Di.Google Scholar
Häussler, R. (1998) Motivations and ideologies of Romanization. In Forcey, C., Hawthorne, J. and Witcher, R. (eds), TRAC 97: Proceedings of the Seventh Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference Nottingham 1997: 11–19. Oxford, Oxbow Books.Google Scholar
Hodder, I. (1979) Economic and social stress and material culture patterning. American Antiquity 44: 446–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodder, I. (1982) Symbols in Action: Ethnoarchaeological Studies of Material Cultures. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Izzet, V.E. (2007) The Archaeology of Etruscan Society. Cambridge/New York, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Izzet, V.E. (2009) Women and the Romanisation of Etruria. In Herring, E. and Lomas, K. (eds), Gender Identities in Italy in the First Millennium BC: 127–34. Oxford, Archeopress (BAR 1983).Google Scholar
Jannot, J.-R. (1987) Sur la representation étrusque des morts. In Hinard, F. (ed.), La mort, les morts et l'au-delà dans le monde romain (Actes du colloque de Caen 1985): 279–91. Caen, Presses universitaires de Caen.Google Scholar
Jannot, J.-R. (2010) Les reliefs de Chiusi: mise à jour de nos connaissances. Mélanges de l’École Française de Rome. Antiquité 122: 51–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaimio, J. (1975) The ousting of Etruscan by Latin in Etruria. In Bruun, P. (ed.), Studies in the Romanization of Etruria: 85–245. Rome, Bardi Editore.Google Scholar
Knappett, C. (2005) Thinking through Material Culture: An Interdisciplinary Perspective. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lambrechts, R. (1959) Essai sur les magistratures des républiques étrusques. Brussels, Palais des Académies.Google Scholar
Langslow, D. (2012) Integration, identity, and language shift: strengths and weaknesses of the ‘linguistic’ evidence. In Roselaar, S.T. (ed.), Processes of Integration and Identity Formation in the Roman Republic: 289–309. Leiden/Boston, MA, Brill.Google Scholar
Levi, D. (1928) Chiusi. Tombe a loculi delle ‘Tassinaie’ e delle ‘Palazze’. Notizie degli Scavi di Antichità 53: 55–82.Google Scholar
Maggiani, A. (2014) La necropoli di Balena. Una communità rurale alla periferia del territorio di Chiusi in età medio e tardo ellenistica (II-I sec. a.C.). In Salvini, M. (ed.), Etruschi e Romani a San Casciano dei Bagni. Le stanze cassianensi: 51–7. Rome, Edizioni Quasar.Google Scholar
Massa-Pairault, F.-H. (1996) La cité des Étrusques. Paris, CNRS Éditions.Google Scholar
Matteini Chiari, M. (1975) La Tomba del Faggeto in territorio perugino. Contributo allo studio dell'architettura funeraria con volta a botte in Etruria. Rome, De Luca.Google Scholar
Minetti, A. and Paolucci, G. (2000) Le necropoli chuisine di età ellenistica. In Rastrelli, A. (ed.), Chiusi etrusca: 204–21. Chiusi, Edizioni Lui.Google Scholar
Morris, I. (1987) Burial and Ancient Society: The Rise of the Greek City-State. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Morris, I. (1994) Death-Ritual and Social Structure in Classical Antiquity. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Mouritsen, H. (1998) Italian Unification: A Study in Ancient and Modern Historiography. London, Institute of Classical Studies.Google Scholar
Mouritsen, H. (2005) Freedmen and decurions: epitaphs and social history in imperial Italy. Journal of Roman Studies 95: 38–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicolet, C. (1974) L'ordre équestre à l’époque républicaine (312–43 av. J.-C.). II Prosopographie des chevaliers romains. Paris, Diffusion De Boccard.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (1985) Women in the late Etruscan society. Practices of commemoration and social stress. In Waaben, E. (ed.), Fromhed og verdslighed i Middelalder og Renaissance, Festskrift til Thelma Jexlev: 192–202. Odense, Odense Universitetsforlag.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (1989) Women and family in a changing society. A quantitative approach to late Etruscan burials. Analecta Romana Insituti Danici 17–18: 53–98.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (1990) The relationships between Volterra and its territory illustrated by urns from the Hellenistic period. In Kunze, M. and von Heres, H. (eds), Die Welt der Etrusker: Internationales Kolloquium 24.–26. Oktober 1988 in Berlin: 201–17. Berlin, Akademie-Verlag.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (1999) Common tombs for women in Etruria: buried matriarchies? In Setälä, P. and Savunen, L. (eds), Female Networks and the Public Sphere in Roman Society: 65–139. Rome, Institutum Romanum Finlandiae.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (2002) ‘…stemmate quod Tusco ramum millesime duci…’ Family tombs and genealogical memory among the Etruscans. In Munk, H. (ed.), Images of Ancestors: 89–126. Aarhus, Aarhus University Press.Google Scholar
Nielsen, M. (2013) The last Etruscans: family tombs in northern Etruria. In Turfa, J. MacIntosh (ed.), The Etruscan World: 180–93. London/New York, Routledge.Google Scholar
Oleson, J.P. (1976a) Regulatory planning and individual site development in Etruscan necropoles. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 35: 204–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oleson, J.P. (1976b) The Galeotti Tomb at Chiusi: the construction techniques of the Etruscan barrel-vaulted tombs. Studi Etruschi 44: 69–85.Google Scholar
Oleson, J.P. (1982) The Sources of Innovation in Later Etruscan Tomb Design (ca. 350–100 B.C.). Rome, L'Erma di Bretschneider.Google Scholar
Pack, E. (1988) Clusium: ritratto di una città romana attraverso l'epigrafia. In Paolucci, G. (ed.), I Romani di Chiusi: rivisitazione attraverso testimonianze epigrafiche, topografiche, archeologiche: 11–104. Rome, Multigrafica Editrice.Google Scholar
Pack, E. and Paolucci, G. (1987) Tituli Clusini. Nuove iscrizioni e correzioni all'epigrafia latina di Chiusi. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 68: 159–91.Google Scholar
Paolucci, G. (1988) Il territorio di Chianciano Terme dalla preistoria al medioevo. Rome, Bonsignori.Google Scholar
Paolucci, G. (2005) Documenti e memorie sulle antichità e il museo di Chiusi. Rome, Istituti editoriali e poligrafici internazionali.Google Scholar
Prayon, F. (1998) Die etruskische Grabarchitektur und Rom. In Aigner-Foresti, L. (ed.), Die Integration der Etrusker und das Weiterwirken Etruskischen Kulturgutes im Republikanischen und Kaiserzeitlichen Rom: 165–76. Vienna, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften.Google Scholar
Pucci, G. and Mascione, C. (2003) (eds) Manifattura ceramica etrusco-romana a Chiusi. Il complesso produttivo di Marcianella. Bari, Edipuglia.Google Scholar
Rix, H. (1963) Das etruskische Cognomen. Untersuchungen zu System, Morphologie und Verwendung der Personennamen auf den jüngeren Inschriften Nordetruriens. Wiesbaden, Harrassowitz.Google Scholar
Roth, R. (2007) Styling Romanisation: Pottery and Society in Central Italy. Cambridge/New York, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Roth, R. (2009) From clay to stone: monumentality and traditionalism in Volterran urns. American Journal of Archaeology 133: 39–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roth, R. (2010) Dichotomising the family in Hellenistic Etruria: forms of strategic display in elite burials. Acta Patristica et Byzantina 21: 176–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roth, R. (2013) Fragmented images: the last tomb paintings of Tarquinia. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 32: 187–201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salvadori, E. (2014) Le tombe con nicchiotti di Chiusi e del territorio chiusino. In Salvini, M. (ed.), Etruschi e Romani a San Casciano dei Bagni. Le stanze cassianensi: 61–75. Rome, Edizioni Quasar.Google Scholar
Sclafani, M. (2002) La tomba dei Matausni. Analisi di un contesto chiusino di età alto-ellenistica. Studi Etruschi 65–8: 121–61.Google Scholar
Sclafani, M. (2010) Urne fittili chiusine e perugine di età medio e tardo ellenistica. Rome, L'Erma di Bretschneider.Google Scholar
Shepherd, E.J. (2014) Le tegole della necropoli di Balena. In Salvini, M. (ed.), Etruschi e Romani a San Casciano dei Bagni. Le stanze cassianensi: 36–41. Rome, Edizioni Quasar.Google Scholar
Spivey, N.J. and Stoddart, S.K.E. (1990) Etruscan Italy. An Archaeological History. London, Batsford.Google Scholar
Steingräber, S. (1981) Etrurien: Städte, Heiligtümer, Nekropolen. Munich, Hirmer.Google Scholar
Steingräber, S. (1995) Funerary architecture in Chiusi. Etruscan Studies 2: 53–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steingräber, S. (2006) Abundance of Life: Etruscan Wall Painting (trans. Stockman, R.). Los Angeles, The J. Paul Getty Museum.Google Scholar
Stevens, N.L.C. (2001) Dating proposal concerning Hellenistic alabaster urns from Chiusi: a chronological appendix to E. Brunn-G. Körte, « I rilievi delle urne etrusche I-III ». BABesch 76: 101–13.Google Scholar
Suolahti, J. (1955) The Junior Officers of the Roman Army in the Republican Period. A Study on Social Structure. Helsinki, Academia Scientiarum Fennica.Google Scholar
Terrenato, N. (1998) The Romanization of Italy: global acculturation or cultural bricolage? In Forcey, C., Hawthorne, J. and Witcher, R. (eds), TRAC 97: Proceedings of the Seventh Annual Theoretical Roman Archaeology Conference Nottingham 1997: 20–7. Oxford, Oxbow Books.Google Scholar
Thimme, J. (1954) Chiusinische Aschenkisten und Sarkophage der hellenistischen Zeit. Ein Beitrag zur Chronologie der etruskischen Kunst. Studi Etruschi 23: 25–147.Google Scholar
Thimme, J. (1957) Chiusinische Aschenkisten und Sarkophage der hellenistischen Zeit. Ein Beitrag zur Chronologie der etruskischen Kunst. Zweiter Teil. Studi Etruschi 25: 87–160.Google Scholar
Thoden van Velzen, D. (1992) A game of tombs: the use of funerary practices in the conflict between Etruscans and Romans in the 2nd and 1st centuries BC in Chiusi, Tuscany. Archaeological Review from Cambridge 11: 65–76.Google Scholar
Tuck, A.S. (1994) The Etruscan seated banquet: Villanovan ritual and Etruscan iconography. American Journal of Archaeology 98: 617–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallace-Hadrill, A. (2008) Rome's Cultural Revolution. Cambridge/New York, Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Warden, P.G. (2013) The importance of being elite: the archaeology of identity in Etruria (500–200). In Evans, J.D. (ed.), A Companion to the Archaeology of the Roman Republic: 354–68. Chichester, Wiley-Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiseman, T.P. (1971) New Men in the Roman Senate, 139 B.C.–A.D. 14. London, Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Witcher, R. (2006) Settlement and society in early imperial Etruria. Journal of Roman Studies 96: 88–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Woolf, G. (1998) Becoming Roman: The Origins of Provincial Civilization in Gaul. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zanda, E. (2011) Fighting Hydra-like Luxury: Sumptuary Regulation in the Roman Republic. London, Bristol Classical Press.Google Scholar