Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T04:27:34.577Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Affirming the right to care, preserving the right to die: Disorders of consciousness and neuroethics after Schiavo

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 August 2006

JOSEPH J. FINS
JOSEPH J. FINS
Affiliation:
Division of Medical Ethics, New York Presbyterian–Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In this article, I attempt to untangle some of the cultural, philosophical, and ethical currents that informed the Schiavo case. My objective is to better apprehend what the Schiavo case means for end-of-life care in general and to assert that our discourse about the ethical issues attendant to brain injury will be impoverished if we limit our discussions about disorders of consciousness solely to the vegetative state. If we ignore emerging developments in neuroscience that are helping to elucidate the nature of these disorders and fail to broaden the conversation about brain injury, beyond the unmitigated futility of the permanent vegetative state, we will imperil others who might improve and be helped. Through such efforts we can help mitigate the tragedy of the Schiavo case and overcome the rhetoric that marked the national discourse in March 2005. Once the complexity of disorders of consciousness is appreciated, rhetorical statements about a right to die or a right to life are exposed as being incompatible with the challenge of providing care to such patients. This is especially true as neuroscience brings greater diagnostic refinement to their assessment and management, a topic addressed in this article, which specifically focuses on the clinical and ethical implications of the recently described minimally conscious state. Instead of staking out ideological positions that do not meet the needs of patients or families, we should strive to both preserve the right to die for those who are beyond hope while affirming the right to care to those who might benefit from coming advances in neuroscience. If we can achieve that delicate balance, we will be able to transcend the partisan debate that shrouded the life and death of Theresa Marie Schiavo and begin to articulate a palliative neuroethics of care for those touched by severe brain injury and disorders of consciousness.

Keywords

NeuroethicsNeuro-palliative careTerri SchiavoTerry WallisDisorders of consciousnessBrain injuryEthics
Type
Research Article
Information
Palliative & Supportive Care , Volume 4 , Issue 2 , June 2006 , pp. 169 - 178
Copyright
© 2006 Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Andrews, K., Murphy, L., Munday, R., et al. (1996). Misdiagnosis of the vegetative state: Retrospective study in a rehabilitation unit. British Medical Journal, 313(7048), 13–16.Google Scholar
Annas, G. (1990). Nancy Cruzan in China. Hastings Center Report, 20(5), 39–41.Google Scholar
Annas, G.J. (1996). The “right to die” in America: Sloganeering from Quinlan and Cruzan to Quill and Kevorkian. Duquesne Law Review, 34(4), 875–897.Google Scholar
Annas, G.J. (2005). “Culture of Life” politics at the bedside—The case of Terri Schiavo. New England Journal of Medicine, 352(16), 1710–1715.Google Scholar
Applebaum, P.S., Lidz, C.W., & Meisel, A. (1987). Informed Consent, Legal Theory and Clinical Practice. New York: Oxford University Press.
Banja, J. (1999). Patient advocacy at risk: Ethical, legal and political dimensions of adverse reimbursement practices in brain injury rehabilitation in the U.S. Brain Injury, 13(10), 745–758.Google Scholar
Beauchamp, T.L. & Childress, J.F. (1994). Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 4th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
Beecher, H.K. (1968). Ethical problems created by the hopelessly unconscious patient. New England Journal of Medicine, 278(26), 1425–1430.Google Scholar
Breitbart, W. (2002). Spirituality and meaning in supportive care: Spirituality- and meaning-centered group psychotherapy interventions in advanced cancer. Supportive Care in Cancer, 10(4), 272–280.Google Scholar
Bumiller, E. (2005). Supporters praise Bush's swift return to Washington. The New York Times, March 21, p. A15.
Cardozo, B. (1929). What medicine can do for law. Bulletin of The New York Academy of Medicine, 5(7), 581–607.Google Scholar
Carey, B. (2005). New signs of awareness seen in some brain injured patients. The New York Times, February 8, p. A1.
Cassell, E.J. (1982). The nature of suffering and the goals of medicine. New England Journal of Medicine, 306(11), 639–645.Google Scholar
Cassell, E.J. (1991). The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press.
Childs, N.L., Mercer, W.N., & Childs, H.W. (1993). Accuracy of diagnosis of persistent vegetative state. Neurology, 43(8), 1465–1467.Google Scholar
Christakis, N.A. (1999). Death Foretold: Prophecy and Prognosis in Medical Care. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Cohen, E. (2005). How liberalism failed Terri Schiavo. The question is not only what she would have wanted, but what we owe her. The Weekly Standard, 10(27). Available at: http://www.eppc.org/publications/pubID.2285/pub_detail.asp.Google Scholar
Colby, W.H. (2002). Long Goodbye, The Deaths of Nancy Cruzan. Carlsad, CA: Hay House.
Committee on Child Health Financing. (2005). Model contractual language for medical necessity for children. Pediatrics, 116(1), 261–262.Google Scholar
Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health (1990).
Didion, J. (2005). The case of Terri Schiavo. The New York Review of Books, June 9, vol. LII(10), pp. 60–69.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2000). A proposed ethical framework for interventional cognitive neuroscience: A consideration of deep brain stimulation in impaired consciousness. Neurological Research, 22(3), 273–278.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2002). When the prognosis leads to indifference. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 5(4), 571–573.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2003). Constructing an ethical stereotaxy for severe brain injury: Balancing risks, benefits and access. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 4(4), 323–327.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2004). Letter to the Editor re: A Patient's Wishes and Terri's Law. The New York Times, September 7, p. A22.
Fins, J.J. (2005a). Clinical pragmatism and the care of brain injured patients: Towards a palliative neuroethics for disorders of consciousness. Progress in Brain Research, 150, 565–582.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2005b). Interview on Lou Dobbs Tonight, March 31 (CNN).
Fins, J.J. (2005c). Letter to the Editor in response to Joan Didion piece on Terri Schiavo. The New York Review of Books, August 11, LII(13), 63.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2005d). Politicians cause trouble when they play physician. Op-Ed. Greenville (South Carolina) News, April 18, p. 7A.
Fins, J.J. (2005e). Rethinking disorders of consciousness: New research and its implications. Hastings Center Report, 35(2), 22–24.Google Scholar
Fins, J.J. (2006). A Palliative Ethic of Care: Clinical Wisdom at Life's End. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.
Fins, J.J. & Plum, F. (2004). Neurological diagnosis is more than a state of mind: Diagnostic clarity and impaired consciousness. Archives of Neurology, 61(9), 1354–1355.Google Scholar
Giacino, J.T., Ashwal, S., Childs, N., et al. (2002). The minimally conscious state: Definition and diagnostic criteria. Neurology, 58(3), 349–353.Google Scholar
Goldsmith, S. (2005). Cover photo. U.S. News & World Report, 138, cover.
Goodnough, A. (2005). Schiavo dies, ending bitter case over feeding tube. The New York Times, April 1, p. A1.
Hoffman, J.M., Doctor, J.N., Chan, L., et al. (2003). Potential impact of the new medicare prospective payment system on reimbursement for traumatic brain injury inpatient rehabilitation. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 84(8), 1165–1172.Google Scholar
Hulse, C. & Kirkpatrick, D.D. (2005). Congress passes and Bush signs Schiavo measure. The New York Times, March 21, p. A1.
In re Quinlan, 355 A 2d 647 (NJ 1976); cert denied 429 US 1992, 1976.
Jennett, B. (2002). The Vegetative State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jennett, B. & Plum, F. (1972). Persistent vegetative state after brain damage. A syndrome in search of a name. Lancet, 7753(1), 734–737.Google Scholar
Kirkpatrick, D.D. & Stolberg, S.G. (2005). How family's cause reached the halls of Congress. The New York Times, March 22, p. A1.
Kobylarz, E.J. & Schiff, N.D. (2004). Functional imaging of severely brain-injured patients: Progress, challenges, and limitations. Archives of Neurology, 61(9), 1357–1360.Google Scholar
Kobylarz, E.J. & Schiff, N.D. (2005). Neurophysiological correlates of persistent vegetative and minimally conscious states. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation, 15(3–4), 323–332.Google Scholar
Lammi, M.H., Smith, V.H., Tate, R.L., et al. (2005). The minimally conscious state and recovery potential: A follow-up study 2 to 5 years after traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 86(4), 746–754.Google Scholar
Laureys, S., Faymonville, M.E., Degueldre, C., et al. (2000). Auditory processing in the vegetative state. Brain, 123(8), 1589–1601.Google Scholar
Laureys, S., Owen, A.M., & Schiff, N.D. (2004). Brain function in coma, vegetative state and related disorders. Lancet Neurology, 3(9), 537–546.Google Scholar
Leo, J. (2005). A regrettable limit on life. U.S. News & World Report, 138(12), 54.Google Scholar
McCloskey, E.L. (1991). Bioethics inside the beltway: The Patient Self-Determination Act. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1(2), 163–169.Google Scholar
Meli, T. (2003). I am the Central Park Jogger. New York: Scribner.
Mills, C.W. (2000). The Power Elite. New York: Oxford University Press.
Multi-Society Task Force on PVS. (1994a). Medical aspects of the persistent vegetative state (1). New England Journal of Medicine, 330(21), 1499–1508.Google Scholar
Multi-Society Task Force on PVS. (1994b). Medical aspects of the persistent vegetative state (2). New England Journal of Medicine, 330(22), 1572–1579.Google Scholar
O'Connor, A. (2005, May 4). Brain-injured fireman's recovery takes science into a murky area. The New York Times, p. B1.
Office of the Press Secretary. (2005, March 17). President's Statement on Terri Schiavo. Available: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/03/20050317-7.html.
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990, Public law no. 10 1-508.
Osborn, C.L. (1998). Over My Head. Kansas City: Andrew McNeal Publishing.
Osler, W. (1904). The leaven of science. In Aequanimitas. London: H.K. Lewis.
Porter, R. (1997). Religion and medicine. In Companion Encyclopedia of the History of Medicine, W.F. Bynum, R. Porter (eds.). New York: Routledge.
Samuel, T. (2005). Bill Frist's balancing act. U.S. News & World Report, 138(12), 16–17.Google Scholar
Schiff, N.D. (2005). Modeling the minimally conscious state: Measurement of brain function and therapeutic possibilities. Progress in Brain Research, 150, 473–503.Google Scholar
Schiff, N.D. & Fins, J.J. (2003). Hope for “comatose” patients. Cerebrum, 5(4), 7–24.Google Scholar
Schiff, N.D., Ribary, U., Moreno, D.R., et al. (2002). Residual cerebral activity and behavioural fragments can remain in the persistently vegetative brain. Brain, 125(6), 1210–1234.Google Scholar
Schiff, N.D., Rodriguez-Moreno, D., Kamal, A., et al. (2005). fMRI reveals large-scale network activation in the minimally conscious state. Neurology, 64(3), 514–523.Google Scholar
Searle, J.R. (2002). Consciousness and Language. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Stevens, M.L. (1995). Redefining death in America, 1968. Caduceus, 11(3), 207–219.Google Scholar
Supreme Court of Florida. No. SC04-925. (2004, September 23). Jeb Bush, Governor of Florida, et al., Appellants vs. Michael Schiavo, guardian of Theresa Schiavo, Appellee.
Weldon, D. (2005, March 20) Statement on House Floor. Transcript from ABC's “This Week with George Stephanopolous.” Broadcast March 27, 2005.
Wilson, F.C., Harpur, J., Watson, T., et al. (2002). Vegetative state and minimally responsive patients—Regional survey, Long-term case outcomes and service recommendations. NeuroRehabilitation, 17(3), 231–236.Google Scholar
Wilson, J.Q. (2005). Killing Terri. The Wall Street Journal, March 21, p. A16.
Winslade, W.J. (1998). Confronting Traumatic Brain Injury: Devastation, Hope and Healing. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Wolfson, J. (2005). Erring on the side of Theresa Schiavo: Reflections of the special guardian ad litem. Hastings Center Report, 35(3), 16–19.Google Scholar
Wolfson, J. (2006). Defined by her dying, not her death: The guardian ad litem's view of Schiavo. Death Studies, 30(2), 113–120.Google Scholar