Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T13:13:04.876Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Casual factors underlying the dramatic decline of the Sumatran orang-utan

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 April 2009

J. M. Yarrow Robertson  and
Carel P. van Schaik
Carel P. van Schaik
Affiliation:
Department of Biological Anthropology and Anatomy, Duke University, Box 90383, Durham, NC 27708-0383, USA, and Wildlife Conservation Society, Asia Program, Bronx, NY 10460, USA
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The Sumatran orang-utan is in dramatic decline, including the population in its main stronghold, the Leuser Ecosystem, in Sumatra, Indonesia (C. P. van Schaik et al. (2001) Oryx 35, 14–25). The major threats to the survival of Sumatran orang-utans are identified as habitat loss (mainly from conversion to oil palm plantations), habitat degradation and habitat fragmentation. The immediate causes of this are identified as weak compliance with regulations and laws; weak law enforcement and the weak legal environment. Corruption is identified as the ultimate causal factor underlying these three immediate causal factors, along with a frontier mentality and bureaucratic constraints. Together, they have resulted in the destruction of prime orang-utan habitat. Several political actions are recommended to improve the effectiveness of habitat conservation for the orang-utan and several technical challenges are to be overcome once the policy context is right. The most crucial problem to solve is the lack of regular funds for enforcement operations and establishing a new system of enforcement that is effective. In addition, the Gunung Leuser National Park needs to be redesigned by enlarging it to cover all high biodiversity areas within the Leuser Ecosystem. Moreover, habitat corridors between important forest tracts need to be re-established.

Keywords

Corruptionillegal loggingLeuser Ecosystemorang-utanpolicySumatra
Type
Research Article
Information
Oryx , Volume 35 , Issue 1 , January 2001 , pp. 26 - 38
Copyright
Copyright © Fauna and Flora International 2001

References

Analisa (1998) Dishut Aceh Timur diminta ungkap pelaku pencurian kayu di lahan HPH PT. TRD. [The Aceh Timur Forestry Service is asked to uncover the identity of illegal loggers in the PT. TRD logging concession area.] 31.12.1998, 7.Google Scholar
Analisa (1999) Oknum aparat disinyalir dukung pencurian kayu di TNGL. [Certain security officials are suspected of supporting illegal logging activities in the Mount Leuser National Park.] 7.12.1999, 7.Google Scholar
Analisa (1999) Kasus perambahan hutan Leuser: Pangdam dan Kapolda harus tindak anggotanya yang diduga terlibat. [Encroachment in the Leuser forest area: the Regional Military Commander and the Provincial Police Chief must take action against their members who were allegedly involved.] 9.12.1999, 7.Google Scholar
Analisa (1999) Ratusan organisasi internasional menuntut penghentian perambahan liar di TNGL. [Hundreds of international organisations demand an end to encroachment activities in the Mount Leuser National Park.] 13.12.1999, 7.Google Scholar
Cohen, M. (2000) Wood cuts: illegal logging could stem the flow of aid to Indonesia. Far Eastern Economic Review, 27.01.2000, 20–22.Google Scholar
Colmey, J. & Liebhold, D. (1999) The Family Firm. Suharto Inc. Time Asia. 24.05.1999.Google Scholar
Delgado, R. & van Schaik, C.P. (2000) The orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus): behavioural ecology and conservation status: a tale of two islands. Evolutionary Anthropology, 9, 201–218.Google Scholar
EIA/Telapak (1999) The Final Cut: Illegal Logging in Indonesia's Orangutan Parks. Penebangan Liar Di Kawasan Perlindungan Di Indonesia. Environmental Investigation Agency, London & Washington, Telapak, Bogor, Indonesia.Google Scholar
IUCN/SSC (1997) Asian Rhinos: Status Survey and Conservation Action Plan. IUCN/SSC Asian Rhino Specialist Group (eds Foose, T. J. & van Strien, N.) IUCN, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
Kompas (2000) Sekjen Dephutbun: Yayasan Bukit Barisan terlibat kasus TNGL. [Secretary-General of Department of Forestry & Estate Crops: Regional Army Foundation involved in Mount Leuser National Park case.] 20.04.2000, 10.Google Scholar
Leuser Development Programme (1997) Overall Work Plan. Leuser Management Unit, Medan, Indonesia.Google Scholar
Leuser Development Programme (1999) Annual Report of the Leuser Development Programme 1998/1999. Leuser Management Unit, Medan, Indonesia.Google Scholar
Medan Pos (1998) Terjadi di Aceh Timur: Ribuan hektar hutan lindung punah dirambah PT. TRD. [Thousands of hectares of protection forest areas have been cleared by logging concessionaire PT. TRD in Aceh Timur.] 11.12.1998, 5.Google Scholar
Media Indonesia (2000) KKN menonjol di 10 instansi. [Corruption, collusion and nepotism exposed in 10 government agencies.] 28.06.2000, 1.Google Scholar
Monk, K.A. & Purba, D. (in press) Progress towards collaborative management of the Leuser Ecosystem, Sumatra, Indonesia. In Proceedings of the 2nd Regional Forum for South-East Asia of the IUCN World Commission for Protected Areas.Google Scholar
Prestasi (1999) Ekses pengrusakan TNGL di Bahorok Langkat: Kepmen diabaikan oleh GubSu dan Kakanwil Dephutbun. [Excess of the damage to the Mount Leuser National Park area in Bahorok Langkat: ministerial decree set aside by North Sumatra Governor and the Head of the Provincial Department of Forestry & Estate Crops Office.] 2.11.1999, 1, 7.Google Scholar
Prestasi (1999) Citra TNI/Polri buruk bila kasus TNGL tak tuntas. [The Military/Police will have a bad image if the Mount Leuser National Park case is not fully settled.] 11.12.1999, 1.Google Scholar
Purnomo, A. (2000) Overcapacity in forestry sector. The Jakarta Post, 27.01.2000, 4.Google Scholar
Rijksen, H.D. & Griffiths, M. (1995) Leuser Development Programme Masterplan. The Integrated Conservation and Development Project for Lowland Rainforest In Aceh. IBN-DLO, Wageningen, The Netherlands.Google Scholar
Rijksen, H.D. & Meijaard, E. (1999) Our Vanishing Relative: The Status of Wild Orang-Utans at the Close of the Twentieth Century. Tropenbos Publications. Wageningen. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
Robertson, J.M.Y. & van Schaik, C.P. (in press) Securing the survival of the Sumatran orang-utan. Proceedings of the 3rd Great Apes of the World Conference, Kucing, Sarawak, Vol. 2.Google Scholar
van Schaik, C.P., Monk, K.A. & Robertson, J.M.Y. (2001) Dramatic decline in orang-utan numbers in the Leuser Ecosystem. Northern Sumatra. Oryx 35, 14–25.Google Scholar
Serambi Indonesia (1998) Penebangan hutan Rawa Singkil makin menggila. [Clearing of forest areas in Singkil Swamp becoming more rampant.] 11.02.1998, 5.Google Scholar
Serambi Indonesia (1999a) Kayu curian iru punya Acan? [Is Acan the owner of the stolen timber?] 02.12.99, 6.Google Scholar
Serambi Indonesia (1999b) POM belum proses truk TNI angkut kayu curian: 141 kayu Tangkapan diduga milik Acan. [The Military Police have not processed the case of a military truck being used to transport stolen timber: 141 confiscated timber beams allegedly owned by Acan.] 02.12.1999, 7.Google Scholar
Serambi Indonesia (2000) Menhutbun: Acan babat 4,000 ha TNGL. [Minister of Forestry & Estate Crops: Acan cleared 4, 000 ha of Mount Leuser National Park.] 28.04.2000, 5.Google Scholar
Sinar Baru Indonesia (1999) Menteri Kehutanan dan Perkebunan akhirnya hentikan pembukaan sawit di TNGL: jalan yang telah dibuka diminta direhabilitasi kembali. [The Minister of Forestry & Estate Crops finally stops the opening of oil palm plantations in the Mount Leuser National Park area: the cleared path must be rehabilitated.] 2.11.1999, 3.Google Scholar
Sinar Baru Indonesia (1999) Sidang lanjutan kasus TNGL, hadirkan 6 saksi dari Polres Langkat: Tak seorangpun saksi tahu batas TNGL. [The proceeding of the Mount Leuser National Park case, testimony by 6 witnesses from the Langkat police: None of the witnesses is aware of the National Park boundary.] 13.12.1999, 9.Google Scholar
Sinar Baru Indonesia (2000) Muspida plus sepakat berhentikan perambahan hutan TNGL. [The Local Leadership Council members agree to stop the clearing of forests in the Mount Leuser National Park area.] 13.01.2000, 9.Google Scholar
Soedjati, D. (1999) Judiciary marred by distorted rule of law concept. The Jakarta Post 17.03.1999, 1.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999) Memorandum of economic and financial policies. 17.03.1999, 5.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999) Asian corruption remains serious problem: analyst. 26.03.1999, 10.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999) World Bank acts firmly. Editorial. 15.04.1999, 4.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999) No leakage? Editorial. 24.04.1999, 4.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999a) RI urged to adopt pact to fight bribery in country. 30.04.1999a, 1.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999b) Witnesses of Ciamis killing spree threatened. 30.04.1999b, 1.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (1999) Ministry uncovers Rp, 2.6, t. graft. 14.07.1999, 1.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Wanted: a good judge. Editorial. 4.02.2000, 4.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Forest team to probe corruption. 8.02.2000, 2.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Big names probed for alleged abuse of forestry funds. 17.02.2000, 8.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) WB upbeat government can fight corruption. 19.02.2000, 1.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Bob Hasan queried over US$2 b forestry fraud. 24.02.2000, 12.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Corruption in Asia threatens recovery. 23.03.2000, 8.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) ‘Bappenas must be dissolved’. 28.03.2000, 9.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) Timber tycoons piling war chests to ‘block probes’. 7.04.2000, 8.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000a) Former forestry minister questioned over graft case. 22.04.2000a, 2.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000b) Soldiers accused of extortion. 22.04.2000b, 9.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000) KL firms allegedly involved in illegal timber trade. 20.05.2000, 8.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000a) Gus Dur says Soeharto worth US$45 billion. 21.06.2000a, 2.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000b) Council says KKN remains rampant in administration. 21.06.2000b, 3.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000a) Annual session of the People's Consultative Assembly 2000: MPR approves nine decrees, TNI's presence included. 19.08.2000a, 2.Google Scholar
The Jakarta Post (2000b) Illegal logging involves ‘central government officials’. 19.08.2000b, 3.Google Scholar
The Rainforest Foundation (1998) Out of Commission: The Environmental and Social Impacts of European Union Development Funding in Tropical Forest Areas. The Rainforest Foundation. London, UK.Google Scholar
The World Bank (1997) Investing in Biodiversity: a Review of Indonesia's Integrated Conservation and Development Projects. The World Bank, Indonesia and Pacific Islands Country Development. Jakarta, Indonesia.Google Scholar
Unidjaja, F.D. (2000) Payoffs prominent in court system. The Jakarta Post, 22.03.2000, 2.Google Scholar
Waspada (1998) Hutan Aceh Timur gundul: dua perusahaan tanpa izin terus beroperasi. [Forests in Aceh Timur destroyed: two companies continue to operate without any license.] 09.02.1998, 6.Google Scholar
Waspada (1998) Ops sikat 98 dan jagawana amankan 80 tersangka perusak kawasan TNGL. [‘Clean Out’ Operation 98 and forest rangers arrest 80 persons accused of causing damage to the Mount Leuser National Park.] 10.08.1998, 5.Google Scholar
Waspada (1999) PT Inhutani IV backing perambahan hutan lindung. [National Forest company PT Inhutani IV backs up the clearing of protection forest.] 7.07.1999, 5.Google Scholar
Waspada (1999) Pencurian kayu di TNGL semakin mengganas: Diduga dibecking aparat. [Illegal logging activities more rampant in Mount Leuser National Park: Backing up by security officials suspected.] 8.12.1999, 5.Google Scholar
Waspada (1999) Soal perambahan TNGL: Pangdam I/BB dan Kapolda Aceh harus bertanggungjawab. [Encroachment problem in Mount Leuser National Park: The Commander of Regional Military Command I/BB and the Chief of the Aceh Police must be held accountable.] 9.12.1999.Google Scholar
Waspada (1999) Perambah TNGL forsir kekuatan. [Encroachers in Mount Leuser National Park gathering strength.] 15.12.1999, 5.Google Scholar
Waspada (2000) Di Panton ada Markas GPK bukan GBPK (GAM). [Headquarters of illegal logging ‘Movement’ at the Panton, but not Aceh Freedom Movement.] 2.03.2000, 5.Google Scholar
Winters, J. (1999) It pays to think big: history favours dictators who take billions not millions. Suharto Inc. Time Asia. 24.05.1999.Google Scholar