No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Polite Patriotism: The Edwardian Gentleman in English Music, 1904 to 1914
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 December 2018
Abstract
In Edwardian England many of the most widely acknowledged qualities of the national character coalesced around the figure of the English gentleman. One of his defining features was his emotional restraint, his ‘stiff upper-lip’. But these were also years during which patriotic and even nationalist sentiment rose to a high tide, and there was considerable tension between the whole-hearted expression of nationalism and the restrain demanded by gentlemanly manners. This article explores this tension as it was staged and negotiated in the folk-song rhapsodies and nature portraits by Vaughan Williams, Holst, Delius and others during the years from 1904 to 1914. As a methodological basis the article adopts the notion of musical subjectivity – that is, the idea that music can offer a virtual persona with which the listener is invited to identify, and as whom he or she may participate in the musical activity. In this context it is possible to identify aspects of musical rhetoric, namely, the manners which regulate the interaction between the virtual subjectivity and the listener. Ultimately the article suggests that it is the embodiment of gentlemanly manners, every bit as much as the use of folk-song or the representation of English landscape, that accounts for the particularly English quality commonly identified in this music.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press, 2018
Footnotes
I gratefully acknowledge the contributions of two anonymous reviewers. I am also grateful to Steve Fenna for thinking of me when he found a lovely old score of Brigg Fair in a second-hand bookshop.
References
1 ‘Art. Xi. – English Patriotic Poetry’, The Quarterly Review 192/384 (1900): 521Google Scholar.
2 Kipling, Rudyard, Stalky & Co (London: Macmillan, 1960), 209–213Google Scholar.
3 ‘Art. Xi. – English Patriotic Poetry’, 521–2.
4 As one remarkably clear example of this view, consider Percy Scholes’s article on ‘Nationalism in Music’ in the Oxford Companion To Music (London: Oxford University Press, 1938)Google Scholar, which opened with the following passage: ‘It is a generally accepted fact that the folk music of various races and nations (even when so near one another as those of Europe) differs in some more or less subtle way that can be accepted as expressing distinctions in national or racial feeling. This difference is inevitably carried into the work of the composers of those races and nations when they have not stultified their racial or national characteristics by adopting a mere cosmopolitan convention.’ One may well read the tensions between Howes’s, Frank The English Musical Renaissance (New York: Stein & Day, 1966)Google Scholar and Pirie’s, Peter The English Musical Renaissance (London: Victor Gollanz, 1979)Google Scholar as a contest between competing ideas as to what constitutes ‘Englishness’ in music.
5 Consciously or not, Wilfrid Mellers echoed the notorious Cecil Sharp when he attributed the ‘powerfully English effect of Elgar’s music, notwithstanding the Teutonic origins of his style’ to ‘the unconscious intrusion of inflexions derived not only from the English language but also from English folk song, and from the modal reflections of those melodies in Tudor polyphony’: Vaughan Williams and the Vision of Albion (London: Barrie & Jenkins, 1989), 9Google Scholar. Christopher Palmer’s biography of Delius is organized by reference to the various countries in which the composer lived and worked, and constructs his musical identity as a blend of these influences: Delius: Portrait of a Cosmopolitan (London: Duckworth, 1976)Google Scholar. Frank Howes criticized both Parry and Tovey on the basis that theirs was ‘essentially a German way of thinking musical thoughts … The next generation discovered that the method was wrong and began digging and planting direct into English soil’: The English Musical Renaissance, 143.
6 For example, see Marsh, Jan, Back to the Land: The Pastoral Impulse in England from 1880 to 1914 (London: Quartet Books, 1982)Google Scholar; Hewison, Robert, The Heritage Industry: Britain in a Climate of Decline (London: Methuen, 1987)Google Scholar; Howkins, Alun, ‘Greensleeves and the Idea of National Music’, in Patriotism: The Making and Unmaking of British National Identity, Volume III: National Fictions, ed. Samuel Raphael (London: Routledge, 1989), 89–98Google Scholar.
7 Stradling, Robert and Hughes, Meirion, The English Musical Renaissance, 1860–1940: Construction and Deconstruction (London: Routledge, 1993)Google Scholar.
8 Earle, Ben, ‘Modernism and Reification in the Music of Frank Bridge’, Journal of the Royal Musical Association 141/2 (2016): 384CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
9 Some examples include: Harrington, Paul, ‘Holst and Vaughan Williams: Radical Pastoral’, in Music and the Politics of Culture, ed. Christopher Norris (London: Lawrence and Wishart, 1989), 106–127Google Scholar; Whittall, Arnold, ‘The Signs of Genre: Britten’s Version of Pastoral’, in Sundry Sorts of Music Books: Essays on the British Library Collections: Presented to O.W. Neighbour on His 70th Birthday, ed. Chris Banks, Arthur Searle, and Malcolm Turner (London: The British Library, 1993), 363–374Google Scholar; Francmanis, John, ‘National Music to National Redeemer: The Consolidation of a “Folk-Song” Construct in Edwardian England’, Popular Music 21/1 (2002): 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Frogley, Alain, ‘Constructing Englishness in Music: National Character and the Reception of Vaughan Williams’, in Vaughan Williams Studies, ed. Alain Frogley (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 1–22Google Scholar; Riley, Matthew, ‘Rustling Reeds and Lofty Pines: Elgar and the Music of Nature’, 19th-Century Music 26 (2002), 155–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Dremel, Erik, Pastoral Träume: Die Idealisierung Von Natur in Der Englischen Musik 1900–1950 (Cologne: Böhlau, 2005)Google Scholar; Saylor, Eric, ‘“It’s Not Lambkins Frisking at All”: English Pastoral Music and the Great War’, The Musical Quarterly 91/1 (2008): 39–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Barone, Anthony, ‘Modernist Rifts in a Pastoral Landscape: Observations on the Manuscripts of Vaughan Williams’s Fourth Symphony’, The Musical Quarterly 91/1 (2008): 60–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Doctor, Jenny, ‘The Parataxis of “British Musical Modernism”’, The Musical Quarterly 91/1 (2008): 89–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Downes, Stephen, ‘Modern Maritime Pastoral: Wave Deformations in the Music of Frank Bridge’, in British Music and Modernism, 1895–1960, Matthew Riley (Farnham: Ashgate, 2010), 93–107Google Scholar.
10 Drawing on critical commentary by Schumann, Robert, Edward Cone makes the point succinctly in the chapter entitled ‘Participation and Identification’ in The Composer’s Voice (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1974), 118–119Google Scholar.
11 Poulet, George, ‘Phenomenology of Reading’, New Literary History 1/1 (October 1969): 53–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
12 Poulet, ‘Phenomenology of Reading’, 54.
13 Poulet, ‘Phenomenology of Reading’, 56.
14 Poulet, ‘Phenomenology of Reading’, 56.
15 Poulet, ‘Phenomenology of Reading’, 57.
16 Naomi Cumming makes the point in similar terms when she writes: ‘I might feel “desire” for a resolution, and feel it with an urgency that would make me uncomfortable if it were unfulfilled, but that desire is not a personal thing. I may feel an “expectancy” not as my personally formed expectation, but as a state predicated by the realization of a style’s possibilities. My mental states are not, effectively, my own’: The Sonic Self: Musical Subjectivity and Signification (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2000), 183–184Google Scholar.
17 See, for instance Lidov, David, ‘Mind and Body in Music’, Semiotica 1/3 (1987): 69–97Google Scholar; Hatten, Robert, Musical Meaning in Beethoven: Markedness, Correlation, and Interpretation (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1994)Google Scholar; Gritten, Anthony and King, Elaine, eds, Music and Gesture (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006)Google Scholar; Gritten, Anthony and King, Elaine, eds, New Perspectives on Music and Gesture (Farnham: Ashgate, 2011)Google Scholar; and Cox, Arnie, ‘Embodying Music: Principles of the Mimetic Hypothesis’, Music Theory Online 17/2 (2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
18 Cumming, The Sonic Self, 204. See also Cumming, Naomi, ‘The Subjectivities of “Ebarme Dich”’, Music Analysis 16/1 (1997): 5–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
19 Cone, The Composer’s Voice, 94.
20 Kramer, Lawrence, ‘The Mysteries of Animation: History, Analysis and Musical Subjectivity’, Music Analysis 20/2 (2001): 153–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Idem, Interpreting Music (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2010), 46–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
21 Kramer, Interpreting Music, 48.
22 McVeigh, Simon and Ehrlich, Cyril, ‘The Modernisation of London Concert Life around 1900’, in The Business of Music, ed. Michael Talbot (Liverpool University Press, 2002), 106Google Scholar.
23 McVeigh and Ehrlich suggest that the total potential London concert-going public might have numbered as few as 10,000: ‘The Modernisation of London Concert Life around 1900’, 108–9.
24 McVeigh and Ehrlich, ‘The Modernisation of London Concert Life around 1900’, 99.
25 Lloyd, T.O., Empire to Welfare State: English History 1906–1976, 2nd ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979), 24Google Scholar.
26 Howley, John, ‘Ave Atque Vale, Honestates’, The Monthly Review 19/55 (April 1905): 24Google Scholar.
27 Barker, Ernest, ‘Some Constraints on the English Character’, in Writing Englishness 1900–1950: An Introductory Sourcebook on National Identity, ed. Julie Giles and Tim Middleton (London: Routledge, 1995), 59Google Scholar.
28 ‘Attention to Little Things’, New London Journal 6/135 (1908): 84Google Scholar.
29 Jeune, Mary, ‘The Duchess of Teck’, The Contemporary Review 72 (1897): 782Google Scholar.
30 ‘Musings without Method’, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine 170/1034 (1901): 852Google Scholar.
31 Galsworthy, John, ‘Diagnosis of the Englishman’, The North American Review 201/714 (1915): 684Google Scholar.
32 Galsworthy, ‘Diagnosis of the Englishman’, 688.
33 Fyfe, H. Hamilton, ‘Nationality in Dramatic Art’, The Monthly Review 4/12 (September 1901): 98Google Scholar.
34 Ford, Ford Madox, The Spirit of the People: An Analysis of the English Mind (London: Alston Rivers, 1907), 144–145Google Scholar.
35 ‘English Genius in Music’, Musical Standard 4/84 (10 August 1895): 87–89 at 88Google Scholar.
36 Sykes, J., ‘Tears in Parliament’, The Leisure Hour (August 1901): 831–836 at 831Google Scholar.
37 Galsworthy, ‘Diagnosis of the Englishman’, 688.
38 Galsworthy, ‘Diagnosis of the Englishman’, 685.
39 Leadman, Wilfrid M., ‘Religion and Emotionalism’, Westminster Review 167/5 (1907): 493Google Scholar.
40 Baughan, Edward A., ‘The Gentleman in Music’, The Monthly Musical Record 31/371 (1901): 242Google Scholar.
41 Stapleton, Julia, ‘Citizenship Versus Patriotism in Twentieth-Century England’, The Historical Journal 48/1 (2005): 153CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
42 Orwell, George, ‘Notes on Nationalism’, Polemic 1 (October 1945)Google Scholar.
43 Stapleton, ‘Citizenship Versus Patriotism in Twentieth-Century England’, 153.
44 Chesterton, G.K., ‘The Patriotic Idea’, in England: A Nation: Being the Papers of the Patriots’ Club, Lucian Oldershaw (London: R. Brimley Johnson, 1904), 5Google Scholar.
45 Vaninskaya, Anna, ‘“My Mother, Drunk or Sober”: G.K. Chesterton and Patriotic Anti-Imperialism’, History of European Ideas 34 (2008): 538CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
46 Maurizio Viroli’s more recent suggestion that the critical distinction between patriotism and nationalism is that the ‘primary value [for patriots] is the republic and the free way of life that the republic permits’, whereas ‘for the nationalists, the primary values are the spiritual and cultural unity of the people’ is of limited relevance for the purposes of this study: as Viroli himself notes (and indeed laments), over the course of the nineteenth century civic-minded patriotism came to be coloured or tainted by the nationalist idea of the spirit of the people: For Love of Country: An Essay on Patriotism and Nationalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995)Google Scholar.
47 Hobhouse, L.T., Democracy and Reaction (London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1904), 17Google Scholar.
48 Chesterton, G.K., The Defendant, 2nd ed. (London: R. Brimley Johnson, 1902), 126Google Scholar.
49 Chesterton, The Defendant, 129.
50 R.B.W, ‘The English Gentleman’, The National Review 7/38 (1886): 266Google Scholar.
51 Hobhouse, Democracy and Reaction, 70.
52 Collins, Marcus, ‘The Fall of the English Gentleman: The National Character in Decline, c. 1918–1970’, Historical Research 75/187 (2002): 93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
53 Scott, Charles Kennedy, ‘What of English Music’, The Musical Times 57, no. 879 (1916): 229CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
54 Cumberland, Gerald, ‘The Bane of Cleverness’, The Musical Times 61, no. 923 (1920): 17CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
55 Davies, H. Walford, ‘Music in Relation to Other Arts’, The Musical Times 51, no. 806 (1910): 237Google Scholar.
56 ‘Dr Walford Davies’, The Musical Times 49, no. 784 (1908): 365CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
57 Mcalpin, Colin, ‘Germany: Her Music’, The Musical Times 57, no. 882 (1916): 364Google Scholar.
58 Newman, Ernest, ‘Medtner’, The Musical Times 56, no. 863 (1915): 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
59 Hope, Anthony, ‘The Fly on the Wheel’, The Windsor Magazine: an Illustrated Monthly For Men and Women 1 (1895): 704Google Scholar.
60 Kennedy, Michael, A Catalogue of the Works of Ralph Vaughan Williams (London: Oxford University Press, 1964), 29Google Scholar.
61 Importantly, as Michael Vaillancourt notes, before 1903 Vaughan Williams appears to have held a quite different and far less positive attitude towards English folk-song: Vaillancourt, Michael, ‘Coming of Age: The Earliest Orchestral Works of Ralph Vaughan Williams’, in Vaughan Williams Studies, ed. Alain Frogley (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 25Google Scholar.
62 See for instance, Ernest Newman, who wrote that ‘the self-contained and self-evolving great nation is a myth. One is almost tempted to say that “the Frenchman”, “the German”, “the Englishman” and all the rest of them are myths. Our good friends the nationalists and the folk-song enthusiasts always seem to me to come to grief here’: ‘Debussy on Nationality in Music’, The Musical Times 51, no. 813 (1910): 700CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
63 Charles Kennedy Scott described folk-song as ‘the source’, or the ‘deep pure waters’ of English national music: ‘What of English Music’, Musical Times 57, no. 879 (1916): 229Google Scholar. The inimitable Cecil Sharp understood it as ‘a communal and racial product, the expression, in musical idiom, of aims and ideals that are primarily national in character’: English Folk Song: Some Conclusions, 4th ed. (London: Mercury Books, 1965), xxivGoogle Scholar.
64 ‘English Folk-song’, The Musical Times 52, no. 816 (1911): 102Google Scholar.
65 ‘English Folk-song’, 104.
66 ‘Music in Relation to Other Arts’, The Musical Times 51, no. 806 (1910): 237Google Scholar.
67 Helsinger, Elizabeth K., Rural Scenes and National Representation: Britain 1815–1850 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1997), 24Google Scholar.
68 Robert Stradling and Meirion Hughes, in their ‘deconstruction’ of the English musical renaissance, emphasize the irony of a German playing so pivotal a role in the English folk-song revival. They argue that Engel’s importance has been downplayed by subsequent historians of English music such as Frank Howes and Michael Kennedy: The English Musical Renaissance, 1860–1940, 62–64.
69 Cecil Sharp’s reputed first encounter with English folk art occurred at Christmas in 1899, when he saw a performance by the Headington Morris Dancers. His interest was sparked again in 1903 when he overheard a gardener (named John England) sing the folk-song ‘The Seeds of Love’: Karpeles, Maud, An Introduction to English Folk Song (London: Oxford University Press, 1973), 92Google Scholar.
70 Stradling and Hughes, The English Musical Renaissance, 1860–1940, 65.
71 Cecil Sharp was renowned for his successful ‘collection’ technique: ‘It is not given to everybody to combine the pachydermatous spirit and insidious bedside manner demanded in order to induce the old folks to sing, with the skill to quickly write down queer modal tunes in queerer rhythms, and set sometimes to highly embarrassing words’: ‘Occasional Notes’, The Musical Times 47, no. 755 (January 1906): 26Google Scholar.
72 Frank Howes suggested that ‘the rhapsody was the accepted way of overcoming the recalcitrance of self-subsistent national tunes to the third-degree processes of symphonic music’. The English Musical Renaissance, 155.
73 Fenby, Eric, Delius as I Knew Him (London: G Bell & Sons, 1936), 63Google Scholar.
74 Beecham, Thomas, Delius (London: Hutchinson & Co, 1959)Google Scholar.
75 Palmer, Christopher, Delius: Portrait of a Cosmopolitan (London: Duckworth, 1976)Google Scholar. For instance, Palmer suggests that Delius was probably not ‘conscious of the magnitude of his debt’ to his wife Jelka, but simply and ungraciously ‘accepted it merely as his right’: ibid., x.
76 ‘On Shearing the Black Sheep in Spring’, in Music and the Politics of Culture, ed. Christopher Norris (London: Lawrence and Wishart, 1989), 74–75Google Scholar.
77 Delius was introduced to the folk-song ‘Brigg Fair’ by Percy Grainger, who had ‘collected’ it near Lincoln in 1905 and published a part-song arrangement of it in 1906. The two met during Delius’s visit to London in April 1907 when Delius meet with Henry Wood to arrange performances of the Piano Concerto for the coming Autumn. At that time Grainger provided Delius with a copy of his arrangement. Subsequently in a letter to the pianist Sźantó dated 11 July Delius remarked that he had completed his ‘English Rhapsody’: Carely, Lionel, Delius: A Life in Letters, volume I: 1862–1908 (London: Scolar Press, 1983), 278–299Google Scholar.
78 Carely, Delius: A Life in Letters, I, 278. Beecham, Delius, 143–4.
79 Peter Pirie described this passage as ‘utterly English’, and identified it as one of the earliest manifestations of ‘this elusive quality’ in English music, although by way of definition he could do no better than identify it by example; see The English Musical Renaissance, 55.
80 Earle, ‘Modernism and Reification in the Music of Frank Bridge’, 383.
81 Foss, Hubert, Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Study (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1950), 75Google Scholar.
82 Earle, ‘Modernism and Reification in the Music of Frank Bridge’, 382–4.
83 Barone, ‘Modernist Rifts in a Pastoral Landscape’, 84.
84 Earle, ‘Modernism and Reification in the Music of Frank Bridge’, 382 and 384.
85 Michael Kennedy, ‘Vaughan Williams: Pastoral Symphony/Norfolk Rhapsodies 1 & 2’, liner notes to Vaughan Williams: Pastoral Symphony, London Symphony Orchestra, Richard Hickox, Chandos, CHAN 10001, 2002.
86 In addition to Butterworth’s orchestral works discussed here, Stephen Banfield notes a Barcarolle performed in 1903 but now lost, and a Fantasia of 1914 which I have not been able to locate either in the form of a score or recording. See Stephen Banfield, ‘Butterworth, George’, in Grove Music Online (accessed 29 September 2018).
87 Vaillancourt, ‘Coming of Age’, 37.
88 ‘English Folk-Song and English Music’, The Musical Times 51, no. 809 (1910), 428CrossRefGoogle Scholar.