Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T22:15:34.393Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Striptease’ as Ideology

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 April 2011

Steven Huebner
Steven Huebner
Affiliation:
McGill University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Vincent d'Indy's Istar (1897), a set of variations for orchestra, commands attention for its unusual ground plan: the variations proceed from complex textures to simple ones. Analysis reveals how certain melodic and harmonic details unfold at larger structural levels. Istar's symmetries and organic construction are set in the context not only of previous variation sets but also of Debussy's Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune, a symphonic poem of similar dimensions that was premiered shortly before d'Indy composed his piece. Resemblances between the two works suggest that d'Indy may have intended Istar as a response to Debussy. Juxtaposition of Debussy and d'Indy provides insight into the different connotations of modernity at the fin de siècle. Istar's programme and compositional strategies reflect d'Indy's firm historicism and commitment to tradition. Yet the work was received as experimental and daring in its day. In its materials Istar paradoxically illustrates a ‘backward progression’: its stylistic allusions move backward in time, yet the tonal direction aims forward towards the concluding tonic. Such idiosyncrasies provide insight into d'Indy's aesthetics and ideology, which sought to conflate commitment to progress with adherence to Faith.

Type
Articles
Information
Nineteenth-Century Music Review , Volume 1 , Issue 2 , November 2004 , pp. 3 - 24
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2004

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘Je pioche mes variations assyriennes, déjà très avancées. Elles se présentent bien, mais qui diable pourra bien comprendre ce morceau bizarrement bâti? Toi peut-être.’ From letter fragment cited in Maus, Madeleine Octave, Trente années de lutte pour l'art 1884–1914 (Brussels, 1926), 214Google Scholar.

2 ‘ça m'a énormément amusé à écrire’. Letter of 15 Sept. 1896, cited by Léon Vallas, Vincent D'Indy (Paris, 1946–1950), 2: 237Google Scholar; the letter is at Bibliothèque nationale, Mus., Vincent D'Indy, l.a.s. 181. Here D'Indy also wrote: ‘Je n’en suis pas mécontent, seulement ce contentement me restera personnel (et avec quelques amis), car je doute fort qu'un public quelconque comprenne la façon insolite dont mon morceau est bâti.’

3 Letter to his father, 17 Sept. 1896, in d'Indy, Vincent, Ma vie, ed. D'Indy, Marie (Paris, 2001), 548.Google Scholar

4 Review of Trouhanova, Concerts de Danse, Comœdia illustré, 15 May 1912Google Scholar.

5 Performances took place on 3 and 9 May 1911 at the Châtelet theatre with the Colonne orchestra.

6 See Brussel's, major article ‘Préambule pour deux concerts de danse’, Le Courrier musical, 1 May 1911Google Scholar.

7 Performances took place on 22, 23, 25 and 27 April 1912 at the the Châtelet theatre with the Lamoureux orchestra.

8 Vallas, Léon, Vincent d'Indy, 2: 237.Google Scholar

9 See Hart, Brian, ‘Wagner and the Franckiste “Message-Symphony” in Early Twentieth-Century France’, in Von Wagner zum Wagnérisme: Musik, Literatur, Kunst, Politik, ed. Fauser, Annegret and Schwartz, Manuela (Leipzig, 1999), 315–37; andGoogle ScholarFulcher, Jane F., French Cultural Politics and Music: From the Dreyfus Affair to the First World War (New York, 1999), 65–6Google Scholar.

10 D'Indy, Vincent, Cours de composition musicale, ed. Sé¶Ôeyx, Auguste and Lioncourt, Guy de, 3 vols (Paris, 1: 1899; 2/1: 1909; 2/2: 1933; and 3: 1950).Google Scholar

11 Andrew Thomson, Vincent D'Indy and His World (Oxford, 1996), 113.

12 Barthes, Roland, ‘Striptease’, Mythologies, trans. Lavers, Annette (London, 1972), 84–7.Google Scholar

13 ‘l'autre échafaudait des variations sur un thème, qui ne se montrait qu'g la fin, descendant peu à peu du compliqué au simple. C’étaient des joujoux très savants. Il fallait être à la fois très vieux et très enfant pour pouvoir s’en amuser.’ Rolland, Romain, Jean-Christophe (Paris, 1931), 1:690–91Google Scholar.

14 D'Indy, , Cours, 1: 9–10.Google Scholar

15 Jullien, Adolphe, Review of Istar, Le Journal des débats, 23 Jan. 1898. Reviews byGoogle ScholarKufferath, Maurice, Le Guide musical, 17 Jan. 1897Google Scholar; Borne, Fernand Le, Le Monde artiste, 23 Jan. 1898Google Scholar; Imbert, Hugues, Le Guide musical, 23 Jan. 1898Google Scholar; Barbedette, Henri, Le Ménestrel, 23 Jan. 1898Google Scholar; Mercadier, Auguste, Le Monde musical, 30 Jan. 1898Google Scholar.

16 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/1: 435–87.Google Scholar

17 Ibid., 484–6. Other published analyses of Istar include Vallas, , Vincent D'Indy, 2: 236–41;Google ScholarDemuth, Norman, A Course in Musical Composition (London, n.d.), 2: 56–61;Google ScholarCook, Peter, ‘Vincent d'Indy's Istar’, Music Review, 52 (1991): 237–45;Google ScholarEhrhardt, Damien, ‘Zwischen Symphonie und Drama. Die Programmmusik und ihre Gattungen bei Vincent D'Indy’, in Pluralismus wider Willen? Stilistische Tendenzen in der Musik Vincent D'Indys, ed. Schwartz, Manuela and Keym, Stefan (Hildesheim, 2002), 45–8.Google Scholar Demuth, Cook, and Ehrhardt closely follow d'Indy's analysis but do not go much beyond it. Nor do they position Istar in a wider context, although Cook does discuss the Babylonian myth upon which the piece is based. Ehrhardt points out that Schumann also positions the theme at the end of a variation set in his early Beethoven-Variationen, but notes that this work was unlikely to have been an influence on d'Indy because it had not been published by the time Istar was composed.

18 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/1: 447.Google Scholar

19 Ibid., 448.

20 For concise surveys of d'Indy's constructions of history see Thomson, , Vincent d'Indy, 77–95;Google ScholarHuebner, Steven, French Opera at the Fin de Siècle: Wagnerism, Nationalism, and Style (Oxford, 1999), 301–16Google Scholar.

21 D'Indy, , Cours, 1: 123–32.Google Scholar

22 In the Cours analysis of Istar it is claimed that all the variations are in keys closely related to F minor. That is the case for all of them except Variation 4 in F sharp major. In other words, in the case of a minor mode tonic, the minor dominant falls within the range of close modulations. Nevertheless, it should be recognized that the piece is directed toward a major mode conclusion.

23 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/2: 167–8.Google Scholar

24 ‘Chacune de ces sept Variations est dans une tonalité voisine de celle de fa, et l'ordre de ces tonalités procède par modulations à la sixième quinte (quarte augmentée), afin que tout se rapporte au principal personnage, sans changements trop brusques accusant un excès d'ombre ou de lumière: ces modulations, en effet, comme on l'a vu cidessus (p. 258), sont neutres.’ D'Indy, , Cours, 2/1: 486Google Scholar.

25 For a general discussion of Beethoven as model for d'Indy see Seiberts, Ruth, Studien zu den Sinfonien Vincent d'Indys (Mainz, 1998), 85–90Google Scholar.

26 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/2: 127–8.Google Scholar

27 Ibid., 146–7.

28 For an overview see Webster, James, ‘The Form of the Finale of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony’, Beethoven Forum, 1 (1992): 25–62.Google Scholar

29 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/1: 482.Google Scholar

30 The chapter is in Cours 2/2: 297–332.Google Scholar

31 Letter to Michel Calvocoressi, 16 Apr. 1908, Bibliothèque nationale, Mus., Vincent D'Indy, l.a.s. 74.

32 D'Indy, , Cours, 2/2: 315.Google Scholar

33 Ibid., 325.

34 ‘[ils] portent la marque du véritable “génie” de l'auteur, encore qu’il n’y ait pas, à proprement parler, d'“enseignement,” à en recueillir, au point de vue de la composition.’ Ibid., 322.

35 Bréville is cited by Laloy, Louis in ‘Vincent D'Indy’, La Revue musicale, 15 Dec. 1903Google Scholar.

36 Letter to Willy, 10 Oct. 1895, Debussy, , Correspondance 1884–1918, ed. Lesure, François (Paris, 1993), 114Google Scholar.

37 For a sensitive analysis of the conclusion see Code, David, ‘Hearing Debussy Reading Mallarmé: Music après Wagner in the Prélude à l'après-midi d’un faune,’ Journal of the American Musicological Society, 54 (2001): 493–548CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Ibid., 548.

39 Fulcher, , French Cultural Politics, 65.Google Scholar

40 Winock, Michel, Nationalisme, antisémitisme, et fascisme en France (Paris, 1990), 165.Google Scholar

41 Schorske, Carl E., Thinking with History: Explorations in the Passage to Modernism (Princeton, 1998), 3.Google Scholar

42 Frisch, Walter, ‘Reger's Bach and Historicist Modernism’, 19th-Century Music, 25 (2001–2002), 296–312.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

43 Pasler, Jann, ‘Paris: Conflicting Notions of Progress’, Music and Society: The Late Romantic Era, ed. Samson, Jim (Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1991), 401–3.Google Scholar

44 Hart, , ‘Wagner and the Franckiste “Message-Symphony”’, 327.Google Scholar He emphasizes that the modernity-tradition argument was advanced not by the composer but rather by his pupil René de Castéra.

45 ‘Me voici de retour de Londres, dans l'enthousiasme des sculptures assyriennes du British Museum: quel bel art et quel flagrant délit de vie et de vérité dans ces tableaux d’une civilisation qui valait bien la nôtre! … J'éprouve une impression bien plus grande et plus réellement artistique devant l'art assyrien du VIIIe siècle avant J.C. que devant celui de Péricles.’ Cited in Vallas, , Vincent D'Indy, 2: 238Google Scholar.

46 Unfortunately I have been unable to locate the source that D'Indy excerpted for the programme, the so-called ‘Epopée d’Izdubar’. Sources I have used are all thematically concordant with the programme. They include: Moran, William, ‘The Gilgamesh Epic: A Masterpiece from Ancient Mesopotamia’, Civilizations of the Ancient Near East, ed. Sasson, Jack M. (New York, 1995), 2327–36;Google ScholarJacobsen, Thornkild, Treasures of Darkness: A History of Mesopotamian Religion (New Haven, 1976)Google Scholar; Babylonian and Assyrian Literature, Comprising the Epic of Izdubar, Hymns, Tablets, and Cuneiform Inscriptions, trans. Hamilton, Leonidas Le Cenci, rev. edn (New York, 1901)Google Scholar.

47 Babylonian and Assyrian Literature, 92.

48 ‘enfin Fervaal est d'une esthétique rigoureusement opposée à celle du génie de Bayreuth: celle-ci accumulant les moyens pour atteindre le maximum d'effet … celle-là procédant en sens inverse, s'acheminant du complexe au simple selon nos traditions plus hautains et désintéressées. Avec Wagner, en effet, lœuvre se trouble dans la mesure où elle se rapproche de ses fins. Avec d'Indy, elle se simplifie, se clarifie pour conclure dans cette atmosphère spirituelle de pureté suprême et de conciliation sentimentale qui sont, pour tout être bien né, des miroirs de la perfection du monde. La fin de Fervaal? un solo de ténor dans l'écho d'un chœur lointain. La fin d'Istar? une affirmation impérieuse de cet art monodique médiéval ou l'accord est de trop. La fin de la Légende de Saint-Christophe? Un chœur d'où l'orchestre est exclus.’ Giriat, Pierre, ‘Remarques sur l'œuvre dramatique’, Latinité (Mar. 1930)Google Scholar.