No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Silence, Metaphor and the Communication of Religious Meaning Part I
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 February 2024
Extract
In his important study of The New Era in Religious Communication, Pierre Babin offers a startling juxtaposition of two very different thought- world. First, he introduces us to the practice, among some Indian tribes living in the Canadian wilderness, of plugging children’s nostrils and covering their eyes soon after birth, the better to attune them to the noises of the forest in which they will have to survive. Then, in stark contrast to these “hyperauditory” individuals, made alert to the subtlest natural sounds: the whisper of snow falling on the leafless branches of aspen and birch, the footfalls of deer in soft summer mud, the long indrawn breath of a hibernating bear and so on, Babin invites readers to consider a modem American adolescent reared in front of the brash sights and sounds of the TV screen. Such an individual will have logged some 20,000 hours of viewing by the age of sixteen. How, Babin asks, can these two individuals be supposed to have the same reference range or to have a similar idea of God and the transcendent? Is it possible that their sense of the holy could follow even remotely similar contours or be effectively explored or addressed by a single method of approach?
To some extent, the hyperauditory Indian and the media-saturated American can be taken as representing two forms of consciousness and communication which Babin spends much of his book outlining. On the one hand there is the linear, analytic, and alphabetical mode.
- Type
- Original Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 1993 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers
References
1 Babin, Pierre, The New Era in Religious Communication, tr. Smith, David, Minneapolis: 1991, pp 56–57Google Scholar.
2 Ibid., p 118.
3 Ibid., p 120.
4 Otto, Rudolf, The Idea of the Holy, tr. Harvey, John W, London: 1923, p 6Google Scholar.
5 Quoted (from Suzuki's Mysticism Christian and Buddhist) by Morgan, John H in “Silence as Creative Therapy: a Contemplative Approach to Pastoral Care”, Journal of Pastoral Care, Vol. 29 (1975), p 249.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
6 Smart, Ninian, Beyond Ideology, Religion and the Future of Western Civilization, London: 1981, p 21Google Scholar.
7 The Stories of Heinrich Böll, tr. Leila Vennevitz, London: 1988. The story in question is “Murke's Collected Silences”, pp 495–513.
8 Jones, Rufus M, “Silence”, inHastings, James (ed.), the Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics, Edinburgh:1920, 12 volsGoogle Scholar.
9 McCumsey, Elizabeth, “Silence”, in Eliade, Mircea (ed.), the Encyclopedia of Religion, New York: 1987, 16volsGoogle Scholar.
10 Leeuw, Gerardus van der, Religion in Essence and Manifestation, tr. Turner, J E, London: 1938, p 433Google Scholar.
11 Buren, Paul van, The Edges of Language, London: 1972, p 157Google Scholar.
12 Hardy, Alister, The Spiritual Nature of Man, Oxford: 1979, p 28Google Scholar.
13 Hay, David, Exploring Inner Space, Harmondsworth: 1982, p 28Google Scholar.
14 Thomas Carlyle, Essays, “Memoirs of the Life of Scott”, quoted in Stevenson' s Dictionary of Quotations, p 1823.
15 Henry David Thoreau, Journal, entry for February 9 1841.
16 Seraphina Lansdown, “The Language of Silence”, the Downside Review, Vol. 98 (1980), pp 1–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
17 Dauenhauer, Bernard P, “On Silence”, Research in Phenomenology, Vol. 3 (1973), p. 9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
18 Ibid.
19 Tong, Lik Kuen, “The Meaning of Philosophical Silence: Some Reflections on the Use of Language in Chinese Thought”, Journal of Chinese Philosophy, Vol. 3 (1976), p 169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
20 Ibid.
21 Abhisiktananda (Henri La Saux), Prayer London: 1967, p 40Google Scholar.
22 Rosen, Stanley, Nihilism: a Philosophical Essay, New Haven: 1969Google Scholar, as cited in Cormier, Ramona, “Silence in Philosophy and Literature”, Philosophy Today, Vol. 22 (1978), p 301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
23 Hassan, Ihab, The Literature of Silence, New York: 1967Google Scholar, as cited by Cormier, op. cit.
24 Steiner, George, Language and Silence, London: 1967, p 67.Google Scholar
25 Ibid., pp 67–8.
26 Ibid., p 65.
27 Ibid., p 58.