Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T00:42:27.540Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Ideology—the New Blackfriars Debate 1973 — 1984. A case study in Christian left thought

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2024

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

During the 1970s, there appeared in New Blackfriars a series of articles on the theme of the relationship between Christianity and Marxism. The inspiration for this debate lay partly with those who had been involved with the journal Slant, which was published by Sheed and Ward between 1964 and 1970, and notably Terry Eagleton and Brian Wicker.

Although not covering very many pages put together, the New Blackfriars debate covered an enormous range of issues. However, from Denys Turner’s first article (1973) onwards, the concept of ideology was among the most prominent. This concept also played a major part in the more systematic argument developed by Turner in his subsequent book, Marxism and Christianity (1983b). My aim in this article is critically to defend Turner’s account as one which is still useful and relevant.

I will avoid discussing the question as to whether the use made of this central concept by Turner was really Marxist or not. Turner deliberately eschewed the question of labelling in his contributions to the debate, and Herbert McCabe, the editor of New Blackfriars, decided not to publish an article whose main aim was to show that Turner was not a real Marxist. In so far as the question is of relevance to him, Turner views Marxism as a tradition to be lived out in the form of a revolutionary praxis. Hence, therefore, an intellectual synthesis of Christianity and Marxism, even if it could be achieved, would be inadequate; what matters is that there should be a form of life which enables one to live out both traditions.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © 1987 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers

References

Place of publication of books is London unless otherwise stated. All the articles listed appeared in New Blackfriars..Google Scholar
Barker, F. (1976): ‘The Morality of Knowledge and the Disappearance of God’ in Vol. 57 No. 676.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barker, F. (1977): ‘Science and Ideology’ in Vol. 58 No. 680.Google Scholar
Eliot, G. (1866): Felix Holt, the Radical (ed. Penguin, , 1972).Google Scholar
Giddens, A. (1981): The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies (2nd edn; Hutchinson).Google Scholar
Lash, N.L.A. (1981): A Matter of Hope: A Theologian's Reflections on the Thought of Karl Marx (Darton , Longman & Todd).Google Scholar
Lash, N.L.A. (1983): Review of Turner (1983b) in Vol. 64 No. 762.Google Scholar
Lukes, S.M. (1974): Power (Macmillan).Google Scholar
McCabe, O.P. H. (1964): The New Creation (Sheed & Ward).Google Scholar
Marx, K.H. (1867): Capital Vol. 1 (ed. & trans. Penguin, 1976).Google Scholar
Oestreicher, P. (1968): Preface to Klugmann, J. & Oestreicher, (eds), What Kind of Revolution? A Christian‐Communist Dialogue (Penguin, 1968).Google Scholar
Rhys, G.S. (1986): Alienation, Ideology and the Christian Left 1970–85 (M. Phil, thesis, Oxford University).Google Scholar
Schattschneider, E.E, (1960): The Semisovereign People (Holt, Reinhart & Winston, New York ).Google Scholar
Thompson, E.P. (1978): The Poverty of Theory and Other Essays (Merlin).Google Scholar
Thompson, J.B. (1984): Studies in the Theory of Ideology (Polity, Cambridge ).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1973): ‘Morality is Marxism’ in Vol. 54 Nos. 633 & 634.Google Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1975): ‘Can a Christian be a Marxist?’ in Vol. 56 No. 661.Google Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1977): ‘Marxism, Christianity and Morality’ in Vol. 58 No. 683.Google Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1978): ‘The “Subject” and the “Self”’ in Vol. 59 No 694.Google Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1983a): ‘Sacrament and Ideology’ in Vol. 64 No. 754.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1983b): Marxism and Christianity (Blackwell, Oxford ).Google Scholar
Turner, D.M. (1984): ‘Marx, Matter and Christianity’ in Vol. 65 No. 764.Google Scholar
Wall, A. (1975): ‘Slant and the Language of Revolution’ in Vol. 56 No. 666.Google Scholar
Wicker, B. (1975): ‘Marxists and Chrsitians: Questions for Denys Turner’ in Vol. 56 No. 665.Google Scholar
Wicker, B. (1976): ‘Sincerity, Authenticity and God’ in Vol. 57 No. 672.Google Scholar
Wicker, B. (1977): ‘Marxist Science and Christian Theology’ in Vol. 58 No. 681.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wicker, B. (1978): ‘“God” and Ideology’ in Vol. 59 No. 695.Google Scholar