Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T20:26:46.177Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

To reject or not to reject nationalism: debating Marx and Engels’ struggles with nationalism, 1840s–1880s

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Michal Kasprzak
Michal Kasprzak*
Affiliation:
Department of History, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada
*
*Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The relationship between Marxism and nationalism has been tumultuous. While theoretically attempting to reject nationalism as a transient product of capitalism, Marxism has in practice oftentimes exploited its appeal and utilized its extensive institutional repertoire. To a large extent, the difficult dialogue between the two ideological constellations can be traced back to Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels who neglected to leave a definitive statement on the nationality question. The article traces the evolution of Marxism's conceptualization of the nationality question – a slow shift from an outright rejection of nationalism to an acceptance of its progressive features, complexity, varieties and influences. It re-evaluates Marx and Engels’ views on the nationality question, from its outright denial to limited acceptance and application. After identifying factors that shaped their perception of the nationality question, the study offers an analysis of the evolution of these attitudes from the 1840s to the 1860s. The objective is to show how Marx and Engels’ theoretical dogmatism was tainted by their desire for activism. Their views were not inflexible but rather evolved in response to changing circumstances in the mid 19th century.

Keywords

MarxismnationalismKarl Marx and Friedrich Engelshistoriography
Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 40 , Issue 4 , July 2012 , pp. 585 - 606
Copyright
Copyright © 2012 Association for the Study of Nationalities 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Avineri, Shlomo. “Marxism and Nationalism.” Journal of Contemporary History 26.3–4 (1991): 637–57. Print.Google Scholar
Bakunin, Mikhail. “Marx, Engels and Lenin.” Australian Journal of Politics & History 25. 1 (1979): 29–38. Print.Google Scholar
Bakunin, Mikhail. “Patriotism's Part in Man's Struggle.” The Political Philosophy of Bakunin: Scientific Anarchism. Ed. Maximoff, G.P. Glencoe: The Free P, 1953. Print.Google Scholar
Bakunin, Mikhail. “Fatherland and Nationality.” The Political Philosophy of Bakunin: Scientific Anarchism. Ed. Maximoff, G.P. Glencoe: The Free P, 1953. Print.Google Scholar
Bakunin, Mikhail. “Class Interests in Modern Patriotism.” The Political Philosophy of Bakunin: Scientific Anarchism. Ed. Maximoff, G.P. Glencoe: The Free P, 1953. Print.Google Scholar
Bębenek, Marian. “Innowacja i tradycja w refleksji klasykow marksizmu nad sjawiskiem narodowym.” Studia Filozoficzne 257.4 (1987). Print.Google Scholar
Benner, Erica. Really Existing Nationalisms: A Post-Communist View from Marx and Engels. Oxford: Clarendon, 1995. Print.Google Scholar
Berger, Stefan, and Smith, Angel. “Between Scylla and Charybdis: nationalism, Labour and ethnicity across five continents, 1870–1939.” Nationalism, Labour and ethnicity 1870–1939. Ed. Berger, Stefan and Smith, Angel. Manchester: Manchester UP, 1999. Print.Google Scholar
Bloom, Solomon F. The World of Nations: A Study of the National Implications in the Work of Karl Marx. New York: AMS, 1967. Print.Google Scholar
Ciołkosz, Adam. “Karl Marx and the Polish Insurrection of 1863.” The Polish Review 10.4 (1965). Print.Google Scholar
Connor, Walker. The National Question in Marxist–Leninist Theory and Strategy. Princeton: Princeton UP, 1984. Print.Google Scholar
Conquest, Robert. Where Marx Went Wrong. London: Chaucer, 1970. Print.Google Scholar
Davis, Horace B. Nationalism & Socialism: Marxist and Labor Theories of Nationalism to 1917. New York: Monthly Review P. 1967. Print.Google Scholar
Engels, Frederick. “The Beginning of the End in Austria.” originally published in Deutsche-Brüsseler-Zeitung, January 27, 1848. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 6. New York: International P, 1976. Print.Google Scholar
Engels, Frederick. “The Movements of 1847,” Deutsche-Brüsseler-Zeitung, January 23, 1848. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 6. New York: International P, 1976. 520–30. Print.Google Scholar
Engels, Frederick. “Democratic Panslavism.” Neue Rheinische Zeitung No. 222. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 8. New York: International P, 1977. 362–79. Print.Google Scholar
Engels, Frederick. “Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 11. New York: International Publishers, 1979. Print.Google Scholar
Felix, David. Marx as Politician. Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP, 1983.Google Scholar
Felix, David. “The Dialectic of the First International and Nationalism.” The Review of Politics 45.1 (January 1983): 20–44. Print.Google Scholar
Fischer, Gerhard. “'The State Begins to Wither Away …’: Notes on the Interpretation of the Paris Commune by Bakunin, Marx, Engels and Lenin.” Australian Journal of Politics & History 25.1 (1979): 29–38. Print.Google Scholar
Furet, François. Marx and the French Revolution. Translated by Deborah Furet, 1988. Print.Google Scholar
Gay, Peter. The Dilemma of Democratic Socialism: Eduard Bernstein's Challenge to Marx. New York: Octagon Books, 1983. Print.Google Scholar
Gellner, Ernest. Nations and Nationalism. Oxford: Blackwell, 1983. Print.Google Scholar
Greenfeld, Liah. “Nationalism and Class Struggle: Two Forces or One?” Survey 29.3 (1985). Print.Google Scholar
Herod, Charles C. The Nation in the History of Marxian Thought: The Concept of Nations With History and Nations Without History. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1976. Print.Google Scholar
Himka, John-Paul. “Introduction.” Engels and the “Nonhistoric” Peoples. Ed. Roman Rosdolsky. Print.Google Scholar
Hobsbawm, Eric. Nations and Nationalism Since 1780, 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1992. Print.Google Scholar
Hoffman, John and, Mzala, Nxumalo. Science & Society 54.4 (Winter 1990–1991). Print.Google Scholar
Knapp, Vincent J. “Ferdinand Lassalle on the State and Society: A Legacy to Welfare Statism.” Australian Journal of Politics & History 17.3 (1971): 377–85. Print.Google Scholar
Kofman, M. “The Reaction of Two Anarchists to Nationalism: Proudhon and Bakunin on the Polish Question.” Labour History 14 (1968). Print.Google Scholar
Kołakowski, Leszek. Main Currents of Marxism: The Founders, the Golden Age, the Breakdown. Volume One. 1978. Oxford UP. Print.Google Scholar
Kryukov, Michael V. “Self-determination from Marx to Mao.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 19.2 (April 1996). Print.Google Scholar
Laski, Harold Joseph. Harold J. Laski on the Communist Manifesto; An Introduction. New York: Pantheon Books, 1967. Print.Google Scholar
Lim, Jie-Hyun. “Marx's Theory of Imperialism and the Irish National Question.” Science & Society 56.2 (Summer 1992): 163–178. Print.Google Scholar
Lindemann, Albert S. A History of European Socialism. New Haven: Yale UP, 1983. Print.Google Scholar
Lovell, David W. From Marx to Lenin: An evaluation of Marx's responsibility for Soviet authoritarianism. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1984. Print.Google Scholar
Löwy, Michael. Fatherland or Mother Earth? Essays on the National Question. London: Pluto, 1998. Print.Google Scholar
Löwy, Michael. “Marxists and the National Question.” New Left Review I (March–April 1976). Print.Google Scholar
Luxemburg, Rosa. “The National Question and Autonomy.” The National Question: Selected Writings by Rosa Luxemburg. Ed. Davis, Horace B. New York: Monthly Review P, 1976. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Poland and the Russian Menace.” published in Glos Wolny. February 10, 1867. Available at Marx & Engels Internet Archive. Web.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. The Civil War in France, March-May 1871. London: Zodiac & Brian Baggins, 1871. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Manifesto of the Communist Party.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Selected Works, Vol. One. Moscow: Progress P, 1969. 98–137. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. Ireland and the Irish Question: A Collection of Writings by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. New York: International P, 1972. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Law.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 3. New York: International Publishers, 1975. 3–129. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Communism, Revolution and a Free Poland.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 6. New York: International P, 1976. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Russian Policy Against Turkey.” originally printed in New-York Daily Tribune, No. 3819, July 14, 1853. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 12. New York: International P, 1979. 163–74. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “The First Address. July 23, 1870, [The Beginning of the Franco-Prussian War].” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 22. New York: International P, 1986. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “Critique of the Gotha Programme.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works Vol. 24. New York: International Publishers, 1975. 75–100. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “The British Rule in India.” New-York Daily Tribune, June 25, 1853. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 12. New York: International P, 1979. 125–34. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl. “The Revolt in the Indian Army.” New York Daily Tribune, July 15, 1857. Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 15. New York: International P, 1986. 279–301. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl and Engels, Frederick. “The German Ideology. Critique of Modern German Philosophy According to Its Representatives Feuerbach, B. Bauer and Stirner, and of German Socialism According to Its Various Prophets.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works Vol. 5. New York: International Publishers, 1975. 19–584. Print.Google Scholar
Marx, Karl and Engels, Frederick. “On the Jewish Question.” Karl Marx, Frederick Engels: Collected Works, Vol. 3 (New York: International Publishers, 1975. 146–174. Print.Google Scholar
McLellan, David. Karl Marx: A Biography. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006. Print.Google Scholar
Mitchison, Paul G. “The ‘pig-headed’ Nation: Marxism grapples with the national question.” East European Quarterly 55.2 (June 1991). Print.Google Scholar
Morris, Brian. Bakunin: The Philosophy of Freedom. Montreal: Black P Books, 1993. Print.Google Scholar
Munck, Ronaldo. The Difficult Dialogue: Marxism and Nationalism. London: Zed Books Ltd., 1986. Print.Google Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. Marxism and Nationalism: Theoretical Origins of a Political Crisis. London: Pluto, 1991. Print.Google Scholar
Novack, George. “The First and Second Internationals.” The First Three Internationals: Their History and Lessons. Eds. Novack, George, Frankel, Dave and Feldman, Fred. New York: Pathfinder, 1974. Print.Google Scholar
Pelczynski, Z.A. “Nation, civil society, state: Hegelian sources of the Marxian non-theory of nationality.” The State & Civil Society: Studies in Hegel's Political Philosophy. Ed. Pelczynski, Z.A. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1984. Print.Google Scholar
Pipes, Richard. Communism: A History. New York: Random House, 2001. Print.Google Scholar
Ritter, Harry R. “Friedrich Engels and the East European Nationality Problem.” East European Quarterly 10.2 (1976). Print.Google Scholar
Rosdolsky, Roman. Engels and the “Nonhistoric” Peoples: The National Question in the Revolution of 1848. Trans. John-Paul Himka. Glasgow: Critique, 1987. Print.Google Scholar
Stalin, Joseph. “The Nation.” Nationalism. Ed. Hutchinson, John and Smith, Anthony D. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1994. Print.Google Scholar
Swoboda, Wolfram W. “The Changing Views of Marx and Engels about the Nationalities in the Austrian Monarchy, 1845–1855.” Austrian History Yearbook (1973–1974). Print.Google Scholar
Szporluk, Roman. Communism and Nationalism: Karl Marx Versus Friedrich List. New York: Oxford UP, 1988. Print.Google Scholar
Taylor, Peter J. “The Paradox of Geographical Scale in Marx's Politics.” Antipode 19.3 (1987): 292–95. Print.Google Scholar
Traverso, Enzo. The Marxists and the Jewish Question: The History of a Debate 1843–1943. Trans. Bernard Gibbons. Atlantic Highlands: Humanities P International, 1994. Print.Google Scholar
Traverso, Enzo, and Löwy, Michael. “The Marxist Approach to the National Question: A Critique of Nimni's Interpretation.” Science & Society 54.2 (Summer 1990). Print.Google Scholar
The General Council of the First International. 1864–1866. The London Conference 1865. Minutes. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1964.Google Scholar
Waldenberg, Marek. Kwestie Narodowe w Europe Środkowo-Wschodniej. Dzieje. Idee. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, 1992. Print.Google Scholar
Walicki, Andrzej. Marxism and the Leap to the Kingdom of Freedom: The Rise and Fall of the Communist Utopia. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1995. Print.Google Scholar
Wetherly, Paul. “A Capitalist State? Marx's Ambiguous Legacy.” The Communist Manifesto: New Interpretations. Ed. Cowling, Mark. Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP, 1998.Google Scholar
Wetherly, Paul. Marxism and the State: An Analytical Approach. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005. Print.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Bertram. Marxism: One Hundred Years in the Life of a Doctrine. New York: The Dial P, 1965. Print.Google Scholar
Zwick, Peter. “The Marxist Roots of National Communism.” Canadian Review of Studies in Nationalism 3.2 (1976): 127–45. Print.Google Scholar