Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:48:26.022Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Spontaneity Versus Formalization in East Europe: Some Problems of Bureaucratization under State Socialism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Alexander Matejko
Alexander Matejko*
Affiliation:
The University of Alberta
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The dilemma of spontaneity versus formalization is more or less valid for all societies. Freedom as the availability of alternative courses of action has been a precious cultural and moral value in history. The functional requisites of societies, related to communication, production, distribution, defense, replacement of members, and social control (Lenski, Lenski, 1974:28) have provided a more or less convincing justification for the limitation of freedom. Specialization, hierarchy, rules, procedures, impersonality and cult of competence, all these bureaucratic characteristics have been treated for centuries as remedia for laziness, irresponsibility, and parochialism. The progress of formalization has historically contributed to the strengthening of authority, as a legitimized power which brings about compliance of people to behave according to the will of those who occupy crucial positions. However, rigidification of such structures has several negative side effects: dissolution of several important and useful human bonds, ineffectiveness against external change, internal struggle between various groups to preserve and enlarge their areas of discretion (Crozier 1963), keeping too much to the rules, over-adherence to organizational means (and not ends), spoiling of superiors by the power enjoyed by them, superiors spending too much of their time and effort in controlling subordinates, etc. Strict separation of office and incumbent, in the sense that the official does not possess his office, has been historically beneficial for the material well being of societies, but it also has limited the personal involvement of office occupants. In the bureaucracies people who occupy crucial positions tend to develop vested interests within the scope of their jurisdiction. The constituent parts of bureaucracies resist actions which do not serve their own purposes (the problem of recalcitrance), and people in control of these parts become the prime beneficiaries (Blau, Scott 1962) of them. The ‘rules of the game’ that apply to the bureaucratic organizations as human artefacts quite often prevent them from achieving a dynamic equilibrium, namely to react to forces of change in an adaptive manner. Those organizations easily transform themselves from goal-seeking entities into the security-seeking mechanisms. Following Etzioni (1965) it is possible to say that they follow a ‘survival model’ instead of an ‘efficiency model'.

Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 5 , Issue 1 , Spring 1977 , pp. 22 - 66
Copyright
Copyright © 1976 by the Association for the Study of the Nationalities (USSR and East Europe) Inc. 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Sources

(Some of the European entries are incomplete because sources are now unavailable to the author. In all entries, however, enough information is given for the source to be identified and used as a reference.)Google Scholar
Aitov, N. A. 1974 “Changes of Class Position,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Amalrik, Andrei 1969 “Will the USSR Survive until 1984?” Survey, 73.Google Scholar
Amvrosov, A. A. and Staroverov, V. I. 1974 “Changes in the Structure of the USSR Rural Population,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Andorka, Rudolf 1974 “Studies in Social Mobility,” Szociologia, 5, pp. 37–44.Google Scholar
Anasz, Marian and Wesolowski, Wlodzimierz 1974 “Changes in Social Structure of People's Poland,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Armstron, John A. 1965 “Sources of Administrative Behaviour: Some Soviet and Western European Comparisons.” American Political Science Review, 59.Google Scholar
Armstrong, John A. 1973 The European Administrative Elite. Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Askanas, Benedykt 1972 Wirtschaftstrukturen in Osteuropa. Wien: Osterreichisches Institut fur Wirtschaftsforschung.Google Scholar
Berliner, J. C. 1957 Factory and Manager in the USSR. Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Blau, P. M. and Scott, W. R. 1962 Formal Organizations. Chandler.Google Scholar
Bornstein, Morris, ed. 1973 Plan and Market Economic Reform in Eastern Europe. Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Bromke, Adam 1971 “Beyond the Gomulka Era.” Foreign Affairs, 49.Google Scholar
Bromke, Adam and Rakowska-Harmstone, Teresa, eds. 1972 The Communist States in Disarray. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Chalinski, Josef 1958 Przeszlosc i przyszlosc inteligencji polskiej (Past and Present of the Polish Intelligentsia). Warszawa: Ludowa Spoldz. Wydawnicza.Google Scholar
Cohen, Leonard and Shapiro, Jane P., eds. 1974 Communist Systems in Comparative Perspective. Garden City: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
Connor, Walter D. 1974 “Occupational Mobility in the European Socialist States.” paper presented at the 69th Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, Montreal, August 25–29, 1974. (mimeo.).Google Scholar
Crozier, Michael 1973 Le Phénomène Bureaucratique. Paris: Editions du Sevil.Google Scholar
Churchward, L. C. 1968 “Bureaucracy - USA: USSR.” Co-existence, 5.Google Scholar
Churchward, L. C. 1973 The Soviet Intelligentsia. London: Routledge & Kogan Paul Google Scholar
Czepulis-Rastenis, Ryszarda 1973 Klasa umyslowa: Inteligencja Krolewstwa Polskiego 1832–1862 (The Intellectual Class: Intelligentsia of the Polish Kingdom, 1832–1862.) Warszawa: Ksiazka i Wiedza.Google Scholar
Dellin, L. A. D. and Gross, Herman, eds. 1972 Reforms in the Soviet and Eastern European Economies. Lexington: D. C. Hearth.Google Scholar
Eisenstadt, Shmuel N. 1963 The Political Systems of Empires. London: Free Press.Google Scholar
Enloe, Cynthia H. 1973 Ethnic Conflict and Political Development. Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Etzioni, Amitai 1965 Modern Organizations. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Feuer, Lewis 1964 “Marxism and the Hegemony of the Intellectual Class.” Transactions of the Fifth World Congress of Sociology. International Sociological Association, 4:93–96.Google Scholar
Filippov, F. R. 1974 “Changes in Social Make-up and Composition of the Soviet Intelligentsia,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, N. M. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Frederich, C. J. and Brzezinski, Z. K. 1966 Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy. New York.Google Scholar
Gella, Alexander 1971 “The Life and Death of the Old Polish Intelligentsia,” Slavic Review, 30:1–27.Google Scholar
Gheliuta, A. M. and Gogoliukhin, S. P. 1974 “The Formation of a New Type of Worker,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevich, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Goode, W. J. 1963 World Revolution and Family Patterns. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Granick, David 1950 The Red Executive. Doubleday.Google Scholar
Gupta, Krishna P. 1974 “Continuties in Change.” Problems of Communism, 23, 5.Google Scholar
Gvishani, D. M. 1966 “Problemy upravleniia sotsiialisticheskoi promyshlennostiu” (Problem of Managing Socialist Enterprises). Voprosy filosofii, 1966:2.Google Scholar
Halmos, Paul, ed. 1972 Hungarian Sociological Studies. University of Keel, February 1972.Google Scholar
Hawlowitsch, Johann 1972 “Yugoslavia: The Pioneer Still Leads,” in Reforms in the Soviet and Eastern European Economics, ed. by Dellin, L. A. D. and Gross, H. Lexington: Heath.Google Scholar
Hollander, Paul 1973 Soviet and American Society. Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Inkeles, Alex 1968 Social Change in Soviet Russia. Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Jarosinska, Maria and Kulpinska, Jolanta 1974 “Transformation of the Working Class in People's Poland,” Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Johnson, Charles, ed. 1970 Changes in Communist Systems. Stanford University.Google Scholar
Kassof, Allen 1964 “The Administered Society,” World Politics, 16.Google Scholar
Keren, Michael 1973 “Concentration Amid Devolution in East Germany's Reforms,” in Plan and Market, ed. by Bornstein, M. Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Kiezun, Witold 1969 “Style kierownictwa na tle zadan organizacyjnych” (Style of Management and Organizational Tasks) in Socjologia Kierownictwa, ed. by Matejko, A. Warszawa: Panstwowe Wydawnictwo Ekonomiczne, 117–154.Google Scholar
Kolbanovsky, V. V. 1974 “The Impact of Scientific and Technological Progress in the Working Class Structure in the USSR,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Korbonski, Andrzej 1974 “The Prospects for Change in Eastern Europe,” Slavic Review, 33:2.Google Scholar
Kornhauser, William 1960 The Politics of Mass Society. Free Press, Glencoe, Il.Google Scholar
Kowalewski, S. 1970 Przelozony-podwladny (Supervisor-Subordinate). 2nd ed. Warszawa: Panstwowe Wydawnictwo Ekonomiczne.Google Scholar
Krejci, Jaroslav 1972 Social Change and Stratification in Postwar Czechoslovakia. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Lane, David 1971a The End of Inequality? Stratification Under State Socialism. Penquin Books.Google Scholar
Lane, David 1971b Politics and Society in the USSR. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Lane, David and Kolankiewicz, George, eds. 1973 Social Groups in Polish Society. Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Lenski, Gerard and Lenski, Jean 1974 Human Societies. McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Liberthal, Kenneth 1974 “Social Stratification: A Cross-Cultural Analysis.” Problems of Communism, 23, 5.Google Scholar
Lipset, S. M. and Bendix, R. 1967 Social Mobility in Industrial Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Matejko, Alexander 1969 “Planning and Tradition in Polish Higher Education.” Minerva, 42:621–628.Google Scholar
Matejko, Alexander 1973a “Institutional Conditions of Scientific Inquiry.” Small Group Behavior, 4:1.Google Scholar
Matejko, Alexander 1973b “Industrial Democracy.” Our Generation, 9:1.Google Scholar
Matejko, Alexander 1974 Social Change and Stratification in Eastern Europe; An Interpretive Analysis of Poland and Her Neighbours. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
Matejko, A. 1975 “Dilemmas of Hierarchical Organizations and of Individual Bureaucracy.” Paper for the Second International Conference on Self-Management. Ithaca.Google Scholar
Matthews, Merwyn 1972 Class and Society in Soviet Russia. Allen Lane: The Penguin Press.Google Scholar
Meissner, Boris, ed. 1972 Social Change in the Soviet Union. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Meyer, Alfred G. 1965 The Soviet Political System. Richman.Google Scholar
Mickiewicz, Ellen 1973 Handbook of Soviet Social Science Data. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Morawski, Witold 1969 “Funkcje samorzadu robotniczego w systemie zarzadzania przemyslem” (Functions of Workers’ Self-Management in Managing Industry), in Przemysl i Spoleczenstwo w Polsce Ludowej, ed. by Szczepanski, J. Wroclaw: Ossolineum.Google Scholar
Najduchowska, Halina 1969a “Drogi zawodowe kadry kierowniczej” (Professional Careers of Executives, Studia Socjologiczne (3):253–269.Google Scholar
Najduchowska, Halina 1969b “Dyrektorzy przedsiebiorstw przemyslowych” (Industrial Executives) in Przemysl i Spoleczenstwo w Polsce Ludowej, ed. by Szczepanski, J. Wroclaw: Ossolineum.Google Scholar
Nove, Alec 1972 “The USSR: The Reform that Never Was,” in Reforms in the Soviet and Eastern European Economics, ed. by Dellin, L. A. D. and Gross, H. Lexington: Heath.Google Scholar
Parkin, J. F. 1969 “Class Stratification in Socialist Societies,” British Journal of Sociology, 4:355–374.Google Scholar
Rakowska-Harmstone, Teresa 1972 “Patterns of Political Change,” in The Communist States in Disarray, ed. by Bromke, A. and Rakowska-Harmstone, T. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Rakowska-Harmstone, Teresa 1974 “The Dialectics of Nationalism in the USSR,” Problems of Communism, 23, 3.Google Scholar
(no author) 1974 Reports on Population/Family Planning. New York: The Population Council.Google Scholar
Richman, Barry M. 1965 Soviet Management. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
Rigby, T. H. 1964 “Traditional, Market and Organizational Societies and the USSR,” World Politics, 16.Google Scholar
Rostow, W. W. 1971 Politics and the Stages of Growth. Cambridge: At the University Press.Google Scholar
Ruffmann, Karl Heinz 1972 “Social Change in Russia Prior to the October Revolution,” in Social Change in the Soviet Union, ed. by Meissner, B. University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Rupinski, G. and Taubwurzel, S. 1961 Elementy organizacji i zarzadzenia przedsiebiorstwem (Elements of Business Organization). Lodz: Zaklad Prod. Skryptow Politechniki Poznanskiej.Google Scholar
Rutkevitch, N. M. 1974 “Social Structure of Socialist Society in the USSR and its Development Towards Social Homogeneity,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. 1974 Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland. Mo scow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Sarapata, Adam 1970 “Motywacje i satysfakcje dyrektorow: Studium porownawcze” (Motives and Satisfactions of Executives: A Comparative Study), Studia Socjologiczne, 3:61–89.Google Scholar
Selucky, Radoslav 1972 Economic Reforms in Eastern Europe. New York: Praeger.Google Scholar
Semyonov, V. S. 1974 “Trends in the Development of the Social Structure in the USSR.” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Shanin, Teodor 1972 The Awkward Class. Oxford: At the Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Sit, Ota 1972 “Czechoslovakia Prohibitive Odds,” in Reforms in the Soviet and Eastern European Economics, ed. by Dellin, L. A. D. and Gross, H. Lexington: Heath.Google Scholar
Skilling, Gordon and Griffiths, Franklyn, eds. 1971 Interest Groups in Soviet Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Slesarev, G. A. 1974 “Socio-Demographic Groups Within the Soviet Working Class,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland, ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Swaniewicz, S. 1968 “World Economic Growth and the Soviet Challenge,” The Review of Politics, 4:455–475.Google Scholar
Swaniewicz, S. 1969 “The Impact of Ideology on Soviet Economic Policy.” Canadian Slavonic Papers, 1:66–81.Google Scholar
Szabady, Egon 1972 “Changes in Hungarian Society During 1945–1970.” Hungarian Sociological Studies. University of Keele.Google Scholar
Szczepanski, Jan 1962 “The Polish Intelligentsia, Past and Present,” World Politics, 14 (April).Google Scholar
Thalheim, Karl C. 1972 “The Sociological Impact of Soviet Economic Policy,” in Social Change in the Soviet Union, ed. by Meisner, B. University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Vasilyev, V. G. et al. 1974 Social Programme of the Ninth Five Year Plan. Moscow: Progress Publ.Google Scholar
Weinburg, Elizabeth Ann 1974 The Development of Sociology in the Soviet Union. London: Routledge & Kegan.Google Scholar
Wesolowski, Wlodzimierz 1962 “Robotnicy o swojej pracy i zakladach” (Workers about their Jobs and Workplaces), Studia Socjologiczno-Polityczne, 12.Google Scholar
Wesolowski, W., ed. 1970 Struktura i dynamika spoleczenstwa polskiego. Warsaw: Panstwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe.Google Scholar
Wilczynski, J. 1973 Profit, Risk and Incentives under Socialist Economic Planning. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Wittfogel, K. A. 1957 Oriental Despotism. New Haven.Google Scholar
Yanowitch, M. and Fisher, W. A., eds. 1973 Social Stratification and Mobility in the USSR. White Plains: International Arts and Sciences Press.Google Scholar
Zagorski, Krzysztof 1974 “Changes of Social Structure and Social Mobility in Poland,” in Transformations of Social Structure in the USSR and Poland,” ed. by Rutkevitch, M. N. et al. Moscow-Warsaw.Google Scholar
Zielinski, Janusz 1973 Economic Reforms in Polish Industry. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Zolotarev, W. T. 1975 Programma ekonomicheskogo sotrudnichestva sotsiialisti-sticheskikh stran. Moscow: Izd. Mezhdunarodnyie Otnosheniia.Google Scholar