Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:56:29.743Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Twilight of the Two-State Solution in Israel-Palestine: Shared Sovereignty and Nonterritorial Autonomy as the New Dawn

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 November 2019

Ephraim Nimni
Ephraim Nimni*
Affiliation:
Queen’s University, Belfast, United Kingdom of Great Britain
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article analyzes the international consensus on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that there should be a two state solution and finds it unworkable on several counts. The conflict has no territorial solution: high population density makes partition impossible without leaving unwanted pockets of one people in the territory of the other; it is not possible for any Israeli government to dismantle settlements in the West Bank without causing a civil war; and in such a small and overcrowded territory, it is not feasible to have monocultural nation-states when the population is now evenly divided between the two conflicting national communities that reside in overlapping areas. Demographic forecasts show in the short term, a decrease in the proportion of Israeli Jews and an increase in the proportion of Palestinians. In the face of this stalemate, the article recalls the 90-year-old proposal by enlightened Jewish personalities to create a binational state under the modality of national-cultural autonomy. Furthermore, and paradoxically, in a reversal of the situation 90 years ago, Palestinian Israeli citizens are slowly creating a bottom-up series of autonomous communal organizations that provide self-government without territorial control, a model for nonterritorial autonomy in a manner that reminds of the earlier proposals of the Jewish personalities. The article concludes that this could potentially be a way out of this stalled and protracted conflict. A plurinational state in Israel-Palestine based on the model of National Cultural Autonomy with shared sovereignty and collective rights for all communities.

Keywords

Israel Palestinenational cultural autonomyone-state solutionBrit ShalomHans Kohn
Type
Special Issue Article
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 48 , Special Issue 2: Special Issue on National Cultural Autonomy in Diverse Political Communities: Practices, Challenges, and Perspectives , March 2020 , pp. 339 - 356
Copyright
© Association for the Study of Nationalities 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Al-Haj, Majid. 1995. Education, Empowerment, and Control: The Case of the Arabs in Israel. New York: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
Almog, Yael. 2015. “Migration and Its Discontents: Israelis in Berlin and Homeland Politics.” Transit 10 (1): 1–8.Google Scholar
Amir, Ruth. 2019. “The Politics of Victimhood, A Vision of an Apocalypse.” In Victimhood Discourse in Contemporary Israel, edited by Peleg, Ilan. 153–176. Lanham: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Aran, Gideon. 1991. “Jewish Zionist Fundamentalism: The Bloc of Faithful (Gush Emunim).” In Fundamentalisms Observed, edited by Marty, M. E. and Appleby, R Scott. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Arnow, David. 1994. “The Holocaust and the Birth of Israel.” The Journal of Israel History 15 (3): 257–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arendt, Hannah. 2007. Jewish Writings, edited by Kohn, J. and Feldman, R.. New York: Schocken Books.Google Scholar
Aschheim, Steven E. 2007. Beyond the Border: The German-Jewish Legacy Abroad. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barzilai, Gad. 2000. “Fantasies of Liberalism and Liberal Jurisprudence: State Law, Politics, and the Israeli Arab-Palestinian Community.” Israel Law Review 34 (3): 425–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bauer, Otto. 1898/2000. The Question of Nationalities and Social Democracy, with an introduction to the English reading audience by Ephraim Nimni. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Beilin, Yossi. 2000. His Brother’s Keeper. [In Hebrew.] New York: Schoken Books.Google Scholar
Bing, Anthony. 1990. Israeli Pacifist, The Life of Joseph Abileah, Foreword by Yehudi Menuhim. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.Google Scholar
Bishara, Azmi. 2017. “Zionism and Equal Citizenship: Essential and Incidental Citizenship in the Jewish State.” In Israel and the Palestinian Citizens: Ethnic Privileges in the Jewish State, edited by Rouhana, Nadim N., 137–155. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black, Edwin, 1984. The Transfer Agreement. New York: MacMillan Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Braverman, Irus. 2018. “Renouncing Citizenship as Protest: Reflections by a Jewish Israeli Ethnographer.” Critical Inquiry 444 (2).Google Scholar
Bhungalia, Lisa. 2010. “A Liminal Territory: Gaza, Executive Discretion, and Sanctions Turned Humanitarian.” GeoJournal 75 (4): 347–357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burton, Mark. 2015. “Community Psychology Under Colonial Occupation: The Case of Palestine.” Journal of Community Psychology 43 (1): 119–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Butt, Khalid Manzoor, and Butt, Anam Abid. 2016. “Blockade on the Gaza Strip: A Living Hell on Earth.” Journal of Political Studies 23 (1): 157–182.Google Scholar
Caplan, Neil. 1992. “A Tale of Two Cities: The Rhodes and Lausanne Conferences, 1949.” Journal of Palestine Studies 21 (3): 5–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chitrit, Sami Shalom. 2010. Intra-Jewish Conflict in Israel: White Jews, Black Jews. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Chylińska, Bożenna. 2009. “Cultural Zionism, Ahad Ha’am and His American Adherents.” In Ideology and Rhetoric: Constructing America, edited by Chylińska, Bożenna, 241–254. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.Google Scholar
Cohen, Michael. 1989. The Origins and Evolution of the Arab-Zionist Conflict. Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Diner, Dan, and Golb, Joel. 1997. “On Guilt Discourse and Other Narratives: Epistemological Observations Regarding the Holocaust.” History and Memory 9 (1/2): 301–320.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DellaPergola, S. 2017. World Jewish Population, 2016. In American Jewish Year Book 2016, edited by Dashefsky, A. and Sheskin, I., 253–330. Cham: Springer.Google Scholar
Dowty, Alan. 2000. “Much Ado about Little: Ahad Ha’am’s ‘Truth from Eretz Yisrael’, Zionism, and the Arabs.” Israel Studies 5 (2): 154–181.Google Scholar
Dubnow, Simon. 1970. Nationalism and History: Essays in Old and New Judaism. New York: Atheneum.Google Scholar
Einstein, Albert. 1956. Out of My Later Years. New York: Wings Books.Google Scholar
Feige, Michael. 2013. “Soft power: The meaning of home for Gush Emunim settlers.” Journal of Israeli History 32 (1): 109–126.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flapan, Simha. 1987. The Birth of Israel: Myths and Realities New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
Friesel, Evyatar. 2008. “On the Myth of the Connection between the Holocaust and the Creation of Israel.” Israel Affairs 14 (3): 446–466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gechtman, Roni. 2013. “Nationalizing the Bund? Zionist Historiography and the Jewish Labour Movement.” East European Jewish Affairs 43 (3): 249–264.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gechtman, Roni. 2016. “Jews and Non-Territorial Autonomy: Political Programs and Historical Perspectives.” Ethnopolitics 15 (1): 66–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghanem, As’ad. 2016. “Israel’s Second-Class Citizens: Arabs in Israel and the Struggle for Equal Rights.” Foreign Affairs 37 (2): 37–42.Google Scholar
As’ad, Ghanem, and Bavly, Dan. 2015. Towards a Bi-National Homeland for Israelis and Palestinians: In Search of a Doable Solution-A United Democracy. Saarbrücken: Lap Lambert Academic Publishing.Google Scholar
Gordon, Adi, ed. 2008. Brit Shalom veha Tsiyonut ha du-Leumit: Ha-Sheilah ha-Aravit ke-Sheelah Yehudit (Eng.: Brit Shalom and the Binational Question: The Arabic Question as a Jewish Question) Jerusalem: Carmel Books.Google Scholar
Gordon, Adi, 2017. Toward Nationalism’s End: An Intellectual Biography of Hans Kohn. Waltham/Boston, MA: Brandeis University Press.Google Scholar
Gordon, Neve, and Cohen, Yinon. 2012. “Western Interests, Israeli Unilateralism, and the Two-State Solution.” Journal of Palestine Studies 12 (3): 13.Google Scholar
Gordon, Neve, and Ram, Moriel. 2016. “Ethnic Cleansing and the Formation of Settler Colonial Geographies.” Political Geography 53 (2): 20–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gorenberg, Gershon. 2006. The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967–1977. New York: Times Books, Henry Holt & Company.Google Scholar
Haklai, Oded. 2009. “State Mutability and Ethnic Civil Society: The Palestinian Arab Minority in Israel.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 32 (5): 864–882.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hersh, Jacques. 2009. “Inconvenient Truths about ‘Real Existing’ Zionism.” Monthly Review 61 (1): 19–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hillal, Jamil. 2007. Where Now for Palestine? The Demise of the Two State Solution. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Hobsbawm, Eric J. 1992. Nations and Nationalism Since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Irvin-Erickson, Douglas. 2017. Raphaël Lemkin and the Concept of Genocide. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jamal, Amal. 2005. “On the Morality of Arab Collective Rights in Israel.” Adalah’s Newsletter. 12 (April) 1–IL7.Google Scholar
Jamal, Amal, 2007. “Strategies of Minority Struggle for Equality in Ethnic States: Arab Politics in Israel.” Citizenship Studies 11 (3): 263–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jamal, Amal, 2008. “The Counter-Hegemonic role of Civil Society: Palestinian–Arab NGOs in Israel.” Citizenship Studies 12 (3): 283–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Judt, Tony. 2003. “Israel: The Alternative.” The New York Review of Books, October 23.Google Scholar
Karkabi, Nadeem. 2018. “How and Why Haifa Has Become the ‘Palestinian Cultural Capital’ in Israel.” City & Community, Journal of the American Sociological Association 17 (4): 1168–1188.Google Scholar
Klar, Yechiel, Schori-Eyal, Noa, and Klar, Yonat. 2013. “The “Never Again” State of Israel: The Emergence of the Holocaust as a Core Feature of Israeli Identity and Its Four Incongruent Voices.” Journal of Social Issues 69 (1): 125–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keating, Michael. 2009. “Social citizenship, solidarity and welfare in regionalized and plurinational states.” Citizenship Studies 13 (5): 500–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Khalidi, Walid. 1988. “Plan Dalet: Master Plan for the Conquest of Palestine.” Journal of Palestine Studies 18 (1): 4–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Khalidi, Walid, ed. 1992. All That Remains: The Palestinian Villages Occupied and Depopulated by Israel in 1948. Washington: Institute for Palestine Studies.Google Scholar
Kimmerling, Baruch 2001. The Invention and Decline of Israeliness: State, Society, and the Military. Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Kohn, Hans. 1925. Toldot HaTneua HaLeumit Arabit, (History of the Arab National Movement). Tel Aviv: Hapoel Hatzair Editions.Google Scholar
Kohn, Hans. 1919/1992. “The Arab Question” In The Jews of Bohemia and Moravia: A Historical Reader, edited by Iggers, Wilma, 239–242. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.Google Scholar
Kohn, Hans. 1970. “Zion and the Jewish National Idea.” In Zionism Reconsidered, edited by Selzer, Michael. London: MacMillan.Google Scholar
Kraines, Oscar. 1976. The Impossible Dilemma: Who Is a Jew in the State of Israel? New York: Bloch.Google Scholar
Landau, Jacob M. 1969/2015. The Arabs in Israel: A Political Study. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Laqueur, Walter. 1972. A History of Zionism. New York: MJF Books.Google Scholar
Levene, Mark. 1992. “The Balfour Declaration: A Case of Mistaken Identity.” The English Historical Review 107 (422): 54–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
LeVine, Mark, and Mossberg, Matias. 2014. One Land, Two States: Israel and Palestine as Parallel States. Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
London, Yaron. 2018. “Welcome to Israel, the most crowded nation on earth” Ynet News, December 23. https://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-5430319,00.html. (Accessed October 20, 2019.)Google Scholar
Lustick, Ian. 1991. For the Land and the Lord: Jewish Fundamentalism in Israel. New York: Council on Foreign Relations.Google Scholar
Mildenstein, Leopold von. 1934. “Ein Nazi Fährt Nach Palästina.” (A Nazi Travels to Palestine) Series of articles, Der Angriff, September-October 1934.Google Scholar
Maimon, Dov. “European Jewry in 2030” Judaïsme Massorti (Website of Traditional Judaism in France) https://www.massorti.com/IMG/pdf/maimon_european.pdf. (Accessed December 2018.)Google Scholar
Masalha, Nur. 2012. The Palestine Nakba: Decolonising History, Narrating the Subaltern, Reclaiming Memory. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Morris, Benny. 1987. The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Morris, Benny. 1988. “The New Historiography: Israel Confronts Its Past.” Tikkun 19 (23): 99–102.Google Scholar
Newman, David. 1996. “The Territorial Politics of Exurbanization: Reflections on 25 Years of Jewish Settlement in the West Bank.” Israel Affairs 3 (1): 61–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 1999. “Nationalist Multiculturalism in Late Imperial Austria as a Critique of Contemporary Liberalism: The Case of Bauer and Renner.” Journal of Political Ideologies 4: 289–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2000. “Introduction to the English Reading Audience.” In Otto Bauer, The Question of Nationalities and Social Democracy (Nationalitätenfrage und die Sozialdemokratie). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2003. “From Galut to T’fusoth, Post Zionism and the Dislocation of Jewish Diasporas.” In The Challenge of Post Zionism, Alternatives to Israel’s Fundamentalist Politics, edited by Nimni, Ephraim, 117–152. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2007. “National Cultural Autonomy as an Alternative to Minority Nationalism.” Ethnopolitics 3 (3): 345–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2012. “Counter State Zionism and Political Zionism.” Journal of Palestine Studies, 41 (3): 131–136.Google Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2015. “Minorities and the Limits of Liberal Democracy.” In Minority Accommodation through Territorial and Non-Territorial Autonomy, edited by Malloy, Tove and Palermo, Francesco, 57–82. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Nicosia, Francis. 2008. Zionism and Anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Ottolenghi, Emmanuele. 2005. “A National Home.” In Modern Judaism, edited by De Lange, Nicolas and Freud-Kandel, Miri, 54–65. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Pappé, Ilan. 1988. Britain and the Arab-Israeli Conflict, 1948–1951. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.Google Scholar
Pappé, Ilan. 2006. The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. Oxford: Oneworld.Google Scholar
Pedahzur, Ami and McCarthy, Holly. 2015. “Against All Odds—The Paradoxical Victory of the West Bank Settlers: Interest Groups and Policy Enforcement.” Israel Affairs 21 (3): 443–461.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peled, Yoav. 1992. “Ethnic Democracy and the Legal Construction of Citizenship: Arab Citizens of the Jewish State.” The American Political Science Review, 86 (2): 432–443.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peled, Yoav. 2013. “Challenging Zionism through Non-Territorial Autonomy, From Vilna to Nazareth.” In The Challenge of Non-Territorial Autonomy, Theory and Practice, edited by Nimni, Ephraim, Osipov, Alexander, and Smith, David J., 39–54. Bern: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Peled, Yoav, and Rouhana, Nadim. 2004. “Transitional Justice and the Right of Return of the Palestinian Refugees.” Theoretical Enquiries in Law 5 (2): 317–332.Google Scholar
Piterberg, Gabriel. 1996. “Domestic Orientalism: The Representation of ‘Oriental’ Jews in Zionist/Israeli Historiography. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 23 (2): 125–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pianko, Noam. 2010. Zionism: The Roads Not Taken. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Ram, Uri 1999, “The State of the Nation: Contemporary Challenges to Zionism in Israel.” Constellations 6 (3): 325–338.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Requejo, Ferran. 1999. “Cultural Pluralism, Nationalism and Federalism: A Revision of Democratic Citizenship in Plurinational States.” European Journal of Political Research 35 (2): 255–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Renner, Karl. 2005. “State and Nation.” In National Cultural Autonomy and Its Contemporary Critics, edited by Nimni, Ephraim, 15–47. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Renton, James. 2007. The Zionist Masquerade: The Birth of the Anglo-Zionist Alliance 1914–1918. London: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roy, Sara. 2005. “Praying with Their Eyes Closed: Reflections on The Disengagement from Gaza.” Journal of Palestine Studies 34 (4): 64–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rynhold, Jonathan, and Waxman, Dov. 2008. “Ideological Change and Israel’s Disengagement from Gaza.” Political Science Quarterly 123 (1): 11–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sa’di, Ahmad H. 2002. “Catastrophe, Memory and Identity: Al-Nakba as a Component of Palestinian Identity.” Israel Studies 7 (2): 175–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Safran, William. 2005. “The Jewish Diaspora in a Comparative and Theoretical Perspective.” Israel Studies 10 (1): 36–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Said, Edward. 1980. “Zionism from the Standpoint of its Victims.” In The Question of Palestine. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
Salzberger, Fania. 2015. “Israelis in Germany.” In Being Jewish in 21st-Century Germany, edited by Glöckner, Olaf and Fireberg, Haim, 117–129. Oldenbourg: De Gruyter.Google Scholar
Segev, Tom. 2000 The Seventh Million: The Israelis and the Holocaust. New York: Henry Holt.Google Scholar
Shohat, Ella. 1998. “Sephardim in Israel: Zionism from the Standpoint of Its Jewish Victims.“ Social Text 19/20: 1–35.Google Scholar
Shapira, Anita, and Wiskind-Elper, Ora. 1995. “Politics and Collective Memory: The Debate over the “New Historians” in Israel.” History and Memory 7 (1): 9–40.Google Scholar
Shenhav, Yehouda. 2006. The Arab Jews. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Shenhav, Yehouda. 2012. Beyond the Two States Solution. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Shlaim, Avi. 1988. Collusion across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement, and the Partition of Palestine. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Shlaim, Avi. 1999. The Politics of Partition: King Abdullah, the Zionists, and Palestine 1921–1951. London: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Shlaim, Avi, and Louis, William Roger, eds. 2012. The 1967 Arab-Israeli War: Origins and Consequences. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Smith, David J., and Hiden, John. 2012. Ethnic Diversity and the Nation State: National Cultural Autonomy Revisited. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, David. 2011. “National Cultural Autonomy.” In Routledge Handbook of Ethnic Conflict, edited by Cordell, Karl and Wolff, Stefan, 278–287. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Smooha, Samy. 2002. “The Model of Ethnic Democracy: Israel as a Jewish and Democratic State.” Nations and Nationalism 8 (4): 475–503.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Surkes, S. and Bachner, M.. 2018. “Members of Knesset Argue over Claim that Palestinians Have Reached Demographic Parity with Jews.” Times Of Israel, March 26.Google Scholar
Swirski, Shlomo. 1989. Israel: The Oriental Majority. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Tal, Alon. 2016. The Land is Full. Addressing Overpopulation in Israel, Princeton: Yale University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
on Palestine, United Nations Special Commission. 1947. The Official Records of the United Nations on the Partition of Palestine. https://undocs.org/A/364(SUPP).Google Scholar
Weiss, Yfaat. 2004. “Central European Ethnonationalism and Zionist Binationalism.” Jewish Social Studies 11(1): 93–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wexler, Ellen. 2018. “The New Israeli Americans.” The Moment Magazine, January.Google Scholar
Yiftachel, Oren. 2006. Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Zeller, Ursula. 2003. “Between Goldene Medine and Promised Land: Legitimizing American Jewish Diaspora.” In Diaspora and Multiculturalism: Common Traditions and New Developments, edited by Fludernik, Monika, 1–44. Amsterdam: Rodopi.Google Scholar
Zertal, Idith. 2005. Israel’s Holocaust and the Politics of Nationhood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar