Six nanocomposite coatings of yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ), Au, diamond like carbon and MoS2 have been studied by in situ tribometry. The coatings all had a nominal MoS2 content of between 14 and 18 mol%, while the concentrations of the other components were varied. Steady state friction coefficients in both dry (0.04–0.05) and wet sliding conditions (0.06–0.08) were similar for all coatings. However, by in situ tribometry, wear mechanisms were found to differ depending on coating composition and test environment humidity. Friction spiking in high YSZ coatings was identified with local plowing and scoring of the track followed by an extrusion of transfer film material. Trends in coating hardness and modulus are correlated to composition and coating wear processes.