Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T03:10:34.775Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Technical and Analytical Study of Two Silver Plates in the Collection of the J.Paul Getty Museum

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2011

David Scott
David Scott*
Affiliation:
Head, Museum Services, Scientific Program, Getty Conservation Institute, 4503 Glencoe Avenue, Marina del Rey, California 90292-6537
Get access

Abstract

Two silver plates in the collection of the J. Paul Getty Museum were studied by non-destructive x-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, inductively-coupled plasma-mass spectrometry, xradiography, optical metallography, electron microprobe analysis and lead isotopic composition. One plate depicts a scene of philosophical discourse (the ‘Philosopher plate’) and the other an aged fisherman with his catch (the ‘Fisherman plate’). Both plates have designs on the fronts made not by repousse but by a combination of working and annealing followed by carving to shape. Technical and analytical results are described which support the attribution of a date in the early centuries AD. There are several differences between the two plates, such as the way in which the footring has been made and attached. Both, however, have thick corrosion crusts and have suffered intergranular corrosion. Determination of trace elements, such as zinc and gold, together with the method of manufacture suggests that both plates are ancient. Lead isotopic data for the two plates is different, with the Philosopher plate showing a close relationship to other Byzantine objects, even though a Renaissance date had been suggested.

Type
Research Article
Information
MRS Online Proceedings Library (OPL) , Volume 185: Symposium G – Materials Issues in Art and Archaeology II , 1990 , 665
Copyright
Copyright © Materials Research Society 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Cutler, Anthony, “Authentic Iconography: Ptolemy and Hermes in Malibu, California” lecture presented at the College Art Association (1986) (unpublished).Google Scholar
2. Cutler, Anthony, “The Disputa Plate in the J. Paul Getty Museum and its Cinquecento Context” Getty Museum Journal (in press).Google Scholar
3. Kitzinger, Ernst private communication, Antiquities Department, J. Paul Getty Museum (May 1989).Google Scholar
4. Frazer, Margaret, private communication, Antiquities Department, J. Paul Getty Museum (April 1986).Google Scholar
5. Bennett, Anna, “Conservation Treatment Report to the Department of Antiquities Conservation,” J. Paul Getty Museum (1983) (unpublished).Google Scholar
6. Harper, Prudence O., “Catalogue and Interpretation: in: Silver Vessels of the Sasanian Period. Harper and Meyers, Vol.1: Royal Imagery, The Metropolitan Museum of Art: New York (p.15–24) (1981).Google Scholar
7. Tylecote, R.F., The Solid Phase Welding of Metals. Edward Arnold: London (1968),Google Scholar
8. Chase, Thomas, “The Examination of Two Sasanian Silver Plates,” Ars Orientalis;. Vol. 7, p. 75–93 (1968).Google Scholar
9. Gibbons, D.F., Ruhl, K.C. and Shepherd, D.G., “Techniques of Silversmithing in the Hormizd II Plate,” Ars Orientalis. Vol. 11, p.163–176 (1979).Google Scholar
10. Foltz, E., “Zur Herstellungstechnik der byzantinische Silberschaler aus dem Schatzfund vor Lamousa,” Jaruc e Roemisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums Mainz. Vol. 22, p. 221–245 (1975).Google Scholar
11. Meyers, Pieter “Elemental Compositions of the Sion Treasure and other Byzantine Silver Objects,” ins.Google Scholar
12. Schweizer, Francois and Meyers, Pieter, “Authenticity of ancient silver objects: a new approach,” MASCA, Vol. 1, p. 9–10 (1978).Google Scholar
13. Schweizer, Francois and Meyers, Pieter, “Structural changes in ancient silver alloys: the discontinuous precipitation of copper,” lOOM Committee for Conservation: Zagreb (1978).Google Scholar
14. Heywood, Ann and Croome, Elizabeth, “The Metallography of Ancient Silver-Copper Alloys,” AIC Conference: Cincinnati (June 1989) (unpublished).Google Scholar
15. Maryon, Herbert, “The Mildenhall Treasure: Some Technical Problems,” Man, Vol. 48, p. 25–27, 38-41 (1948).Google Scholar
16. Meyers, Pieter, “Technical Study: Part Two” in Silver Vessels of the Sasanian Period (P.O. Harper and P. Meyers), Metropolitan Museum of Art: New York (1981).Google Scholar
17. Carroll, Diane Lee, “Tools of the Renaissance Jeweler: a Goldsmith's Workshop in 1576,” Archeomaterials, Vol. 1, p. 153–172.Google Scholar
18. Schilling, Michael, “Internal Report on the X-Ray Fluorescence Analysis of Two Silver Objects,” G.CL.p Report (1986).Google Scholar
19. Johnson, A.B. Jr., and Francis, B., Durability of Metals from Archaeological Obiects. Metal Meteorites and Native Metals. U.S. Dept. of Energy: Gontract number IV-/6-G-06-1b30, 1ateie Memorial Institute: Ohio, PNL-3198 UC-70 (1980).Google Scholar
20. Scott, David, “The Corrosive Penetration of Copper and Silver Alloys after Long Periods of Burial” (unpublished manuscript) (1989).Google Scholar
21. North, Neil and MacLeod, Ian D., “Corrosion of Metals” in Conservation of Marine Archaeological Objects (Ed. Pearson, Colin), Butterworths: London (1987) p. 94–95.Google Scholar
22. X-radiography work by Maish, J. and Elston, M. using the facilities at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art with the kind assistance of P. Meyers (1990).Google Scholar
23. “Metallography and Microstructures,” Metals Handbook (9th edition), American Society for Metals, Metals Park: Ohio (1985).Google Scholar
24. Martin, Graham, Analysis of Silver Obiects in the Collections of the Victoria and Albert Museum, Victoria and Albert Museum Report: London (unpublished) (1987).Google Scholar
25. Vocke, R., “Report on Lead Isotope Analysis for the Getty Conservation Institute” (unpublished) (1990).Google Scholar
26. Meyers, P., personal communication (1990).Google Scholar
27. Reedy, Chandra L. and Reedy, Terry J., “Lead Isotope Analysis for Provenance Studies in the Aegean region: a Re-evaluation, Materials Issues in Art and Archaeology (edited by Sayre, Edward V.; P. Vandiver, J. Druzik and C. Stevenson) MRS Symposium Proc. Vol. 123, p. 65–70 (1988).Google Scholar
28. Scott, D.A., “Technological, Analytical and Microstructural Studies of a Renaissance Silver Basin,” Archeomaterials, (1990) (in press).Google Scholar