Brief context of system integration of natural materials
The creation of new materials and products using natural resources has been occurring since ancient times. Reference Callister and Rethwisch1 After decades of using synthetic materials for many industrial applications ( Figure 1 ), Reference Möhring, Brecher, Abele, Fleischer and Bleicher2 in the late 1980s, interest in turning to natural materials started flourishing again, owing to the thrust toward sustainable design with the release of the Brundtland Commission Report. Reference Durham3,4 Previous issues of MRS Bulletin have tangentially touched on the use of functional natural materials, including in the construction industry, Reference Bonfield5,Reference Kurtis6 health applications, Reference Kossovsky and Millett7–Reference Truss9 energy production and supply, Reference Hurd, Kelley, Eggert and Lee10,Reference Ku and Shapiro11 chemical products, Reference Glasser12,Reference Halley and Dorgan13 fibers, Reference Vollrath, Porter and Holland14 and sustainable development in general. Reference Green, Espinal, Traversa and Amis15,Reference Halada and Yamamoto16 However, there has not been a complete issue focused on the development of functional materials from natural resources with a systems integration approach. In this issue, materials such as hydrogels, Reference Akintewe, DuPont, Elineni, Cross, Toomey and Gallant17,Reference Toomey, Vidyasagar, Ortiz, Knoll and Advincula18 cellulose, Reference Hubbe, Rojas, Fingas and Gupta19–Reference Jocher, Gattermayer, Kleebe, Kleemann and Biesalski23 paper, Reference Hubbe, Venditti and Rojas24–Reference Ruettiger, Mehlhase, Vowinkel, Cherkashinin, Liu, Dietz, Stark, Biesalski and Gallei29 cells, Reference Zhernenkov, Ashkar, Feng, Akintewe, Gallant, Toomey, Ankner and Pynn30–Reference Falahat, Wiranowska, Toomey and Alcantar34 plants, Reference Alvarez, Rojas, Rojano and Ganan35–Reference Bandyopadhyay, Peralta-Videa and Gardea-Torresdey40 nanocomposites, Reference Hubbe, Rojas, Lucia and Sain20,Reference Habibi, Lucia and Rojas21,Reference Peralta-Videa, Zhao, Lopez-Moreno, de la Rosa, Hong and Gardea-Torresdey25,Reference Geissler, Loyal, Biesalski and Zhang41–Reference Auad, Mosiewicki, Richardson, Aranguren and Marcovich43 and biomass Reference Trujillo-Reyes, Peralta-Videa and Gardea-Torresdey44–Reference Celikbag, Robinson, Via, Adhikari and Auad46 are featured as the core thematic thread that links how a systems integration approach is the essence of materials design.
The significance of working with natural materials
Natural materials have emerged as materials of choice for a wide range of applications, ranging from biomedical to energy to environmental. The many attributes of natural materials, such as intrinsic biocompatibility and surface active properties, make them prime sources for state-of-the-art applications. Regarding the use of natural products for medicinal applications, there are many examples such as the integration of aloe vera, genistein from soybean, green tea leaves, carrot root, mango pulp, and more recently, Carvalho’s cactus mucilage—the viscous liquid inside cactus pads—in wound healing. Reference Carvalho, Soares, Blau, Menegon and Joaquim47,Reference Tabassum and Hamdani48 Natural plant-based products are classified as phytochemicals and have been found to exhibit anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, antimicrobial, regenerative, and biocompatible properties, and are viewed as safer and more affordable than conventional/standard therapies. Reference Tabassum and Hamdani48–Reference Sivamani, Ma, Wehrli and Maverakis52
Recent investigations continue to diversify the benefits of using extracts from plants such as cactus mucilage in the functional form of a filtration membrane. Reference Thomas, Devisetty, Katakam, Perez, Guo, Stebbins, Alcantar, Muppaneni, Abelson, Granqvist and Traversa38,Reference Thomas, Pais and Alcantar53,Reference Thomas, Alcantar, Pais, Bermudez, Majewski, Alcantar and Hurd54 Opuntia ficus-indica cactus mucilage extracts have been functionalized in the form of a nanofiber membrane ( Figure 2 ) for integration into rural or urban point-of-use filtration systems. Reference Thomas, Devisetty, Katakam, Perez, Guo, Stebbins, Alcantar, Muppaneni, Abelson, Granqvist and Traversa38,Reference Young, Anzalone, Pichler, Picquart, Alcantar, Shannon, Ginley and Weiss39,Reference Thomas, Pais and Alcantar53–Reference Vecino, Devesa-Rey, de Lima Stebbins, Moldes, Cruz and Alcantar57 Mucilage is a natural, nontoxic, biocompatible, biodegradable, inexpensive, and abundant material and is composed of proteins, monosaccharides, and polysaccharides ( Figure 3 ). Two fractions of the mucilage can be extracted. The solids portion after maceration leads to the gelling extract (GE), which is a pectin-rich polysaccharide; while the nongelling extract (NE), which is considered a galactomannan polysaccharide, can be obtained from the liquid supernatant. Reference Young, Anzalone, Pichler, Picquart, Alcantar, Shannon, Ginley and Weiss39,Reference Buttice, Stroot, Lim, Stroot and Alcantar56,Reference Alcantar, Joseph and Young58–Reference Fox, Stebbins and Alcantar61
Mucilage as an organic material is capable of interacting with metals, cations, and biological substances promoting flocculation—clumping pollutants into flocs—for removing arsenic, bacteria such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus cereus, and other particulates from drinking water ( Figure 4 ). Reference Buttice, Stroot, Lim, Stroot and Alcantar56,Reference Buttice, Alcantar and Ahuja59,Reference Fox, Stebbins and Alcantar61,Reference Alcantar, Fox, Thomas and Toomey65 This natural material has the potential to be used as a sustainable method for water filtration and contaminant sensing. A mucilage nanofiber membrane has been integrated into a filtration system to treat a 50-parts-per-billion (ppb) arsenic solution. Results demonstrate the natural functionality of the mucilage to absorb arsenic (As) atoms in the filtration system, and this is measured from filtration data in terms of the percentage of arsenic removed. Reference Thomas, Devisetty, Katakam, Perez, Guo, Stebbins, Alcantar, Muppaneni, Abelson, Granqvist and Traversa38 For instance, when mucilage was added in combination with iron, >90% removal of As was attained in just 10 min. Reference Fox, Stebbins and Alcantar61 When mucilage was added as a pure powder or in membrane form, up to 50% As or 18–20% As was removed, respectively. Reference Eppili55,Reference Vecino, Devesa-Rey, de Lima Stebbins, Moldes, Cruz and Alcantar57 Sibaja et al., Reference Sibaja, Culbertson, Marshall, Boy, Broughton, Solano, Esquivel, Parker, De la Fuente and Auad62 Vollrath et al., Reference Vollrath, Porter and Holland14 and Truss Reference Truss9 have also used natural fibers in functional applications such as textiles and tissue scaffolds. These studies elucidate that mucilage nanofiber membranes, silks, and biocomposite fibers have the potential to serve as the basis for the next generation of economically sustainable filtration devices that make use of a natural nontoxic material for sustainable systems integration designs.
Nanocomposites, polymer hybrids, hydrogels, and cactus mucilage have also been demonstrated as natural dispersants; Reference Green, Espinal, Traversa and Amis15,Reference Hubbe, Rojas, Fingas and Gupta19,Reference Dubois, Herzog, Ruttiger, Geissler, Grange, Kunz, Kleebe, Biesalski, Meckel, Gutmann, Gallei and Andrieu-Brunsen26,Reference Trujillo-Reyes, Peralta-Videa and Gardea-Torresdey44,Reference Jabbari, Veleta, Zarei-Chaleshtori, Gardea-Torresdey and Villagran63–Reference Alcantar, Fox, Thomas and Toomey65 hence, they have the potential of being used for oil spill cleanup operations. Reference Alcantar, Fox, Thomas and Toomey65 It is well known that extensive damage to marine and wildlife habitats can occur due to oil spills. Chemical dispersants can potentially bioconcentrate (when dispersant concentration exceeds that in water), causing damage to the marine life and environment. On the other hand, the use of surface active natural chemicals leads to nontoxic dispersants. John et al. Reference Jadhav, Vemula, Kumar, Raghavan and John66,Reference John, Shankar, Jadhav and Vemula67 have developed bio-based dispersants that can gelate crude oil and enhance its recovery. Reference Jadhav, Vemula, Kumar, Raghavan and John66,Reference Divya, Miroshnikov, Dutta, Vemula, Ajayan and John68 Similarly, NE and GE extracts from the cactus plant can be made less toxic by formulating oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions (Figure 3). Mucilage disperses oil in O/W emulsions by lowering the surface and interfacial tension. Higher emulsion stabilities were shown to have smaller droplet size in the systems with cactus mucilage. Reference Fox, Stebbins and Alcantar61,Reference Alcantar, Fox, Thomas and Toomey65
Toxicity is also an important issue to consider when working with natural materials. According to the US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) toxicity categories are used to classify chemicals based on their acute toxicity (US EPA, 2010b). Reference Denton, Miller and Stuber69 One of the most common parameters to measure toxicity is the LC50, which stands for the lethal concentration of a substance that causes 50% of a population of selected sensitive organisms to perish after 24 h of exposure. If the LC50 is less than 100 mg/L, by convention, the chemical in question can be considered toxic. The lesser the value of LC50, the more toxic a chemical. In our experience, mucilage from cactus, such as the NE and GE extracts, would be classified as practically nontoxic. When aquatic life is exposed to the mucilage, specifically Daphnia magna, the survival rate is almost 100% for concentrations equal to or lower than 100 mg/L. For concentrations ranging from 200–2000 mg/L of GE and NE, the survival rate of Daphnia was higher than 70%. In general, nonexistent toxicity is a beneficial property of working with natural materials. The contribution by Medina-Velo et al. shows in detail how toxicity could be a significant problem in plant biology when plants are exposed to different kinds of materials.
The previous examples mentioned that cactus mucilage properties demonstrate the ability of a natural material to be immersed in fresh and aquatic water systems, and how such systems can be integrated into water-treatment technologies. There are several other natural materials that offer critical benefits to systems integration of functional natural materials, and these will be discussed in the different contributions in this issue. Figure 5 shows a schematic representation of the contributions for this issue in regards to the integration of natural materials into functionalized sustainable systems. For instance, it illustrates how natural materials such as cellulose, lignin, cactus plants, biomass, and cells can be processed to produce paper for light, nonpower sensor applications, lignin nano- and macroparticulates, membrane filtration systems for water purification, bio-oils for energy and high-strength polymers, and functionalized tissue substrates. It is also worth mentioning that the analysis of how natural materials react to potential contaminants produced during nanomanufacturing will be discussed in this issue.
In this issue
Fabrication of functional tissue
Natural polymers and polysaccharides are of particular interest as nano- and macrostructures for wound care, skin grafting, and tissue engineering due to their chemical and biological properties, which mimic the extracellular matrix (ECM) to recreate the conditions needed for the physical bioenvironment and the biochemical reactions around cells. Reference Mano, Silva, Azevedo, Malafaya, Sousa, Silva, Boesel, Oliveira, Santos, Marques, Neves and Reis70 As the ECM provides structural and biochemical support to cells, an electrospun matrix of a polysaccharide-based natural material and biodegradable polymer has the potential to produce a biomembrane that can promote cell proliferation. This strategy of functionalizing a three-dimensional (3D) matrix of natural materials to be integrated for tissue engineering systems to promote cellular migration, proliferation, and growth can be viewed as a “top-down” outlook. Reference Akintewe, DuPont, Elineni, Cross, Toomey and Gallant17,Reference Zhernenkov, Ashkar, Feng, Akintewe, Gallant, Toomey, Ankner and Pynn30,Reference Cross, Toomey and Gallant32
In their article in this issue, Baksh et al. review an innovative method for bottom-up integration, which utilizes natural cell–cell junctions as in an ECM to build functional tissue layer by layer. The stacking of cells layer by layer on thermally responsive polymers in a three-dimensional (3D) environment produces “engineered cell sheets.” There is great promise for the utilization of engineered cell sheets for integration and direct adhesion to existing tissue in vitro or in vivo, without the use of intermediate scaffolds. This form of bottom-up integration functionalizes engineered cell sheets to mimic living cell proliferation and growth for tissue systems or tumors. Reference Maisonet, Elineni, Toomey and Gallant31,Reference Falahat, Wiranowska, Toomey and Alcantar34 Cell sheet engineered functional constructs have been integrated successfully in clinical trials and several surgical applications. With this advancement, there are still research questions that must be resolved regarding intercellular response from cell-cell and cell-release (i.e., cell detachment).
Functional paper for microfluidic devices
Microfluidic paper capitalizes on the rich natural porous characteristics of pulp (fiber-like cellulose material). In their article, Böhm and Biesalski review platforms for microfluidic paper devices, which have great flexibility for “manipulating fluid streams” by capillary action. The diversification of paper-based microfluidic systems ranges from medical to environmental applications. Reference Dubois, Herzog, Ruttiger, Geissler, Grange, Kunz, Kleebe, Biesalski, Meckel, Gutmann, Gallei and Andrieu-Brunsen26,Reference Bohm, Carstens, Trieb, Schabel and Biesalski27,Reference Ruettiger, Mehlhase, Vowinkel, Cherkashinin, Liu, Dietz, Stark, Biesalski and Gallei29 Several techniques are used to functionalize paper-based devices, including 3D splitting, mixing, or filtering delays. That is, these three forms of fluid transport were described as the separation of fluid into multiple streams (splitting); combining of fluid streams into a single channel (mixing); and separation from the fluid by a membrane (filtering). Microfluidic paper devices can be integrated into several systems, from DNA diagnostics to food-quality control.
This article also discusses the effects of the chemistry and structure of paper in its capacity to be chemically modified to increase its hydrophobicity. Such functionalization has been shown to have a large effect on capillary forces, which are used to control the flow direction and rate in paper-based microfluidic devices. The advantages of using paper as a platform in microfluidics include its low cost, versatility for being integrated with other materials and electronic systems, ease of use, and complete biodegradation after use. The applications of such functional materials is elegantly presented as a function of porosity, surface chemistry, and fiber structure, and the article evaluates the effects of such parameters in a general application involving DNA testing.
Functional materials from biomass
In energy, polymeric materials, based on valorization (i.e., real cost of the materials that considers the cost for their extraction, manufacturing, reuse, and end-of-life processes) of bio-based derived materials and renewable feedstocks, can be a critical alternative to fossil resources. High-performance biopolymers and bioresins use lignocellulosic biomass, which is generally obtained from plant-based materials such as agricultural residues, forestry wastes, and energy crops. In their article, Sibaja Hernández et al. report on these new polymeric materials that have a unique combination of thermal resistance and superior mechanical performance of polymeric resins, sufficient to compete with high-performance structural polyurethanes. Similarly, bio-oils can also be used as building blocks for high-performance biopolymers and bioresins with special surface active properties. Reference Trujillo-Reyes, Peralta-Videa and Gardea-Torresdey44,Reference Bird, Clary, Jajam, Tippur and Auad71 Similar to the cactus mucilage composition, bio-oils also contain high-value sugar and carbohydrates, which make them suitable to form fibers for membranes. Reference Marcovich, Auad, Aranguren, Oksman, Mathew, Bismarck, Rojas and Sain72 In addition, this article includes discussion of techniques that make possible the transformation of biomass into sustainable-energy sources, which have been regarded as transformative in the way bio-oils are utilized in polymer engineering.
Functional nano- and microparticles from lignin
The processing of lignin can also form new functional particles. Rojas and colleagues have been pioneers in the field of functional cellulosic crystals with nano- and microscales for various applications such as in new chemical, superhydrophobic surfaces, emulsifiers, adhesives, sensing devices, and bioscaffolds. Reference Hubbe, Rojas, Lucia and Sain20,Reference Habibi, Lucia and Rojas21,Reference Hubbe, Venditti and Rojas24,Reference Salas, Nypelo, Rodriguez-Abreu, Carrillo and Rojas42 Lignin has been of interest because it is durable and resistant to chemical attack. At the same time, it can be biodegraded by some microorganisms making it a suitable material for “green” applications. The lignin nanoparticles can be functionalized with metals and dielectrics to enhance their applicability in energy storage systems. In their article, Ago et al. present techniques for the processing of lignin particles such as self-assembly, extrusion, or coalescence. Such techniques are also important for processing other natural materials with similar properties into drug carriers, dispersants, food emulsifiers, and compound encapsulates. They also discuss how different colloidal properties can be finely controlled, depending on the type, size, and chemistry of the lignin particles.
Assessing the effects of functional materials via plant uptake mechanisms
For quite some time, we have been questioning what effects, if any, nano- or microscale materials have in plants as well as their fate in the environment. Gardea-Torresday’s group is a pioneer in this area and has been able to evaluate how these mechanisms take place in plants. One of the main concerns is whether engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) such as CeO2, SiO2, ZnO, or TiO2 enhance or inhibit the functionalities of biological, agricultural, and environmental systems. What is known is the natural ability of plants to adhere to an uptake or transport process, which is the elemental transition from soil to root or roots to tissues.
In their article in this issue, Medina-Velo et al. discuss the uptake and translocation of ENMs and the interactions with plant roots, tissue, and seeds. When natural plants are integrated into a system, there is the potential for the behavior of the system to change after the uptake of ENMs. The authors offer a unique perspective that shows the alarming amounts of ENMs produced per year and their potential effects. Reference Hubbe, Venditti and Rojas24,Reference Young, Anzalone, Pichler, Picquart, Alcantar, Shannon, Ginley and Weiss39 They have discovered that the mechanisms in plants are unique. Both a synchrotron micro x-ray fluorescence imaging technique and x-ray absorption near-edge structure were able to discern how nanoscale metals interact with plant biology and their effect on several food crops such as tomatoes, soybean, corn, and cucumbers, where the type of metal and chemistry plays a significant role in how the plant reacts to their presence.
System integration in sustainable design
Federal agencies started recognizing the importance of supporting projects that touched on the integration of natural materials in sustainable design. In the early 1990s, the EPA and the National Science Foundation (NSF) started supporting projects that included sustainable materials and processes. The NSF implemented “Biocomplexity in the Environment Programs” in the early 2000s. Consequently, the “Materials Use: Science, Engineering and Society” Program was promoted in 2003 with approximately USD$65 million investment. Subsequently, the creation of various institutes for sustainability along with different undergraduate and graduate curricula that relate to this issue increased exponentially. The current program that supports research and development across disciplines in this area is the “Sustainable Chemistry, Engineering, and Materials Program” at NSF. The great majority of technologies, new materials, and novel designs that resulted from such initiatives have shown that system integration of natural materials is key to enhancing our understanding of how to best learn from nature.
Summary
The successful application of natural materials in the construction of membranes, filtration devices, sensors, organic electronics, flexible smart materials, support structures, hydrated systems, chemical synthesis, and hydrophobic surfaces are displayed in the articles in this issue of MRS Bulletin. The contributions present various types of functionalized natural materials/composites engineered for high chemical and mechanical performance, which have a significant role in manufacturing and materials flow analysis. The benefits of fundamental science related to natural systems include prime relationships to sustainability such as life-cycle assessments, and life-cycle costs in health and safety that will continue to pave pathways to transform materials science and create better materials systems.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative and the National Science Foundation’s awards on Collaborative Research-SusChEM: Graded Interpenetrating Polymer Membranes Based on Sustainable Materials for Selective Removal of Organics from Water (CBET: 1512225) and EAGER: Fabrication, Characterization, and Implementation of an OFI Mucilage Nanofiber Membrane System (CBET: 1241582).
Financial Disclosure
N.A. Alcantar is an inventor of the following technologies, each of which is related to the project and is licensed by Water, Health, and Sustainability, LLC: Water Purification Method Using Plant Molecules (USF Tech ID 06A004PRC); Composition and Method to Reduce Sediment and Bacterial Contamination from Water (USF Tech ID USF 06A004PR2C); Use of Cactus Mucilage as a Dispersant and Absorbant for Oil in Oil-Water Mixtures (USF Tech ID USF 10A064); and Cactus Mucilage and Ferric Ions for the Removal of Arsenate (As[V]) from Water (USF Tech ID USF 11B122). N.A. Alcantar and S.W. Thomas are inventors of the following technology, which is also licensed by Water, Health, and Sustainability, LLC: Electrospun Cactus Mucilage Nanofibers (USF Tech ID 11A082).
Sylvia W. Thomas is an associate professor in electrical engineering and leads the Advanced Materials Bio and Integration Research Laboratory at the University of South Florida (USF). She joined the USF system in 2005 as the assistant dean in the College of Engineering. She received her bachelor’s and master’s degrees in electrical engineering in 1988 and 1990, respectively, from Vanderbilt University. She received her PhD degree in electrical engineering with a concentration in electronic device materials from Howard University in 1999. Thomas has published several articles, book chapters, and holds six patents. She is a member of the National Academy of Inventors and a 2012 McKnight Junior Faculty Fellow. She has received numerous awards, including an NSF Materials Research Science and Engineering Center Fellowship and the 2015 USF-Graduate Faculty Mentor Award. Her current research interests include processing and characterizing biomembranes, nanocomposites, biocompatible materials, and polymers for biomedical, water purification, energy harvesting, and electronic devices. Thomas can be reached by phone at 813-974-4011 or by email at [email protected].
Norma A. Alcantar is a professor in the Department of Chemical and Biomedical Engineering at the University of South Florida (USF). She is director of the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation Minority Scholars Program; co-director of the Water, Health, and Sustainability Graduate Certificate; and the director of the Materials Science and Engineering Graduate Certificate. She received her bachelor’s degree in chemical engineering in 1993 at the Universidad National Autónama de México, and her doctorate degree in chemical engineering at the University of California, Santa Barbara, in 2000. Her numerous awards include the 2010 USF–Hispanic Pathways Award, a 2016 Excellence in Innovation Award by the National Academy of Inventors, and a 2016–2017 Core Fulbright US Scholar Award. Alcantar has authored more than 44 publications and book chapters, and holds 10 patents. Her current research interests include interfacial phenomena and chemical characterization of biomimetic membranes, micellar surfactants, green chemistry materials, water purification systems, nanoparticles, and organic/inorganic thin films. Alcantar can be reached by phone at 813-974-8009 or by email at [email protected] and [email protected].