Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-lnqnp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T02:10:58.390Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A new military history of the Italian Risorgimento and Anti-Risorgimento: the case of ‘transnational soldiers’

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 January 2016

Ferdinand Nicolas Göhde
Ferdinand Nicolas Göhde*
Affiliation:
Department of History and Civilisation, European University Institute, Florence, Italy
*
∗Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The article discusses new studies of foreign soldiers in the Italian armed groups of the (Anti-)Risorgimento against the background of recent scholarship on ‘transnational soldiers’, which acknowledges the complexities of foreigners' initial motives for enlistment and of the transnational processes inside the single armies. The article suggests that from the mundane structures of military life to the perceptions of the rank-and-file, many aspects of the soldiering experience in the multinational armed groups on all sides of the Risorgimento actually advanced rather than obviated national boundaries. This paper further demonstrates that the military cultures of the nationalists and the anti-unity forces were much more porous and mutually constitutive than is often recognised. The histories of the ‘transnational soldiers’ in the armed groups of the Risorgimento and Anti-Risorgimento are crucial for a possibly new, comparative history of the armed groups of the (Anti-)Risorigmento. This paper explores approaches of the culturally revived ‘new military history’ and suggests that it provides much still unrealised potential for Risorgimento historiography.

Keywords

RisorgimentoAnti-Risorgimentomilitary historytransnational soldierstransnationalism
Type
Articles
Information
Modern Italy , Volume 19 , Issue 1: The Italian Risorgimento: transnational perspectives , February 2014 , pp. 21 - 39
Copyright
Copyright © Association for the study of Modern Italy 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alberton, A. M. 2011. “Perché partire? La scelta di indossare la camicia rossa. Percorsi in area veneta (1849–1866)” Società e storia 131:68–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arielli, N. 2013. “Getting There: Enlistment Considerations and the Recruitment Networks of the International Brigades during the Spanish Civil War.” In Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era, edited by Arielli, N., and Collins, B., 219–232. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arielli, N., and Collins, B. 2013. “Introduction: Transnational Military Service since the Eighteenth Century.” In Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era, edited by Arielli, N., and Collins, B., 1–12. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arielli, N., and Collins, B., eds. 2013. Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Aust, M., and Schönpflug, D. 2007. “Vom Gegner lernen. Einführende Überlegungen zu einer Interpretationsfigur der Geschichte Europas im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert.” In Vom Gegner lernen. Feindschaften und Kulturtransfers im Europa des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts, edited by Aust, M., and Schönpflug, D., 9–35. Frankfurt am Main: Campus.Google Scholar
Banti, A. M. 2000. La nazione del Risorgimento. Parentela, santità e onore alle origini dell'Italia unita. Turin: Einaudi.Google Scholar
Banti, A. M. 2005. L'onore della nazione. Identità sessuali e violenza nel nazionalismo europeo dal XVIII secolo alla Grande Guerra. Turin: Einaudi.Google Scholar
Banti, A. M., and Ginsborg, P., eds. 2007. Storia d'Italia. Annali 22. Il Risorgimento. Turin: Einaudi.Google Scholar
Banti, A. M., and Mondini, M. 2002. “Da Novara a Custoza: culture militari e discorso nazionale tra Risorgimento e Unità.” In Storia d'Italia. Annali 18. Guerra e pace, edited by Barberis, W., 415–462. Turin: Einaudi.Google Scholar
Berghahn, V. R. 1981. Militarism: the History of an International Debate, 1861–1979. Leamington Spa: Berg.Google Scholar
Bertrand, G., Brice, C., and Montègre, G., eds. 2012. Fraternité. Pour une histoire du concept, Les Cahiers du CRHIPA 20. Grenoble: CRIHPA.Google Scholar
Brice, C. 2009. “Alberto M. Banti. A Historian of Politics?” Nations and Nationalism 15(3):434–438.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brilli, A. 2006. Il viaggio in Italia. Storia di una grande tradizione culturale. Bologna: Il mulino.Google Scholar
Bron, G. 2009. “The Exiles of the Risorgimento. Italian Volunteers in the Portuguese Civil War (1832–34)” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 14(1):427–444.Google Scholar
Bulst, N., Gilcher-Holtey, I., and Haupt, H.-G., eds. 2008. Gewalt im politischen Raum. Fallanalysen vom Spätmittelalter bis ins 20. Jahrhundert. Frankfurt am Main: Campus.Google Scholar
Buschmann, N., and Carl, H. 2001. Die Erfahrung des Krieges: erfahrungsgeschichtliche Perspektiven von der Französischen Revolution bis zum Zweiten Weltkrieg. Paderborn: Schöningh.Google Scholar
Butler, J. 1997. The Psychic Life of Power: Theories in Subjection. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Buttà, G. 1883. Viaggio da Boccadifalco a Gaeta. Memorie della rivoluzione dal 1860 al 1861. Napoli: Comm. G. de Angelis & figlio tipogr.Google Scholar
Capuzzi, G. 1860. “La spedizione di Garibaldi in Sicilia. Memorie di un volontario.” In Vita di Giuseppe Garibaldi. Con la giunta di Garibaldi in Sicilia di Giuseppe Capuzzi, edited by Boggio, P. C., 217–296. Turin: s. n. Google Scholar
Casti, R. B. 2011. “L'addestramento militare e l'educazione dei giovani allievi Carabinieri nella storica caserma Cernaia. Il contributo dell'Arma alla unificazione italiana.” Paper presented at the conference La ginnastica militare e la ginnastica educativa nella costruzione dell'Italia unita, Turin, October 28–29.Google Scholar
Cecchinato, E. 2007. Camicie rosse. I garibaldini dall'unità alla Grande Guerra. Rome– Bari: Laterza.Google Scholar
Clark, C. 2006. “The New Catholicism and the European Culture Wars.” In Culture Wars. Secular-Catholic Conflict in Nineteenth-Century Europe, edited by Clark, C., 11–46. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Connell, R. W. 2005. “The Social Organization of Masculinities.” In Masculinities, 67–86. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Davis, J. A. 2008. “L'Antirisorgimento.” In Fare l'Italia. Unità e disunità nel Risorgimento (Gli italiani in guerra. Conflitti, identità, memorie dal Risorgimento ai nostri giorni, vol. 1), edited by Isnenghi, M., and Cecchinato, E., 753–769. Turin: UTET.Google Scholar
Decree from 17 May 1860. In Collezione delle leggi, decreti e disposizioni governative compilate dall'avvocato Nicolò Porcelli, edited by Porcelli, N., 9–10. Palermo: Carini.Google Scholar
Eickholt, K. A. 1917. Roms letzte Tage unter der Tiara. Erinnerungen eines römischen Kanoniers aus den Jahren 1868 bis 1870. Freiburg: Herder.Google Scholar
Förster, S., Jansen, C., and Kronenbitter, G., eds. 2010. Rückkehr der Condottieri? Krieg und Militär zwischen staatlichem Monopol und Privatisierung: Von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. Paderborn: Schöningh.Google Scholar
Forth, C. E. 2008. “Building Bodies. Violence, Pain and the Nation.” In Masculinity in the Modern West: Gender, Civilization and the Body, 114–138. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Frevert, U. 2004. A Nation in Barracks: Modern Germany, Military Conscription and Civil Society. Oxford: Berg.Google Scholar
Gareis, S. B. 2012. “Militärische Multinationalität.” In Militärsoziologie. Eine Einführung, edited by Leonhard, N., and Werkner, I.-J., 342–366. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.Google Scholar
Garibaldi, G. 1934a. “Alcune parole agli ufficiali e militi dell'esercito.” In Edizione nazionale degli scritti di Giuseppe Garibaldi. Scritti e discorsi politici e militari, vol. 1, 287–288. Bologna: Cappelli.Google Scholar
Garibaldi, G. 1934b. “All'emigrazione polacca – Firenze, Caprera, 5 febbraio 1863.” In Edizione nazionale degli scritti di Giuseppe Garibaldi. Scritti e discorsi politici e militari, vol. 1, 184. Bologna: Cappelli.Google Scholar
Ginsborg, P. 2012. “European Romanticism and the Italian Risorgimento.” In The Risorgimento Revisited. Nationalism and Culture in Nineteenth-Century Italy, edited by Patriarca, S., and Riall, L., 18–36. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Goffman, E. 1961. Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Göhde, F. N. 2009. “German Volunteers in the Armed Conflicts of the Italian Risorgimento 1834–70” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 14(4):461–475.Google Scholar
Handbuch für die Unterofficiere und Corporäle der päpstlichen Fremden-Regimenter enthaltend die Soldaten- und Plotons-Schule in Fragen und Antworten 1858. Macerata: Bianchini.Google Scholar
Harring, P. H. 1834. Mémoires sur la Jeune Italie et sur les derniers événements de Savoi, par un témoin oculaire. Paris: Libraire de M. Dérivaux.Google Scholar
Haupt, H.-G. 2012. Gewalt und Politik im Europa des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts. Göttingen: Wallstein.Google Scholar
Hippler, T. 2007. “Les soldats allemands dans l'armée napoléonienne d'après leurs autobiographies: microrépublicanisme et décivilisation” Annales Historiques de la Revolution Francaise 348:117–130.Google Scholar
Hippler, T. 2008. Citizens, Soldiers and National Armies: Military Service in France and Germany, 1789–1830. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hippler, T. 2011. “Volunteers of the French Revolutionary Wars: Myths and Reinterpretations.” In War Volunteering in Modern Times: from the French Revolution to the Second World War, edited by Krüger, C. G., and Levsen, S., 23–39. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Hochgeschwender, M. 2011. “Fág an Bealeagh: Irish Volunteers in the American Civil War.” In War Volunteering in Modern Times: from the French Revolution to the Second World War, edited by Krüger, C. G., and Levsen, S., 78–91. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Hoffstetter, G. v. 1851. Tagebuch aus Italien 1849. Zurich: F. Schulthess.Google Scholar
Hughes, M. J. 2012. Forging Napoleon's Grande Armée: Motivation, Military Culture, and Masculinity in the French Army, 1800–1808. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Ignace, A.-C. 2009. “French Volunteers in Italy, 1848–49. A Collective Incarnation of the Fraternity of the Peoples and of the Tradition of French Military Engagement in Italy and Europe” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 14(4):445–460.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Isastia, A. M. 1996. “Volontari provenienti dall'estero nell'esercito di Vittorio Emanuele II.” In Studi in onore di Federico Curato. Vol. II, edited by Albònico, A., 171–190. Milan: Angeli.Google Scholar
Isastia, A. M. 2008. “La guerra dei volontari. Ruolo politico e dimensione militare.” In Fare l'Italia. Unità e disunità nel Risorgimento (Gli italiani in guerra. Conflitti, identità, memorie dal Risorgimento ai nostri giorni, vol. 1), edited by Isnenghi, M., and Cecchinato, E. Turin: UTET.Google Scholar
Jackman, S. D. 2004. “Shoulder to Shoulder. Close Control and ‘Old Prussian Drill’ in German Offensive Infantry Tactics 1871–1914” Journal of Military History 68:73–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James, L. S. 2011. “For the Fatherland? The Motivations of Austrian and Prussian Volunteers during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars.” In War Volunteering in Modern Times: from the French Revolution to the Second World War, edited by Krüger, C. G., and Levsen, S., 40–58. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Koller, C. 2013. “Recruitment Policies and Recruitment Experiences in the French Foreign Legion.” In Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era, edited by Arielli, N., and Collins, B., 87–104. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Krüger, C. G., and Levsen, S. 2011. “Introduction: Volunteers, War, and the Nation since the French Revolution.” In War Volunteering in Modern Times: from the French Revolution to the Second World War, edited by Krüger, C. G., and Levsen, S., 1–22. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Kühne, T., and Ziemann, B., eds. 2000. Was ist Militärgeschichte? Paderborn: Schöningh.Google Scholar
Lyttelton, A. 2012. “The Hero and the People.” In The Risorgimento Revisited: Nationalism and Culture in Nineteenth-Century Italy, edited by Patriarca, S., and Riall, L., 37–55. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maag, A. 1909. Geschichte der Schweizertruppen in neapolitanischen Diensten 1825–1861. Zurich: Schulthess.Google Scholar
Maier, M. 1861. Der Kampf zwischen der deutschen Fremden-Legion und den Garibaldianern im Königreich beider Sicilien vom 6. April bis 28. October 1860. Karlsruhe: Druck von Friedrich Gutsch.Google Scholar
Martin, B. J. 2011. Napoleonic Friendship: Military Fraternity, Intimacy, and Sexuality in Nineteenth-Century France. Durham: University of New Hampshire Press.Google Scholar
Matricole, – Corpi esteri 1832–1870. Fondo Ministero delle Armi: Archivio di Stato di Roma.Google Scholar
Mazzini, G. 1908. “Atto di fratellanza della Giovine Europa.” In Scritti editi ed inediti di Giuseppe Mazzini, vol. IV, 3–6. Imola: Cooperativa Tipografica-Editrice Paolo Galeati.Google Scholar
Miani-Calabrese, D. 1960. “Lineamenti strutturali del gruppo demografico dei Mille” Statistica [Bologna] 4:559–584.Google Scholar
Mondini, M. 2008. “Militarismo e militarizzazione. Modelli nazionali nel rapporto tra armi e politica nell'Europa contemporanea” Ricerca e memoria 28:9–24.Google Scholar
Mösinger, G. 1868. Wozu braucht der heilige Vater eine Armee? Den Katholiken Deutschlands und Österreichs beantwortet. Salzburg: J. Oberer's Buchhandlung.Google Scholar
Moufang, C. 1868. Der Kampf um Rom und seine Folgen für Italien und die Welt. Zwei Reden gehalten auf den Katholiken-Versammlungen zu Münster und Cöln am 2. December 1867 und 27. Januar 1868 von Dr. Christoph Moufang, Domcapitular und Regens am bischöflichen Seminar in Mainz. Mainz: Franz Kirchheim.Google Scholar
Nieuwazny, A. 2010. “Patriotes ou mercenaires? Les légions polonaises au service de la France (1797–1807)” Revue historique des armées 260:26–36.Google Scholar
Nowosadtko, J. 2002. Krieg, Gewalt und Ordnung. Einführung in die Militärgeschichte. Tübingen: edition diskord.Google Scholar
Ordinanza di Sua Maestà pel governo, il servizio e la disciplina delle Reali Truppe nelle piazze 1831. Naples: Reale Tipografia della Guerra.Google Scholar
Patel, K. K. 2004. “Überlegungen zu einer transnationalen Geschichte” Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft 52:626–645.Google Scholar
Patel, K. K. 2009. “Transnations among Transnations? The Debate on Transnational History in the US and Germany” American Studies 53:451–472.Google Scholar
Patriarca, S. 2005. “Indolence and Regeneration: Tropes and Tensions of Risorgimento Patriotism” American Historical Review 110(2):350–379.Google Scholar
Patriarca, S., and Riall, L. 2012. The Risorgimento Revisited: Nationalism and Culture in Nineteenth-Century Italy. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Pecorini Manzoni, C. 1882. Richiami del gia capitano di stato maggiore Pecorini-Manzoni sopra alcuni appunti fatti alla storia della 15. divisione Turr. Catanzaro: Tip. G. Dastoli.Google Scholar
Pécout, G. 2004. “Philhellenism in Italy. Political Friendship and the Italian Volunteers in the Mediterranean in the Nineteenth Century” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 9(4):405–427.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pécout, G. 2009. “The International Armed Volunteers: Pilgrims of a Transnational Risorgimento” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 14(4):413–425.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pécout, G. 2012. “Pour une lecture méditerranéenne et transnationale du Risorgimento” Revue d'histoire du XIXe siècle 44(1):29–47.Google Scholar
Pellegrino Sutcliffe, M. 2013. “British Red Shirts: A History of the Garibaldi Volunteers (1860).” In Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era, edited by Arielli, N., and Collins, B., 202–218. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Pellicciari, A. 2008. Risorgimento ed Europa. Miti, pericoli, antidoti. Verona: Fede & Cultura.Google Scholar
Pernau, M. 2011. Transnationale Geschichte. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.Google Scholar
Porch, D. 2010. The French Foreign Legion: A Complete History of the Legendary Fighting Force. New York: Skyhorse Publishing.Google Scholar
Prechner, W. 1924. “Der Savoyerzug 1834. Die Geschichte eines mißlungenen Revolutionsversuchs” Zeitschrift für schweizerische Geschichte 4:459–507.Google Scholar
Pries, L. 2008a. Die Transnationalisierung der sozialen Welt. Sozialräume jenseits von Nationalgesellschaften. Frankfurt on Main: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar
Pries, L. 2008b. “Transnational Social Spaces: Which Units of Analysis, Reference and Measurement.” In Rethinking Transnationalism: The Meso-Link of Organizations, edited by Pries, L., 1–20. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Proklamation an die deutschen Soldaten im Dienste des Königs Franz II. von Neapel 1860. Staatsarchiv Basel-Stadt: Personal estates of Johann Lucas von Mechel.Google Scholar
Raphael, L. 1996. “Diskurse, Lebenswelten und Felder. Implizite Vorannahmen über das soziale Handeln von Kulturproduzenten im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert.” In Kulturgeschichte heute, edited by Hardtwig, W., and Wehler, H.-U., 165–181. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.Google Scholar
Riall, L. 2007a. Garibaldi: Invention of a Hero. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Riall, L. 2007b. “Eroi maschili, virilità e forme della guerra.” In Storia d'Italia. Annali 22. Il Risorgimento, edited by Banti, A. M., and Ginsborg, P., 253–288. Turin: Einaudi.Google Scholar
Riall, L. 2010. “Martyr Cults in Nineteenth-century Italy” Journal of Modern History 82(2):255–287.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Riall, L. 2012. “Guerre et nation dans l'Italie du Risorgimento” Revue d'histoire du XIXe siècle 44:49–64.Google Scholar
Robson, M. 2013. “‘Strangers, Mercenaries, Heretics, Scoffers, Polluters’: Volunteering for the British Auxiliary Legion in Spain, 1835.” In Transnational Soldiers: Foreign Military Enlistment in the Modern Era, edited by Arielli, N., and Collins, B., 181–201. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Rowlands, G. 2010. “Foreign Service in the Age of Absolute Monarchy: Louis XIV and His Forces Étrangères” War in History 17:141–165.Google Scholar
Rüstow, W. F. 1858. “Ausbildung.” In Militärisches Hand-Wörterbuch nach dem Standpunkte der neuesten Literatur und mit Unterstützung von Fachmännern. Zurich: Friedrich Schultheß.Google Scholar
Rüstow, W. F. 1861. Erinnerungen aus dem italienischen Feldzuge von 1860, vol. 1. Leipzig: F.A. Brockhaus.Google Scholar
Sanfilippo, M. 2007. “Fuggitivi e avventurieri: volontari nord americani tra Garibaldi e Pio IX. Una proposta di ricerca” Ricerche di storia politica 10(1):67–77.Google Scholar
Sarlin, S. 1860. “Fighting the Risorgimento: Foreign Volunteers in Southern Italy (1860–63)” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 14(4):476–490.Google Scholar
Schieder, W. 1972. “Brüderlichkeit.” In Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe. Historisches Lexikon zur politischsozialen Sprache in Deutschland, vol. 1, edited by Brunner, O., Conze, W., and Koselleck, R., 552–581. Stuttgart: Klett-Cottafs.Google Scholar
Severini, M. 2011. La Repubblica romana del 1849. Venice: Marsilio.Google Scholar
“Si dà un premio di ducati 50 alla fine della guerra a tutti i disertori napolitani che verranno a militare sotto le nostre bandiere (25/06).” 1860. Collezione delle leggi, decreti e disposizioni governative compilate dall'avvocato Nicolò Porcelli. edited by Porcelli, N., 69. Palermo: Carini.Google Scholar
Sikora, M. 2007. “Aneignung zur Abwehr. Scharnhorst, Frankreich und die preußische Heeresreform.” In Vom Gegner lernen. Feindschaften und Kulturtransfers im Europa des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts, edited by Aust, M., and Schönpflug, D., 61–94. Frankfurt am Main: Campus.Google Scholar
Spiegel, G. M., ed. 2005. Practicing History: New Directions in Historical Writing after the Linguistic Turn. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Stambolis, B. 2009. “Nationalisierung trotz Ultramontanisierung oder: ‘Alles für Deutschland. Deutschland aber für Christus.’ Mentalitätsleitende Wertorientierung deutscher Katholiken im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert” Historische Zeitschrift 269:57–97.Google Scholar
Thiesse, A.-M. 1999. La création des identités nationales. Europe XVIIIe–XXe siècle. Paris: Ed. du Seuil.Google Scholar
Vico, P. 1908. “Diritto penale militare.” In Enciclopedia del diritto penale italiano, edited by Pessina, E., 1–406. Milan: Società editrice libraria. 11.Google Scholar
Vigevano, A. 1914. La compagnia estera garibaldina nella campagna del 1860. Estratti dai fascicoli de “La nuova rivista della fanteria”. Rome: Stamperia Reale D. Ripamonti.Google Scholar
Vigevano, A. 1924. Legione ungherese in Italia (1859–1867). Rome: Libreria dello Stato.Google Scholar
Vogel, J. 2007. “Lernen vom Feind. Das Militär als Träger des deutsch-französischen Kulturtransfers im 19. Jahrhundert.” In Vom Gegner lernen. Feindschaften und Kulturtransfers im Europa des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts, edited by Aust, M., and Schönpflug, D., 95–113. Frankfurt am Main: Campus.Google Scholar
Wild, K. 1964. Auswanderer und Emigranten in der Geschichte der Leibesübungen. Schorndorf bei Stuttgart: Karl Hoffmann.Google Scholar
Wilson, P. H. 2008. “Defining Military Culture” Journal of Military History 72(1):11–41.Google Scholar
Zimmermann, L. R. 1864. “Erinnerungen eines ehemaligen Briganten-Chefs.” Der Kamerad 4.Google Scholar