Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T09:49:39.125Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

CITIZENS OR FAITHFUL? RELIGION AND THE LIBERAL REVOLUTIONS OF THE 1820S IN SOUTHERN EUROPE*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2015

MAURIZIO ISABELLA
MAURIZIO ISABELLA*
Affiliation:
School of History, Queen Mary University of London E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Historians of liberalism have tended to ignore or underplay the contribution of southern Europe. However, in the 1820s this part of the world was at the forefront of the struggle for liberal values. This essay explores the relationship between constitutional culture and religion during the liberal revolutionary wave that affected Portugal, Spain, the Italian peninsula and Greece, by examining parliamentary debates, the revolutionary press, literature targeting the masses, religious sermons and exile writings. It argues that rather than rejecting religion, liberals strove to find an accommodation between their values and revealed truth—they were convinced that no society could survive without religious morality. In this way, they developed a variety of religious attitudes that ranged from deism to forms of crypto-Protestantism without abandoning their established religions. At the same time, although they defended individual rights and freedom of expression against the opposition of the churches, and argued for reformed and enlightened forms of religiosity, most of them considered the religious uniformity of their societies advantageous and even opposed religious toleration.

Type
Forum: Global Liberalisms
Information
Modern Intellectual History , Volume 12 , Issue 3 , November 2015 , pp. 555 - 578
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I would like to thank Joanna Innes, Roberto Romani, Helena Rosenblatt and Konstantina Zanou, as well as audiences in Palermo and Oxford for helpful comments on earlier version of this piece. The research for this article was carried out while holding a Leverhulme Research Fellowship.

References

1 Bayly, C. A., “Rammohan Roy and the Advent of Constitutional Liberalism in India: 1800–1830,” Modern Intellectual History, 4/1 (2007), 25–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Bayly, , Recovering Liberties: Indian Thought in the Age of Liberalism and Empire (Cambridge, 2011), 50–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Bayly, Recovering Liberties, 19–21, 35–41.

3 Sebastián, Javier Fernandéz, “Toleration and Freedom of Expression in the Hispanic World between Enlightenment and Liberalism,” Past and Present, 211/1 (2011), 159–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schwartz, Stuart B., All Can Be Saved: Religious Tolerance and Salvation in the Iberian Atlantic World (New Haven and London, 2008)Google Scholar; Eastman, Scott, Preaching Spanish Nationalism across the Hispanic Atlantic 1759–1823 (Baton Rouge, 2012)Google Scholar. Kitromilides, Paschalis, “Orthodoxy and the West: Reformation to Enlightenment,” in Angold, M., ed., Cambridge History of Christianity, vol. 5, Eastern Christianity (Cambridge, 2008), 187–208Google Scholar.

4 On this intellectual space see Paquette, Gabriel, Imperial Portugal in the Age of Atlantic Revolutions: The Luso-Brazilian World, c.1770–1850 (Cambridge, 2014)Google Scholar. Sebastián, Javier Fernández, ed., Diccionario político y social del mundo iberoamericano: La era de las revoluciones, 1750–1850 (Madrid, 2009)Google Scholar.

5 On the constitutional culture of Spain and Italy see Spaeth, Jens, Revolution in Europa 1820–23: Verfassung und Verfassungskultur in den Königreichen Spanien, beider Sizilien und Sardinien-Piemont (Cologne, 2012)Google Scholar; Sarasola, Ignacio Fernandez, La Constitución de Cádiz: Origen, Contenido y proyección internacional (Madrid, 2011)Google Scholar; on exiles see Isabella, Maurizio, Risorgimento in Exile: Italian Emigrés and the Liberal International (Oxford 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Simal, Juan Luis, Emigrados: España y el Exilio Internacional, 1814–1834 (Madrid, 2012)Google Scholar.

6 Broers, Michael, The Politics of Religion in Napoleonic Italy: The War against God 1801–1814 (London and New York, 2002)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Perreau-Saussine, Emile, Catholicism and Democracy: An Essay in the History of Political Thought (Princeton, NJ and Oxford, 2011), 32–3Google Scholar.

8 Clogg, Richard, “The ‘Dhidhaskalia Patriki’ (1798): An Orthodox Reaction to French Revolutionary Propaganda,” in Anatolica: Studies in the Greek East in the 18th and 19th Centuries (Aldershot, 1996), 87–115Google Scholar; Clogg, “Anti-Clericalism in Pre-independence Greece c.1750–1821,” in ibid., 257–76.

9 Lehener, L. and Printy, M. eds., A Companion to the Catholic Enlightenment in Europe (Leiden, 2010)Google Scholar; Kitromilides, Paschalis, Enlightenment and Revolution: The Making of Modern Greece (Cambridge, MA, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Jones, Gareth Stedman and Katznelson, Ira, eds., Religion and the Political Imagination (Cambridge, 2010)Google Scholar. Van Kley, Dale K., The Religious Origins of the French Revolution: From Calvin to the Civil Constitution, 1570–1791 (Basingstoke, 2000)Google Scholar.

11 Rosenblatt, Helena, Liberal Values: Benjamin Constant and the Politics of Religion (Cambridge, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Innes, Joanna, “‘L’éducation nationale’ dans les îles Britanniques 1765–1815: Variations britanniques sur un thème européen,” Annales HSS, 65/5 (2010), 1087–1116CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Sarasola, Fernández, La Constitución de Cádiz, 112–13Google Scholar.

14 Barkey, Karen, “In the Lands of the Ottomans: Religion and Politics,” in Stedman, Jones and Katznelson, Religion and the Political Imagination, 90–111Google Scholar.

15 Kitromilides, Paschalis, “Itineraries in the World of the Enlightenment: Adamantios Korais from Smyrna via Montpellier to Paris,” in Kitromilides, , ed., Adamantios Korais and the European Enlightenment (Oxford, 2010), 1–33, at 26Google Scholar.

16 Gazi, Effi, “Revisiting Religion and Nationalism in Nineteenth-Century Greece,” in Beaton, R. and Ricks, D., eds., The Making of Modern Greece (Farnham, 2009), 95–196Google Scholar.

17 Freeze, Charles Anthony, The Orthodox Church and Independent Greece 1821–1852 (Cambridge, 1969), 45–6Google Scholar.

18 On Naples see Caglioti, Luigia, Vite parallele: Una minoranza protestante nell’Italia dell’Ottocento (Bologna, 2006)Google Scholar. In Greece Jews were either massacred or expelled from the territories controlled by the revolutionaries, and tensions emerged also with the Catholic minorities. Fleming, Katherine, Greece: A Jewish History (Princeton, NJ, 2008), 15–17Google Scholar.

19 Lupoli, Arcangelo, Rimostranza dell’Arcivescovo di Conza per la liberta’ della chiesa (Conza, 1821), 5, 14–15Google Scholar.

20 Racioppi, Felice, Al Parlamento Nazionale, Petizione del Canonico Felice Racioppi di Apice in P.U. (Avellino, n.d.)Google Scholar.

21 Aurelio, Lepre, La rivoluzione napoletana del 1820–21 (Rome, 1967), 247–53Google Scholar.

22 Galanti, Luigi, Catechismo costituzionale per uso del regno Unito delle Sicilie (Naples, 1820), 16Google Scholar. On Galanti see Narciso, Enrico, “Illuminismo e cultura sannita nel secolo XVIII,” in Narciso, , ed., Illuminismo meridionale e comunità locali (Naples, 1988), 25–62Google Scholar, at 49–50.

23 Diario das Cortes, 1821, 1771–3.

24 Ibid., 6 Aug. 1821, 1799–1802.

25 Diaro Das Cortes, 6 Aug. 1821, 1802.

26 Bispo de Béja, in Diario das Cortes, 3 Aug. 1821, 1772.

27 For the text of the bases see now Vieira, Benedicta Maria Duque, ed., O Problema político português no tempo das primeiras cortes liberais: Estudoes e documentos (Lisbon, 1991)Google Scholar.

28 Alberti, Annibale, ed, Atti del Parlamento delle Due Sicilie 1820–21, 3 vols. (Bologna, 1926), 2: 170–77Google Scholar.

29 On the legislation see Sarasola, La Constitución de Cádiz, 263; on the cardinal Borbon see Brea, Rodríguez López, Don Luis de Borbón el cardinal de los liberales: 1777–1823 (Toledo, 2002), 302–4Google Scholar.

30 “Dell’utilità dei giornali in uno stato costituzionale,” L’Imparziale, Naples, 14 Aug. 1820, 4. Similar arguments in “Atti de’ varii poteri. Potere legislative. Affari ecclesiastici,” Il Censore, Naples, 16 Jan. 1821, 61–2; Luigi Galanti, “Rapporto della commissione di esame a tutela della costituzione sulla mozione del signor deputato Catalano,” in Lettera dell’Arcivescovo di Napoli al parlamento nazionale e risposta del Parlamento (Naples, 1821), 14.

31 The debates have been published in Dias, Augusto da Costa, Discursos sobre a libertade de imprensa no primeiro parlamento português (1821) (Lisbon, 1978), 72–4 and 126–30Google Scholar for Castelo Branco's interventions, 92–3 for Senor Peçanha, 94 for similar ideas by Carmelo Fortes.

32 Fernandes Tomás, in ibid., 106.

33 Ibid., 76–7.

34 Ibid., 101.

35 Faria, Anna Moura, “A condiçao do clero português durante a primeira experiência de implantaçao do liberalism: As influências do processo revolucionário francês e seus limites,” Revista portuguésa de Historia, 23 (1987), 301–31Google Scholar. On censorship see also Tengarrinha, José, Da Liberdade Mitificada à Liberdade Subvertida (Lisbon, 1993)Google Scholar.

36 Baeza, Rafael Sagredo, De la colonia a la república: Los catecismos políticos americanos, 1811–1827 (Madrid, 2009)Google Scholar.

37 Don Apolinar Contoni, Cartilla de explicacíon de la constitución política de la monarquia Española, para la instruccíon de los niños de la parroquia de Santiago de la ciudad de Baza (Sevilla, 1821), repr. in Catecismos politicos españoles (Madrid, 1989), 205.

38 Ibid., 206. de Miranda, Inocencio Antonio, O Cidadão lusitano (Lisbon, 1822), 48–50Google Scholar.

39 Palma, Alerino, Political Catechism for the Greek Youth (in Greek) (Hydra, 1826)Google Scholar.

40 Garrett, Almeida, “Da protecção, e introspecção da religião, da instrução pública, e da corrupção da moral, que da qui provinha,” in Garrett, O dia vinte e quatro de agosto [1821], in Garrett, , Obras Completas, Obra Politica, Escritos do vintismo (1820–23) (Lisbon, 1985), 214–16Google Scholar. Similar ideas in O parocho constitucional ou: Dialogo entre hum parocho de Riba-Tejo e hum citadão liberal de Lisboa seu amigo (Lisbon, 1821).

41 Estere, Notizie, “Francia, Parigi, 19 Agosto 1820,” Giornale patriottico di Sicilia, Palermo, 25 Sept. 1820, 4Google Scholar.

42 De Miranda, O Cidadão lusitano, 55–6.

43 A.C.B.D., Parlata dell’uomo sincero: Avviso alla piu’ parte della nazione (n.d., n.p., but Naples, 1820).

44 Candido de Almeida y Sandoval, O fanatismo e a Intolerancia combatidos por hum filosofo Christão (Lisbon, 1821), 3,4Google Scholar.

45 Exposição da lei natural; ou catecismo do citadão (Lisbon, 1820), 9, 55, 60.

46 Catechismo patriottico estratto dalla opera di La Croix ed adottato al regno delle due Sicilie tradotto dal francese da Giovanni Taddej (Naples, 1820), 10.

47 “Dialogos de un Aldeano con el Domine del Lugar,” Diario de Barcelona, 28 March 1820, 57–8.

48 Kapodistrias, Ioannis, “The Address of Count Ioannis Kapodistrias to the Greeks” [1819], in Clogg, R., ed., The Movement for Greek Independence 1770–1821 (London and Basingstoke, 1976), 131–6Google Scholar. On Korais's ideas about religion see also Clogg, , “The Correspondence of Adhamantios Korais with the British and Foreign Bible Society (1808),” in Clogg, Anatolica, 65–84Google Scholar.

49 Nicola Salerno, Compendio della Terapeutica costituzionale, o sia ristretto ragionamento su la cura de’ mali politici e legali del nuovo governo costituzionae del Regno di Napoli (Naples, 1820), 14–15.

50 “Papel de hum academico, impresso de ordem do Governo: Conimbricenses,” Gazeta de Lisboa, 3 Oct. 1820. See also Cathecismo Constitucional: Reimpresso, corregido e augmentado offerecido a's cortes gerais, extraordinarias, e constituentes da nação portugueza (Lisbon, 1821), 36.

51 Rosenblatt, Helena, “The Christian Enlightenment,” in Stewart J. Brown and Timothy Tackett, eds., The Cambridge History of Christianity, vol. 7, Enlightenment, Reawakening and Revolution 1660–1815 (Cambridge, 2006), 283–301Google Scholar; Rosa, M., ed., Cattolicesimo e lumi nel settecento italiano (Rome, 1981)Google Scholar; Callahan, William, Church, Politics and Society in Spain, 1750–1874 (Cambridge, MA, 1984)Google Scholar.

52 Avila, Alfredo, “El Cristiano Constitucional: Libertad, derecho y naturaleza en la retórica de Manuel de la Bárcena,” Estudios de Historia Moderna y Contemporanea de México, 25 (2003), 5–41Google Scholar; Ruiz, Víctor Peralta, “Sermones y pastorales frente a un nuevo lenguaje político,” in Hébrard, V. and Verdo, G., eds., Un objecto de Historia: Las Indipendencias Hispanoamericanas (1810–1830) (Madrid, 2013), 117–34Google Scholar.

53 Dufour, Gérard, “Estudio Preliminar y presentación,” in Dufour, Sermones revolucionarios del Trienio Liberal (1820–1823) (Alicante, 1991), 7–57Google Scholar.

54 Don Mariano Garcia Zamora, Breve discurso o sermon que ne la misa de espíritu-santo celebrada en la iglesia catedral de Caragena sita en Murcia . . .: A los electores de partido [1820], in Dufour, Sermones revolucionarios, 89, 92–3.

55 Barbara, António Santa, Sermão em acção de graças pela desejada e muito feliz união da junta provisoria do governo supremo do reino com o governo interino de Lisboa—verificada no 1.⁰ de outubro de 1820 (Porto, 1820), 27Google Scholar.

56 Ibid., 20.

57 Allocuzione del Sacerdote Don Luigi Amendola, recitata nella parrochiale chiesa di S. Giuseppe di Otajano nel di’ 16 luglio 1820 (Naples, 1820), 6.

58 A Soberania da Nação, ou manifesto aos Frades e Clérigos, obra util a todo o citadao (Lisbon, 1821), 4, 5, 12.

59 Hartzopoulos, Marios, “From Resurrection to Insurrection: ‘Sacred’ Myths, Motifs, and Symbols in the Greek War of Independence,” in Beaton, and Ricks, , The Making of Modern Greece, 81–93Google Scholar, at 88. Kitromilides, Paschalis, “Athos and the Enlightenment,” chap. 7 of Kitromilides, An Orthodox Enlightenment: Symbolic Legacies and Cultural Encounters in Southeastern Europe (Aldershot, 2007), 257–72Google Scholar, at 269.

60 Argyriou, Astérios, Les éxèges grecques de l’apocalypse à l’epoque turque (1453–1821): Esquisse d’une historie des courants idéologiques au sein du people grec asservi (Thessaloniki, 1982), 101–2Google Scholar.

61 Santa Barbara, Sermão, p.17.

62 Campanile, Gennaro, Allocuzione nel rendimento di grazie all’altissimo per l’ottenuta costituzione (Naples, 1820), 27–8Google Scholar, italics in the original.

63 Clary, Michele Basilio, Il liberalismo cristiano: Omelie sacro-politiche (Messina, 1821)Google Scholar.

64 Ibid., 3–5, 14–17.

65 Ibid., 93–120.

66 de Pradt, Dominique Dufour, De la Révolution actuelle de l’Espagne, et de ses suites (Paris, 1820)Google Scholar. On French liberal Catholicism see Rosenblatt, Liberal Values, 185–6; and Kelly, George Armstrong, The Humane Comedy: Constant, Tocqueville and French Liberalism (Cambridge, 1992), 92–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar et seq. De Pradt's intervention in French Restoration debates on religion was represented by his Les quatre Concordats (Paris, 1818).

67 De Pradt, De la Révolution actuelle, 194–6.

68 Lanjuinais, Jean-Denis, Vues politiques sur les changemens à faire a la constitution de l’Espagne, afin de la consolider, spécialement dans le Royaume des Deux Sicilies (Paris, 1820), 20Google Scholar.

69 Rosenblatt, Liberal Values, 172–6. Benjamin Constant, Principles of Politics [1815], in Constant, Political Writings, ed. B. M. Fontana (Cambridge, 1993), 285.

70 Rosen, Frederick, Bentham, Byron and Greece: Constitutionalism, Nationalism, and Early Liberal Political Thought (Oxford, 1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 Ibid., 84–9. Bentham, Jeremy, “Observations,” in Bentham, , Securities against Misrule and Other Constitutional Writings from Tripoli and Greece, in Bentham, , Collected Works, ed. Schofield, T. P. (Oxford, 1990), 209–15Google Scholar, and esp. 254–6.

72 Kitromilides, “Itineraries in the World of the Enlightenment,” 22. Korais's views are included in his Simeioseis eis to Prosorinon Politevma tis Ellados tou 1822 etous (Notes on the Provisional Constitution of Greece of the Year 1822), ed. Th. P. Volidis (Athens, 1933), 3–8.

73 Estrada, Alvaro Florez, El Español Constitucional, 1825, 452–3Google Scholar.

74 “Filantropismo—tolerancia religiosa,” El Español Constitutional, 1819, 51–6, at 52 ff.

75 Pecchio, Giuseppe, Semi-serious Observations of an Italian Exile during His Residence in England [1830] (Philadelphia, 1833), 188, 197, 198Google Scholar.

76 See, for example, the case of the writings of Joaquin Lorenzo Villanueva in his magazine Ocios de espanõles emigrados. Alonso, Gregorio, “Learning from the Enemy: Liberal Catholicism and Protestantism in the Exiles Experience,” in Muñoz-Sempere, D. and Alonso, G., eds., Londres y el Liberalismo Hispánico (Madrid, 2011), 59–75Google Scholar. Isabella, Risorgimento in Exile, 129–34.

77 Fuentes, Juan Francisco, “El liberalismo radical ante la unidad religiosa,” in Libéralisme chrétien et catholicisme libéral en Espagne, France et Italie dans la première moitié du XIXe siècle (Aix en Provence, 1989), 127–41Google Scholar.

78 Fernandéz Sebastián, “Toleration and Freedom of Expression.”

79 Kelly, The Humane Comedy, 91–2.