Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T18:31:33.307Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Those Noble Exemplars of the True Military Tradition’; Constructions of the Indian Army in the Mid-Victorian Press1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Douglas M. Peers
Douglas M. Peers
Affiliation:
University of Calgary
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper is directed first at identifying where and by whom military influences or topics manifested themselves in the periodical pressʼns coverage of India in the period up to the Indian Rebellion. How such manifestations changed over time, as well as the convergence of Anglo-Indian and British newspapers and magazines on Indian topics, will form an important component of this study. Stemming from these initial enquiries, I will further suggest that the model often employed to comprehend such representations —namely ‘orientalism’ —is, as it is often configured, too simplistic and reductionist to account for all the forces at work in the production of images of India. Instead, the mid-Victorian image of India was produced by a very fractured discourse. Racial stereotypes and affirmations of British superiority were certainly to the forefront, but these were frequently inflected by quite separate agendaʼns, such as the military's pursuit of political and professional status and influence, publishers’ search for profits, and the quest for suitable middle-class role models. Moreover, it was a discourse constrained by the dominant contemporary literary conventions and tropes, notably the historical romance in fiction and didacticism in history and biography. Yet there is one strand that runs through these various agendas and literary strategies and that is the one provided by the Indian army. India was by the third decade of the nineteenth-century as much a military as it was a commercial site. In 1850, the then reigning governor-general, Lord Dalhousie, was reminded by John Lawrence of this fact when the latter insisted that ‘public opinion is essentially military in India. Military views, feelings and interests are therefore paramount’.

Type
Articles
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 31 , Issue 1 , February 1997 , pp. 109 - 142
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1997

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 The didactic strategies of philosphical history, and their application to India, have been discussed in Martha, McLaren, ‘From Analysis to Prescription: Scottish Concepts of Asian Despotism in Early Nineteenth-Century British India’, International History Review, 15(1993): 469–501.Google Scholar

3 Oriental and India Office Collections [hereafter OIOC], Lawrence to Dalhousie, 20 Sept. 1850, MSS Eur F90/3.Google Scholar

4 [Kaye, J. W.], ‘The Romance of Indian Warfare’, North British Review, 12(1849/1950): 222.Google Scholar

5 For the Sikhs, see Fox, Richard, Lions in the Punjab; Culture in the Making (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985);Google ScholarOberoi, Harjot, The Construction of Religious Boundaries: Culture, Identity and Diversity in the Sikh Tradition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994);Google Scholarand Omissi, David, The Sepoy and the Raj (London: Macmillan, 1994).Google Scholar

6 For the period prior to the 1830s, see Peers, Douglas M.,‘ “The Habitual Nobility of Being”: British Officers and the Social Construction of the Bengal Army in the Early Nineteenth Century’, Modern Asian Studies, 25(1991): 545–69.Google Scholar

7 It is interesting to note that Walter Scott's historical romances were among the few fictional works deemed suitable reading for the European rank and file and hence they were to be found in Indian regimental libraries. OIOC, Military Letter from Bengal, 29 Aug. 1834, F/4/1486, no. 58611.Google Scholar

8 The volume of postorientalist critiques of South Asian historiography, initially inspired by Said, Edward, Orientalism(New York: Routledge, 1978) is too voluminous to list here.Google Scholar However, major works in this field include Inden, Ronald, Imagining India (Oxford: Blackwell, 1990),Google ScholarSuleri, Sara, The Rhetoric of English India (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992),Google ScholarViswanathan, Gauri, Masks of Conquest; Literary Study and British Rule in India (New York: Columbia UP, 1989),Google Scholar and Spivak, Gayatri, ‘The Burden of English’, Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament; Perspectives on South Asia, Breckenridge, Carol and Veer, Peter van der (eds) (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1993), 134–57.Google ScholarA recent assessment of the field is offered by Prakash, Gyan, ‘Subaltern Studies as Postcolonial Criticism’, American Historical Review, 99(1994): 1475–90Google Scholar

9 Breckenridge, and Veer, van der, Introduction, Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament, 6.Google Scholar

10 See for example O'Hanon, Rosalind and Washbrook, David, ‘Histories in Transition: Approaches to the Study of Colonialism and Culture in India’, History Workshop Journal, 32(1991): 110–28;Google ScholarO'Hanlon, Rosalind, ‘Cultures of Rule, Communities of Resistance: Gender, Discourse and Tradition in Recent South Asian Historiographies’, Social Analysis, 25(1989): 94–114;Google ScholarMacKenzie, John M., ‘Edward Said and the Historians’, Nineteenth Century Contexts, 18(1994): 9–26;Google Scholarand Rocher, Rosane, ‘British Orientalism in the Eighteenth Century: the Dialectics of Knowledge and Government’, Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament, 215–49.Google Scholar

11 See for example, Dirks, Nicholas B., ‘Colonial Histories and Native Informants: Biography of an Archive’, and Arjun Appadurai, ‘Number in the Colonial Imagination’, Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament, 279–313, 314–39.Google ScholarAlso, Richards, Thomas, The Imperial Archive (London: Verso, 1993).Google Scholar

12 Regulation XI of 1835 provided the press in India with the freedom to print what they wanted. No longer would they require a license that could be revoked by the government. In effect, the only legal limits on the press from 1835 were those provided by the laws governing libel.Google Scholar

13 Anon, ‘The Subaltern's Logbook’, Naval and Military Magazine 4 (1828): 165.Google Scholar

14 See for example the petitions for 1830–1838, National Archives of India, Public Consultations, 1830–1838.Google Scholar

15 Spry, Henry, Modern India (London, 1837), 86.Google Scholar

16 [Chips, ], ‘Books for the Indian Army’, Household Words, 18(1858): 437.Google Scholar

17 Tidrick, Kathryn, Empire and the English Character (London: Tauris, 1992), 16;Google ScholarRamsay, Balcarres D. Wardlaw, Rough Recollections of Military Service and Society (Edinburgh: Blackwood, 1882), i, 114.Google Scholar

18 Spry, , Modern India, 88.Google Scholar

19 The Mofussilite was first published in Calcutta in the second half of 1845; it was then published in Meerut from 1847 to 1852, moving to Agra from 1853–59, returning to Meerut from 1860–68, Delhi in 1869, and finally winding up at Ambala from 1870–74.Google Scholar

20 Vizetelly, Henry, Glances Back Through Seventy Years: Autobiographical and Other Reminiscences (London: Kegan Paul, 1893), ii, 8–9.Google Scholar

21 Lang, John, ‘Starting a Paper’, Household Words, 7(1853): 95.Google Scholar

22 For example, the leading article in the Mofussilite, 16 Aug. 1845, 1–2.Google Scholar

23 See for example National Library of Scotland, Diary of Private John Charles Brown, 1856 [?], MS 15393.Google Scholar

24 Mofussilite, 20 Sept. 1845, 11 O c t. 1845, 1 Nov. 1845, 22 Nov. 1845.Google Scholar

25 Ramsay, , Rough Recollections, i, 124.Google Scholar

26 Ibid., i, 181.

27 Marshall, P. J.,‘ “Cornwallis Triumphant”: War in India and the British Public in the Late Eighteenth Century’, War, Strategy and International Politics; Essays in Honour of Sir Michael Howard, Hayes, Lawrence Freedman Paul, and O'Neill, Robert, eds (Oxford: Clarendon, 1992), 57–74.Google Scholar

28 Gleig, G. R., The Life of Major General Sir Thomas Munro (London: Colburn and Bentley, 1830), iii, pp. iii–iv.Google Scholar

29 Milne, Morris, ‘The Management of a Nineteenth-Century Magazine: William Blackwood and Sons, 1827–47’, Journal of Newspaper and Periodical History, 1(1985): 30.David Finkelstein's recent work on Blackwoods has shown that this journal continued to cultivate its colonial readership until well into the 20th century.Google Scholar

30 National Library of Scotland, Gleig to Blackwood, 29 Dec. 1826, MS 4017, f.99 (Blackwood Papers).Google Scholar

31 National Library of Scotland, Gleig to Blackwood, 30 July 1826, MS 4017, f.82 (Blackwood Papers).Google Scholar

32 Palmegiano, Eugenie, ‘The Indian Mutiny in the Mid-Victorian Press’, Journal of Newspaper and Periodical History, 7 ( 1991 ): 3.Google Scholar

33 Lohrli, Anne (comp.), Household Words: a Weekly Journal, 1850–1859 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press 1973), 23.Google ScholarFigures for Blackwood's circulation are taken from Milne, , ‘Management of a Nineteenth-Century Magazine’, 25Google Scholarand for the Edinburgh Review they are taken from Fetter, Frank, ‘Economic Controversy in the British Reviews, 1802–1850’, Economica, n.s. 32(1965): 425. Milne also suggests that for most periodicals, a multiplier of eight or nine would not be unreasonable in trying to estimate the total number of people who came into contact with these journals.Google Scholar

34 Marshall, , ‘Cornwallis Triumphant’, 58–9.Google Scholar

35 The impact of accelerated communications is discussed in Cranfield, G. A., The Press and Society, from Caxton to Northcliffe (Harlow: Longman, 1978), esp. p p. 163–71.Google Scholar

36 The rise and development of the military press in India has as yet received little attention though Albert Tucker has provided a useful summary in an essay in Victorian Periodicals and Victorian Society, Vann, J. Don and VanArsdel, Rosemary T., eds (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994).Google ScholarThe importance of the military press in prompting military reforms in Britain is persuasively argued in Strachan, Hew, Wellington's Legacy: the Reform of the British Army, 1830–1854 (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1984).Google Scholar

37 The fullest account available of Henry Colburn is provided in Rosa, Matthew Whiting, The Silver-Fork School: Novels of Fashion Preceding ‘Vanity Fair’ (New York: Columbia University Press, 1936). Colburn's illegitimacy is reported on p. 179.Google ScholarSee Sutherland, John, ‘Henry Colburn Publisher’, Publishing History, 19(1986): 59–84.Google Scholar

38 Tucker, , 67.Google Scholar

39 Singh, Nihar Nandan, British Historiography on British Rule in India: the Life and Writings of Sri John William Kaye, 1814–1876 (Patna: Janaki Prakashan, 1986), appendix. I am grateful to C. A. Bayly for drawing my attention to this important and unjustly overlooked work.Google Scholar

40 [Kaye, J. W. ], ‘ The Crisis in India ‘, North British Review, 27(1857): 254–76,Google Scholarand Kaye, Q. W.], ‘India‘, Edinburgh Review, 106(1857): 544–94.Google Scholar

41 Singh, , British Historiography, 2–4.Google Scholar

42 Kaye, J. W., The Administration of the East India Company; a History of Indian Progress, 2nd ed. (London: Richard Bentley), 1853, 450.Google Scholar

43 Singh, , British Historiography, places great emphasis on the importance of Scott's historical romances in configuring the discourse through which Kaye and other writers on India worked.Google Scholar

44 Tucker, , Victorian Periodicals, 66.Google Scholar

45 Dictionary of National Biography, xviii, 1282–83.Google Scholar

46 I am grateful to David Finkelstein for explaining Henry Reeve's role in securing publishing openings for Philip Meadows Taylor.Google Scholar

47 Taylor, Philip Meadows, The Story of My Life, edited by his daughter (Edinbugh: Blackwood, 1878), 116, 295.Google Scholar

48 Taylor, , Story of My Life, 217–19.Google Scholar

49 Barrell, John, The Infection of Thomas De Quincey: A Psycopathology of Imperialism (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1991). See also the Robert Baird Smith papers in the National Library of Scotland.Google Scholar

50 Mofussilite, 1848;Google ScholarFraser's Magazine, 47(1853).Google Scholar

51 Mofussilite, 22 Nov. 1845, 323.Google Scholar

52 OIOC, Hardinge to Peel, 18 Aug. 1845, MSS Eur Neg II 692; and Peel to Hardinge, 24 Sept. 18(45?), MSS Eur Neg 11693 [Hardinge Papers].Google Scholar

53 , Hardinge to Walter James, 13 Aug. 1846, The Letters of the First Viscount Hardinge of Lahore, Singh, Bawa Satinder (ed.), Camden Fourth Series, Vol. 32 (London: Royal Historical Society, 1986), 186.Google Scholar

54 [Dunlop, William], ‘Authentic Narrative of Facts which occurred during a March in India’, Fraser's Magazine, 12(1835): 667–9.Google Scholar

55 Articles on thagi include one by Taylor, Meadows in the New Monthly Magazine (1833),Google ScholarTrevelyan, in the Edinburgh Review (1836),Google ScholarHolme, Frederick in Blackwood's Magazine (1841),Google Scholarand anonymous contributions in Foreign Quarterly Review (1838),Google Scholar and Dublin University Magazine (1840).Google Scholar

56 [Kaye, J. W.], ‘The War on the Sutlej’, North British Review, 5(1846): 258.Google Scholar

57 quoted in MacKenzie, J. M. (ed.), Popular Imperialism and the Military (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1992), 2.Google Scholar

58 [Ludlow, J. M.], ‘Captain Hervey's Ten Years in India’, Fraser's Magazine, 42(1850): 479–82.Google Scholar

59 The Times, 2 Sept. 1837.Google Scholar

60 Lang, , ‘Starting a Paper’, 96.Google Scholar

61 Brantlinger, , Rule of Darkness, 81.Google Scholar

62 [Townsend, E. and Hamilton, A. H. A.], ‘Indian Recruits and Indian English’, Household Words, 16(1857): 222.Google Scholar

63 Barrell, , Thomas De Quincey, 7.Google Scholar

64 The common implication that good gunnery was the consequence of deserters going over to the enemy was made in 1825 in Burma, again in 1825 for Bhartpur, as well as in some of the smaller campaigns of the 1830s and 1840s such as Chittoor and Gwalior.Google Scholar

65 Sir Scott, Walter, The Surgeon's Daughter (reprint of 1827 edn, Edinburgh): 10.Google Scholar

66 Select Committee on East India Company Affairs (Parliamentary Papers, 1831/32, Vol. 13), 165.Google Scholar

67 Anon, ‘Considerations on the Native Army and General Defence of India’, United Service Journal, 7(1831): 3.Google Scholar

68 Belich, James, ‘The Victorian Interpretation of Racial Conflict and the New Zealand Wars: An Approach to the Problem of One-Sided Evidence’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, 15(1987): 123–47.Google Scholar

69 An example of this is the description of the siege and capture of Bhartpur in 1825. See [Veritas, ], ‘Siege of Bhurtpore’, Naval and Military Magazine, 3(1828): 396–408.Google Scholar

70 An Old Indian [Gleig, G. R.], ‘The Indian Army’, Blackwood's Magazine, 21(1827): 563–73; National Library of Scotland, Gleig to Blackwood, 30 April 1828, MS 4021 (Blackwood Papers).Google Scholar

71 Peers, , ‘Habitual Nobility of Being’.Google Scholar

72 [ Carnaticus, ], Four Letters of Camaticus, Explanatory of his Views of the Indian Army … (London: np, 1821).Google Scholar

73 Anon, ‘The Indian Army as it now is’, Colbum's United Service Magazine, 1847(1): 508.Google Scholar

74 Anon, ‘Memoir of the Emperor Jahangueir’, Colbum's United Service Magazine, 2(1829): 203.Google Scholar

75 Asiatic Journal and Monthly Register, 20(1825): 223.Google Scholar

76 Examiner, 3 Jan. 1830, 11.Google Scholar

77 Bolt, Christine, ‘Race and the Victorians‘, British Imperialism in the Nineteenth Century (London: Macmillan, 1984), 126.Google Scholar

78 India Office Library and Records, memo by Lt. Col. Frederick, 1828, MSS Eur F765/3 (Frederick Papers).Google Scholar

79 Crossick, Geoffrey, ‘From Gentlemen to the Residuum: Languages of Social Description in Victorian Britain’, Language, History and Class, Corfield, Penelope J., ed. (Oxford: Blackwell, 1990), 160.Google Scholar

80 Anon, ‘The Indian Army, no. 3’, United Service Journal, 20(1836).Google Scholar

81 [, S. S.], ‘ An Apology for the Indian Army’, United Service Journal, 8(1832): 32.Google Scholar

82 [Kaye, J. W.], ‘The Romance of Indian Warfare’, 195.Google Scholar

83 Ibid., 194.

84 Ibid.

85 Anon, ‘The Anglo-Indian Army’, Foreign and Quarterly Review, 33(1844): 391.Google Scholar

86 [Arnold, W. D.], ‘Jack Sepoy’, Fraser's Magazine, 54(1856): 359–60.Google Scholar

87 Mofussilite, 11 Feb. 1848, 91–2.Google Scholar

88 [J. W. Kay e], ‘The Crisis in India ‘, North British Review, 27(1857): 268.Google Scholar

89 Anon, ‘Jack Sepoy’, Bentley's Miscellany, 32(1852): 80.Google Scholar

90 Ibid.

91 [Andrews, Augustus], ‘The Indian Army’, Fraser's Magazine, 56(1857): 169.Google Scholar

92 [Addison, H. R.], ‘The Native Sentinel’, Bentley's Miscellany, 15(1844): 621.Google Scholar

93 Jacob, John, The Views and Opinions of Brigadier General John Jacob, 2nd edn (London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1858), 415.Google Scholar

94 [J. W. Kaye], ‘The Romance of Indian Warfare’, 197.The gendering of identities under colonialism has recently produced several studies, see for example Tosh, John, ‘What should Historians do with Masculinity? Reflections on Nineteenthcentury Britain’, History Workshop Journal, 38(1994): 179–202;Google Scholar and Dawson, Graham, Soldier Heroes; British Adventure, Empire and the Imagining of Masculinities (London: Routledge, 1994). This issue is also discussed in Barrell, Thomas De Quincey, 174–5.Google Scholar

95 This is witnessed in, for example, Mill, James, History of British India,Google ScholarElphinstone, Mountstuart, The History of India,Google Scholar and Orme, Robert, History of the Military Transactions of the British Nation in Indostan.Google Scholar

96 Illustrated London News, 21 Sept. 1844, 180.Google Scholar

97 [N.C.O. of the 13th Light Dragoons], ‘Campaigning in India’, Colbum's United Service Magazine, 1844(1): 94.Google Scholar

98 Anon, ‘Jack Sepoy’, Bentley's Miscellany, 32(1852): 77.Google Scholar

99 Civis [Ellis, Henry], Times, 4 Sept. 1847.Google Scholar

100 The Times, 2 Sept. 1837.Google Scholar

101 Difficulties in the Burmese War had also led to a similar scapegoating of the Indian sepoys. See Peers, , ‘Habitual Nobility of Being’.Google Scholar

102 Anon, ‘A Glance at Indian Affairs, Retrospective and Prospective’, Colburn's United Service Magazine, 1844(1): 182;Google ScholarAnon, ‘Jack Sepoy’, Benlley's Miscellany, 32(1857): 77.Google Scholar

103 Peers, , ‘The Habitual Nobility of Being’.Google Scholar

104 The Times, 1 March 1839; 5 April 1842; 5 April, 6 May, 7 May, 8 May, 5 June, n Sept., 3 Oct., 1 Nov. 1844; 12 Dec. 1845; 26 Feb. 1846; 3 Feb. 1848; 22 March, 2 April, 18 April, 2 Sept. 1850.Google Scholar

105 Anon, ‘The Peasants of British India’, Household Words, 4 (1852): 388.Google Scholar See also Anon, ‘The Mofussil’, Household Words, 13(1856): 556–9 for another account of the corruption associated with the employment of Indians in official positions.Google Scholar

106 Stocqueler, J. H., ‘Justice for “Natives” ’, Household Words, 7(1853): 397–402.Google Scholar

107 Taylor, , Story of My Life, 354–6;Google ScholarTaylor, ,‘Correspondence from India’, Times, 8 Oct. 1842.Google Scholar

108 [Chadwick, Edwin], ‘Our Army in India’, North British Review, 29(1858): 211.Google Scholar

109 The Times, 2 Sept. 1837.Google Scholar

110 OIOC, L/Mil/3/42, Military Letter from Bengal, 4 May 1842.Google ScholarSome of the earlier reports include Breton, P., Medico-Topography of the Ceded Provinces; South West Frontier (Calcutta: Asiatic Library Press, 1826);Google ScholarYoung, D. S., ‘Medical Topography of Aurangabad’, Transactions of the Medical and Physical Society of Calcutta, 2(1825): 325–33;Google ScholarJackson, Thomas, ‘A Sketch of the General and Medical Topography of Meerut’, Transactions of the Medical and Physical Society of Calcutta, 1(1825): 292–8.Google ScholarThe parameters intended to guide such studies are considered at length in the editor's preface, Madras Quarterly Medical Journal, 1(1839): i–ix.Google Scholar

111 The Times, 9 June, 20 Nov. 1832.Google Scholar

112 Taylor, Philip Meadows, ‘The Great Cat and Dog Question’, Household Words, 1(1850): 172–5.Google Scholar

113 The Times, 2 April 1846.Google Scholar

114 Thg Times, 27 March, 4 April 1846.Google Scholar

115 The Times, 26 June, 19 Dec. 1848; 22 Jan. 1849.Google Scholar

116 Lang, John, ‘The Wetherbys—Father and Son’, Fraser's Magazine, 47(1853); 531.Google Scholar

117 Tosh, , ‘What Should Historians do with Masculinity?’, 180.Google Scholar

118 Lohrli, (comp.), Household Words, 4.Google Scholar

119 In a letter written to Miss Coutts during the Indian Rebellion, Dickens complained that recent events demonstrated the necessity of opening up the army's officer corps to the middle classes. Oddie, William, ‘Dickens and the Indian Mutiny’, Dickensian, 68(1972): 10.Google Scholar Like Kaye, Dickens also tended to idealize the Punjab School. John Lawrence, in particular, was written up as a paragon of middle class virtues in a May 1859 article in All the Year Round.Ibid., 11–12.

120 The Times, 3 May 1842;Google Scholar‘Remarks on Silladar Cavalry’, Colbum's United Service Magazine, 2(1847): 583–6.Google Scholar

121 Lang, John, ‘The Wetherbys—Father and Son’, Fraser's Magazine, 47(1853); 53O–1.Google Scholar

122 [Meason, Malcolm], ‘Regulars and Irregulars’, Household Words, 12(1856): 58–60.Google Scholar

123 [Townsend, E.], ‘Indian Irregulars’, Household Words, 16(1857): 245.Google Scholar

124 Kaye, J. W., Lives of Indian Officers, i, preface.Google Scholar

125 Hall, Catherine, ‘“From Green land's Icy Mountains … to Afric's Golden Sand”: Ethnicity, Race and Nation in Mid-Nineteenth-Century England’, Gender and History, 5(1993): 219–21.Google Scholar

126 Mofussilite, 30 May, 25 Aug., 1848.Google Scholar

127 MacDonald, Robert H., ‘A Poetics of War: Militarist Discourse in the British Empire, 1880–1918’, Mosaic, 1990 23(3): 18.Google Scholar