Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T10:13:06.296Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Plague, Policy and Popular Unrest in British India

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Ira Klein
Ira Klein
Affiliation:
The American UniversityWashington, DC
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The dark and fatal passage of plague across the Indian sub-continent in the early twentieth-century, and the inability of Western medicine quickly to halt its incursions symptomized disharmonies in the relationship between modernization and Indian society and ecology. The impact of economic development and environmental change on Indian mortality has been examined elsewhere, but the result was the perpetuation or increase of high death-rates from a multiplicity of diseases through the end of World War I. In the half-century 1872-1921 annual mortality ranged between 40 and 50 per thousand, more than twice the death-rates of the advanced West, and life expectancy fell from about 25 to 20 years. The Indian experience was not unique. Epidemics of cholera and the ‘white plague’ of tuberculosis in the industrializing West, and the ordeal of mortality in the colonial Philippines also illustrated how development activities induced social and environmental disruptions and sustained or promoted high death-rates.

Type
Articles
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 22 , Issue 4 , October 1988 , pp. 723 - 755
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Klein, Ira, ‘Death in India’, Journal of Asian Studies, 08. 1973, 642–5.Google ScholarPubMed

2 Davis, Kingsley, Population of India and Pakistan (Princeton, 1951), 8.Google Scholar

3 Pollitzer, R., Cholera (Geneva, 1959), 17–24;Google ScholarPubMedRosenberg, Charles, The Cholera Years in The United States (Chicago, 1961), 1 and passim,Google ScholarSmith, Peter, ‘Crisis Mortality in the Nineteenth Century Philippines’, Journal of Asian Studies, 11. 1978, 51–76.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

4 For statistics on the first decade of plague mortality in India's modern ordeal see ‘Indian Sanitary Proceedings’, India Office Library, 1907, v. 7602, 1816–17.Google Scholar

5 Parliamentary Papers, 1902, LXXII, ‘Report of the Indian Plague Commission, 13–51, 334–51 and passim; ‘Plague in India’, IOL, I, 293–349 and passim.Google Scholar

6 Defoe, Daniel, Journal of the Plague Year (London, 1712), passim.Google Scholar

7 Bacot, A. W. and Martin, C. J., ‘Observations on the Mechanism of the Transmission of Plague by Fleas’, Journal of Hygiene, XIV, 1914 (Plague Supplements 3–4), 432–4.Google Scholar

8 Kartman, Leo, Miles, V. I. and Prince, F. M., ‘Ecological Studies of Wild Rodent Plague in the San Francisco Bay Area of California’ The American Journal of Tropical Medicine, VII, 1958, 13;Google ScholarKartman, LeoPrince, F. N., Quon, Stuart and Stark, Harold, ‘New Knowledge on the Ecology of Sylvatic Plague’, Annals of the New York Academy of Science, LXX, Section 3, 1958, 669, 679;Google ScholarBalthazard, M. and Bahmanyar, M., ‘Recherches sur la peste en Inde’, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, XXIII, 214 and passim;Google ScholarBalthazard, M. et al. , and ‘Recherches sur la peste áJave’, BWHO, XXIII, 1960, 217 and passim;Google ScholarBalthazard, M. and Seydian, B., ‘Enquéte sur les conditions de la peste au Moyen-Orient’, BWHO, XXIII, 1960, 167 and passim;Google ScholarFenyuk, B. F., ‘Experience in the Eradication of Enzootic Plague in the Northwest Part of the Caspian Region of the USSR’, BWHO, XXIII, 1960, 266–70.Google Scholar

9 Seal, S. C., ‘Epidemiological Studies of Plague in India’, BWHO, XXIII, 1960, 283;Google ScholarBalthazard, , ‘Inde’, 206 and passim.Google Scholar

10 Balthazard, , ‘Inde’, 214.Google Scholar

11 Scrimshaw, Taylor and Gordon in their exhaustive study reported two experiments by G. G. Korobkov and associates on rats, testing the effects of protein deficiency on P. pestis, one inconclusive, one in which protein deficiency increased rodent resistance to plague. Scrimshaw and his co-authors noted that such laboratory experiments induced more extreme deficiencies than usually found in nature and that each element of nutrition must be tested including vitamins and minerals, to determine the total relationship between food intake and infection. See Scrimshaw, Nevin, Taylor, Carl and Gordon, John, The Interactions of Nutrition and Infection (Geneva, 1968), 70.Google ScholarPubMed

12 Griffiths, E., ‘Adaption and Multiplication of Bacteria in Host Tissues’, Smith, Harry (ed.), The Determinants of Bacterial and Viral Pathology (London, 1983), 91;Google ScholarScrimshaw, Taylor, and Gordon, , Nutrition and Infection, 13. Scrimshaw and his co-authors commented that ‘there is no verified instance in which a natural or experimental nutritional deficiency has been shown to be antagonistic to any infection in man.’Google Scholar

13 Mims, Cedric, The Pathogenesis of Infectious Diseases (London, 1976), 60, 102.Google Scholar

14 Report CPH, 1935, 3, 191.Google Scholar

15 PP, 1900, XXXI, ‘Indian Plague Commission’, 484.Google Scholar

16 ‘Report on Plague in the Punjab’, IOL, 15.

17 For a more complete discussion of mortality in Bombay city, see Klein, Ira, ‘Urban Development and Death: Bombay City, 1870–1914’, Modern Asian Studies, Oct. 1986, passim.Google Scholar

18 Christophers, S. R., ‘Malaria in the Punjab’, Scientific Memoirs by Officers of the Medical and Sanitary Departments, XLI (Calcutta, 1911), 107–11.Google Scholar

19 Seal, , ‘Epidemiological Studies’, 298.Google Scholar

20 Davis, D. H., ‘Plague in Africa’, BWHO, IX, 1953, 691.Google Scholar

21 Ziegler, Philip, The Black Death (London, 1969), 3–34 and passim.Google Scholar

22 Davis, , ‘Plague in Africa’, 693.Google Scholar

23 ‘Plague in India’, 32–73.Google Scholar

24 Ibid., 86.

25 Ibid., 93.

26 Hirst, L. F., The Conquest of the Plague (London, 1953), 312, 388.Google Scholar

27 Ibid., 312.

28 Madras Municipal Report, 1868, 197.Google Scholar

29 MMR, 1872, 154.Google Scholar

30 Hirst, , Conquest of the Plague, 352.Google Scholar

31 Ibid., 352; Seal, , ‘Epidemiological Studies’, 297.Google Scholar

32 For the effects of development policies in perpetuating or increasing differences in living standards and poverty, and in stimulating unhealthy environmental change see Klein, , ‘Death’, 645–8, 658;Google Scholar Klein ‘Urban Development and Death’, passim; Klein, Ira, ‘Urban Development and Public Health in Calcutta’, Main Currents in Indian Sociology VI: Urban India (Delhi, 1983), 176, 183–91;Google ScholarKlein, Ira, ‘Malaria and Mortality in Bengal’, Indian Economic and Social History Review, June 1972, 137–52 and passim.Google Scholar

33 For the persistence of established mores on health in post-World War II village India, see, for example, Hasan, K. A., The Cultural Frontiers of Health in Village India (Bombay, 1967), 48–9, 66, 119–20, 146–50.Google Scholar

34 For a more detailed discussion of water-logging, see Klein, ‘Urban Development and Death’, passim; for the famines, see Klein, Ira, ‘When the Rains Failed’, IESHR, Dec. 1984, 202–5.Google Scholar

35 Gazetteer of Bombay City and Island, I (Bombay, 1909), 210–11;Google ScholarCI, 1911, VIII, 2: 118–21;Google ScholarBMR, 1888, 377;Google ScholarBMR, 1891, 410.Google Scholar

36 Plague Research Commission, ‘The Immunity of the Wild Rat in India’, Journal of Hygiene, XIII, 1913–1914, Plague Supplement 2, 229.Google Scholar

37 ‘Account of Plague Administration in Bombay Presidency 1896–1997’, British Library, 10.Google Scholar

38 Ibid., 10.

39 Snow, P. C., ‘Report on Bombay Plague 1896–1997’, IOL, 237.Google Scholar

40 ‘Report on Bubonic Plague in Bombay’, IOL, 6.Google Scholar

41 ‘Account’, 10.Google Scholar

42 ‘Plague in India’, 148; ‘Bubonic Plague’, 6.Google Scholar

43 ‘Bubonic Plague’, 6–7.Google Scholar

44 Ibid.

45 Ibid.

46 ‘Account’, 21.Google Scholar

47 Ibid., 21–2.

48 Ibid., 66.

49 Ibid., 219.

50 Ibid., 222.

51 Ibid.

52 Ibid., Supplement, 7.

53 Ibid., Supplement, 11.

54 Ibid., 223.

55 Ibid., 100.

56 Ibid., 105.

57 Ibid.

58 PP, 1902, LXXII, 38–40.Google Scholar

59 ‘Madras Plague Proceedings’, IOL, 1905, July, From Collector, N. Arcot to Sec'y, Local and Municipal Dep't, July 25, 1905.Google Scholar

60 Ibid.

61 ‘MPP’, 1898, March, no. 173, Acting Collector, Kurnool to Sec'y, Local and Municipal Dep't, March 2, 1898.Google Scholar

62 ‘MPP’, 1902, Aug. no. 1179, Lt. Col. King, W. G., Sanitary Commissioner to Sec'y, Local and Municipal Dep't, Aug. 25, 1902.Google Scholar

63 ‘MPP’, 1902, March, no. 970, Note by King, , March 13, 1902.Google Scholar

64 ‘MPP’, 1902, August, King to L and M Dep't, August 25.Google Scholar

65 ‘ISP’, 1901, July, no. 178, Casson, H. A., Judicial and General Sec'y, Punjab to Sec'y, Gov't of India, Home Dept., June 12, 1901; and no. 176, Tollington, H. R., Deputy Commissioner, Sialkot to Commissioner and Sup't, Rawalpindi Division.Google Scholar

66 ‘MPP’, 1898, Aug. no. 774–5, Note on Plague Administration, 7.Google Scholar

67 PP, 1902, LXXII, 335, 339.Google Scholar

68 Ibid., 346.

69 Ibid., 352.

70 Ibid., 401.

71 ‘Plague in Punjab’, 58.Google Scholar

72 Ibid., 72.

73 Ibid.

74 ‘ISP’, 1906, Feb. no. 327, Report on Plague.Google Scholar

75 ‘United Provinces Sanitary Proceedings’,IOL,1903, July, no. 1, Offic. Sec'y U.P. to Inspector Gen. of Hospitals, June 2, 1903.Google Scholar

76 ‘UPSP’, 1904, Sept., no. 2, Notes By Major White, J. Chaytor, Chief Plague Officer, March 1, 1904.Google Scholar

77 ‘USPS’, 1904, Sept., no. 2, Remarks by Col. O'Brien, Insp. Gen. of Hospitals.Google Scholar

78 ‘Plague in Punjab’, 23, 30.Google Scholar

79 Ibid. See also ‘MPP’, 1905, Chief Medical Officer, Jalarpit to Sec'y, L and M Dep't, Aug. 2, 1905.

80 ‘Plague in Punjab’, 5.Google Scholar

81 Ibid., 23.

82 ‘USPS’, 1906, Aug., no. 3, Plague Admin. in the United Provinces, 1905.Google Scholar

83 Simond, P. L., ‘The Propagation of Plague’, Annales de l'Institut Pasteur, XII, 1898, 669.Google Scholar

84 Liston, W. G., ‘Plague, Rats and Fleas’, Indian Medical Gazette, Feb. 1905, 43–9.Google Scholar

85 PRC, ‘Experiments upon the Transmission of Plague by Fleas’, JH, 1906, VI, 466;Google ScholarPRC, ‘Epidemiological Observations Made by the Commission in Bombay City’, JH, 1907, VII, 764–8;Google ScholarPRC, ‘Experimental Production of Plague Epidemics among 'Animals’, JH, 1910, X, 316–33, Hirst, Conquest of Plague, 173.Google Scholar

86 Bacot, and Martin, , ‘Observations’, 424–5, 431, 435.Google Scholar

87 Hirst, , Conquest of Plague, 356–8.Google Scholar

88 Davis, , Population, 45.Google Scholar

89 CPH, 1934, 177; ‘USPS’, 1919, Oct., no. 5A; ‘Bengal Municipal (Sanitary) Proceedings’, IOL, v. 10521, Sanitary Commissioner's Notes on the Recommendations of the Public Service Commission.Google Scholar

90 ‘BM(S)P’, v. 10521, San. Com's Notes.

91 Blyn, George, Agricultural Trends in India, 1891–1947 (Philadelphia, 1966), 100, 243, 248, 334.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

92 CPH, 1935, 3, 191.Google Scholar

93 Briggs, George W., The Chamars (London, 1920), 224–5;Google ScholarO'Malley, L. S. S., Indian Caste Customs (Cambridge, 1932), 46–8.Google Scholar

94 PP, 1930–1931, XI,Google Scholar‘Report of the Royal Commission on Labour’, 224–6.Google Scholar

95 CPH, 1936, 125–34;Google ScholarPP, 1930–1931, XI, ‘Labour’, 270, 277–8.Google Scholar

96 Nossal, G. V., Antibodies and Immunities (N.Y., 1978), passim;Google ScholarWilson, David, Body and Antibody (N.Y., 1977), passim.Google Scholar

97 PRC, ‘The Immunity of the Wild Rat in India’, JH, XIII, 1913–1914, Plague Supplement 2, 229–33;Google ScholarSeal, , ‘Epidemiological Studies’, 287, 293, 295.Google Scholar