Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T22:22:03.507Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Multiple Images: Jute Mill Strikes of 1929 and 1937 Seen Through Other's Eyes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Omkar Goswami
Omkar Goswami
Affiliation:
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The jute mills of Bengal had witnessed communal violence as well as bursts of working men's unrest even in the late nineteenth century. In the eyes of the employers, however, they were merely localized and disorganized flashes of protest, which could be typically nipped by the arrival of the Scottish mill manager and his entourage of Nepali darwans. A quick arbitration by the sahib under the peepul tree, liberally laced with pidgin Hindi abuse, was followed by the protector's judgment. Some would be happy with the verdict, others would remain aggrieved while the bara sahib, after a few words with the European assistant and the native sirdar, would imperiously stride back to his office, acknowledging numerous salams on his way. With such powerful ma-baaps, the mills rarely felt the need to report what they considered were piffling matters to the local police or the district magistrate. Thus, in February 1886, the Indian Jute Mills' Association could rule that ‘all hands whose work stopped during the days the mills were closed [for short-time working] should cease to be paid for that time’ without the slightest fear of serious protest from the labouring people. And in the late 1920s, in spite of the Rowlatt satyagraha, the Khilafat and the non-cooperation movement, the Chairman of IJMA could note with great satisfaction that ‘for many years the jute mill industry has been more or less immune from industrial disputes’.

Type
Articles
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 21 , Issue 3 , July 1987 , pp. 547 - 583
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

I am grateful to Shahid Amin, Partha Chatterjee, Partha Sarathi Gupta and Chitra Joshi for extremely helpful comments made during an earlier presentation. I hope Dipesh Chakrabarty and Ranajit Dasgupta will excuse my naive and ill-equipped intrusion into their domain.

1 See Chakrabarty, Dipesh, ‘Communal Riots and Labour: Bengal's Jute Mill-Hands in the 1890s’, Past and Present, 05 1981.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 IJMA, Report of the Committee 1924 (hereafter IJMA, R Ctee) (Calcutta, 1925), p. 242.Google Scholar

3 IJMA, R Ctee 1929 (Calcutta, 1930), p. 3.Google Scholar

4 Centre for South Asian Studies, Cambridge (CSAS), Benthall Papers (BP), Box XI, Thomas–Benthall, 5.7.1937.

5 Chakrabarty, Dipesh, ‘Conditions of Knowledge of Working Class Conditions: Employers, Government and Jute Workers of Calcutta 1890–1940’, in Guha, Ranajit (ed.), Subaltern Studies, vol. II, p. 259.Google Scholar This is hereafter referred to as Chakrabarty in SSII.

6 Wallace, D. R., The Romance of Jute, 2nd edn (London, 1928), p. 54.Google Scholar

7 Leng, John, Letters from India and Ceylon 1895–96 (Dundee, 1896), p. 53.Google Scholar

8 West Bengal State Archives (WBSA), Govt. of Bengal (GOB), Misc. Branch, General Dept., F.1–F/4, Progs B41–44, January 1907.

9 Ibid., marginal comment by Walsh, Spl Inspector of Factories.

10 Report of the Royal Commission on Labour in India (London, 1930)Google Scholar, hereafter RCLI, V(1) P 3.

11 Ibid., p. 282.

12 Ibid.

13 Ibid., pp. 282–3.

14 Ibid., evidence of Dr Batra, pp. 31–2.

15 Ibid., p. 32, p. 331.

16 Ibid., pp. 309–11 and p. 331.

17 Ibid., note by GOB, p. 25.

18 Ibid., note by IJMA, p. 305, emphasis mine.

19 Ibid., p. 312.

20 Ibid., evidence of GOB, pp. 93–4 and pp. 97–8.

21 Chakrabarty, in SSII, p. 272.Google Scholar

22 Ibid.

23 Mitra, Ira, ‘Growth of Trade Union Consciousness among Jute Mill Workers, 1920–40’. Economic and Political Weekly, Spl Number 1981, pp. 1839–1848.Google Scholar

24 Govt. of lndia, Deshpande, S. R., Report on an Enquiry into the Conditions of Labour in the Jute Mill Industry of India (Delhi, 1946)Google Scholar, hereafter GOI, Deshpande Report, p. 6.Google Scholar

25 RCLI, V(2)Google Scholar, oral evidence of Bhattacharyya, S. C., 2.2. 1930, p. 37.Google Scholar

26 RCLI, V (1), p. 10Google Scholar. For further details see Lalita Chakravarty in IESHR, 1978 and Ranajit Dasgupta in IESHR, 1976.

27 RCLI, V(2), oral evidence of Noor Mohammed, 4.2.1930, p. 26.Google Scholar

28 Ibid., oral evidence of Abdul Hakim, 7.2.1930, p. 80.

29 RCLI, V(1), note by Gilchrist, R. N., p. 130.Google Scholar

30 See Tanika Sarkar's article in IESHR, 1984(1), p. 92.Google Scholar

31 RCLI, V (1), note by the Kankinnarrah Labour Union, p. 264.Google Scholar

32 Ibid., p. 264.

33 Ibid., note by Dr Batra, p. 31.

34 Ibid.

35 GOI, Deshpande Report, pp. 30–1.Google Scholar

36 RCLI, V(1), note by GOB, pp. 3–4.Google Scholar

37 Ibid., evidence of IJMA, p. 142.

38 Ibid., evidence of IJMA, p. 150.

39 RCLI, oral evidence of Babuniya, 7.2.1930, pp. 77 (vol.V(1))Google Scholar. See also evidence of Muniya, , Harilal, and Jumrath, , pp. 77–8.Google Scholar

40 Ibid., oral evidence of Sorju, 4.2.1930, p. 26. Emphasis mine.

41 Ibid., oral evidence of Sime, p. 119, Williamson, p. 143 and K. C. Raychaudhuri, p. 124.

42 See my thesis, ‘The Jute Economy of Bengal 1900–47’ (unpublished D.Phil, thesis, Oxford, 1982), pp. 4–5.Google Scholar

43 This is clearly brought out in Barker, S. G., Report on the Scientific and Technical Development of the Jute Manufacturing Industry of Bengal (Calcutta, 1935).Google Scholar

44 See Chakrabarty, in SSII, p. 305.Google Scholar

45 RCLI, V(2), evidence of Sime, p. 119 and IJMA, p. 143Google Scholar. Also RCLI, V(1), note by IJMA, p. 280.Google Scholar

46 Ibid., p. 195.

47 IJMA, R Ctee 1929 (Calcutta, 1930), pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

48 IJMA, R Ctee 1937 (Calcutta, 1938), p. 41.Google Scholar

49 On the issue of harmony, there was an excellent question-answer session between K. C. Raychaudhuri and the representatives of IJMA. The gist of it was, according to IJMA, that the examples of disharmony pointed out by Raychaudhuri were due to ‘politial agitators more than anything else.’ RCLI, V(2) p. 153.Google Scholar

50 IJMA, R Ctee 1929, p. 3.Google Scholar

51 These are from IJMA, R Ctee 1937, p. 11Google Scholar and R Ctee 1938, pp. 17–19, emphasis mine.Google Scholar

52 IJMA, Report of the Committee 1938, p. 20.Google Scholar

53 Ibid., pp. 18–19, emphasis mine.

54 CSAS, BP, Box XIV, Morton-Benthall, 14.12.1937, emphasis mine.

55 RCLI V(1), note by Gilchrist, pp. 128–30Google Scholar and Bengal Legislative Assembly Progs (BLA Progs), Niharendu Datta Mazumdar, 20. 8. 1937, p. 361, and GOB, WBSA, Home Department, Political (Confidential), hereafter HDP(C), F. 484/37.

56 RCLI, V(1), note by Gilchrist, p. 128.Google Scholar

57 Ibid., pp. 128–30.

58 BLA Progs, Cooper, C. G., IJMA's representative, 20.8.1937, p. 359.Google Scholar

59 BLA Progs, Suhrawardy, H. S., 6.9.1937, p. 1103.Google Scholar

60 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.60/37, Symons-Martin, , 3.2.1937.Google Scholar

61 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 128/37, note by Carter, , 8.6.1937.Google Scholar

62 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 362/38, Colson-Chief, Secy., GOB, 15.10.1938.Google Scholar

63 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 473/37, A Brief Summary of the Political Events in the Presidency of Bengal (Alipore, 1938), pp. 14–18. Emphasis mine.Google Scholar

64 RCLI, V(2), oral evidence of Raychaudhuri, pp. 119–20.Google Scholar

65 Ibid., p. 125 and RCLI, V(1), note by KLU, p. 274.

66 RCLI, V(2), p. 127.Google Scholar

67 Ibid., p. 127.

68 Ibid., p. 128.

69 Ibid., p. 128 and p. 135.

70 RCLI, V (1), pp. 129–30 and p. 276.Google Scholar

71 Ibid., note by KLU, p. 276.

72 Ibid, note by Gilchrist.

73 Ibid., p. 150.

74 Ibid., p. 159, p. 161.

75 Ibid., p. 145.

76 Nehru Memorial Museum and Library (NMML), Transcript of Interview with Prabhavati Dasgupta, 1968, p. 16.Google Scholar

77 NMML, Prabhavati Transcript, p. 18. Emphasis mine.Google Scholar

78 RCLI V(1), p. 411.Google Scholar Emphasis mine.

79 NMML, Prabhavati Transcript, p. 19. Emphasis mine.Google Scholar

80 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.60/37, Symons-Martin, , 3.2.1937.Google Scholar

81 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 128/37. Carter-Twynam, , 8.6.1937.Google Scholar

82 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.60/37, Symons-Martin, , 3.2.1937.Google Scholar

83 BLA Progs, Nalinaksha Sanyal, 8.4.1937, pp. 30–31Google Scholar, Basu, Santosh, p. 39Google Scholar and Mazumdar, Niharendu Datta, p. 44.Google Scholar

84 GOI, Deshpande Report.Google Scholar

85 Mukherji, K. in Artha Vijnana, 2(1)Google Scholar, given in Bagchi, A. K., Private Investment in India 1900–39 (Cambridge, 1972), p. 122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

86 RCLI, V(2), p. 25.Google Scholar

87 Ibid., p. 27.

88 Ibid., p. 26.

89 RCLI, V(1), evidence of Mitra, J. K., p. 49.Google Scholar

90 Ibid., p. 32.

91 RCLI, V(2), oral evidence of Mangrul, p. 77.Google Scholar

92 RCLI, Vol. I, Report, pp. 215–16.Google Scholar

93 GOI, Deshpande Report p. 6Google Scholar, Bagchi, , Private Investment in India, p. 122Google Scholar and IJMA, R Ctee 1930, pp. 23–4.Google Scholar

94 RCLI, V(1), pp. 122–4.Google Scholar

95 BLA Progs, Sibnath Banerjee, 8.4.1937Google Scholar, Nazimuddin, Khwaja, 8.4.1937Google Scholar and Amrita Bazar Patrika, Calcutta daily, 17.2.1937.Google Scholar

96 RCLI, V(1), note by Gilchrist, p. 144Google Scholar

97 Ibid., p. 129.

98 Ibid.

99 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.60/37, Symons-Martin, , 3.2.1937.Google Scholar

100 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.484/37, weekly reports, Hughes-Secy, , GOI, 6.2.1937 and 27.2.1937.Google Scholar

101 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 128/37, note by Sinha, , SDO, Sadar, 24-Parganas, 8.3.1937.Google Scholar

102 Ibid.

103 Ibid.

104 Ibid.

105 RCLI, V(1), note by Gilchrist, , pp. 126–32, esp. p. 132.Google Scholar

106 Compiled and described from GOB, Files 60/37, 128/37, 128/37(II), 473/37 and 484/37, all of HDP(C).Google Scholar

107 CSAS, BP, Box XI, Thomas-Benthall, , 3.6.1937.Google Scholar

108 RCLI, V(1), note by Gilchrist, , pp. 129–30 and p. 132.Google Scholar

109 CSAS, BP, Box XI, Thomas-Benthall, , 3.6.1937.Google Scholar

110 Same as fn. 95.

111 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 484/37, weekly report, Hughes-Secy, , GOI, 10.4.1937.Google Scholar

112 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.128/37(II). 1937.Google Scholar

113 RCLI, V(1), p. 130.Google Scholar

114 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.484/37, weekly report, Hughes-Secy, , GOI, 24.4.1937.Google Scholar

115 Ibid., F. 484/37, weekly report. 1.5.1937.

116 Ibid.

117 Ibid., 8.5.1937.

118 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.128/37, note by Carter, , 8.6.1937.Google Scholar

119 Amrita Bazar Patrika, 25.2.1937.Google Scholar

120 RCLI, V(1), p. 276.Google Scholar

121 Ibid., pp. 160–1.

122 Ibid., pp. 276–7.

123 It started on 20 August and ended on 11 September; it involved more than 25,000 workers who suffered a wage loss of Rs 315,000.

124 RCLI, V(1), p. 151.Google Scholar

125 Ibid., p. 130. Gilchrist also referred to the strikes as a ‘rapidly spreading contagious disease’ (p. 132).

126 WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F. 128/37, Carter-Twynam, , 8.6.1937.Google Scholar

127 Ibid.

128 Basumati, Calcutta daily, 12.9.1929.Google Scholar

129 NMML, Prabhavati Transcript, pp. 11–12 and RCLI, V(1), p. 145.Google Scholar

130 For details of such antagonisms see my article, ‘Collaboration and Conflict…’, in IESHR, 1982.

131 GOB, Todd, J. A., Further Report on the Jute Futures and Hessian Futures Market (Alipore, 1944), Stat. App., Table XVI, p. 16.Google Scholar

132 RCLI, V(1), evidence of IJMA, p. 303.Google Scholar

133 NMML, Colin, B. C. Roy, F.133Google Scholar, and ibid., p. 130.

134 Small wonder that Benthall greeted the formation of the 1937 cabinet with the remark: ‘What a powerful position we have with the Government… In fact, if we were to work things right, I believe they would adopt any policy that we liked to press on them.’ CAAS, BP, Box XII, Benthall-McKerrow, , 11.8.1937.Google Scholar

135 BLA Progs, Banerjee, Sibnath, 20.8.1937, pp. 325–6, 356–7.Google Scholar

136 BLA Progs, Suhrawardy, H. S., 20.8.1937, p. 357 and 371.Google Scholar

137 CSAS, BP, Box XIV, Morton-Benthall, , 14.12.1937Google Scholar & Benthall, Paul-Edward, 21.12.1937.Google Scholar

138 Se WBSA, GOB, HDP(C), F.

139 CSAS, BP, Vox XII, Mortimer-Benthall, Chapman, 7.6.1937.Google Scholar

140 Ibid.

141 BLA Progs, Mazumdar, N. Datta, 20.8.1937, p. 363.Google Scholar

142 GOB, WBSA, HDP(C), F. 484/37, weekly report, 17.7.1937.Google Scholar

143 See GOB, WBSA, HDP(C), F-370/38, SP,24-Parganas-DM,24-Parganas, 18.11.1938.Google Scholar

144 CSAS, BP, Box XI, Benthall, Paul-Edward, 19.7.1937.Google Scholar

145 IJMA, R Ctee 1938, p. 22.Google Scholar

146 Ibid.