Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T07:20:47.866Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Making of the India–Pakistan Dynamic: Nehru, Liaquat, and the No War Pact correspondence of 1950*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 June 2016

PALLAVI RAGHAVAN
PALLAVI RAGHAVAN*
Affiliation:
Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi, India Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In January 1950, Jawaharlal Nehru wrote to Liaquat Ali Khan, seeking a joint declaration of a No War Pact by the governments of India and Pakistan. The two prime ministers undertook a lengthy correspondence on this subject, spanning a year that saw rising levels of resentment and hostility between the two countries. Yet, as the inter-dominion correspondence on the No War declaration during this period shows, neither government was actually predisposed to take a belligerent position and critically engaged with the possibility of signing a declaration that renounced the use of war. As I hope to show through my discussion of the ‘No War Pact’ correspondence, relations between India and Pakistan were not necessarily confined to hostile exchanges, and both governments also repeatedly engaged with each other to attempt to find spaces of agreement and compromise. Although much of the existing literature on India–Pakistan relations characterizes it as locked in acrimony and conflict, which arose from the bitterness of partition, a closer scrutiny reveals a more nuanced picture. Attempts at cooperation and dialogue between the two governments—and the rationale for undertaking them—complicate our understanding of a relationship apparently limited to instinctive antagonism, and help in creating a more rounded picture of the India–Pakistan dynamic.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 50 , Issue 5 , September 2016 , pp. 1645 - 1678
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to my two anonymous reviewers for their excellent comments. I am also hugely indebted to the Centre for Policy Research for its institutional support, as well as for the generous and informative feedback from its faculty. In particular, I would like to thank Pratap Bhanu Mehta and Srinath Raghavan for their help and encouragement with this project. Finally, I would also like to thank Professor Joya Chatterji and the team at Modern Asian Studies. All errors are mine alone.

References

1 Akbar, M. J., Blood Brothers: A Family Saga, Roli Books, New Delhi, 2006 Google Scholar.

2 Talbot, Ian (ed.), The Deadly Embrace: Religion, Violence and Politics in India and Pakistan, Oxford University Press, Karachi, 2007.

3 Talbot, Ian, Pakistan: A Modern History, St Martin's Press, New York, 1998 Google Scholar.

4 For a discussion of the chronology of India–Pakistan relations in this period, see, for example: Dasgupta, Jyoti Bhusan, Indo-Pakistan Relations, 1947–1955, Djambatan, Amsterdam, 1960 Google Scholar; Blinkenberg, Lars, India-Pakistan: The History of Unsolved Conflicts, Udenrigspolitisk Instituts, Odensk, 1999 Google Scholar; Chaudhry, G. W., Pakistan's Relations with India, 1947–1966, Frederick A. Praeger, New York, 1968 Google Scholar.

5 Burke, S. M. and Ziring, L., Pakistan's Foreign Policy: An Historical Analysis, Oxford University Press, Karachi, 1990 Google Scholar.

6 Cohen, Stephen P., The Idea of Pakistan, Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC, 2004 Google Scholar. See also his Shooting for a Century: The India-Pakistan Conundrum, Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC, 2013.

7 Pande, A., Explaining Pakistan's Foreign Policy: Escaping India, Routledge, London and New York, 2011 Google Scholar.

8 Paul, T. V. ‘Why has the India-Pakistan rivalry been so enduring? Power asymmetry and intractable conflict’, Security Studies, Vol. 15, No. 4, Oct–Dec 2006 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and his The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2014.

9 Ganguly, S., Conflict Unending: India Pakistan Tensions Since 1947, Columbia University Press, New York, 2001 Google Scholar.

10 See also, for instance, McLeod, Duncan, Friends, Rivals, or Enemies, Ashgate, Vermont, 2008 Google Scholar.

11 Feldman, H., From Crisis to Crisis, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1972, p. 120 Google Scholar.

12 Choudhury, G. W., The Last Days of United Pakistan, Hurst, London, 1974 Google Scholar.

13 See, for instance, accounts by Patel, H. M., The First Flush of Freedom: Reflections and Recollections, Rupa & Co., New Delhi, 2005 Google Scholar, and Muhammad Ali, C., The Emergence of Pakistan, Columbia University Press, New York, 1967 Google Scholar.

14 Chatterji, J., ‘Secularisation and partition emergencies: deep diplomacy in South Asia’, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. XLVIII, No. 50, 14 December 2013 Google Scholar.

15 Ibid.

16 Dawn, Editorial, 29 November 1950. Excerpted in File No. 23 (75)-Pak III/ 50, ‘Joint Declaration by the governments of India and Pakistan’, Ministry of External Affairs Archives, New Delhi (hereafter MEAA).

17 Times of India, Editorial, 30 November 1950. Excerpted in File No. 23 (75)-Pak III/50, ‘Joint Declaration by the governments of India and Pakistan’, MEAA.

18 Correspondence which has taken place between the Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan on the subject of No War Declaration, New Delhi, Ministry of External Affairs, 1950.

19 ‘Fortnightly political report of British High Commissioner in India, January 1950’, FO 371/84198, Public Records Office (PRO), London.

20 For an excellent account of centre–provincial turbulence in Pakistan over the refugee question, see, for instance, Ansari, S., Migration, Community and Strife in Sindh, 1947–1962, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2005 Google Scholar.

21 Address to the meeting of the Congress Working Committee, 11 November 1949, in Das, Durga (ed.) Sardar Patel's Correspondence, 1945–1950, Vol. 6, Navajivan Publishing House, Ahmedabad, 1971–1974 Google Scholar.

22 ‘Proposed Joint Declaration by Governments of India and Pakistan re: Method of Settlement of all Matters in Depute between the two Countries’, File No. 31/54/NGO, MEAA.

23 Ibid.

24 File No. 23 (75)-Pak III/50, ‘Joint Declaration by the governments of India and Pakistan’, MEA File, MEAA.

25 For perspectives of the Government of Pakistan relating to the No War Pact, I have worked mainly from sections of their correspondence enclosed within the files of the MEA, kept both in the National Archives of India, as well as in the MEAA. I have also consulted ‘White Papers’ published by the Government of Pakistan during this decade, published memoirs of officials serving in Pakistan's Foreign Ministry during this time, as well as files containing their letters and telegrams in the Public Record Office in London.

26 Nehru, J., Selected Works of Jawaharlal Nehru, Second Series, Vol. 14, Part 1, Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund, New Delhi, 1984, p. 1Google Scholar. (Hereafter SWJN, SS.)

27 File No. 23 (75)-Pak III/50, ‘Joint Declaration by the governments of India and Pakistan’, MEAA.

28 Ibid.

29 Ibid.

30 Note by G. S. Bajpai, dated 18 February 1950, File No. 31/54/NGO, ‘Proposed Joint Declaration by Governments of India and Pakistan re: Method of Settlement of all Matters in Dispute between the two Countries’, MEAA.

31 Letter from Patel to Nehru, 25 February 1950, ibid.

32 Ibid.

33 Ibid.

34 To S. Gopal, for instance, ‘Nehru's sustained endeavour in the face of discouragement to control the development of nuclear weapons, his courageous and outspoken resistance to United States policy and his achievement in holding together the South Asian governments on Indo-China ensured for him a commanding stature in world politics.’ In Gopal, S., Jawaharlal Nehru: A Biography, Vol. II, 1947–1956, New Delhi, Oxford University Press, 1979, p. 192 Google Scholar. See also, for instance, McGarr, Paul M., ‘India's Rasputin?: V. K. Krishna Menon and Anglo-American misperceptions of Indian foreign policymaking, 1947–1964’, Diplomacy and Statecraft, Vol. 22, No. 2, 2011, pp. 239–260 Google Scholar. McGarr usefully illustrates how, regardless of Krishna Menon's many, and widely known, failings, he was consistently promoted by Nehru, in part due to his search for allies within the Cabinet. See also Brown, J.M., Nehru: A Political Life, Yale University Press, New Haven, 2003 Google Scholar.

35 Nehru, Selected Works, p. 48.

36 Excerpt from speech in December 1949, File No. F.9-10/48-Pak I, Ministry of External Affairs, Pak I Branch, National Archives of India (NAI), New Delhi.

37 Excerpted in File No. FO 371/84198, ‘Fortnightly political report of British High Commissioner in India, January 1950’, PRO, Kew.

38 Ibid.

39 Ibid.

40 Note by C.C&R Department, ‘West Bengal Refugee Problem’, File No. F.9-10/48-Pak I, Ministry of External Affairs, Pak I Branch, NAI.

41 ‘The mission of Ghulam Sarwar: What price justice in East Bengal?’, Hindustan Times, 22 March 1949.

42 In Bengal, the politics of refugee rehabilitation have had a long afterlife, manifested in various ways, up to the present day. See, for instance, Chatterji, J., The Spoils of Partition: Bengal and India, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2007 Google Scholar; Sen, Uditi, ‘The myths refugees live by: memory and history in the making of Bengali refugee identity’, Modern Asian Studies, January 2014; Samaddar, Ranabir (ed.), Refugees and the State: Practices of Asylum and Care in India, Sage Publications, New Delhi, 2003 Google Scholar.

43 Speech to Constituent Assembly, February 1950, SWJN, SS, p. 35.

44 For a detailed account of these developments, see also Raghavan, Srinath, War and Peace in Modern India: A Strategic History of the Nehru Years, Permanent Black, Ranikhet, 2010 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Nehru to C. Rajagopalachari, 19 March 1950, SWJN, SS, p. 126.

46 Telegram from the UK High Commissioner in India to Commonwealth Relations Office, 28 March 1950, File No. FO 371/84253, ‘India-Pakistan Relations’, PRO.

47 Telegram from Liaquat Ali Khan to Attlee, 10 March 1950, File No. FO 371/84253, ‘India-Pakistan Relations’, PRO.

48 Telegram from the UK High Commissioner in India to Commonwealth Relations Office, 28 March 1950.

49 Ibid.

50 Ibid.

51 Text of Nehru-Liaquat Agreement, 8 April 1950, File No. 20(16)-R/C/50, Ministry of States, Rehabilitation Branch, NAI.

52 Visaria, P. M., ‘Migration between India and Pakistan, 1951–1961’, Demography, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 323–334 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Nehru's Note on Meeting with Editors, 7 May 1950, File No. 4(21) Pak/50, MEAA.

54 Fortnightly Report of deputy high commissioner of India in Lahore, for 15–30 April 1950 in File No. F10(11) Pak III/50, ‘Implementation of Agreement on Evacuee Property’, MEAA.

55 Note of S. Dutt on Meeting of the Information Consultative Committee in New Delhi on 6 May 1950, File No. 4(21) Pak/50 of 1950, MEAA.

56 Memorandum by Gordon Walker, May 1950, ‘Note of Meeting with Pakistan Prime Minister’, File No. FO 371/84198, PRO.

57 Times of India, 30 November 1950.

58 White Paper on No War Correspondence, New Delhi, Ministry of External Affairs, 1950.

59 Speech in Parliament, 28 November 1950, Jawaharlal Nehru's Speeches, Vol. 2, Publications Division, Government of India.

60 File No. 31/54/NGO, ‘Proposed Joint Declaration by Governments of India and Pakistan re: Method of Settlement of all Matters in Depute between the two Countries’, MEAA.

61 White Paper on No War Correspondence, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi, 1950; No War Declaration and Canal Water Dispute: Correspondence between the Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan, 18 January–24 November, Karachi, Government of Pakistan, 1950.

62 Ibid.

63 Letter from Nehru to Liaquat Ali Khan, File No. 31/54/NGO, ‘Proposed Joint Declaration by Governments of India and Pakistan re: Method of Settlement of all Matters in Depute between the two Countries’, MEAA.

64 Telegram dated 21 November, 1950, ibid.

65 Editorial, Dawn, September 1950. Excerpted in File No. 23 (75)-Pak III/50, ‘Joint Declaration by the governments of India and Pakistan’, MEA File, MEAA.

66 Makieg, Douglas C., ‘War, no war, and the India-Pakistan negotiating process’, Pacific Affairs, Vol. 60, No. 2, pp. 271–294 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 See also, for instance, Schaffer, Howard B., The Limits of Influence: America's Role in Kashmir, Penguin India, New Delhi, 2009 Google Scholar

68 Amin, S. M, Pakistan's Foreign Policy: A Reappraisal, Oxford University Press, Karachi, 2000, p. 119 Google Scholar.

69 Ibid.

70 Gupta, S., Kashmir: A Study in India-Pakistan Relations, Indian Council of World Affairs, Delhi, 1966 Google Scholar.

71 Manela, E., The Wilsonian Moment: Self Determination and the International Origins of Anticolonial Nationalism, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2007 Google Scholar.

72 Batalvi, A. H. and Khan, Z., The Forgotten Years, Vanguard Books, Lahore, 1991 Google Scholar. See also, ‘The Reminiscences of Sir Muhammad Zafrullah Khan’. Interviews conducted by Professors Wayne Wilcox and Aislie T. Embree for Columbia University, available at: http://www.apnaorg.com/books/zafrullah-1/zafrullah.php?fldr=book, pp. 168–173, [accessed 22 March 2016].

73 For longer discussions about the making of the American relationships with India and Pakistan, see, for instance, Chaudhuri, R., Forged in Crisis: India and the United States since 1947, Hurst & Co., London, 2013 Google Scholar; Haqqani, H., Magnificent Delusions: Pakistan, the United States and an Epic History of Misunderstanding, Public Affairs, New York, 2013 Google Scholar; McMahon, R. J., The Cold War and the Periphery: The United States, India, and Pakistan, Columbia University Press, New York, 1996 Google Scholar; Kux, Dennis, Disenchanted Allies: Pakistan and the United States, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore and London, 2001 Google Scholar.

74 Memorandum of Conversation with Ambassador of India Vijaya Lakshmi Pandit, George C. McGhee and T. Eloit Weil, 29 December 1950, Secretary of State File. Acheson Papers, Truman Archives.

75 Oberoi, P., ‘South Asia and the creation of the international refugee regime’, Refugee, Vol. 19, No. 5, 2001 Google Scholar.

76 Lloyd, L., ‘“A most auspicious beginning”: the 1946 United Nations General Assembly and the question of the treatment of Indians in South Africa’, Review of International Studies, Vol. 16, No. 2, April 1990 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

77 For an excellent account of India's and Pakistan's positions on Non Alignment, see, for instance, Abraham, Itty, ‘From Bandung to NAM: Non-Alignment and Indian foreign policy, 1947–1965’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, April 2008.

78 Fortnightly report from M. K. Kirpalani, Deputy High Commissioner for India in Lahore, 17 September 1948, File No. 8-15/48-Pak I, MEA File, NAI.

79 Nehru's speech in parliament on 7 December 1949 on the role of realism and idealism in foreign policy, cited in Appadorai, A. (ed.), Documents on India's Foreign Policy. 1947–1972, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1982 Google Scholar.