Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T23:27:54.776Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Discipline and Morale of the African, British and Indian Army units in Burma and India during World War II: July 1943 to August 1945*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2010

KAUSHIK ROY
KAUSHIK ROY*
Affiliation:
Centre for the Study of Civil War (CSCW), International Peace Research Institute, Oslo (PRIO), Hausmanns Gate—7, NO-0186, Oslo, Norway and Department of History, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, Pin Code 700032, West Bengal, India Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Towards the end of World War II, the morale of British units stationed in Burma and India was on a downslide. In contrast, the morale of Indian units was quite high. In fact, after the 1943 Arakan Campaign, the morale of Indian units rose slowly but steadily. The morale and discipline of Indian troops are also compared and contrasted with another colonial army: the African troops. By making a comparative study of the Commonwealth troops deployed in Burma and India, this paper attempts to show how and why the contours of morale and discipline changed among the various groups of troops at different times. The study of morale and discipline of the troops deployed in these two regions represents two extreme conditions: while Burma remained a war front, India did not experience any actual warfare except for some skirmishes with Indus tribes at the northwest frontier. In general, bad discipline is partly responsible for bad morale and vice versa, which adversely affects the fighting power of armies. This turns to the issue of ‘why do men fight’? The ‘will to war’ is directly proportional to good discipline and strong morale amongst troops. This paper will look for the causative factors shaping discipline and morale of both metropolitan and colonial soldiers, based mainly on military intelligence reports on morale. We will see that rather than grand ideas like nationalism and anti-fascism, mundane factors like the supply of good rations, access to sex and service conditions, influence the morale and discipline of soldiers, and hence their combat-worthiness.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 44 , Issue 6 , November 2010 , pp. 1255 - 1282
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Strachan, Hew, ‘Training, Morale and Modern War’ in Journal of Contemporary History (henceforth JCH), Vol. 41, No. 2 (2006), pp. 211–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Rush, Robert S., ‘A Different Perspective: Cohesion, Morale, and Operational Effectiveness in the German Army, Fall 1944’ in Armed Forces & Society, Vol. 25, No. 3 (1999), pp. 485, 501CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Bourke, Joanna, An Intimate History of Killing: Face to Face Killing in Twentieth Century Warfare (1999, reprint, London: Granta, 2000)Google Scholar.

4 Bartov, Omer, ‘Indoctrination and Motivation in the Wehrmacht: The Importance of the Unquantifiable’ in Journal of Strategic Studies (hereafter JSS), Vol. 9, No. 1 (1986), pp. 16–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar; ‘Daily Life and Motivation in War: The Wehrmacht in the Soviet Union’ in JSS, Vol. 12, No. 2 (1989), pp. 200–14.

5 Merridale, Catherine, Ivan's War: The Red Army, 1939–45 (London: Faber and Faber, 2005), p. 331Google Scholar.

6 Deshpande, Anirudh, British Military Policy in India, 1900–45: Colonial Constraints and Declining Power (New Delhi: Manohar, 2005), pp. 145–184Google Scholar.

7 Barkawi, Tarak, ‘Culture and Combat in the Colonies: The Indian Army in the Second World War’ in JCH, Vol. 41, No. 2 (2006), pp. 325–355Google Scholar.

8 Barkawi, Tarak, ‘Peoples, Homelands, and Wars? Ethnicity, the Military, and Battle among British Imperial Forces in the War against Japan’ in Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 46, No. 1 (2004), pp. 134–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Marston, Daniel P., Phoenix from the Ashes: The Indian Army in the Burma Campaign (Westport, Connecticut, London: Praeger, 2003)Google Scholar; Moreman, T.R., The Jungle, the Japanese and the British Commonwealth Armies at War, 1941–45: Fighting Methods, Doctrine and Training for Jungle Warfare (London, New York: Frank Cass, 2005)Google Scholar.

10 For the training curriculum of the Indian and British units see Infantry Liaison Letter No. 4, 17 Feb. 1944, L/WS/1/778, India Office Records (hereafter IOR), British Library (henceforth BL), London.

11 Howard, Michael, ‘Leadership in the British Army in the Second World War: Some Personal Observations’ in Sheffield, G.D. (ed.), Leadership and Command: The Anglo-American Military Experience since 1861 (London, Washington: Brassey's, 1997), p. 125Google Scholar.

12 Sharma, Lieutenant-Colonel Gautam, Nationalisation of the Indian Army: 1885–1947 (New Delhi: Allied, 1996), p. 184Google Scholar.

13 Karaka, D.F., With the 14th Army (Bombay: Thacker & Co. Pvt. Ltd., 1944), p. 36Google Scholar.

14 Director of Military Training's (hereafter DMT) Report on tour of South East Asia Command (henceforth SEAC)–India, 2 August 1945, Para 19, L/WS/1/762, IOR.

15 Killingray, David, ‘Gender Issues and African Colonial Armies’ in Killingray, and Omissi, David (eds.), Guardians of Empire: The Armed Forces of the Colonial Powers c. 1700–1964 (Manchester, New York: Manchester University Press, 1999), pp. 222–223Google Scholar.

16 Marjomaa, Risto, ‘The Veterans’ Dilemma: Employment of Ex-Soldiers of the King's African Rifles’ Nyasaland (Malawi) Battalions, 1902–39’, HEMISPHERES, No. 20 (2005), p. 53Google Scholar.

17 Waites, Bernard, ‘Black men in white men's wars’ in Bourne, John, Liddle, Peter and Whitehead, Ian (eds.), The Great World War, 1914–45: Who Won? Who Lost? vol. 2 (London: Harper Collins, 2001), p. 258Google Scholar.

18 Kirby, Major-General S. Woodburn, The War against Japan, vol. 2, India's Most Dangerous Hour (London: HMSO, 1958), pp. 385, 387Google Scholar.

19 Kirby, Major-General S. Woodburn, The War against Japan, vol. 4, The Reconquest of Burma (London: HMSO, 1965), Appendix 18, p. 472Google Scholar.

20 Barua, Pradeep, The Army Officer Corps and Military Modernization in Later Colonial India (Hull: University of Hull, 1999), p. 138Google Scholar.

21 McCann, John, Return to Kohima (Oldham: Published by John McCann, 1993), p. 497Google Scholar.

22 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1, L/WS/1/939, IOR.

23 Major-General, Director of Intelligence, 17 August 1944, India Command, Inter-Service Morale Summary No. 1 for the Quarter May, June and July, 1944, Quarterly Reports of the Adjutant-General (hereafter AG) in India on Morale, Para 2, L/WS/1/939.

24 Hart, Stephen, ‘Montgomery, Morale, Casualty Conservation and “Colossal Cracks”: 21st Army Group's Operational Technique in North-West Europe, 1944–45’ in JSS, Vol. 19, No. 4 (1996), p. 135Google Scholar.

25 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1.

26 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para, 7&8, L/WS/1/939.

27 British Soldier looks at India: Letters of Clive Branson (1944, reprint, Bombay: People's Publishing House, 1945), p. i.

28 Letters of Clive Branson, p. 45.

29 Report by the Earl of Munster on the Welfare of Troops in India and SEAC, Annexure II, Para 4, 13, Cabinet Papers, vol. 5, no. 28799, Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, New Delhi.

30 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 2(b).

31 Major-General, Director of Intelligence, 17 August. 1944, Secret, India Command, Inter-Service Morale Summary No. 1 for the Quarter May, June and July, 1944, Quarterly Reports of the AG in India on Morale, Para 3.

32 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 3 (b), 6 ©7 (d).

33 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 2(b).

34 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 4.

35 Quotation from Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 2(b).

36 Major-General, Director of Intelligence, 17 August 1944, Secret, India Command, Inter-Service Morale Summary No. 1 for the Quarter May, June and July, 1944, Quarterly Reports of the AG in India on Morale, Para 9.

37 AG in India's Committee on Morale, Report of the Fourth Meeting, Morale Reports, India and SEAC, 15 July–15 October 1943, Part II, Para 1, L/WS/2/71, IOR.

38 Maj.-Gen., Director of Intelligence, 17 Aug. 1944, India Command, Inter-Service Morale Summary No. 1 for the Quarter May, June and July, 1944, Quarterly Reports of the AG in India on Morale, Para 3.

39 Prasad, Nandan, Expansion of the Armed Forces and Defence Organization: 1939–45, Official History of the Indian Armed Forces during Second World War, General Editor Prasad, B. (New Delhi: Combined Inter-Services Historical Section, India & Pakistan, 1956), Appendix 16Google Scholar.

40 Major-General, Director of Intelligence, 17 August 1944, India Command, Inter-Service Morale Summary No. 1 for the Quarter May, June and July, 1944, Quarterly Reports of the AG in India on Morale, Para 4.

41 AG in India's Committee on Morale, Report of the Fourth Meeting, Morale Reports, India and SEAC, 15 July–15 October 1943, Part II, Para 5, Post War Prospects.

42 Brayne, Colonel F.L, ‘The Punjabi Soldier at Home’ in Journal of the United Service Institution of India, Vol. LXXIII, No. 310 (1943), p. 86Google Scholar.

43 Morale Reports, India and SEAC, 15 July–15 October 1943, Part II, Para 2 (a), L/WS/2/71.

44 AG in India's Committee on Morale, Report of the Fourth Meeting, Morale Reports, India and SEAC, 15 July–15 October 1943, Part II, Para 5.

45 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 October 1944, Part I, Para 3 (a).

46 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 October 1944, Part I, Para 3, Part II, Para 3, 5, L/WS/2/71.

47 Singh, Brigadier Rajendra, Soldier & Soldiering in India: Twelve Essays (1954, reprint, New Delhi: Army Educational Stores, 1964), p. ixGoogle Scholar.

48 Bristow, Brigadier R.C.B., Memories of the British Raj: A Soldier in India (London: Johnson, 1974), p. 118Google Scholar.

49 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 1944 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part IV, Para 2.

50 Timothy Parsons, ‘All askaris are family men: Sex, Domesticity and Discipline in the King's African Rifles, 1902–64’ in Killingray and Omissi (eds.), Guardians of Empire, pp. 161–162.

51 Marjomaa, Risto, ‘The Martial Spirit: Yao Soldiers in British Service in Nyasaland (Malawi), 1895–1939’ in Journal of African History, Vol. 44 (2003), p. 422CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

52 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 1944 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part IV, Para 3–5.

53 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 1944 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part V.

54 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1.

55 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para 2, L/WS/1/939; Bayly, C. and Harper, Tim, Forgotten Armies: The Fall of British Asia, 1941–45 (London: Allen Lane, 2004), p. 364Google Scholar.

56 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para 1.

57 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1.

58 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1.

59 Report by Munster, Para 7.

60 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months Feb., March & April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para 10.

61 Leathart, Scott, With the Gurkhas: India, Burma, Singapore, Malaya, Indonesia, 1940–59 (Edinburgh, Cambridge, Durham: Pentland, 1996), p. 1Google Scholar.

62 Report by Munster, Para 15, 16, 19.

63 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para 11.

64 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and Colonial Troops of Allied Land Forces South East Asia for the months of August, September and October. 1944, Part II, Para 6, L/WS/2/71.

65 Davis, Patrick, A Child at Arms (1970, reprint, Stroud: Spellmount, 2006), pp. 48–49Google Scholar.

66 Morale Reports, India and SEAC, 15 July–15 October 1943, AG in India's Committee on Morale, Part II, Para 1 (a).

67 French, David, ‘“Tommy is no Soldier”: The Morale of the Second British Army in Normandy, June–August 1944’ in JSS, Vol. 19, No. 4 (1996), p. 158Google Scholar.

68 Allen, Louis, Burma: The Longest War, 1941–45 (1984, reprint, London: Phoenix, 2002), p. 202Google Scholar.

69 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part I, Para 3.

70 Dunlop, Graham, ‘British Tactical Command and Leadership in the Burma Campaign, 1941–45’, in Bond, Brian and Tachikawa, Kyoichi (eds), British and Japanese Military Leadership in the Far Eastern War, 1941–45 (Abingdon, Oxon: Frank Cass, 2004), p. 98Google Scholar.

71 Army in India Morale Report for the three months ended 31 July 44 including information about troops in SEAC, 14 August 1944, Part I, Para 1.

72 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and Colonial Troops of Allied Land Forces South East Asia for the months of August, September, and October 1944, Part II, Para 9, L/WS/2/71; Appendix A, Post War Prospects, A Summary of Field Summary Report on Reactions to Post-War Problems, Quarter April–June 1944, L/WS/1/939.

73 DMT's Report on tour of SEAC-India, 2 August 1945, Para 1.

74 DMT's Report on tour of SEAC-India, 2 August 1945, Para 7.

75 Prendergast, John, Prender's Progress: A Soldier in India, 1931–47 (London: Cassell, 1979), p. 241Google Scholar.

76 Gilmore, Scott with Davis, Patrick, A Connecticut Yankee in the 8th Gurkha Rifles: A Burma Memoir (Washington, London: Brassey's, 1995), p. 169Google Scholar.

77 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part IV, Para 81–3.

78 DMT's Report on tour of SEAC–India, 2 August 1945, Para 10.

79 Elliott, Major-General J.G., A Roll of Honour: The Story of the Indian Army, 1939–45 (Delhi: Army Publishers, 1965), p. 320Google Scholar.

80 Brian Bond, ‘The Army Level of Command: General Sir William Slim and Fourteenth Army in Burma’ in Bond and Tachikawa (eds.), British and Japanese Military Leadership, p. 49.

81 Report on the Morale of British, Indian and African Troops in India Command and SEAC for the three months February, March and April 1944, 18 May 1944, Part IV, Para 85.

82 Frank Furedi, ‘The Demobilized African Soldier and the Blow to White Prestige’ in Killingray and Omissi (eds), Guardians of Empire, p. 188.

83 Killingray, David, ‘Africans and African Americans in Enemy Hands’, in Moore, Bob and Federowich, Kent (eds), Prisoners of War and their Captors in World War II (Oxford, Washington, D.C.: Berg, 1996), p. 182Google Scholar.

84 Pennington, William, Pick up your Parrots and Monkeys and fall in facing the Boat (London: Cassell, 2003), p. 348Google Scholar.

85 Thorat, Lieutenant-General S.P.P., From Reveille to Retreat (New Delhi: Allied, 1986), p. 72Google Scholar.

86 Swynnerton, Brigadier C.R.A., ‘The 1st West African Infantry Brigade in the Arakan: 1944–45’ in Army Quarterly, Vol. LIII, No. 1 (1946), pp. 50–54Google Scholar.

87 Quotation from Swynnerton, ‘1st West African Infantry Brigade’, p. 60.

88 Kenichi Arakawa, ‘Japanese War Leadership in the Burma Theatre: The Imphal Operation’ in Bond and Tachikawa (eds), British and Japanese Military Leadership, pp. 118–121.

89 Barua, Pradeep P., The State at War in South Asia (Lincoln, London: University of Nebraska, 2005), p. 154Google Scholar.